Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Or is dh?

59 replies

cozycusion · 12/05/2022 11:22

I am pregnant and vegetarian.
We're expecting a little girl in July and id like to bring her up as vegetarian as I don't feel it's fair to make her eat animals until she's old enough to decide she is happy to.
Dh on the other hand thinks she should be made to eat meat until she's old enough to decide.
Who is being unreasonable here?

OP posts:
YetAnotherCupOfTea · 12/05/2022 12:47

I'm veggie, DH isn't.

DCs primarily eat similarly to DH - veggie at home most of the time, but the option to eat meat when we're eating out, or having different meals. The main thing we keep in the house for them is fish fingers, as they're convenient and not bad for them. And cheaper than veggie burgers!

DC1 is 5, and starting to make the links to meat and fish being dead animals properly (he's always been told), but it doesn't really bother him that much.

cookiemonster2468 · 12/05/2022 12:44

Giving your child dead animal that's been systemically brutalised etc might not be a choice they're comfortable with later in life

Whilst this is true, there are lots of things that parents do when raising children that the child may look back on and think 'wtf was my parent thinking?'

Interestingly, I once met someone whose parents raised him as vegetarian, and as an adult he felt resentful about this because they didn't give him a varied diet. He didn't like the taste of meat because he wasn't used to it, and he felt restricted about what he could eat in restaurants! He was actively trying to train himself to enjoy eating meat.

The point is, we can't preempt what our children are going to care about when they grow up. We can only do our best for them based on what we know and what we can currently provide.

2pinkginsplease · 12/05/2022 12:41

A child she be fed a balanced diet of all food where they can decide when old enough what food they want to eat.

No adult should decide to restrict a child's diet, according to their own beliefs, everything in moderation.

EmilyBolton · 12/05/2022 12:40

In my experience my dc (now adults) were quite old before they’d tuck into a piece of meat and veg (early teens) . They enjoyed stews or mince things where meat was small and didn’t need much chewing form as soon as they were on solids, But they ate a LOT of fish - and would (and still do) prefer that to meat. we almost became pescatarians!
so, imo is while weening expose your child to a LOT of different foods, multiple times. Then take your lead from them…it’ll move from flavour preferences to texture preference as food gets more solid. Keep it a highly varied and obviously balanced (don’t young children need some other foods as sources of essential minerals and vitamins if they’re not having meat? Iron zinc and B12?) I’d not avoid anything including small amounts of meat when your DH has it so they’re constantly exposed to flavours and textures. There’s good evidence that humans ate more fish and occasional meat in prehistoric times so I used to aim for that and still do.

Just don’t pander to their preferences as they develop- cook one dish only that everyone eats and don’t get sucked into cooking multiple dishes for faddy eaters. All kids take a dislike to a few specific foods and that is easy to avoid giving them without creating specific dishes (DS1 it was banana, peas and raw tomatoes, DS2 ate everything and anything 🤣)

Change123today · 12/05/2022 12:40

Both SIL are vegetarian, two nieces to one have grown up completely vegetarian (BIL is also vegetarian) the older daughter (24) is now also vegan. Hasn’t bothered them & I think as a family it made complete sense. The other sil her partner is a meat eater she was very undecided about what to do so she primarily fed them a vegetarian diet at home, at nursery gave them a choice and the Bil occasionally cooked and would give them meat. The older son is 12 now and much prefers the vegetarian choices and doesn’t eat meat at all the younger son 8 still very undecided or maybe a little to young to fully understand.

in all cases the children are happy and healthy- whether the choice is given with age or meat just not provided for from birth.

cookiemonster2468 · 12/05/2022 12:38

cherrymax · 12/05/2022 12:22

I think I'd go with them being pretty much vegetarian when with you but not restrictive on what they can eat at parties, playdates etc

This sounds like a good compromise.

I don't think you should insist that your child is is fully vegetarian if it's not what your partner wants.

Whilst it can be done, I think a veggie diet can be a little more restrictive for children than adults, due to their additional protein needs and sometimes kids have a tendency to be fussy eaters. I think both partners would have to be on board and committed to supporting the child with vegetarian diet and making sure they get their nutritional needs met.

In your position I think I'd just limit meat intake to when out and about/ when your partner is cooking/ when he's having meat, so it's a compromise.

I think children should be offered the whole range of foods - they can and will show their preferences when they are old enough.

Also importat to remember you haven't committed a transgression against your child by feeding them meat. Your child will make their own ethical/ lifestyle decisions on all kinds of things when they get older, and it won't all be in line with how you raised them, and that's OK.

donquixotedelamancha · 12/05/2022 12:33

It may not be possible to feed her a 100% vegetarian diet. The range of food I would eat as a child was so restricted that I would have been severely malnourished if I had not had meat and fish available to me.

Indeed, both my kids would struggle to get enough protein without meat and they are not that fussy compared to some kids.

Personally I think a balanced, healthy diet is the top priority.

whywhywhy5 · 12/05/2022 12:32

We've found this a really complex question and our approach has evolved over time.

I don't agree meat should be the default - at all. Healthy food is the objective. Giving your child dead animal that's been systemically brutalised etc might not be a choice they're comfortable with later in life.

We started off with a vegan diet that had been heavily, heavily researched and took hours and hours and hours to make. With a pandemic and me getting some health issues that limits time and energy, that wasn't sustainable. Plus nursery were giving them processed replacement crap.

They now have meat and fish once a week here, plus the standard fare at nursery. We don't like it, but that's the world we live in at the moment.

ElenaSt · 12/05/2022 12:32

I'm a vegetarian but raises my children to eat 'everything'.

I know I made the right choice when we were at a children's party and a four year old who was being raised as a vegetarian/vegan was crying her eyes out because she wanted to eat what the other children were eating (cocktail sausages, ham sandwiches, chicken etc) and her mother wouldn't let her and had brought her own tub of food that looked completely unappealing when compared to the party food.

Children are often fussy when it comes to food so why start off limiting what they can eat especially when children will encounter many social situations where food is key.

Ansjovis · 12/05/2022 12:24

It may not be possible to feed her a 100% vegetarian diet. The range of food I would eat as a child was so restricted that I would have been severely malnourished if I had not had meat and fish available to me. And yes, when given the choice to eat what was provided or go hungry I chose the latter option every time. By all means encourage her to eat the type of food you eat but be open to the idea that eating meat and fish may be best for her as she grows.

cherrymax · 12/05/2022 12:22

I think I'd go with them being pretty much vegetarian when with you but not restrictive on what they can eat at parties, playdates etc

cozycusion · 12/05/2022 12:20

Thank you everyone, I appreciate all your thoughts.

OP posts:
StageRage · 12/05/2022 12:18

‘Made’ to eat meat? Is that what he actually said?

I am very sympathetic to the veggie way of life, but as we are omnivores by design I think it reasonable to include some meat in her diet until she is old enough to decide. The majority of her diet can be veggie but from time to time give her some if your DH’s food.

My veggie friend brought her kids up like that and now they are older teens two are veggie / vegan and one is omni. All eat the veggie meals she cooks, her DH cooks meat or chicken curries etc.

ResentfulLemon · 12/05/2022 12:12

As you're the one preparing the meals then just be led by your daughter. If she wants to try some of what her dad is eating let her, but otherwise just prepare meals for her as you would your own would be my approach.

My daughter is a vegetarian - not for any reason other than she despises the texture of meat. These things work themselves out pretty quickly when you start weaning.

JenniferPlantain · 12/05/2022 12:10

Neither of you are BU.

If pushed I’d say let her eat meat (I’m veggie) as it will probably just make life easier for her at school/friends houses when she’s growing up. You modelling vegetarianism and giving her a mix of meat and veggie meals at home will be a nice background for her to choose when she’s ready to choose.

OchonAgusOchonOh · 12/05/2022 11:58

Polly271220 · 12/05/2022 11:27

You are....as you should both decide when she's of age

That is exactly what the op is suggesting - wait until she is at a suitable age to decide if meat should be added to her diet.

Her dh is suggesting much the same - wait until she is a suitable age to decide if meat should be removed from her diet.

Neither is more right or wrong than the other. There is no reason to assume meat eating is the default or that vegetarian is the default.

That said, I'm veggie and fed meat to mine growing up. Main reason was meat is an excellent source of dense calories and as they were all very involved in pretty intense levels of sport, it would be hard to get sufficient calories in to them. When they were younger it was more of a mix. Dh made meat based meals and I made veggie.

StarDolphins · 12/05/2022 11:53

Neither is right or wrong. I don’t eat meat but I make my DD meat - although she’s now starting to ask where her chicken nuggets/bacon etc come from.

I definitely don’t think she’s ‘missing out’ on anything by not having meat in her diet!

PizzaPatel · 12/05/2022 11:48

Depends who does the cooking

Etinoxaurus · 12/05/2022 11:46

Mad cow disease was a thing when DD (now 26 was a born) so I avoided meat until she was 2ish. She chose to be vegetarian from 5-16, now omnivorous.
You’re a saint to prepare meat for your DH. Why don’t you suggest that whoever cooks feeds her?

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 12/05/2022 11:41

cozycusion · 12/05/2022 11:39

Dh doesn't do any of the cooking, although I do cook him meat as I know that's what he likes to eat so the preparation of meat is not an issue.

Well if he isn't making meals then he can't have a say. Personally if I were veggie I'd not even prepare meat but seeing as you are halfway there.

cozycusion · 12/05/2022 11:39

Dh doesn't do any of the cooking, although I do cook him meat as I know that's what he likes to eat so the preparation of meat is not an issue.

OP posts:
BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 12/05/2022 11:39

We're expecting a little girl in July and id like to bring her up as vegetarian as I don't feel it's fair to make her eat animals until she's old enough to decide she is happy to

There are an awful lot of "choices" we make for our dcs before they are able to show a preference or truly understand their options.

We raise them to acknowledge the religious events customary to our household, before they get a chance to explore other options.

We raise them usually with the plan of putting them into formal education, and make steps to either place them into this system or opt out.

We raise them consuming dairy (or withholding it), consuming television (or withholding it), we vaccinate them (or withholding them).

ALL of which we do without their knowledge, understanding or choice.

How do you feel about all the other decisions you will make for her before she can truly choose?

LightDrizzle · 12/05/2022 11:37

I assume neither of you will “make her” eat anything.
Your husband wants to offer her omnivorous foods until she is able to choose for herself and you want to offer her vegetarian foods until she is able to choose for yourself.
YABU for your manipulative misuse of language but as to the issue, I’d probably err on the side of whoever feels most strongly and that’s likely to be the vegetarian.
The way you’ve described this dilemma this makes me suspect your child’s freedom to choose in the future will be thoroughly circumscribed by the guilt you will load onto a choice that differs from the one you’ve made for yourself.

FlimFlamJimJams · 12/05/2022 11:35

In what way has he said he is going to "make" her eat meat?
You say that with the implication that if she had a choice, she wouldn't eat it.
However, until she's old enough to make a choice - the fair thing to do would be to expose her to the widest variety of choices and (unbiased) information, so she's in the best position to make an informed decision when she's capable of doing so.

latetothefisting · 12/05/2022 11:35

Your wording isn't exactly objective is it....presumably she's never going to be "made" to eat meat with her mouth being held open and it stuffed down her throat....the actual question is whether she will be offered some meals with meat in them or not.

I think the fairest way is for her to have a primarily vegetarian diet, but if DH wants to offer her meat occasionally e.g. as part of the meal he's making then fair enough. Same if shes at school or at a friend's for tea when she's a bit older, she should be allowed to try the meat option if she likes without feeling its forbidden or naughty. She might decide herself not to eat it, I've got lots of friends who are the only vegetarians/vegans in their family, some of whom decided it at a really young age, as they just didn't like the taste of meat.