Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Or is dh?

59 replies

cozycusion · 12/05/2022 11:22

I am pregnant and vegetarian.
We're expecting a little girl in July and id like to bring her up as vegetarian as I don't feel it's fair to make her eat animals until she's old enough to decide she is happy to.
Dh on the other hand thinks she should be made to eat meat until she's old enough to decide.
Who is being unreasonable here?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Kitty878 · 13/05/2022 02:33

I can only comment from my own experience, but I was brought up vegetarian in the way you hope to bring your daughter up. (I'm in my thirties now). I was always told I could eat meat if and when I wanted to, but I've never wanted to or felt the need to. I quickly formed my own reasons for why I don't want to eat meat, and I don't think it will necessarily be that long before she is capable of deciding by herself- I understood what eating meat entailed by the time I was three or four, and wanted no part of it. I don't personally feel like I missed out. And I certainly don't struggle like some of my friends do, who want to be veggie or vegan for ethical reasons but find it tough to give up their favourite foods. Meat has no attraction for me.

Similarly, I had a friend who is veggie, and she brought her children up veggie until they were old enough to decide for themselves. Her son decided to stay veggie, but her daughter was quite happily eating meat by the time she was five, so it very much depends on the child, and it should only be a few years until she's capable of making her own mind up. I hope this helps.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 12/05/2022 16:16

I think YABU because if you don't bring a child up to eat something, its much harder for them to get used to it when they are older. Eg never have beef then they're going to find that taste really strong and different...and most (but not all!) children are afraid of strong and different! So it's not a balanced choice for them if that makes sense

However he is BU to think he gets any say in what she is fed if he doesnt contribute to the cooking!

HedgehogintheFog · 12/05/2022 16:05

You are both being unreasonable in my opinion. She should not be "made" to eat anything. In my opinion, you should expose her to a wide range of foodstuffs, but YANBU to not prepare meat for her.

coffeecupsandfairylights · 12/05/2022 15:59

I don't think it makes sense to avoid a whole food group when they're so young.

By all means feed her vegetarian meals yourself, but I do think she should be able to eat meat and fish if it's provided at school/parties, or if your DH wants to buy and cook it for her himself.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 12/05/2022 15:43

I'd say the fairest compromise is that if you buy her/make her a meal, it will be veggie, and if he buys her/makes her a meal, it can be veggie/carni.

At some point she will show a preference.

This! And she can make her own choices at school.

I do think your wording that he wants her to be “made” to eat meat is off though - no one is going to force her, presumably? She’d just be offered it in a normal way?

StrawberrySquash · 12/05/2022 15:25

I think there's a danger that this becomes a battleground between you and DH and I'd work to make sure it doesn't. Don't tie eating meat to her being on Mummy or Daddy's 'side'. That's just a way to breed neurosis. So if she wants to try a bit of Daddy's steak or eat meat at a friend's then let her.

Princetopple · 12/05/2022 15:12

If you're sharing cooking, I think it'd make sense that she eats vegetarian meals on days you're cooking and whatever your partner cooks when he does. Growing up, my mother was a vegetarian and my dad wasn't. She did all of the cooking and cooked us meat. I think she was concerned about us not getting enough good stuff and I was a very fussy eater. Some things which we'd all eat would be made with meat substitutes instead but then others she would substitute something instead of the meat we were having on her plate. I became a vegetarian for a few years (thought mainly because of disliking the texture of meat) and then went back to eating meat. I now eat meat and it is one of the few things which doesn't cause me digestive problems!

SlickShady · 12/05/2022 14:56

I don't think you need to be any more angsty than the animals you eat. As long as they don't have these kind of existential morality dilemmas, go ahead and do what they would.

10HailMarys · 12/05/2022 14:42

I may be wrong here, but isn't there an issue if someone has never eaten meat then their stomach develops differently and they may end up ill if the do eat meat?

Nope, that's a myth. I have a friend who insists that meat makes her sick now, but a while ago she had a stomach ache after eating what she only thought was meat, when in fact it wasn't. So my guess is that it's actually just the idea of it that makes people feel ill, rather than the reality. It really is incredible what an effect the mind can have on the stomach - think of people who throw up at the sight of blood etc.

AskingforaBaskin · 12/05/2022 14:36

You feed her a veggie diet, he feeds her meat.

10HailMarys · 12/05/2022 14:34

I think you both have equal say in what she eats, to be honest. I would say that if he's cooking or preparing her food, he can feed her meat if he wants to, but if you're doing in it then you can give her something vegetarian.

FreestyleInTrance · 12/05/2022 14:27

I'm raising my daughter as a vegetarian. I was raised vegetarian (and since gone vegan), so this was a deal breaker for me discussed long before pregnancy. (My husband does eat meat, but not at home).

In contrast to the person mentioned above, I am forever grateful to have been raised vegetarian. It makes perfect sense to me that my Mum wouldn't feed me something she's morally opposed to. Vegetarian food can be totally safe and nutritious, and for me personally it is easy to know what to feed a vegetarian child, because I've been one!

For the fussy eaters mentioned, I've found Quorn Roarsomes and Birds Eye Fishless fingers to fill the gap for beige breaded protein perfectly well, along with crispy tofu bites... and if we have fussy kids over who aren't used to vegetarian substitutes, I've done cheese pizza, waffles and beans/peas with great success!

For parties I certainly don't bring special/disappointing vegetarian food... I've not been to any kids parties that didn't have cheese sandwiches so far, and usually lots of other options like jam sandwiches, egg sandwiches, cheese pizza, plus fruit, houmous, bread sticks, vegetable sticks, crisps, party rings, jelly pots, jammie dodgers... most party food is fine! The only effort required so far has been occasionally swapping out party bag haribo for the vegetarian equivalent... but I already check party bags for hard lollies and swap those out, so it's not a lot of extra trouble!

She's welcome to make a different choice when she's older (my brother and I completely diverged - he took up meat eating and I went vegan!), but until then she's stuck with what I believe is right... same with vaccinations (yes), extended rear facing, a blanket ban on Bing and a strict policy on choking hazards!

SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 12/05/2022 14:26

I may be wrong here, but isn't there an issue if someone has never eaten meat then their stomach develops differently and they may end up ill if the do eat meat?

I've definitely had this shouted at by a vegetarian person when I accidentally put the wrong plate down in front of her back in my waitressing days. She told me that as she hadn't eaten meat since she was a child, her stomach had now developed so digesting meat would cause her to be in pain/ill.

summersnear · 12/05/2022 13:42

I believe trying to "decide " this type of thing beforehand often creates problems. In my opinion it's best to aim for this. We aim to feed our child the best possible diet, with enough protein and nutrients for optimal growth and nutrition.
How we do that will depend upon many things. Some of those will be controlled by us, for example the amount of time and effort we put into buying and preparing her food, some will come from your child. If she is a difficult eater, then giving her a good diet is tricky even without factoring in being vegetarian.
In my opinion in your circumstances it's fairer on your child to have meat and fish as something she has occasionally, even if the majority of the time she eats other food types. In this way her body will learn to digest meat, but will also quite easily be able to cut it out when older if she wishes. I believe in letting my children make their own decisions, but only when they have the mental capacity to do so, others believe the cause they are fighting for is more important than an individual's right to choose.

Katya213 · 12/05/2022 13:15

I’m vegetarian, I brought my daughter up eating meat.

elvislives2012 · 12/05/2022 13:08

I think you have equal say. I'm a vegetarian and my husband eats meat. I do all the cooking so our two daughters are both vegetarian and have been since birth. No issues health wise
I figured when they were older they could decide to eat meat if they wanted. They are now 7&9 and both still want to be vegetarian

Ruraljurer · 12/05/2022 13:05

pinkpinkeverywhere · 12/05/2022 11:28

I’m vegetarian but brought my children up eating meat until they could chose for themselves. One has now chosen to become vegetarian, but the other is happy to continue eating meat.
Selfishly I felt it easier to bring them up eating meat, than worrying they weren’t getting a fully rounded diet by being vegetarian if they were picky and also worrying at parties if they ate a chicken nugget.
I don’t think there is a right or wrong though

I am a vegetarian and I’m also doing precisely this.
My only thought about your dilemma is to wait until the child is actually at the stage of eating solids to have this discussion with your husband. My DH and I tied ourselves in knots arguing before we had children about how we’d bring them up. Enjoy your pregnancy and save these hypothetical issues for when you’re faced with them, you both might feel differently after the child has arrived.

Tamzo85 · 12/05/2022 13:05

You are, I think for young kids and especially that young, meat is the best way to get them the dietary needs they benifet from at that important growing stage. We are really evolved to eat meat, it’s just that when the availability is there we can get those nutrients from other areas - however that’s hard with a wee one. You don’t want her underdeveloped just because of your own personal conviction.

Really the best way for her to get a balanced diet is meat, don’t let ideology come before that. She can choose that later.

MerryMarigold · 12/05/2022 13:04

I don't feel it's fair to make her eat animals

I don't it's fair to force her to be vegetarian either. I would serve both types of food at home (assuming Dh eats meat sometimes) and allow her to choose at relatives houses/ restaurants. When she starts school they usually have a veg and non veg option so again, whatever she prefers on the day. When she's older, she can decide if she wants to v exclusively vegetarian based on any convictions she may/ may not have.

luciatrope · 12/05/2022 13:04

Surely the point of vegetarianism/veganism is to minimise harm to animals? In which case, sustaining your children on a diet of meat is doing the exact opposite.

There are vegetarian and vegan children. I'm with you.

Vsirbdo · 12/05/2022 13:00

What age do you let them decide? My DC have wanted to eat food off my plate since the age of 1 so when they’re a baby and asking do you let them? Or is there a particular age you feel is mature enough to decide?

ChildrenOfTheQuorn · 12/05/2022 12:55

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 12/05/2022 11:28

You both have a say in this, neither is "right" or "wrong".

I'd say the fairest compromise is that if you buy her/make her a meal, it will be veggie, and if he buys her/makes her a meal, it can be veggie/carni.

At some point she will show a preference.

This is exactly what me and my OH do.

Mally100 · 12/05/2022 12:53

donquixotedelamancha · 12/05/2022 12:33

It may not be possible to feed her a 100% vegetarian diet. The range of food I would eat as a child was so restricted that I would have been severely malnourished if I had not had meat and fish available to me.

Indeed, both my kids would struggle to get enough protein without meat and they are not that fussy compared to some kids.

Personally I think a balanced, healthy diet is the top priority.

Agree with this. I have a few friends who are Vegetarian and some vegan and eventually gave in and allowed their children to eat meat without being topped up by a range of vitamins

Shinyandnew1 · 12/05/2022 12:51

Dh on the other hand thinks she should be made to eat meat

Did he actually say, ‘made’? That very emotive language-I’m wondering if that’s your word rather than his.

MiniatureHotdog · 12/05/2022 12:50

A child she be fed a balanced diet of all food where they can decide when old enough what food they want to eat.

No adult should decide to restrict a child's diet, according to their own beliefs, everything in moderation.

I agree with this.