Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I being unreasonable to think the teacher might be cheating in SATs

85 replies

mummybean84 · 12/05/2022 11:02

Our DS is currently sitting his SATs. He came home the first day and said the teacher when reading out the spelling list was pronouncing the silent letters, as an example saying something like “spell Thumb…. Th um b” and with words with double letters “spell Letter Let ter” (These are just examples not the actual words). And was confusing them by saying the words funny to hint at the spelling. Then in the English exam was walking around saying “theres something missing at the end of that sentence and you won’t get a point” when there was no full stop. He also told a pupil they had a maths answer wrong yesterday looking over their shoulder so they went back and checked the sum. Is this just normal is SATs? Or would you count it as cheating?

OP posts:
LouisCatorze · 13/05/2022 14:57

I think it's always been a thing but more so in some schools than others, from what I've gathered.

I do recall that one of DC1 friends burst into tears because the invigilating teacher advised her to look at one question again (which clearly she'd not got right?).

Goldenbear · 13/05/2022 14:47

So depressing to read about teachers not caring or understanding what an 'education' means, it is not purely about tests and it is so damaging to a child to be considered an educational failure at 10/11. You must lack an imagination to see the long term damage this has on a child's ability to learn due to the unnecessary knock to their confidence!

wonderstuff · 13/05/2022 14:45

Shocking really. End of KS2 assessment is really useful, but SATS are not fit for purpose. You put in high stakes exams (for junior schools) and then put the people whose career is impacted by those exams in charge of them, bound to be schools cheating from time to time. Then the poor feeder secondary has KS4 progress benchmarked against those SAT marks.

They need to make them low stakes to remove the temptation.

Goldenbear · 13/05/2022 14:38

The Art comparison is not an accurate one as subjects like Art and Music have been pushed off the curriculum to accommodate the revison and year long preparation for SATs. Primary age children should experience a breadth of education to establish what they are good at but that doesn't happen anymore as the focus is specifically on passing tests!

We are so lucky at our state primary school as we have an amazing music department due to specific music teachers, they line up opportunities like performing at the O2 with the school choir and organise amazing concerts and shows. That level of opportunity is not across the board though and my DD's old primary school down the road from her current one had no such opportunities as they didn't have the calibre of music teachers. It is so hit and miss. Lots of my friends who live elsewhere in the country were in shock that my DD performed in the choir last week at the O2 as their children go to state primaries in different parts of the UK so London, Midlands and Yorkshire and had no such opportunities. It shouldn't be like this as it is now allowing children who do have talents that don't lie in the core subjects to shine, this has a knock on effect on their confidence and self esteem.

hedgehogger1 · 13/05/2022 14:11

I teach secondary. I've had many kids tell me over the years how the primary teachers helped them in their tests. Then they end up with artificially high target grades. It's shit, but I understand why it happens

AngeloMysterioso · 13/05/2022 09:36

I hate how heavily examined children are in this country… I mean these are 10/11 year old kids, frankly I’ve always thought that putting them under the pressure of SATS tests at such a young age is kinda fucked up, particularly now when their education has been so disrupted in the last two years. I remember the KS1 tests I took as an infant in primary school, even then I knew we were being tested and felt anxious about it and I was only 7.

LetitiaLeghorn · 13/05/2022 09:31

@BusyMum47 I was an invigilator and I agree. Our exam officer was very strict and keen. You can't even stress words when you read a question.
And I also disagree with this 'keeping your nose out' @HiJenny35. You might not agree with SATs but they are tests required by the education dept and it's wrong for results to be manipulated.
As for some children failing in comparison to their friends, that's inevitable. And in other things they'll be more successful than their friends. Should there be no art in school because some are naturally gifted and others, me for example, struggle to draw a stick man?

Catshaveiteasy · 13/05/2022 09:21

Its 100% cheating and very much against the guidelines given which all staff involved in SATs should be trained in. You should report this.

Results are not being published this year but things like this are so unfair to schools like mine which follow the rules. We look bad for having lower results but we do often think some neighbouring schools may have cheated.

It's also not fair to the children.

LetitiaLeghorn · 13/05/2022 09:17

As a teacher I don't care whether it does or doesn't have an effect on the child's future or the school. It's not what should happen in an exam. This is why internal exams are unfair. The exam board I used was external but there were some boards that used exams marked internally by the learners' teacher. Their results were so much better than ours. Surprise, surprise.
Unless exams are created by one national exam board and overseen by independent invigilators, there can never be fairness in the system.

BusyMum47 · 13/05/2022 09:15

HiJenny35 · 12/05/2022 14:15

It's not that straightforward at all. Several children in the hall will have different allowances, for many we are allowed to give different levels of assistance, rephrasing the questions, explaining words, help with the context and instructions. With the spelling test however they shouldn't overemphasise any part of the word. Unless yu are very sure the school is cheating I'd keep my nose out. At the end of the day we are putting 10 year olds under a ridiculous amount of pressure where many will end up with results that make them feel like a failure compared to their friends just so we can judge schools, they should be scrapped all together.

I disagree with the first part of this. ⬆️ Yes, some children are permitted extra time, a live scribe or their paper transcribing afterwards & teachers are allowed to read the questions in all but the reading paper but we absolutely are not permitted to re-phrase any questions or explain what any words mean. We're not even supposed to identify the operation involved when reading a maths reasoning question to them.

MumBee40 · 13/05/2022 09:07

My teenage son’s target grade for English was a 3-4 (D-C) on his most recent mock paper, he was just a few marks of a grade 7 6-7 (B-A), in my opinion, they are grade markers but don’t always have a bearing on your overall GCSE grades.

BusyMum47 · 13/05/2022 09:06

I'm a yr6 Teacher & that's blatant cheating & is absolutely not permitted. Trouble is, the official moderators can't be in every test, in every school, so it undoubtedly goes on, up & down the country.

HappySonHappyMum · 13/05/2022 08:57

ItsSnowJokes · 12/05/2022 14:10

And if she was in the wrong set she would be moved. Also estimated results mean nothing. Its the actual results. If your daughter had a bad day at the sats and got a 9 at gcse that's all good! Why do you think an estimated result would affect her? It's not her actual result. It is used for the progress 8 scores for the schools that's all.

She's gone all the way through and got her GCSE results and they did make a difference. Her senior school used a traffic light system on her reports, if she was achieving on the same trajectory as her SATs then she'd be given a green, nearly their amber and underachieving a red. She was moved around in sets but those traffic lights went all the way through and were the basis of the achievement trajectory she was supposed to follow.

ilovesooty · 12/05/2022 18:25

AutumnIsHere21 · 12/05/2022 14:33

It absolutely does have an impact on the students later down the line. GCSE target grades are shared with students from Y9. Imagine how a child will feel consistently being told they aren’t meeting their targets throughout secondary school all because some adult in Y6 wanted to cheat the system and make the school/themselves look good.

Also, as a teacher of a core subject at secondary school, this kicks the can down the road for us. So we’re the ones having to explain why Johnny didn’t get a grade 9 when he got a level 6 (or 120) in his SATS (when he told us his teacher sat down and rubbed out wrong answers on his paper so he could try again!)

Excellent points.

donquixotedelamancha · 12/05/2022 15:09

if you report can you do so anonymously?

The teacher shouldn't find out who reported them but if you want it to be a credible allegation then you need to put a name to it.

viques · 12/05/2022 15:07

A child at a school I know didn’t turn up for KS2 stats, turned out his mother, a HT in a neighbouring borough had somehow managed to add him onto her cohort ( he was assessed at level 5 across the board) . It became known as these things always do, the local advisors got involved and she lost her job. I know of at least three other head teachers who did similar things, all nice people, all currently not working as HTs, the pressure on them not to slip down the league is horrific and for some it is too much.

BettySundaes · 12/05/2022 14:59

It's happened a my child's school too - I am in a quandary as to what to do - if you report can you do so anonymously? I'm really shocked that my child's school would do this.

MargeIsBack · 12/05/2022 14:42

This is definitely cheating and shouldn't happen. As a school governor, I've often been into schools to observe SATS as an independent(ish) observer so that the school can say they have done things properly and had some scrutiny. The sorts of things you describe are detailed as not being allowed.
I would suggest you contact the Head and Governors and let them know what you've been told.

AutumnIsHere21 · 12/05/2022 14:33

It absolutely does have an impact on the students later down the line. GCSE target grades are shared with students from Y9. Imagine how a child will feel consistently being told they aren’t meeting their targets throughout secondary school all because some adult in Y6 wanted to cheat the system and make the school/themselves look good.

Also, as a teacher of a core subject at secondary school, this kicks the can down the road for us. So we’re the ones having to explain why Johnny didn’t get a grade 9 when he got a level 6 (or 120) in his SATS (when he told us his teacher sat down and rubbed out wrong answers on his paper so he could try again!)

HiJenny35 · 12/05/2022 14:25

InChocolateWeTrust · 12/05/2022 12:47

They aren't a waste of time.

There is a need for objective accountability in teaching.

I do sympathise with teachers. At the root of the problem is government failing to recognise a) not all children have the capacity, academically, to make equal rates of progress b) there are many many factors affecting a child's progress that are not within a teachers control.

However that doesnt mean we can't try and asses how well children progress, objectively. Over time you should see trends, a teacher who moves round more than one school/yeargroup etc and never manages to have pupils making decent progress, needs support to improve. Teachers who achieve excellent progress regardless of intake should be encouraged to share their best practices and help others improve, & should be rewarded for their achievement.

Absolute rubbish, teacher move around year groups and therefore this sort of accountability is impossible, in year 6 we don't even really teach anything it's just all revision of how well its been taught in the previous year. Teachers are assessed on their pupils progress, the sats results in nearly all schools are used in this way so it wouldn't highlight any individual teacher failing these would show through your tracking, classroom observation, teacher assessment and paperwork which is linked to your capability. Sats are simply a government rod to beat schools with and force academisation

Sapphirensteel · 12/05/2022 14:25

I feel really mean now. I never helped kids during SATs didn’t even give hints for spelling.😳Sorry to any kids I taught in Year 6, I obviously followed the instructions too literally.

Squillerman · 12/05/2022 14:22

I mean, they’re only 10/11 years old and SATs ultimately aren’t important so I can’t get worked up about this at all. Cheat away.

Plantstrees · 12/05/2022 14:22

Who cares? If the teacher is trying to help a few children improve their SATS scores I can't see the problem. I have never understood why people worry about SATS as they are fairly meaningless for the children as they are intended as a measure of how a class or school is performing rather than the individual.

cecilthehungryspider · 12/05/2022 14:21

It is absolutely cheating, it would never be tolerated in the school where I worked and should absolutely be reported! I'm a bit shocked that people think it doesn't matter.

www.gov.uk/guidance/how-to-report-maladministration-at-key-stage-1-and-key-stage-2

Apart from anything else, it's going to leave those children with the impression that it is acceptable to cheat in exams.

donquixotedelamancha · 12/05/2022 14:18

It's not that straightforward at all. Several children in the hall will have different allowances, for many we are allowed to give different levels of assistance, rephrasing the questions, explaining words, help with the context and instructions.

What OP describes doesn't sound remotely like special access arrangements.

Swipe left for the next trending thread