Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I being unreasonable to think the teacher might be cheating in SATs

85 replies

mummybean84 · 12/05/2022 11:02

Our DS is currently sitting his SATs. He came home the first day and said the teacher when reading out the spelling list was pronouncing the silent letters, as an example saying something like “spell Thumb…. Th um b” and with words with double letters “spell Letter Let ter” (These are just examples not the actual words). And was confusing them by saying the words funny to hint at the spelling. Then in the English exam was walking around saying “theres something missing at the end of that sentence and you won’t get a point” when there was no full stop. He also told a pupil they had a maths answer wrong yesterday looking over their shoulder so they went back and checked the sum. Is this just normal is SATs? Or would you count it as cheating?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
LouisCatorze · 16/05/2022 16:37

DD's primary school had most of the year group (two form entry) in school at 8am doing extra lessons for about half a term before the actual KS2 SATs exams. They were a rather naughty and not overly bright year cohort, it was fair to say, so I suspect the school was keen to do everything they could for as many pupils to pass as possible. But it felt very much more like child abuse punishment rather than the extra learning support that they presented it as.

In the end I pulled DD out of the extra classes because she was getting so tired and fractious for having that extra 45 minutes (we had a long walk to school) tacked onto the beginning of her school days (and she's not a morning person at the best of times). It definitely didn't seem in her best interests but rather those of the pushy new HT and her deputy, clearly keen to start as they meant to go on.

And no, I'm not anti-education but just thought the whole thing was farcical. She passed her SATs too, as we always had every confidence that she would.

EveSix · 16/05/2022 11:09

SATs aren't fit for purpose.
The pressures on head teachers and therefore teachers, to pull ever-improving SATs results out of the bag, have always been immense, even now, despite coming straight out of a pandemic. I've sat in so many meetings with local authority advisers and school improvement officers (all schools, irrespective of grading, have them) where head teachers have been baldly told to 'sort it', if realistically predicted expected combined results are not looking as good as LA adviser or SIO would like. There is always implied pressure to build on previous success, and not to 'coast', 'be caught napping' or 'rest on one's laurels'. It's so silly, as this becomes completely arbitrary. If heads stand their ground and hold firm that a particular cohort will not perform as well as advisers would like, what is on the table is further pressure on leadership, staff and pupils through increased scrutiny masquerading as support, not actual funding or bodies on the ground.

My current school has always barely scraped through, yet most of our pupils start Reception with little or no English, a huge % of Pupil Premium, chaotic lives, high numbers of pupil absence and EW referrals, a higher than average instance of SEN, higher than average involvement of outside agencies in families' lives, many looked after children and pupils from refugee families. We are SO proud of our pupils' achievements. Our teachers bust a gut every day for both our pupils and their families, and the children's progress over time is incredible. But the SATs don't reflect this. Since Christmas, Y6 teachers in our cluster of similar schools have been offering out of hours Zoom tuition and SATs revision on evenings and weekends for groups and individual pupils, after school SATs revision clubs 5 days per week, half term and holiday SATs revision clubs, you name it. A huge amount of pressure and additional workload for no remuneration. It's just expected.

Meanwhile, at my DCs' leafy suburban primary, the pressures are different but equally intense. As there are no apparent barriers to continuously improved results, the stakes are incredibly high and the HT and staff are compelled to evidence ever increasing examples of GD.

Nobody wins, but please don't think that cheating in SATs arises as a result of preening head teachers trying to 'look good'. These are bullied, harassed professional leaders who feel at the end of their tethers and are desperate to shield their hardworking staff and pupils from the stress and unmanageable workload that accompanies a demoralising local authority intervention.

Words · 16/05/2022 09:50

I find this horrifying. Of course it's cheating.
Also ludicrous to refer to schoolchildren as 'students'.
The terminology, as well as the grades, seems to be over inflated.

110APiccadilly · 16/05/2022 09:43

Those who are saying it doesn't matter - I was a child with a tendency to over-dramatise things in my head and if this had happened when I was 11 I'd probably have built it up in my head into some massive thing where all my results would be declared invalid and I'd have a black mark against my name for the rest of my life!

It's not right and that will worry at least some of the children (some of course won't realise or won't worry). That alone IMO is reason to report it.

ginghamstarfish · 16/05/2022 09:31

Shameful cheating. Might as well just let the kids stay home and the teacher fill in the results for everyone, makes the teacher look fantastic. I taught high school for years and would never have dreamed of doing this, although I was aware some teachers did 'help' improve their class results, because it made it look as if they were a better and more successful teacher. No, it's just cheating.

SpaceJamtart · 16/05/2022 09:23

This happened when I sat my SATs, I remember being confused why our teacher was suddenly pronouncing words like scissors 'sskkissors' and doing the 'B E A Utiful' pronunciation from Bruce Almighty.

IncyWincyGrownUp · 16/05/2022 09:22

I was a reader for SATs for several years. It was painful watching the children make really basic mistakes that they’d never make in a normal lesson, but rules are rules. You can read the question, but you cannot help - and tone and inflection are included as helping.

Luculentus · 16/05/2022 09:04

My children's school invited governors to sit in on SATs. So it would have been impossible to cheat anyway.

Littepinkyogapants · 16/05/2022 08:56

Same with data.
To get a pay rise you have to hit targets . So teachers hit them.

Example :
35% of class need to be at greater depth
50 % must be at expected

So teachers ensure that happens .

When I was innocent and naive - I went to my pupils progress meeting with my data. The head told me that ‘Emily ‘ was at expected ( even though Emily couldn’t use full stops !) The head didn’t care about Emily - the head cared about getting 76% of children to expected and above !!!!!

WAKE UP! It’s all a farce .

Littepinkyogapants · 16/05/2022 08:52

Teacher here .
Do adults seriously believe teachers don’t hint at and even damn well tell children the answers .

Why do you really think children are split into little groups and the paper is read ( answers fold to kids !!!)

My head and deputy used to change answers .

SATS are a complete farce .
Designed to rank schools. Schools are under such pressure. I honestly can’t believe people think SATS aren’t manipulated.

cansu · 16/05/2022 08:41

That is definitely cheating. The school should have made sure that the teachers understood the guidance. We had a meeting and discussed exactly what is and is not allowed. We also had two people in each room to ensure there could be no allegations. This is beyond stupid on the teacher's part. They may have been instructed to cheat by the head as some people are utterly bonkers about sats but it is wrong.

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 16/05/2022 08:32

ItsSnowJokes · 12/05/2022 11:41

Sats mean fuck all anyway for the student and everything for the school. I couldn't get het up about this. Leave them be and get the kids to get them all over and done with.

I agree. Happened at my ds's school too.

FairyCakeWings · 16/05/2022 08:29

It’s cheating and it needs to be reported.

Fifthtimelucky · 16/05/2022 08:25

Of course it's cheating and I am shocked by the number of posters who don't think it doesn't matter. What a lesson to be teaching young people. Well done to the OP's son for realising that it was not right.

partystress · 15/05/2022 23:15

The whole system is massively flawed, and I can absolutely see why it happens. But it is wrong. There is a report published each year on maladministration allegations and investigations. The more people who report, the more it will become clear that there is no level playing field and that stats and individual school results should not be used for any high stakes purpose.

As part of ‘levelling up’, the government is going to require schools to achieve 90% of children passing reading, writing and maths in Y6 - up from around 70ish % at the moment. The 90% is apparently achievable because it’s what the top performing multi-academy trusts manage to get. But if those trusts include more of the cheating schools, then those results aren’t actually achievable.

The intense pressure to achieve the impossible is a big factor in both our retention crisis (teachers and headteachers) and children’s mental heath and well-being.

Valeriekat · 15/05/2022 22:53

The results make no difference to the children!

quietnightmare · 13/05/2022 17:27

Good I'm glad the teachers helping the children. Year 6 SATS can cause unnecessary stress on some children, which is sad to see especially when the tests are all repeated in year 7 to determine class sets.

BadlydoneHelen · 13/05/2022 17:16

No such test anymore as mental maths though so I'm not sure what multiple choice paper a PP is referencing? I have done many years of being an invigilator scribe or prompter in SATS and knowing how closely we stick to the rules it's depressing to learn all these cheating stories. It doesn't surprise me though: a couple of local church schools that are Ofsted outstanding are renowned for getting 100% of their pupils through SATS. It's just not possible with a varied cohort including children with a variety of SEN unless you're either cheating or keeping them out of the testsHmm

MakkaPakkas · 13/05/2022 17:05

Yes, cheating and not all that uncommon. It definitely happened in a school I worked in.

Soapboxqueen · 13/05/2022 16:59

This has always gone on. Some schools more prolific and hands on than others.

Things have gone on that to my mind were against the rules, other schools being told were totally OK. 🤷🏻

Some children struggling because they don't quite meet the threshold for support, other children getting a level 4 (a few years ago now) based on one sentence he'd memorised from somewhere and we were worried it would impact his special school placement. No idea what the marker was thinking.

At any rate, for the most part, I couldn't care less. SATs are utterly stupid.

If staff are literally telling children what to write or altering answering themselves, I might be more concerned but otherwise..

Idbemonica1 · 13/05/2022 16:36

This has been going on for years, remember trying to let my daughter down gently by telling her "No, you definitly wont get to write that essay that you've been practising for weeks" in your Sats.
Day 1 of Sats, asked how it went, it was easy, we just wrote our story thst we've been practising.

exLtEveDallas · 13/05/2022 16:35

I’m not convinced that SATS make any difference to secondary sets. My poor DD bombed out in her maths papers with a full on anxiety attack in the middle of one of the papers. She missed almost half of the questions. Another child in her class wrote his name on the front of an English paper and then chucked it on the floor, refusing to complete.

Both got to secondary and were in the top sets from the start. They did CATS about 6 weeks in I think, and I know there was some movement in sets after (DD was most put out that she ‘lost’ a friend in class as a result).

I think this years SATS were quite hard. I was a prompter this year (have previously been a reader and a scribe) and there were definitely some questions that made me look twice. Very few of our children completed all the papers, most missed the last page or two in all the tests. I’ll admit it was very hard not to help, watching my lad get more and more frustrated it was all I could do to keep him reading the papers. I can sympathise with someone tempted to help them along, not someone who would blatantly tell an answer, but a “maybe you should look at that one again” could be forgiven.

MargaretThursday · 13/05/2022 16:20

Catshaveiteasy · 13/05/2022 09:21

Its 100% cheating and very much against the guidelines given which all staff involved in SATs should be trained in. You should report this.

Results are not being published this year but things like this are so unfair to schools like mine which follow the rules. We look bad for having lower results but we do often think some neighbouring schools may have cheated.

It's also not fair to the children.

I think this is quite a big thing. It penalises honest schools.
Plus I think it does effect the children. They know by year 6 that they haven't got it honestly, so it makes them nervous of being tested again.
Then you have their target grades/sets. Who cares, is what a lot of people are saying?
Having a child struggling in a set too hard for them, or being moved down may well be far more knocking to their confidence than scoring a few marks lower in SATS.
Ds' school uses target grades in doing internal tests. He's got a higher target than he's going to achieve in a lot of subjects (7). Often in internal tests they are aiming for no less than 2 grades below their target. So he'll come out indignant that he has to go back for a revision session because he scored a 4 in a subject that he'll be doing well to get a 5 in, and other children scored the same but don't have to go back because their target is a 6.

My dd was in the 2020 batch of GCSEs. Her school was pretty reasonably accurate on grades from what I've heard from her results and other parents. Other local schools were not, including one that predicted 9s across the board (when they normally have good but across the board grades).
DD points out that she is doubly disadvantaged: She didn't have inflated grades, but everyone assumes the grades were inflated.
But actually those who did get inflated grades have other issues. They didn't feel proud in the grades because they knew they were inflated. Some of them took A-level subjects that they have struggled immensely with. I know a number who have dropped a year to restart or are only taking 2 A-levels because they started with ones that they hoped to be able to do, and haven't coped. They're also extremely stressed about A-levels because they feel pressurised to live up to the grade they got, to prove it was right.
It may well help a number of them getting university places, but I think mentally it has been overall bad for them.
Yes GCSEs are bigger exams than SATS but the point is artificially inflating grades does not necessarily help the child.

pointythings · 13/05/2022 15:05

DockOTheBay · 13/05/2022 14:59

Wouldn't be surprised. I teach secondary school, and I've had more than one child put in top/middle set based on their SATs results, and then it became clear very quickly that they were below average ability and needed a lot more help than they were getting. One of them told me his teacher "told him what to write" in his SATs and it explained a lot.

And that's increadibly sad for everyone - it will knock the child's confidence, it makes the secondary look bad and it (justifiably) ruins the reputation of the original primary school. But the solution is to abandon this high stakes testing.

I do know there was a lot of movement in sets at my DDs' primary - they both started in middle sets and were in top sets by Yr 8. Students from other schools moved down. It was pretty clear which schools were playing it straight.

DockOTheBay · 13/05/2022 14:59

Wouldn't be surprised. I teach secondary school, and I've had more than one child put in top/middle set based on their SATs results, and then it became clear very quickly that they were below average ability and needed a lot more help than they were getting. One of them told me his teacher "told him what to write" in his SATs and it explained a lot.

Swipe left for the next trending thread