Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Housing price crash

534 replies

Eucalyptusbee · 12/05/2022 09:58

It's happening!

AIBU to be excited

OP posts:
Fluffycloudland77 · 12/05/2022 10:38

People have been saying this since 2008.

bumblefeline · 12/05/2022 10:38

Nice goady thread for a Thursday morning OP.

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 12/05/2022 10:38

Eucalyptusbee · 12/05/2022 10:09

Exciting because buying a home might become affordable again

No, it won't.

Chances are that exactly what happened last time will happen again. Many people living on the financial edge will go under with huge debts. Banks will pick up housing stock and will wait, mainly because lending criteria will be tightened so much that you and your DH won't be able to qualify. Interest rates will remain high, very high, like 20% high. Deposits required will be a minumum of 25/30% of the value of any property.

And all will return to 1970s, early 80s style of lending. Strict criteria, low multiples of salary, every bank having to clearly show that they have done due diligence on every applicant - so much so it will feel intrusive to an extent that nobody who has applied for a mortgage or loan in the last 20 years will recognise the situation.

Credit of any kind will be tightened, similarly intrusive searches will be done for applications of any reasonable sum.

All sorts of other financial issues wil happen as the housing crisis hits everything else and Loh! Another Credit Crunch. And this time happening to a generation of people who have never really had any experience of the utterly patriarchal banking system that treats everyone like small children. The clash between staid banking and the current commodity based society will ring loud.

Housing stock will be bought by larger firms, insurance companies, pension companies. Rents will increase - oh yes, you read that right! - and home ownership will recede even further.

Yes, some will strike it lucky, will have deposits etc ready to go and will be able to buy as the first tranche of housing hits the market combined with the government squashing lending rates. But they may become victims of the bounce, just like the second crash back in 1991 - the one everyone talks about which was the bounceback crash after the late 80s boom and bust. You have to wait for a few more years until it is safe to buy again.

We did that in 1989. Managed to buy a very cheap flat. But we were then unable to sell it for about 20 years because nobody would look at it. That effectively meant we had an unsaleable property, 100% negative equity. Houses were eventually cheaper, you got more for your money than if you bought a cheap to run, newish build flat. So we went to University instead, taking advantage of its cheap to runness. Eventually, in 2000, we sold the flat for what felt like a fortune, almost at the peak of its saleability. And found we couldn't afford to buy anywhere else. So we rented a property we couldn't afford to buy.

After another 20 years we have finally managed to buy another property. Far, far away from areas we would like to live, where we work. But it is a lovely house, nice place and we will be able to retire here without being too stretched.

So rein in that glee. Start looking up, reading around the realities of what might happen. Work out what your real situation is and what you really can afford. For example, we bought our cheap flat when interest rates were at about 8% - sounds horrendously high now but was relatively low back then. We worked out what we could afford at 20% and stuck with that. With our 1% over base rate mortgage the interest rates topped out at about 19% and we just managed to keep everything together and not lose it.

It was those who had bought relatively recently that got hit by that second hit. Those who had 2 year fixed rates that ended as the second wave came in. Young people who had thought they had caught the wave at the right time. Regardless what many here have said over the years, people really did hand their keys back to the bank and give up their homes. They couldn't afford the mortgage and nobody was buying. Banks ran out of patience or the ability to wait and so took back properties, which were then sold off cheaply to investment buyers, leaving the original mortgage holders with large debts! That won't be so easy these days as social housing won't be thre to pick up the pieces. Low as stock was back in the 90s it did exist, the 1988 Housing Act saw the development of Housing Associations, so they were in the first flush of building.

So, whilst your DH has some idea he hasn't got the whole picture. The whole picture is miserable! Much more so than now!

Stop smiling, start reseacrhing and checking your actual financial position!

Thehop · 12/05/2022 10:37

That’s an awful OP.

WhatsHoppening · 12/05/2022 10:36

Right...so OP owns a house...mortgage free...and is excited for a housing crash for her siblings? Seems legit.

ReeseWitherfork · 12/05/2022 10:35

Perhaps if your DH thinks he's so knowledgeable, he should talk to some older relatives who were adults in previous recessions.

if OPs DH is mid thirties then he is definitely old enough to be affected by the recession in ~2008. In theory he would have been leaving uni just as no one was hiring etc. I can’t picture a scenario where he somehow missed the fallout. Makes it all the more baffling.

Whinge · 12/05/2022 10:34

WhatsHoppening · 12/05/2022 10:30

Why would you be excited then if you have a house @Eucalyptusbee ? Are you excited for your mortgage payments to spiral beyond what you can afford? Are you looking forward the value of your biggest asset dropping considerably? As a homeowner there is literally nothing 'exciting' about a recession and market crash.

Agreed. I thought the OP was a FTB.

A housing crash is never a good thing, but being a FTB it would have at least helped explain why the OP might have been excited by the news. But I really can't wrap my head around anyone who owns a house being excited by a housing crash. Confused

SarahSissions · 12/05/2022 10:34

Prices will drop because people can’t afford to borrow in order to buy. Those who can’t afford now, won’t be able to afford in 6 months which is why prices will drop.
if interest rates go up and borrowing becomes more expensive then fewer people can afford to buy so demand drops and that is what drives prices down.
all this means is some people will go into negative equity and end up stuck in homes that aren’t suitable or others will lose their homes completely

Whammyyammy · 12/05/2022 10:34

Is it an inset day today?

Jizzle · 12/05/2022 10:34

Eucalyptusbee · 12/05/2022 10:09

Exciting because buying a home might become affordable again

I think you might need an economics lesson OP.

If house prices crash, that doesn't suddenly make them affordable to people who don't own a home. If there is a big crash, the banks will simply tighten up their lending criteria, meaning you will need say a 25%+ deposit and years and years of solid employment on very high salaries.

If the market crashed by 50% (massively unlikely imho) then a £700k house now costs £350k, but you need a deposit of nearly £90k and salaries of £50k plus. Saving for that kind of deposit, whilst rents go up massively as landlords mortgage rates go up, will be basically impossible for those not already on the ladder.

Don't get me wrong, i am a house owner and hope prices do correct, but don't believe for one minute this will help anyone except the wealthiest who can scoop up an additional property or two.

Aroundtheworldin80moves · 12/05/2022 10:34

There isn't magically more houses. There's still the same number, and the same number of people can buy one...

lassof · 12/05/2022 10:33

So things in shops will cost more and houses will cost less? Does that sound very likely?

amijustparanoidorjuststoned · 12/05/2022 10:32

Hi OP,

Sorry to burst your bubble but demand for housing is still very high in a lot of areas. The more demand = the higher prices will climb.

The market is definitely starting to slow in some areas (my area, actually!) but there is unlikely to be a crash unless there is suddenly too much housing and not enough buyers.

But you are right, it is slowing!

Eucalyptusbee · 12/05/2022 10:32

WhatsHoppening · 12/05/2022 10:30

Why would you be excited then if you have a house @Eucalyptusbee ? Are you excited for your mortgage payments to spiral beyond what you can afford? Are you looking forward the value of your biggest asset dropping considerably? As a homeowner there is literally nothing 'exciting' about a recession and market crash.

No mortgage and not planning on moving .

OP posts:
Eucalyptusbee · 12/05/2022 10:31

EmmaH2022 · 12/05/2022 10:28

OP "Husband (lawyer but studied economics and works closely in markets / property) said things looking very bleak, in 6m time we will long for today's prices / interest rates"

long for today's high prices?

As in things will cost even more in 6m / interest rates will be even higher.

Today's prices for goods / gas etc will seem cheap

OP posts:
LoveSpringDaffs · 12/05/2022 10:31

Hopefully people will see beyond your frankly ridiculous title and read the thread to realise you don't have a clue. Nor does your husband. One has to hope you've misunderstood his comment, or it's a real worry that he thinks that.

WhatsHoppening · 12/05/2022 10:30

Why would you be excited then if you have a house @Eucalyptusbee ? Are you excited for your mortgage payments to spiral beyond what you can afford? Are you looking forward the value of your biggest asset dropping considerably? As a homeowner there is literally nothing 'exciting' about a recession and market crash.

Swayingpalmtrees · 12/05/2022 10:29

The prices here are going up vertically with at least 6-10 cash buyers fighting over each one. A housing crash is NOT coming, I am sorry to ruin your day.

Demand is way outstripping supply, and that doesn't look likely to change for a very very long time. London is certainly being flooded with families from HK and China at the moment, and so many still looking to relocate to the country.

Nope, you are in for a long wait op

EmmaH2022 · 12/05/2022 10:28

OP "Husband (lawyer but studied economics and works closely in markets / property) said things looking very bleak, in 6m time we will long for today's prices / interest rates"

long for today's high prices?

3peassuit · 12/05/2022 10:28

People who were hurt by negative equity in 90s will be less excited by this. Also, prices aren’t coming down round here yet (Kent).

mooneclipse · 12/05/2022 10:26

Yes OP that would be marvellous news for FTB. They'll struggle to actually get a mortgage, there will be little coming on the market because everybody will be staying put, and every house they do offer on they will go to a cash buying landlord. Put the champagne on ice!

Getoffmyshoes · 12/05/2022 10:24

YABU

  1. because it’s pretty distasteful to be so gleeful about the possible misfortune of others

  2. because a crash (or even a dip) in the housing market won’t magically enable people to get on the property ladder. Firstly, if house prices are dropping then lenders will almost immediately tighten lending criteria - that 10% deposit you used to need will now be more like 25% or possibly even more, so if deposit is your problem, you’d actually be in a worse position. Secondly, people won’t be moving house due to not wanting/being able to afford to lose money, this will restrict the supply of housing and start to push prices back up if demand outstrips supply.

Bumtum126 · 12/05/2022 10:23

Yeah I wouldn't get your hopes up , might be a blip but unlikely to be a crash. House building is fairly low and demand is high . Don't need a degree to work out the rest.

NomenOmen · 12/05/2022 10:22

If there is a crash, aside from the reasons given by other posters above, it is likely to be horrible, since it will be unequally distributed. Rich areas will continue to see high demand which will keep prices up (in my city, mid-range priced houses, which admittedly are already ludicrously priced, get 30+ offers and go within a couple of days on the market), while the crash, if it happens, will destroy economies in poorer areas.

Whammyyammy · 12/05/2022 10:21

DappledShade · 12/05/2022 10:13

It wouldn't help people get on the ladder as lending would become far tighter and so it would be more difficult to get a mortgage. Might benefit those who are cash rich and can buy several properties cheap to sell after a dip. The Telegraph are always predicting this though and have been for about the last 10 years!

Exactly. Happened last time, lending criteria was tightened and only landlords with cash benefited.
Be careful what you wish for....

Swipe left for the next trending thread