Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Housing price crash

534 replies

Eucalyptusbee · 12/05/2022 09:58

It's happening!

AIBU to be excited

OP posts:
NellesVilla · 12/05/2022 11:58

Yay, OP!

I do not want anyone to lose their home but if they lose some of their properties, I personally couldn’t give a shit.

A decent one bedroom flat in my area is approx £250/275k. A tiny box. I’m single and currently on a low salary due to mental health, although I’m well qualified. Ain’t gonna get a mortgage currently, however many degrees I hold.

DomesticatedZombie · 12/05/2022 11:56

Eucalyptusbee · 12/05/2022 10:09

Exciting because buying a home might become affordable again

Yes.

FreddyVoorhees · 12/05/2022 11:56

You may see a correction, but you won't be seeing a crash anytime soon.

Too many people, not enough houses. If we need to build over 300,000 houses every single year for the foreseeable to deal with the current problem, there is no real economic reason for prices to massively decrease.

You may see prices decrease in areas now the rush to move for WFH etc has died down but as it is, prices will keep moving up accordingly.

TedMullins · 12/05/2022 11:52

LeftFootForward · 12/05/2022 11:50

On a personal level I would be happy with a crash as we have no mortgage and are looking to buy a second home, mainly with cash. However, on a countrywide level and considering others I would be happy with a cessation of the rising prices we currently have.

House prices have got beyond ridiculous and something really needs to be 'reset'.

if you think house prices are ridiculous (which they are) you could always not buy a second home and leave it for sale for someone who doesn't even have a first home yet!

SushiShopSearch · 12/05/2022 11:51

A house price crash is well overdue. If it hadn't been propped up after the GFC things would have been a lot better by now.

Jonny234 · 12/05/2022 11:50

I see a lot of interesting comments, imho the most notable from those who have lived through experiences and have first hand knowledge.

I think 2 things affect the housing market above all, unemployment levels and interest rates. Fortunately at the moment the first does not appear to be much of an issue.

Interest rates are an issue but before I get onto that something else unprecedented is at play. That is the balance of household expenditure. In the last 2 years of the pandemic many have had limited acess to spend money on other things such as eating out, foreign holidays, etc. This means more has been accumulated in savings, and more diverted towards household expenditure. This has fuelled the rising housing market.

What is occurring now is rebalancing back to historic norms. People are going out more, and spending more on non housing. Allied to this we have rising inflation which puts a further squeeze on household finances. The amount families have to spend on housing costs will definitely have fallen vs 12/18 months ago. I believe markedly so.

Then you throw rising interest rates into the mix and things get worse, its another squeeze.

So perhaps 12/18 months ago a household maybe had income of £3,000pm and spent £1,000 on a mortgage, and it was fine. But now that mortgage is £1,200 a month, their back in work and have travel expenses, want a new car, holiday, visiting friends, family etc, it all costs. Things are tough.

Now some may say it's fine because lots of mortgages are fixed. When these deals end people are in for a shock as the new deals will be far higher. Also you have another thing in play, if house prices fall, and I am sure they will, applicants then may be faced with a higher LTV. If I bought say a £300k property and had £75k deposit then I'd have 25% down and would get a deal considering that. If house prices fall even 5% my equity drops from £75k to £60k and that 25% deal is no longer on the table, so I drop to a 15% deal and pay even more.

People forget that mortgages are leveraged products, instead they look at the romanticism of the rising property market.

This will be painful. I would not be surprised if interest rates reach 3%, and this resulted in London prices falling 15-20%. Across the country I believe it will be more pronounced, perhaps 25%.

LeftFootForward · 12/05/2022 11:50

On a personal level I would be happy with a crash as we have no mortgage and are looking to buy a second home, mainly with cash. However, on a countrywide level and considering others I would be happy with a cessation of the rising prices we currently have.

House prices have got beyond ridiculous and something really needs to be 'reset'.

howtomoveforwards · 12/05/2022 11:50

I get if you're struggling to buy, it would be good news but it's poor taste not to consider the very many lives that will be impacted negatively by a housing crash.

Testina · 12/05/2022 11:48

Right, so someone who is lucky enough to own a house with no mortgage and doesn’t actually understand the wider economic consequences (but has a husband who might have attended an economy’s lecture 15 years ago) is excited?

🙄

BellePeppa · 12/05/2022 11:46

Sweetpeasaremadeforbees · 12/05/2022 11:33

I'm not sure why you think your DH having a degree in economics gives him a greater insight into the property market than any of us.

Anyway, I agree with what PPs have said, a housing crash would have a lot of negative consequences which aren't immediately obvious. Older homeowners will be less likely to downsize because they won't end up with as much cash to fund their life choices so larger family homes will still be in short supply. Older people going into care won't get as much money to self fund and the cost of care will fall back on the local council ( i.e. taxpayers like you and me). Just 2 consequences. Plus if some houseowners lose their homes they'll need rented accommodation and the competition will put rental prices up.

I agree with the pp who said we need wages to catch up with house prices. So I think stagnation is ok but a crash would be a disaster.

Stagnation is the better option. House prices rising and rising whilst wages never catch up is soul destroying. It won’t be long before a bog standard two up two down will cost a million pounds - I bought one a few years back (since sold) for £124k it’s now going for £400k which is absolutely nuts, it’s literally a two up two down. When you can’t afford to re-buy your own home as little as a year or two after buying it then something is very wrong.

oakleaffy · 12/05/2022 11:46

Housing price crash??
For the sakes of young people, I hope so.
but in our area , they are rising still with sealed bids for even ordinary Victorian terraces.

Useranon1 · 12/05/2022 11:45

As in things will cost even more in 6m / interest rates will be even higher.
Today's prices for goods / gas etc will seem cheap

And you're excited for this? And for your house price to fall? Bizarre.

TedMullins · 12/05/2022 11:45

If you buy a property surely you are acknowledging/accepting that its value can go down as well as up? People who wail about negative equity and treat it as some apocalyptic scenario seem not to have considered that with any asset driven by market forces, it's always a possibility. I say this as a homeowner. I didn't buy with any expectation that I'd accrue value in it, make a profit, or be able to 'move up the ladder', because thanks to bad housing policy over the last few decades the ladder no longer exists. If it never crossed your mind that you could end up in negative equity, you're naive imo. You're still more secure than non-homeowners – just stay put.

Marchitectmummy · 12/05/2022 11:43

Wishful thinking doesn't make it true. The cost of construction is rising massively, bricks rose 25% between Christmas and March due to CO2 shortages which has not been resolved. Just think about that and what developers might now be doing?

I can tell you what our clients are doing which is putting their sites not already started on hold. The knock on of that is supply will increase at a very slow rate until predictability returns or costs drop.

Without new builds, demand continues to outstrip supply, so unlikely prices will drop. We have just accepted an offer on our house and I would have loved the market to have dropped to reduce the gap to our next house but nope no drop in price here.

Riverlee · 12/05/2022 11:42

express

Sorry if this has been posted before, haven’t got time to read whole thread. However, this article suggests a fall but not a crash. Also, it will be harder for some people to get mortgages, as the criteria for getting them will be tightened.

Silversprinkles · 12/05/2022 11:41

@SamphirethePogoingStickerist excellent post but I fear wasted on our lovely OP

ReadyToMoveIt · 12/05/2022 11:41

Antarcticant · 12/05/2022 10:54

I am an avid RighMove watcher and I think 'stabilise' is more likely than 'crash'. What's happening in my area (Yorkshire) is that houses are going on at quite a high price, not selling for a couple of weeks, then being reduced and going very quickly.

Same in my area (Midlands)

MidnightMeltdown · 12/05/2022 11:40

Eucalyptusbee · 12/05/2022 10:08

www.telegraph.co.uk/business/2022/05/08/borrowed-time-bad-will-housing-crash-finally-comes/

Didn't mean to come across as gleeful. Just hoping that those left off the ladder might finally have an in after so long.

Husband (lawyer but studied economics and works closely in markets / property) said things looking very bleak, in 6m time we will long for today's prices / interest rates

Sigh. If you had any understanding economics you would know that a housing crash doesn't benefit first time buyers (unless they have an extremely large deposit. It benefits cash buyers (i.e. the rich)

gothereagain · 12/05/2022 11:40

Eucalyptusbee · 12/05/2022 10:09

Exciting because buying a home might become affordable again

They didn't last time.

Last crash mortgage rates went up, meaning people could borrow less and monthly repayments were higher. Fewer houses came on the market and sellers were less willing to take reductions due to risk of negative equity.

I bought in the last crash, but I was no better off than had I bought before the last crash as the mortgage repayment was higher (7.5% interest rate) and worries that they would crash further.

Rental prices won't come down either - higher demand for rental properties as homes get repossessed coupled with higher mortgage rates for landlords = higher rents.

Crashes are bad all round. They usually mean a bad economy with lots of people losing jobs. Higher cost of living means less affordability for mortgage calculations as well.

NotMyselfWithoutCoffee · 12/05/2022 11:39

@Bluevelvetsofa

Yep, my dh and I scrimped and saved for our house over many years, a housing market crash right now wouldn't benefit us.
We have a 2 year old ds and are hoping to move into a more suitable family home.
Nice to know there are people who would be cheering if we lost all our money/equity just because we own a home, although I can't see any evidence of this "crash".

Silversprinkles · 12/05/2022 11:39

WhatsHoppening · 12/05/2022 10:36

Right...so OP owns a house...mortgage free...and is excited for a housing crash for her siblings? Seems legit.

GrinGrinGrin thinking exactly the same!

BellePeppa · 12/05/2022 11:38

YANBU. I’m so sick of headlines that treat house price rises as a thing to celebrate. They’re only good if you’re downsizing and paid your mortgage years before. I remember when houses were homes not short term profit makers. I’m not sure if it will actually happen though.

Xenia · 12/05/2022 11:37

Some of us have sufferd under it before. In the 1980s we locked in one interest rate of 13% for ten years as that cheaper than our mortgage interest rate! Then we sold two buy to let flats in London and ou rhouse for much less than we bought them, about 50% less for the flats, to buy our house in 1997. I haev neve rmade capital gains I could use to set the losses on the flats against never mind the then called "DVI" losses on the rentals either. So for some of us housing has not been a one way street. I intend to die in my current house so if prices fall that is no issue for me and if they rise no benefit.

However if prices fall it will make it easier for my 5 children to move up to a bigger place more easily - all 5 own a place as I don't really mind if prices fall.

There are still some 95% mortgage out thre by the way so for a couple both working full time buying before they have babies (what we, my children and my parents all had to do - my parents put babies off for nearly 10 year in order to buy in Newcastle) for £350k your 5% deposit is £8750 for each person - 2.5% each - in the couple - which is not an impossible sum to save with 2 full time professional salaries.

terriblyangryattimes · 12/05/2022 11:34

Not happening here. A house 2 doors down has gone on the market for 100k more than what we bought ours for 14 months ago. They are the same layout\spec inside. Ridiculous.

over2021 · 12/05/2022 11:34

Guess what happens to mortgage interest rates when the housing market crashes? A downturn in the general economy normally means less disposable income, fewer jobs, less borrowing which all drive interest rates up.

Let's say prices drop by 40%. You have a deposit saved of £30k and presently the house you are buying is £260k so you need a £230k mortgage. A £230k mortgage over 25 years at 3% is £1,091.

The price drops 40% to £156,000 but demand for the property is now high because people can't afford to move if they are in negative equity and housing stock is low. Interest rates are rising... You get lucky and get the house but still need a mortgage of £126,000. A £126k mortgage over 25 years at 10% is £1,145.

Who wins OP?

P.S no economics or law degree- just Google.