Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think boys aren’t necessarily ‘harder work’ than girls?

130 replies

Cinnabomb · 12/05/2022 08:07

Wondering what wider opinion on this is. I have a toddler DD who, like all toddlers, has her moments, but I guess generally is pretty good apart from a few idiosyncrasies eg fussy eating. She is however extremely active, never sits still and into climbing etc, so definitely not the stereotypical “quiet sit on your lap” type little girl. We also had a horrendous start and she was a very difficult newborn so I feel we deserve our relatively easy time now, ……and she’s not even 2 yet so plenty of time for her to turn into a horror 😬

All of my friends that have boys of a similar age are adamant that boys are ‘harder’ to parent, eg more boisterous, less compliant and more full on. A lot are quite physical with other children eg pushy/ bundling and again they often say that boys will just be boys. Most either just have the one child, a DS, or multiple boys but no girls so I don’t think it’s really a fair comparison.

so what does MN think? Are girls ‘easier’ as young children? Surely it’s child/ personality dependant? I’m also 20 weeks pregnant with a boy so interested!

OP posts:
Abhannmor · 12/05/2022 09:45

C8H10N4O2 · 12/05/2022 08:16

No they are not automatically harder, they are largely made harder by societal expectations of boys and girls and the endless "boys will be boys" nonsense.

However hard you try to treat them the same there will be people, including in childcare and education who will treat boys and girls differently and then cite the resulting behaviour as "proof" that boys are somehow harder.

This is so true. I went to pick the kids up once and they were all waiting patiently in line to be collected. ' The girls are much quieter as usual ' said a teacher. I couldn't see or hear any difference and said so. She told me it was 'only banter' rather huffily . It's as if they need boys and girls to conform to stereotypes? You'd wonder how these unconscious biases play out in the classroom.

Keepitonthedownlow · 12/05/2022 09:45

The conditioning of children starts as soon as they're born. Look at this toy experiment. Swap the clothes and people start treating the babies differently....

PugInTheHouse · 12/05/2022 09:44

We have shown our boys all different types of hobbies (dancing, theatre, sport) and film genres. They both hated dancing and loved football/cricket. They much prefer action films etc. This doesn't mean they like it because they are boys but it also isn't because society has shaped them.

I find it really sad that the assumption is if boys like 'boyish' stuff it must be because it has been pushed on them, same for girls.

Polpetto · 12/05/2022 09:44

I would say that all the toddler boys I have ever met (even my shy quiet and in other ways “feminine” son) have LOVED sticks. Does anyone on this thread have a son that didn’t?

I can assure you I never encouraged this in my child (nor did I discourage it but when we had a bonfire sized pile in the garden I started to suggest we left them in the woods).

WandaWomblesaurus · 12/05/2022 09:43

My friends with boys had a tougher time than me with girls. Anecdotal of course.

AmbushedByCake · 12/05/2022 09:43

Both my DD and DS were absolutely crackers as toddlers and preschoolers. Nearly broke me! At least DS slept...

Dammitthisisshit · 12/05/2022 09:43

m.youtube.com/watch?v=nWu44AqF0iI

3 minutes on a simple small study on the was we treat babies. of course societal expectations have ‘weighed children down’ by the time they reach school. They react to the stimulus around them!

LondonJax · 12/05/2022 09:42

If it's any consolation my mum always reminded me of a chat she had with our then GP when I was three years old in the mid 1960s. They'd just had my younger sister and mum was tired. I was the first born so mum was still in the 'give your child lots of attention' stage with me whilst also trying to split that attention with a baby.

I was always on the go and mum asked the GP what she could do about it. His reply was 'she's three years old, what would you like her to do, sit in a corner all day and play quietly? I'd be more concerned if she did that'.

He did then talk to mum about things like getting me into a nursery for a couple of days a week (which she did and which I loved) and not worrying if I was tearing around the house as long as I was safe if she was dealing with my baby sister or having a quiet sit down herself. He suggested giving me little jobs to do like bringing the baby cream or helping with feeding my sister. And he told her to stop feeling obliged to play all the time with me as children need to learn to do stuff independently and that starts with play. So girls can be riotous and boys can be quiet little things. It's a personality thing I think.

But my mum did enjoy quoting back the 'what would you like her to do' comment at all her daughters when the time came for them to have the toddlers that ran us ragged!

fishonabicycle · 12/05/2022 09:42

Not in my experience. My son was extremely easy from about 3 months onwards. He's 21 now and never been difficult!

lonelyapple · 12/05/2022 09:40

Boys are more physical (when young) but as teenagers less bitchy and don't have big falling outs with their friends in my experience.

PugInTheHouse · 12/05/2022 09:40

I know quite a few teachers and they say they prefer to teach girls till about age 9 or 10 then would prefer boys after that.

My 2 boys have always been sporty but not boisterous. 2 of the children in our friendship group (HV group from birth of abput 10 children) 1 boy who was how boys are typically described, would run off, climb and generally be boisterous, 1 girl who was similar but also would hit and generally be spiteful to the others. All the others were similar, not that much difference in behaviour before school age. Now they are 16 and all good kids. The same 1 girl has always been the most difficult of them all throughout all ages but is a lovely person. The boy was fine once at school.

Norgie · 12/05/2022 09:39

My boys were always easier than my girls, at every age.

DropYourSword · 12/05/2022 09:37

JassyRadlett · 12/05/2022 09:25

(Sorry, that was quite arsey. But we have absolutely no way to know if the differences we see are innate because of the way we treat boys and girls differently, a lot of the time totally unconsciously, from the moment they're born.)

It was pretty arsey. You can disagree with me without being rude.

Of course their upbringing has an influence. But also, if all thyroid young girls were absolutely so desperate to run around, I'm sure they would. At 5/6 years old I don't think societal expectations have weighed them down SO MUCH that they can completely override an internal imperative to run around like a lunatic.

ChairCareOh · 12/05/2022 09:37

This reply has been deleted

Withdrawn at the user's request

Glitterspy · 12/05/2022 09:36

Parents who only have girls haven’t seen, man. They don’t know!!!

Dammitthisisshit · 12/05/2022 09:35

Nah it’s conditioning.
even before they’re born boys are expected to be rougher. Boys are brought up to be ‘little soldiers’ and encouraged to be more physical. Girls are brought up to be ‘little princesses’.

I remember disciplining my girls for running around whacking each other with sticks, to be told ‘oh well boys will just do that’. No- most kids do it unless they’re taught not to.

even in households where things are pretty equal for different sexes, girls and boys get different stimulation outside the home.

I had an argument with my DC nursery when they referred to ‘boys toys’ and ‘girls toys’.

pre puberty there’s nothing inherently different, but right from conception we train them to be different. So I guess it’s a self fulfilling prophecy- we expect them to be different so they are.

User310 · 12/05/2022 09:34

I have found that from 0-3, boys are harder to parent than a girl. However, I do find that boys are more affectionate and loving than girls when they are young.

headbored · 12/05/2022 09:34

In my opinion (I have two of each and have patented them as equally as possible)

Boys are harder are toddlers, girls are harder from about 8years and definitely more difficult as teens

HotDogKetchup · 12/05/2022 09:32

Children are all different. I have two boys. One was a terror toddler and baby. The second is so so chilled in comparison. I suspect he’ll have his moments but he’s just a more laid back character. I’m sure they’re terrors and treasures in girls too!

Dinoteeth · 12/05/2022 09:30

Parenting is never easy.

Boys tend to be more physical, nosier or something. It's not the first time on a boy/boy play date we've bailed out to softplay or the park. They just need to run off that energy and seem to charge of each other.
I've never felt we needed to get out the house when my friends with girls have been round.

I also think girls are more likely to sit and draw than boys, one of mine loved to drop the crayons rather than draw with them.

wonderstuff · 12/05/2022 09:28

My dd was definitely harder as a toddler than my ds (although he had his moments). Now they are both at secondary ds is definitely more work but I know people with easy boys and difficult girls.

the excusing boisterous behaviour in boys thing has been studied and we definitely gender our expectations of very small children.

Comedycook · 12/05/2022 09:27

Ok and I know kids who are also the complete opposite? Again like neither of the parents especially not of the same sex. Doesn’t mean it’s thing just because it is for yours.

Correct. There are overall trends within society. There are always outliers though. On a whole though, if you observe a class of boys and girls, the boys will be more boisterous. That doesn't mean there won't be boisterous girls or quiet boys. There will be.

KevinTheKoala · 12/05/2022 09:25

I've only got girls - the elder has never sat still, never stopped talking - even in her sleep 😂 is loud, finds all things poo and fart related hilarious and is far more 'boistrous' than her peers. The younger one on the other hand is quiet, creative and will happily sit and be read books all day if she could. So I think it is partly personality driven - however I also have three nephews who are all out of control! (all have different parents), they are more violent which I've been lucky to never have a problem with pushing/hitting/biting etc. they all seem to listen less, have more attitude, argue back more and break things more. I'm not totally convinced it isn't down to parenting in some regards but to be honest after seeing how they are, I am quite relieved I don't have a boy because that scares me. (Although my friends little boy is a really sweet, sensitive child who is much quieter than my eldest DD)

JassyRadlett · 12/05/2022 09:25

(Sorry, that was quite arsey. But we have absolutely no way to know if the differences we see are innate because of the way we treat boys and girls differently, a lot of the time totally unconsciously, from the moment they're born.)

JassyRadlett · 12/05/2022 09:23

As much as it pains me to admit (as I used to argue that gender differences only existed because of internal bias!) I see how boys and girls behave differently at school drop off. The boys are way more physical- running around, playing tag, jumping and climbing and being loud. The girls generally are quieter and sit talk or play less physical games.

OMG you're absolutely right, it's totally innate and children have absolutely not experienced any gendered socialisation before they reach school age.