Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think boys aren’t necessarily ‘harder work’ than girls?

130 replies

Cinnabomb · 12/05/2022 08:07

Wondering what wider opinion on this is. I have a toddler DD who, like all toddlers, has her moments, but I guess generally is pretty good apart from a few idiosyncrasies eg fussy eating. She is however extremely active, never sits still and into climbing etc, so definitely not the stereotypical “quiet sit on your lap” type little girl. We also had a horrendous start and she was a very difficult newborn so I feel we deserve our relatively easy time now, ……and she’s not even 2 yet so plenty of time for her to turn into a horror 😬

All of my friends that have boys of a similar age are adamant that boys are ‘harder’ to parent, eg more boisterous, less compliant and more full on. A lot are quite physical with other children eg pushy/ bundling and again they often say that boys will just be boys. Most either just have the one child, a DS, or multiple boys but no girls so I don’t think it’s really a fair comparison.

so what does MN think? Are girls ‘easier’ as young children? Surely it’s child/ personality dependant? I’m also 20 weeks pregnant with a boy so interested!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
HotDogKetchup · 12/05/2022 17:44

FiveNineFive · 12/05/2022 12:34

My ds wasn't badly behaved but if you didn't take him out every day to burn his energy he'd literally be bouncing off the walls.

I have exactly the same experience...with my daughter.

Mine too. I do not understand how people can stay home all day with toddlers.

Squashpocket · 12/05/2022 12:38

I think all children are different, but in general boys are more physical, boisterous and less compliant than girls.

I don't think it's necessarily harder, just different. I can exercise the boisterousness out of my 2 boys, whereas my friends little girl is very good and will sit nicely but my god does she whinge all day long. I know which I prefer.

The bit I struggle with is society's expectation that boys will listen, sit still and behave at 4 years old when they are not developmentally ready for that (in general, I know some will be, but mine were finally ready for school sometime during y1 frankly). It's very unfair for them and sets them up as 'bad boys'.

FiveNineFive · 12/05/2022 12:34

My ds wasn't badly behaved but if you didn't take him out every day to burn his energy he'd literally be bouncing off the walls.

I have exactly the same experience...with my daughter.

PrettyMaybug · 12/05/2022 12:31

My take on it is (and this is JMO) that boys are harder work when they're younger. I have 2 girls, but I knew many people with boys - boys only, and a mixture of boys and girls, and also knew 5 or 6 childminders who looked after boys and girls.

Every last one without fail, said that girls were easier to look after. They occupied themselves, and were less whiny, moany, and clingy. (Don't shoot the messenger! This is what they said.) Girls would sit and draw or paint or read a book, boys wanted to be entertained and occupied, and were much more energetic and demanding. I had several friends who had a nightmare with demanding noisy clingy boys, and I was like 'awwww, my lovely girls are so sweet... And they were... honestly! Would sit there good as gold, reading and watching TV with me, or going for a nice walk.

However...When it came to the teen years, my 'slightly smug mummy of girls' stance was shot down! They turned into little beasts. There's one and a half years between them, and from 13 y.o. and 14½ y.o. they were very hard work, for about 5 years! They would accuse me and their dad of favouring the other, they started swearing, their bedrooms became untidy, and they became lazy.

They got on OK half the time, but sometimes they seemed to HATE each other. They fought physically, they shouted at each other and insulted each other, they got into big arguments with girls at school, and there was always something going on, I fell out with multiple mums because of their arguments, they both started smoking (stopped after a few months thank God.)

One got a small illegal tattoo on her thigh at 15, one got pissed on a bottle of wine at 16, and was puking all over my best rug, and they sneaked out of the upstairs bedrooms (3 or 4 times,) to go to parties that were being held some 10 minutes walk away, at someone's house where everyone was 18-22 and they were 15-16. We had to drag them back kicking and screaming from these bloody parties. They were sullen and grumpy half the time and only seemed to want us for lifts and money! And they only seemed to come home for food, and to sleep!

They were a dream as children (pre-teens,) loving, kind, funny, well-behaved, did well at school, easy to look after, helped around the house, were brilliant to travel with, and always good fun on holiday, and great to go shopping with and to take to my friends and families homes. And then they hit their teens, and were REALLY hard work. Other girls were mean bullies too, and girl bullies are far worse than boy bullies IME and IMO. It's more cruel and insidious with girls...

Right up to about 18-19 really, we had hard times with them... A good 5 years of hard work and headaches. Was a relief when they went to uni!!! They both went together. (at 18 and 19.)The older one had gap year and so they were both at uni at the same time.

They're mid to late 20s now, and are grown adults with their own home, career, and life, and are wonderful young women. Lovely, kind, lots of fun, and amazing human beings. And we're really close. Though me and DH only see them once every 2-3 weeks as they live 20 and 30 miles away. We are in touch most days via social media and whasapp though. Smile So it's turned back around again. Angels to demons, and then back to Angels!

Oh btw, my friends/acquaintances who had boys seemed to have very little trouble when they hit their teens. Some of them had none. And now the boys are grown THEY are good people too, with their own life, home, and careers. So yep, upshot is, they're all pretty much hard work sometimes, and easy work/lots of fun at other times. Like all of us really. So all in all, neither one is harder than the other.

That was a bit long sorry! Blush

Comedycook · 12/05/2022 12:30

She punched a little boy in the eye last week after he stole her glasses and honestly it’s so hard to balance the messages of “be kind, use your words” but also wanting her to keep that fiery spirit and stick up for herself!

I bet if you had a son who punched someone at school you wouldn't be describing it as a "fiery spirit" 🙄

PrettyMaybug · 12/05/2022 12:30

YANBU.

riotlady · 12/05/2022 12:23

Wish someone would have given my DD the memo! She’s brilliant but incredibly lively and physical.

She punched a little boy in the eye last week after he stole her glasses and honestly it’s so hard to balance the messages of “be kind, use your words” but also wanting her to keep that fiery spirit and stick up for herself!

Comedycook · 12/05/2022 12:13

sweeneytoddsrazor · 12/05/2022 11:24

Having a couple of each, I think generally boys are easier but it would depend on your definition of easy. Yes they preferred to be outside, but they were quite happy once we had arrived somewhere to run around kicking a ball and generally this meant I could sit down and watch them with minimal intervention necessary so actually fairly relaxing. Girls were more happy to stay in but needed constant help with craft activities and omg clearing up glitter day after day.
Also fall outs with friends the boys and their friends fell out less but occasionally got a bit physical ( all pulled up and dealt with by parents) all sorted and forgotten about in minutes, whereas the girls all seemed to bear grudges that went on for days bringing a different type of stress. Generally the boys I know are more loving at a younger age but this changes as they get older.

Agree with all of this. My children sound very similar to yours in terms of preferred activities and how they deal with friendship issues. I remember my ds coming home from school telling me his friend had punched him...I said "I thought you were friends" he just shrugged "yeah we're still best friends". Then it was forgotten about

fireandlight · 12/05/2022 11:47

My sweet, easy going boy is a million times easier than my strong minded, independent girl. I think that can change at different stages of life though, my very easy niece was a nightmare teen for example. Boys might be a bit more physical, although that's not always the case, but often aren't so invested in friendships and therefore get over issues faster. All generalisations though.

JesusSufferingFuck22 · 12/05/2022 11:45

In my experience boys are harder physically and girls are harder psychologically.

thing47 · 12/05/2022 11:42

Thanks @JollyWilloughby , it's nice to know mine isn't a total outlier! It was a bit of a shock as DS and DD1 were much more laid back. I used to say if I'd had her first instead of third, she'd be an only child Grin.

So I'm very much in the camp of it being down to personality rather than sex.

That said, in my observation young boys do seem to need a level of physical play which most girls don't. The fact that I have a DD who does need that physicality hasn't changed my general view.

AryaStarkWolf · 12/05/2022 11:38

I hate that gendered shite, children are their person with their own personalities, some will be easier than others

Lunalicious · 12/05/2022 11:30

I have both boys and girls and my girls are actually harder work. It is just their personalities though, rather than because of their sex.

CouldIBeAnymoreOuting · 12/05/2022 11:26

Well I only have boys (quite a few of them!) and have been told many times that girls are much harder. It’s one of those things people love to generalise about. I think it depends on the individual, not the sex.

Misspacorabanne · 12/05/2022 11:24

I must add though that they are super loving, cuddly and very affectionate, they tell me they love me so many times a day, and throw their arms around me!!! I wouldn't change having boys for anything!

sweeneytoddsrazor · 12/05/2022 11:24

Having a couple of each, I think generally boys are easier but it would depend on your definition of easy. Yes they preferred to be outside, but they were quite happy once we had arrived somewhere to run around kicking a ball and generally this meant I could sit down and watch them with minimal intervention necessary so actually fairly relaxing. Girls were more happy to stay in but needed constant help with craft activities and omg clearing up glitter day after day.
Also fall outs with friends the boys and their friends fell out less but occasionally got a bit physical ( all pulled up and dealt with by parents) all sorted and forgotten about in minutes, whereas the girls all seemed to bear grudges that went on for days bringing a different type of stress. Generally the boys I know are more loving at a younger age but this changes as they get older.

JollyWilloughby · 12/05/2022 11:23

@Misspacorabanne

Same, I used to watch my boys tumbling around together on the trampoline engaging in rough play. They would laugh and laugh and laugh.

My daughter would try and engage in the rough play but we had to stop her as she was taking it too far and I was quite concerned she was going to knock one of their teeth out 😂😂! I think she used to forget the “play” aspect 🤦‍♀️.

Misspacorabanne · 12/05/2022 11:20

Most people I know (mum's of both girls and boys) tell me it's the girls that are harder at a young age! I've heard alot that boys are more chilled/laid back than girls, but I only have boys so can't answer myself! Although mine are quite chilled themselves, but do alot of playfighting/rough play!

JollyWilloughby · 12/05/2022 11:16

@thing47

Same as my daughter. Incredibly strong willed and knows exactly what she wants and when. She told me from a very young age she didn’t need advising on anything because “she already knew everything” 🤦‍♀️. I have no doubt these traits will stand her in good stead for later years but sweet lord…..

My sons on the other hand are much more the people pleasing type. I’ve told them people pleasing is unnecessary but it seems to be in their nature. They’re also far more likely to swing their arms around me than my daughter. She will hug me of course, but on her terms only 😂.

thing47 · 12/05/2022 11:08

When I only had boys people would say to me ' you're so lucky to have boys: girls are so independent ' and I would wonder why they thought independence was a bad thing. Now I get it! DD is incredibly strong willed and stubborn and from very early on wanted to do everything herself and would push you away if you tried to help her. These are qualities which will probably be an asset when she's older but make for difficult parenting of a small child.

Hah, yes, this is my life @capricorn12! DD2 was the child who questioned everything, still does. When she asks for advice, she's not really looking for advice, she wants a sounding board but she's already made up her mind whatever her parents may say. Her physical appearance fooled everyone into thinking she was a girly girl. Nope. Her idea of a party outfit was a black T and combat trousers. She could never see a puddle without jumping in it. Very active and forever breaking things – at 10 she had had more GAs and operations than her age. It was exhausting.

She's grown up now and is the same character, but if it's any consolation those traits now manifest themselves as being very focused and determined. She's highly qualified academically (in STEM), travels widely on her own, has played a high level of sport, and believes there is nothing she can't do if she sets her mind to it. It's still exhausting but now it's rewarding too and I love having a daughter who is completely her own person.

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 12/05/2022 10:45

I have to say, my DP's little nephew is the most compliant boy I've ever seen, he's just so obedient.
I have to admit, DP and I are trying for a baby, I'm terrified of having a boy, mine and my dad's relationship wasn't the best during my teenage, early adult yrs.

It was like a clash of the titans.

Swayingpalmtrees · 12/05/2022 10:41

I have teen girls and I have found them easy and effortless. They are very independent.

JollyWilloughby · 12/05/2022 10:37

I can only speak from my own experience. I have two sons and one daughter.

My daughter was a lot easier during her toddler years than both of my sons.

They are all tweens and teens now though and my sons are definitely easier at this stage than my daughter, god love her she is absolutely fab though 😂!!

She dances, and they both play football so personally I love being a dance mum AND a football mum. I am blessed.

Swayingpalmtrees · 12/05/2022 10:33

I don't envy my friends having to stand on freezing rugby pitches for hours on end just to be able to get a minutes peace every weekend.

Nor the endless fighting that seems to feature. I am not into stereotyping but the actual physical violence between boys shocked me (friend has 4 boys) and they fight non stop, and charge around all the time. It DOES in fact look much harder to me, and I am being honest. I couldn't do it. It makes me stressed just being there.

Chicci1 · 12/05/2022 10:33

I think as small children boys are much harder. I was at a twin birthday party recently - one table of 15 five year old boys and the other of 15 five year old girls. It was like night and day. The girls all coloured and chatted quietly. It was carnage at the boys table. There was a food fight, a couple of physical fights and the colouring pages were turned into spit balls!! I think it reverses at about ten though and the girls get harder then.