Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think my dentist is very stuck up

191 replies

cuppateaandabiccie · 11/05/2022 19:31

Was at the dentist today for my routine check up. I have never had a problem with her before in all the years I have been a patient at her surgery, but today it just felt like she was in a foul mood but I think she came across as quite stuck up and arrogant.

let’s say I’m called Sandra and say she’s called Barbara Brown (just a random name) officially she is called Dr Brown.

i was waiting at reception to be called for my appointment, she came to reception and called my name so I got up and walked over and I said “hi Barbara, how are you” then her response was quite sharp.

she had a face like thunder and she said something like “Sorry Sandra, my name is Dr Brown. In future, you call me Dr Brown”

I was really shocked and taken aback - there was no conversation from her during my appointment, usually she is quite chatty and friendly. All she did was tut and sigh.

AIBU to think this was quite unprofessional and arrogant? Why can’t I call her by her first name? She’s not God!

OP posts:
mathanxiety · 11/05/2022 21:15

My dentist practice (in the US) uses Dr Firstname for all of the dentists in the office, male and female, and even when they're addressing each other at work. It's a family business and they all have the same surname, which accounts for the use of the first names, but they still obv prefer to keep that distance between patient and dentist, and accord each other the professional respect that is owed to each one.

If I ever bump into any of them when out and about (we live in the same general neck of the woods) I say Hi Dr Firstname. We're not friends socially so I would never assume a first name only would be ok.

Reallyreallyborednow · 11/05/2022 21:10

A PhD / doctoral qual is not that impressive especially if your social skills are shit

in my experience most postdocs only use Dr in writing. Day to day it’s first names.

Most dentists aren’t post doctoral though. The Dr is a courtesy title for a postgrad.

mathanxiety · 11/05/2022 21:09

Agree with @Babdoc.

It's disrespectful and cheeky to assume first names are ok in a professional setting.

mathanxiety · 11/05/2022 21:08

YABU.

She is a dentist, she was at work, and you are her patient.

Maybe she's had one too many run ins with patients who assume because she's a woman they can be more familiar than she's comfortable with.

You should respect the fact that she worked hard to get that Dr in front of her name, and use her title when you are seeing her professionally.

Unless you're bosom pals you should also use it if you bump into her in the supermarket, etc.

MyCatKeepsRumblingTheDog · 11/05/2022 21:07

She was rude and weird, I work at a University and we call everyone including the Vice-Chancellor by their first names. I’d be asking her to call you Mrs/Ms … and going elsewhere. A PhD / doctoral qual is not that impressive especially if your social skills are shit.

luckylavender · 11/05/2022 21:06

cuppateaandabiccie · 11/05/2022 19:31

Was at the dentist today for my routine check up. I have never had a problem with her before in all the years I have been a patient at her surgery, but today it just felt like she was in a foul mood but I think she came across as quite stuck up and arrogant.

let’s say I’m called Sandra and say she’s called Barbara Brown (just a random name) officially she is called Dr Brown.

i was waiting at reception to be called for my appointment, she came to reception and called my name so I got up and walked over and I said “hi Barbara, how are you” then her response was quite sharp.

she had a face like thunder and she said something like “Sorry Sandra, my name is Dr Brown. In future, you call me Dr Brown”

I was really shocked and taken aback - there was no conversation from her during my appointment, usually she is quite chatty and friendly. All she did was tut and sigh.

AIBU to think this was quite unprofessional and arrogant? Why can’t I call her by her first name? She’s not God!

Well you've never had a problem with her before in all the years you've been seeing her - your words. Do you know her personally? Otherwise it does seem very odd to call her by her first name.

Elsiebear90 · 11/05/2022 21:06

I think it’s a reaction to sexism they face, I’ve worked with doctors for years and noticed female doctors are often assumed to be nurses and male members of staff are often assumed to be doctors. I’ve heard female doctors be called “love”and “bab” by patients and other staff, this never happens to male doctors. Unless I know a doctor well I will always refer to them as Dr X as a sign of respect. So I can’t really blame her for insisting people refer to her by her title at work, she’s worked hard for it and probably has y frequently assume she’s not a doctor because of her sex.

DangerouslyBored · 11/05/2022 21:05

Prestissimo · 11/05/2022 20:03

It doesn't sound like she handled it very well, but just to maybe give the other side. I'm a GP and when I go to work I 'put my game face on' for want of a better description and I'm Dr Prestissimo. This is maybe more important because I live and work in the same place, so sometimes treat my friends and neighbours. I always introduce myself as Dr Prestissimo because that's my role as much as my working name.

Also (and I'm not saying this is the case with you OP), but often it feels as though the patients who call me by my first name are playing power games of some kind - they're usually older than me, often men, or the incite their great friendship with Dr SeniorPartner (called by their first name) from back in the day... It's almost an intimidation tactic and feels a bit off.

So I do try to stick to Dr, but I hope I do it more politely than your dentist managed. Sounds like there was more going on here than you were privy to.

It seems that the trend now is for younger GPs to call themselves Dr Christian name. I like that. They are still a doctor but the first name only softens things, makes things a bit friendlier / warmer

cuppateaandabiccie · 11/05/2022 21:03

to the PP who asked, she isn’t young. She’s in her mid 50s

OP posts:
DoubleYolker · 11/05/2022 21:01

Nancydrawn · 11/05/2022 20:53

You have no idea what's going on. Obviously she shouldn't have snapped at you, but it's also possible, for instance, that she keeps getting called Barbara but her male colleagues Dr. Smith and Dr. Jones and she's really sick of the differential. I don't think it's weird or wrong to want to have a title that you're, well, entitled to.

I was thinking exactly this. I’m a doctor and used to introduce myself by my first name until I got fed up of being referred to as a nurse, when my male colleagues were always correctly identified as doctors.

And, no, there’s absolutely nothing wrong with nurses, but I’m not one and it’s important the patient understands the role of the clinician they’ve seen. It’s the everyday sexism that got to me. I now no longer introduce myself by my first name.

DangerouslyBored · 11/05/2022 21:01

Babdoc · 11/05/2022 19:59

I’m older generation (in my 60s), and, for most of my contemporaries, Christian names are for friends and family only - one waits for permission to use them for anyone else.
So in your example, you would always address her as (title surname), unless or until she says “Oh please call me (Christian name)”.
I must admit, I grit my teeth if a young nurse addresses me by first name instead of Dr Babdoc! It is disrespectful and cheeky.

Why is it rude to call you by your name? Confused such a bizarre and antiquated viewpoint

OooohAhhhh · 11/05/2022 20:58

You don't know someone's circumstances. Anything could have happened to put her in a bad mood, we all have our off days.
As for Dr, that's her title, she has worked hard for it & achieved it.
If you're not normally chitty chatty or on first term names, then I would refer to her as Dr anyway.

cuppateaandabiccie · 11/05/2022 20:58

Her poor dental nurse looked anxious. Her face said it all.

OP posts:
cuppateaandabiccie · 11/05/2022 20:57

She was just horrible today. That’s the worst I’ve ever seen her. So tense and moody.

im already dreading my next appointment! Seriously considering putting in a complaint to the practice manager!

OP posts:
EgonSpengler2020 · 11/05/2022 20:57

But is she a good dentist?

Remember HCPs are human too and have bad days, it doesn't mean it is okay, but so long as she didn't following her snappy retort with a dental extraction without local anaethesia then just accept that maybe she has some nasty shit going on in her life and be compassionate and grateful that she came to work rather than calling in sick/ compassionate leave, and thus cancelling your appointment.

NewJerseyWater · 11/05/2022 20:55

What a twat. 😂

Although I don’t think I’ve ever called my dentist by any name and I’ve been a patient of hers for 15 years. I just say hi. She’s lovely though and I’m very grateful for that as I’ve had a couple of very abrupt dentists before that. Put her in your phone as Dr. Twat.

Nancydrawn · 11/05/2022 20:53

You have no idea what's going on. Obviously she shouldn't have snapped at you, but it's also possible, for instance, that she keeps getting called Barbara but her male colleagues Dr. Smith and Dr. Jones and she's really sick of the differential. I don't think it's weird or wrong to want to have a title that you're, well, entitled to.

Bickles · 11/05/2022 20:51

The Dr thing is so complicated, I hate it.
In this country medical doctors are called Dr but surgeons are Mr/ Miss. Dental surgeons have therefore always been Mr/ Miss.
In Europe and the US even surgeons are Dr. Dentists are all called Dr, so the GDC and BDA said U.K. dental surgeons could use Dr to be in line with the rest of the world.
I am married but practice in my maiden name so would either be Miss Maiden name (but I’m married) or Mrs Maiden name which is my mother.
I get around it by saying call me Bickles to everyone! I like to be professional but warm and friendly with patients.

TheKeatingFive · 11/05/2022 20:50

The disrespect in this country shown towards doctors and dentists is crazy.

Theres nothing disrespectful about calling someone by their name in this day and age, get a grip.

YarnHoarder · 11/05/2022 20:49

I use my dentists first name as it's what she introduced herself as. Her surname (not sure if full) and qualifications are on a plaque on the outside of the building but clearly she prefers her patients to use her first name. I'd feel a little put out if she suddenly changed and abruptly told me to call her Dr Surname as though the previous relationship hadn't existed.

I assume she's introduced herself using her first name in the past which is why you know it. She could definitely have approached it differently but if you got the feeling something else was off during treatment then I'd put it down to something else which translated into a poor interaction with you. I wouldn't be jumping to change dentists if she's otherwise good and this is currently a one off situation. If she's still a little off next time and it's impacting you then I'd consider changing but good dentists that knows your dental history are important and you're only seeing them every 6 months.

LaMarschallin · 11/05/2022 20:48

Roselilly36

My dentist has the tendency to be a bit like this, can be very friendly, if I see him outside the surgery, he will totally blank you, very odd personality.

I suppose he may just not recognise you.
You - I presume - see only one dentist, but he'll see lots of patients. Also, of course, when you see him professionally, he'll have a bit of a clue because of your name being on your notes.
I used to recognise some, but by no means all, of the patients who spotted and greeted me.
Now I'm hoping I covered it up a bit better than your dentist does Smile

Theheartandtheshape · 11/05/2022 20:44

Wanting to be addressed by the professional title she spent 5 years earning isn't thinking she's "god".

The disrespect in this country shown towards doctors and dentists is crazy.

justfiveminutes · 11/05/2022 20:42

So someone who is usually friendly and chatty, with whom you have been very happy for years, was grumpy today? I'm sure it wasn't a nice experience for you but she is only human. Of course mn will pile on to say that it was unprofessional, and it was, but it's a rare person who hasn't had a bad day at work and you've got enough history to know it was out of character.

Bpdqueen · 11/05/2022 20:37

I Can't pronounce my dentists name so never call him by anything. I tend to just say hi you alright as I walk in

nocoolnamesleft · 11/05/2022 20:21

RobinHumphries · 11/05/2022 19:54

I don’t understand how dentists became doctors, unless they hold a PhD of course. I’ve even heard of vets calling themselves Dr Brown, Smith, whatever. When did this start?

It started around 1995. As dentists are dental surgeons they used to have the rank of Mr/ Mrs/ Ms etc so were ranked above medics however the general public didn’t understand the technicalities so it was decided to give them the rank of doctor to gain respect

Surgeons are not ranked above medics!

Swipe left for the next trending thread