Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think my dentist is very stuck up

191 replies

cuppateaandabiccie · 11/05/2022 19:31

Was at the dentist today for my routine check up. I have never had a problem with her before in all the years I have been a patient at her surgery, but today it just felt like she was in a foul mood but I think she came across as quite stuck up and arrogant.

let’s say I’m called Sandra and say she’s called Barbara Brown (just a random name) officially she is called Dr Brown.

i was waiting at reception to be called for my appointment, she came to reception and called my name so I got up and walked over and I said “hi Barbara, how are you” then her response was quite sharp.

she had a face like thunder and she said something like “Sorry Sandra, my name is Dr Brown. In future, you call me Dr Brown”

I was really shocked and taken aback - there was no conversation from her during my appointment, usually she is quite chatty and friendly. All she did was tut and sigh.

AIBU to think this was quite unprofessional and arrogant? Why can’t I call her by her first name? She’s not God!

OP posts:
newnamethanks · 12/05/2022 06:36

I'm with you Dr Babdoc. I've managed to adapt to the practice of being called 'newname' by everyone from delivery people to doctors. Still makes me uncomfortable. Now I have to revert to non-mateyness?

UseOfWeapons · 12/05/2022 06:06

I’ve always called my dentist by her first name, because that’s how she introduced herself to me. She calls me by my familiar name too. However if I am talking about to her her staff, I call her Dr X.
I wouldn’t call a professional by their first name unless invited…about half of the consultants I work with daily I call by their first name, the other half are always Dr or Mr. I’d wait to be invited to address them in any other way,

SillyDoriswithaDangler · 12/05/2022 05:16

It's pretty simple, if she called you by your first name then you are free to call her by her first name. I would absolutely complain about the rudeness to the practice manager, she is not using patient-centered care, which is critical to healthcare.

NewJerseyWater · 12/05/2022 03:53

Don't people know how difficult it is to find a dentist these days?!

If you can go private, you can take your pick. I pay privately so no way I’m putting up with a moody bastard.

StrawberryPot · 12/05/2022 03:10

Don't people know how difficult it is to find a dentist these days?!

Although the receptionists at the practice I use refer to all the dentists by their first names, I would feel slightly uncomfortable using my dentist's first name in conversation. But then I can't really see the need to use any name when talking directly to them.

mackthepony · 12/05/2022 02:43

Dentists are expensive.. Find one you like

Ponderingwindow · 12/05/2022 02:37

Titles should be reciprocal. If she had really addressed you by your first name, I would say that you were fine to respond with her first name.

However, if what she really did was call out your first name without your surname to help maintain anonymity in the waiting area and it wasn’t really an introduction, then jumping to a first name basis was presumptuous.

mathanxiety · 12/05/2022 02:26

If they feel so strongly about being addressed in a certain way they should begin the appointment by saying "Hello you can call me Dr 'Smith' how are you today" etc.........

Err, she kinda did...

Or she would have if the OP hadn't started by addressing her as Barbara.

The dentist immediately set things straight. She didn't have to be polite in response to someone's presumptuousness.

Poppins2016 · 12/05/2022 02:25

This is an interesting one.

I dislike "Hi first name, I'm Dr Surname (or Mrs Surname, etc. in other settings) as it feels as though there's a power imbalance. Someone mentioned being respectful towards people with medical qualifications but actually I think it's more important to be respectful when addressing each other on a human level (I dislike the notion that some people should be seen as superior just because they hold a degree/certain job/etc...). If someone introduces themselves formally as "Dr Surname/Mrs Surname" then I expect to be addressed equally by my surname without question, otherwise it feels too familiar.
I raised an eyebrow the other day in a medical setting when the nurses were calling the doctors "Dr Surname" but the doctors were using first names to address the nurses, when everyone was working together professionally to achieve a common goal and as a team (each role is just as valuable as it can't function without the other). It particularly makes me bristle seeing consultants being treated with deference as though they're gods.

On the other hand... I had a telephone appointment with a GP the other day who introduced himself as "first name from the GP Practice" and although it was refreshing, I found it rather disconcerting and wondered whether it was actually the doctor at first... so I suppose they can't win 🤣

mathanxiety · 12/05/2022 02:23

It's definitely not disrespectful or cheeky. Referring to someone as 'young nurse' is quite condescending.

Nope, it's very likely an accurate descriptor.

mathanxiety · 12/05/2022 02:21

Wanting to be addressed by the professional title she spent 5 years earning isn't thinking she's "god".

THIS ^^

YilingMatriarch · 12/05/2022 01:42

You were presumptuous, and she was brusque, and most likely neither of you meant it.

If you continue to see her professionally then either call her Dr or don't refer to her personally at all. If she refers to you by your given name, simply point out that you prefer to be addressed as .......

Or look for another Dentist.

BackAgain777 · 12/05/2022 00:12

Eh, no, not all dentists have a "medical degree". Whatever gave you that idea? They have a dentistry degree, it's nothing like a medical degree.

The VAST majority are not true doctors i.e they do not have a PhD. The "Dr" title is a courtesy only. A lot don't use it.
Vets recently became allowed to call themselves "Dr" in the same way, but again in my experience as a vet nurse, the only ones who do this are the American vets I've worked with.
The same with medical Doctors. It is a courtesy title, the vast majority will not have a PhD or research doctorate.

However, I know who I would rather have with me in a restaurant if I was choking to death. Clue - not my husband who is a Dr due to his PhD in toxicology..... but I'd want an actual medic. That's why we never book flights, hotels, restaurants etc under Dr and Mrs.
Plus, as my husband say....it's wanky and a bit cringey to refer to yourself as Dr in your everyday life. I tend to agree.

teezletangler · 11/05/2022 23:44

^I’m older generation (in my 60s), and, for most of my contemporaries, Christian names are for friends and family only - one waits for permission to use them for anyone else.
So in your example, you would always address her as (title surname), unless or until she says “Oh please call me (Christian name)”.
I must admit, I grit my teeth if a young nurse addresses me by first name instead of Dr Babdoc! It is disrespectful and cheeky^

To me this comment highlights the unfortunate "us and them" attitude in healthcare that can indirectly lead to poor outcomes. Effective teamwork relies on mutual respect and breaking down barriers between all members of the team, because you are all working together for the best patient outcomes. Unfortunately, I've worked with the odd consultant who insists on being Miss So-and-So to everyone, and it usually goes along with an attitude that is unapproachable. The worst thing you can be as a doctor is unapproachable to the nurses/midwives/junior doctors etc because that's when people will hesitate to escalate problems and leave things longer than they should. This was even highlighted as one of the issues in the Ockenden report! I should note that I am talking about people who work together regularly, if interacting with a doctor I don't know well then I'd always start with Dr, but people who keep the Dr thing up for months and years, well it's a bit odd and people end up thinking you're a bit of a dick.

MillyMollyMardy · 11/05/2022 23:27

Another dentist here, something had obviously happened before you arrived. We are all human, her behaviour was off but I have had awful news, a row with another team member etc, and you have to carry on working. I spent one poor person's treatment intermittently sobbing having just had devastating news.

If your interactions have previously been fine and you want to I would attend next time but if you don't and there is another dentist in the practice you can ask to be moved.

I'm mostly called by my first name but I have been seeing most of my patients for years. I introduce myself as first name+surname and let them decide. I'm always aware I'm invading people's personal space and often working on them for a long time so them having to say Dr+surname feels very formal when I've spent 45 minutes leaning over them. I vary in how I address people and usually take my cue from them. My older patients are always title+surname unless they say otherwise.

AtLeastPretendToCare · 11/05/2022 23:23

Personally I always think it is an obnoxious power play to insist on being called Dr X but call the patient By their first name. I, the medic, am showing that I am more important than you the mere patient.

Either it is Dr Brown and Miss Smith or Barbara (perhaps Dr Barbara) and Sandra.

But then my corporate background is that even at huge international listed companies even the CEO and chairman will be known internally and to clients by their first names.

Lilgamesh2 · 11/05/2022 23:08

Theheartandtheshape · 11/05/2022 20:44

Wanting to be addressed by the professional title she spent 5 years earning isn't thinking she's "god".

The disrespect in this country shown towards doctors and dentists is crazy.

There's nothing wrong with her desire to be addressed by her title BUT she didn't do the same to the patient, she called the patient by her first name! That's why it seems arrogant.

Drs deserve no more, and no less, respect than any other service provider doing their job. They aren't our superiors.

strrawberriesandcream · 11/05/2022 23:04

Babdoc
I’m older generation (in my 60s), and, for most of my contemporaries, Christian names are for friends and family only - one waits for permission to use them for anyone else.
So in your example, you would always address her as (title surname), unless or until she says “Oh please call me (Christian name)”.
I must admit, I grit my teeth if a young nurse addresses me by first name instead of Dr Babdoc! It is disrespectful and cheeky.


We're not in the 1950s anymore, times have changed and people are far less formal than they used to be.
You need to make absolutely clear how you expect to be addressed in work otherwise it is generally the norm for people to use first names by default.

It's definitely not disrespectful or cheeky. Referring to someone as 'young nurse' is quite condescending.

caecilius1 · 11/05/2022 23:00

"You literally have to do a medical degree to be a dentist. So all dentists are doctors. Unless they're dental surgeons then they are Mr/Mrs as are surgeons who are doctors"

Not true. In GB, dentists do a dental degree and have either a BDS or BChD (if you're a Leeds Uni graduate). All British qualified dentists are dental surgeons, it's interchangeable terminology.
Oral Maxillo Facial surgeons are dually qualified in dentistry & medicine ditto Oral Medicine consultants, and that's about it with medical degrees in dentistry.

MagnoliaXYZ · 11/05/2022 22:59

Babdoc · 11/05/2022 19:59

I’m older generation (in my 60s), and, for most of my contemporaries, Christian names are for friends and family only - one waits for permission to use them for anyone else.
So in your example, you would always address her as (title surname), unless or until she says “Oh please call me (Christian name)”.
I must admit, I grit my teeth if a young nurse addresses me by first name instead of Dr Babdoc! It is disrespectful and cheeky.

I presume you do those 'young nurses' the courtesy of addressing them correctly ie Staff Nurse Jones, Sister Williams etc. After all, it would be disrespectful and cheeky if you didn't.

strrawberriesandcream · 11/05/2022 22:47

I can't get my head around people clutching their pearls over use of a first name.

Over familiarity
Rude
Casual
Shocked

It's their actual name fgs!

Talking like a patient has asked them to bend them over the dentist chair and give them a good seeing too

strrawberriesandcream · 11/05/2022 22:38

Many patients are at the dentist begrudgingly either because they are in a lot of pain, are worried about the cost or just generally nervous about dental treatment. Let's face it, it's a place nobody looks forward to going and will appreciate being made to feel comfortable and at ease.

If my dentist created an atmosphere like that and spoke to me so rudely I'd be telling them to sort their attitude out.

If they feel so strongly about being addressed in a certain way they should begin the appointment by saying "Hello you can call me Dr 'Smith' how are you today" etc.........

SleepingFrog · 11/05/2022 22:38

I would never address my dentist or doctor by their first name unless they insisted. I think it could be misconstrued as disrespectful.

When I was at school, staff first names were never really known so parents referred to the teachers as Mrs... Mr.... but in the last 10 years I've been a teacher, parents constantly respond to my emails as "Hi Sleeping" when I've signed off as "Mrs Frog" and I've also addressed them by Mr X or Mrs X in the email. We are not friends or family so I address them respectfully and I am always shocked how casually they reply! Even after their replies, I continue to address them formally but they don't get the hint... 5 emails in, still signing off as Mrs Frog but no change in their greeting to me🤦 I wouldn't mention it to a parent though (I just sigh and move on) as I don't know how you tactfully address it over email 🤣

Maybe your dentist is fed up (like I am) of people being overly casual or familiar and has decided to take a stand on it? I think she should have addressed you as Mrs/Miss Biccie though if she is going to call you out using her title in such an abrupt way.

TheKeatingFive · 11/05/2022 22:29

Then surely she was also 'fresh' with OP by using her first name - which OP confirms she has always done.

Exactly. Goes both ways.

JassyRadlett · 11/05/2022 22:27

Eliakimi · 11/05/2022 21:20

@OP you were rude to call her by her first name. Have you ever called her by her first name before in all the yrs you've been at the practice and does everyone else call her Barbara i.e other patients? there's your answer. You were trying to get fresh with her.

Then surely she was also 'fresh' with OP by using her first name - which OP confirms she has always done.

Swipe left for the next trending thread