Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think my dentist is very stuck up

191 replies

cuppateaandabiccie · 11/05/2022 19:31

Was at the dentist today for my routine check up. I have never had a problem with her before in all the years I have been a patient at her surgery, but today it just felt like she was in a foul mood but I think she came across as quite stuck up and arrogant.

let’s say I’m called Sandra and say she’s called Barbara Brown (just a random name) officially she is called Dr Brown.

i was waiting at reception to be called for my appointment, she came to reception and called my name so I got up and walked over and I said “hi Barbara, how are you” then her response was quite sharp.

she had a face like thunder and she said something like “Sorry Sandra, my name is Dr Brown. In future, you call me Dr Brown”

I was really shocked and taken aback - there was no conversation from her during my appointment, usually she is quite chatty and friendly. All she did was tut and sigh.

AIBU to think this was quite unprofessional and arrogant? Why can’t I call her by her first name? She’s not God!

OP posts:
Walkaround · 12/05/2022 17:21

So you have known your dentist a long time, never had a problem with her, but now all of a sudden find her stuck up. Tbh, that makes you sound almost as histrionic as she did. If you think you know someone well enough to use their first name and have never had a problem with them ever before despite having known them a long time, then I think you know them well enough to give them the benefit of the doubt on this occasion and assume their unusual behaviour has an understandable cause, rather than to jump to the conclusion that they are stuck up. Who knows if she is menopausal, going through a serious crisis in her personal life, having an exceptionally bad day, having trouble with patients becoming too familiar and stalking her, or genuinely just offended by your random decision to call her Sandra (are you sure that’s her name?😂), but you cannot have it both ways: if you expect someone to act professionally, it’s better to treat them as a professional rather than a personal friend.

MajorCarolDanvers · 12/05/2022 16:57

mihimagna · 12/05/2022 08:46

She wishes that she was a real doctor as in Medical Doctor. She couldn't hack it, so resorted to being a dentist. All sorts of pepple can be referred to as a "doctor" but only MD's are true doctors. If you had a medical emergency and you only had the option to choose between a dentist, veterinarian, doctor of philosophy, or a medical doctor which one would you choose to save your life?

Ah bless here we have the winner for the most ignorant post on the thread.
Anyone with doctoral qualification is a 'real doctor'.

Those with a medical doctorate can practice medicine
Those with a dentistry doctorate can practice dentistry
Those with other types of doctorates are qualified to the highest level of university degree in their respective fields.

They are all real.

10HailMarys · 12/05/2022 15:46

If she really wants to be called Dr Brown instead of Barbara, that's up to her, but snapping at you like that was out of order; she could easily have explained politely or even made a joke of it so you didn't feel awkward.

wtfisgoingonhere21 · 12/05/2022 12:09

@cuppateaandabiccie

You are absolutely right here in that she was clearly in a foul mood beforehand and was very unprofessional

My boss has done the same many times either by speaking rudely to us staff or being very abrupt with clients and they don't come back

I can just see how the dental nurse looked because we are like it here.

It's embarrassing and rude and in professional

Never any reason to be rude really so the posters saying you were rude you bloody wernt.

What's happened to people that they think it's ok for someone providing a service to speak to customers or patients like shit and get away with it.

I just couldn't get worked up if someone called me the wrong name etc. it's pretty petty in the grand scheme of things.

Op I would ring and complain about her rudeness and unprofessional manner and let them know you won't be going back

ForTheLoveOfSleep · 12/05/2022 10:56

mihimagna · 12/05/2022 08:46

She wishes that she was a real doctor as in Medical Doctor. She couldn't hack it, so resorted to being a dentist. All sorts of pepple can be referred to as a "doctor" but only MD's are true doctors. If you had a medical emergency and you only had the option to choose between a dentist, veterinarian, doctor of philosophy, or a medical doctor which one would you choose to save your life?

Don't be a twat. Surely it depends on the medical emergency? Being a "medical" Doctor doesn't make you all knowing or a superior being. There are different doctors for every part of the body. Cardiologist (heart), ENTs (ear, nose & throat), neurologists (brain), dentists (oral health), orthopedics (bones). All are medical proffessionals that you would see dependent on your conditions. No way would I go to a GP for a dental abcess or any kind of tooth pain.

pigsDOfly · 12/05/2022 10:56

strrawberriesandcream · 11/05/2022 23:04

Babdoc
I’m older generation (in my 60s), and, for most of my contemporaries, Christian names are for friends and family only - one waits for permission to use them for anyone else.
So in your example, you would always address her as (title surname), unless or until she says “Oh please call me (Christian name)”.
I must admit, I grit my teeth if a young nurse addresses me by first name instead of Dr Babdoc! It is disrespectful and cheeky.


We're not in the 1950s anymore, times have changed and people are far less formal than they used to be.
You need to make absolutely clear how you expect to be addressed in work otherwise it is generally the norm for people to use first names by default.

It's definitely not disrespectful or cheeky. Referring to someone as 'young nurse' is quite condescending.

Given that we are living in a very multi cultural society and you're a stickler for getting things correct and wanting people to be respectful, might I suggest that talking about people's Christian names is a tad outdated.

A large percentage of our population are not Christian and don't have 'Christian' names.

Angrymum22 · 12/05/2022 10:46

mihimagna · 12/05/2022 08:46

She wishes that she was a real doctor as in Medical Doctor. She couldn't hack it, so resorted to being a dentist. All sorts of pepple can be referred to as a "doctor" but only MD's are true doctors. If you had a medical emergency and you only had the option to choose between a dentist, veterinarian, doctor of philosophy, or a medical doctor which one would you choose to save your life?

As a dentist I deeply resent that comment. Dentistry is a vocation and to be be fare would you spend your working life elbow deep in plaque, calculus, last weeks Sunday lunch and the lovely smell of periodontal disease without a vocation. The entry requirements are high and failed medics are not considered in applications I’m afraid.
I chose dentistry over medicine because I wanted a job that involved using my hands ( I’m actually a talented artist but didn’t see a future in that) dealing with people and the challenge of diagnosis. But as I’ve said before we all have our off days. I suffered multiple miscarriages, you can imagine how difficult it was treating and seeing pregnant women and new mothers in the months following a miscarriage. But you fix your smile and go into your professional zone. You only break down after the patient has left the room.
I now only work as an associate so I’m just a dentist at work, however for 26 yrs I owned and ran the practice. Throughout the working day, not only do you have to see patients but also fast manage any problems going on with the business. Some days I would be chief plumber/electrician, complaint resolver, staff manager and fixer of younger dentists problems ( removing teeth they had made a mess of trying to extract) all while calmly treating my own full list of patients.
A bad day is a bad day wherever you work. I know that you shouldn’t drop the act but sometimes it’s just impossible to maintain it.

_nellie_ · 12/05/2022 10:44

Hello,
I used to work in a dental practice that was allowed to be very formal with patients, all the dentists were known by their first names. New owner bought the practice and we as staff weren't even allowed to call the dentists by their first name. We were told we had to correct patients who called dentists by their first names too, it was really difficult.

I'd say if she's not had an issue before it's more on the owners/ management of the practice than her

cookiemonster2468 · 12/05/2022 10:43

cuppateaandabiccie · 11/05/2022 21:33

I never have called her by her name at all, I just said hi “Barbara” without thinking. I didn’t think it would be a problem.

i do think if she wants me to call her by her title then she needs to call me by my title

Well, not really. Some healthcare practices have a general policy that they call patients by first names because most people these days do tend to prefer it. If you expressed a preference for surname then she would use that I'm sure.

She expressed a preference which is fine and she is allowed to do that.

But the way she did it wasn't very professional, and it sounds like her mood was concerning to you. That could impact on her practice so understandable a concern. I think the name is the wrong thing to focus on - it's more about her general demeanour.

cookiemonster2468 · 12/05/2022 10:39

It's OK for her to ask you to call her what she wants to be called. She might find first names too familiar, for whatever reason - that's her perogative. You could do the same and ask to be called by title and surname if you wanted.

The way she did it was rude, though.

Reallyreallyborednow · 12/05/2022 10:38

If you had a medical emergency and you only had the option to choose between a dentist, veterinarian, doctor of philosophy, or a medical doctor which one would you choose to save your life?

if my dog had a medical emergency I would want a vet. If I had a dental medical emergency I’d want a dentist. If I had a novel disease I needed a cure for I’d want a PhD.

and actually, if I had a medical emergency, i wouldn’t necessarily take a medical doctor. I would rather have a trauma nurse, paramedic, a trauma trained police officer, or even a competent first aider over a dermatologist, palliative care practitioner or most GP’s who haven’t had any experience of emergency care in decades.

medical dr’s aren’t all life saving gods rushing around delivering CPR. You watch too much tv.

TheKeatingFive · 12/05/2022 10:35

Whoops wrong thread

TheKeatingFive · 12/05/2022 10:34

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

BackAgain777 · 12/05/2022 10:26

""but only MD's are true doctors""

Absolutely untrue. Traditionally only people with a research doctorate were permitted to "doctors".
MDs (I presume you're from the States) are not true doctors, in the sense that their title is an honorary one and has become commonplace through usage. They are physicians, not doctors, if you want to be technical. Unless they have a PhD they do not hold a doctorate in the real sense.
But actually , no-one really cares these days. It's a bit of friendly banter between people who have the titles. Our cardiologist friend is a Dr, so is DH who is a PhD. They are both legally allowed to use the title.
People with PhDs have done their 4 year degree course and then another 4 - 6 years working on their PhD, it's a far longer process than the 4 year medical degree, so if you want to argue that only "MDs" are real doctors, I would counter that 10 years of specific and intense study gaining your PhD "tops" a medical degree (but I am biased I understand!).

StrawberryPot · 12/05/2022 10:08

If you can go private, you can take your pick. I pay privately so no way I’m putting up with a moody bastard.

Not necessarily true. An awful lot of private dentists aren't taking on new patients. My (private) dentist often tells me how dire things are with so many dentists leaving the profession, how difficult it is to recruit dental nurses and how they can't take on new patients because their existing ones now have to wait months for a routine appointment. She seems very stressed about the whole situation. And as pp said, private dentistry is horrifically expensive. I've spent thousands over the past couple of years on fairly routine treatment.

MrsFezziwig · 12/05/2022 09:42

And considering there are about two threads a day on here about people who can’t find a dentist for love nor money (and don’t have the funds to “just go private”) I’m laughing at people’s advice to immediately find another dentist.

Assuming she carried out your treatment correctly, and you have never had any problems with her in the past, I would give her the benefit of the doubt on this one occasion. If she’s the same when you see her next time, that to me would be the time to take it further.

MrsSkylerWhite · 12/05/2022 09:35

Frankly I’d call a dentist anything they wanted, if I could find an NHS one who would take me 😫

TheKeatingFive · 12/05/2022 09:32

All sorts of pepple can be referred to as a "doctor" but only MD's are true doctors

That's not true, phds are the 'true' doctors if you want to go down that route.

Not that anyone actually cares

MrsFezziwig · 12/05/2022 09:31

mihimagna · 12/05/2022 08:46

She wishes that she was a real doctor as in Medical Doctor. She couldn't hack it, so resorted to being a dentist. All sorts of pepple can be referred to as a "doctor" but only MD's are true doctors. If you had a medical emergency and you only had the option to choose between a dentist, veterinarian, doctor of philosophy, or a medical doctor which one would you choose to save your life?

I presume you’re American. MD is an American term. UK doctors (and dentists) have a bachelor’s degree unless they do further study. UK physicians are still called Dr, and surgeons (once they become Fellows of the Royal College of Surgeons) are called Mr/Mrs/Miss.

JassyRadlett · 12/05/2022 08:47

The dentist immediately set things straight. She didn't have to be polite in response to someone's presumptuousness.

She should at least refrain from being presumptuous herself.

mihimagna · 12/05/2022 08:46

She wishes that she was a real doctor as in Medical Doctor. She couldn't hack it, so resorted to being a dentist. All sorts of pepple can be referred to as a "doctor" but only MD's are true doctors. If you had a medical emergency and you only had the option to choose between a dentist, veterinarian, doctor of philosophy, or a medical doctor which one would you choose to save your life?

hellcatspanglelalala · 12/05/2022 08:13

I'd have replied "To you I'm Mrs/Ms/Miss X, not Sandra!"

cuppateaandabiccie · 12/05/2022 08:06

And yeah, as I said in a PP, she has always called me by my first name.

OP posts:
cuppateaandabiccie · 12/05/2022 08:05

I most definitely wouldn’t have minded if she had called me Mrs (surname) and asked politely.

she was rude, tense and moody. That put me off along with her double standards - not ok to rudely demand I call her Dr Brown when in fact in the same sentence she calls me by my first name!

OP posts:
Angrymum22 · 12/05/2022 07:58

I am old school and always address people with their title and surname unless invited to do otherwise. I also encourage my young nurses to do likewise. I am the same with teachers at DS’s school.
As a dentist I don’t care how people address me. As I said in previous post I don’t use the title Dr professionally but do use my maiden name. It means I can be plain old Mrs Angrymum everywhere else in my life. Most of my doctor and dentist friends are the same.
The younger generation of professionals do seem to be more entitled about their title. Maybe they haven’t realised yet that being addressed by the title Dr can be a double edged sword. They will realise that it can be a bloody nightmare at the school gate when others know what you do.
I used to arrive at least half an hour after pick up time to avoid the impromptu consultations as did the majority of medically qualified parents. It took me a while to realise that we had our own pick up time. And if they were are normal pick up they often stayed in their car rather than join the crowd. Initially no one knew what I did but once it becomes common knowledge it’s a bloody nightmare.

Swipe left for the next trending thread