Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think my dentist is very stuck up

191 replies

cuppateaandabiccie · 11/05/2022 19:31

Was at the dentist today for my routine check up. I have never had a problem with her before in all the years I have been a patient at her surgery, but today it just felt like she was in a foul mood but I think she came across as quite stuck up and arrogant.

let’s say I’m called Sandra and say she’s called Barbara Brown (just a random name) officially she is called Dr Brown.

i was waiting at reception to be called for my appointment, she came to reception and called my name so I got up and walked over and I said “hi Barbara, how are you” then her response was quite sharp.

she had a face like thunder and she said something like “Sorry Sandra, my name is Dr Brown. In future, you call me Dr Brown”

I was really shocked and taken aback - there was no conversation from her during my appointment, usually she is quite chatty and friendly. All she did was tut and sigh.

AIBU to think this was quite unprofessional and arrogant? Why can’t I call her by her first name? She’s not God!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave · 15/05/2022 03:35

I'd decide to call her "My Ex-Dentist"

JKRisGalileo · 15/05/2022 03:30

YANBU. She was unforgivably rude. I would change dentists.

mathanxiety · 15/05/2022 02:14

The D in American MD, DO, DPT, PharmD, DDS, and DVM titles come from Scottish tradition.

newnamethanks · 14/05/2022 08:45

My dentist's name is Fiona. That's is also the name of the hygienist. It leads to confusion and I wish they'd each embrace a surname or title to distinguish them more easily.

JassyRadlett · 14/05/2022 08:45

MMM3 · 14/05/2022 01:31

Hold up…

You have doctors that are not literally doctors? I’d heard of the lower education dentists before, and I think maybe solicitors can have only a bachelors, but I’m stunned that there are classes of people using “Doctor” as a courtesy title…

In the US, all doctors of any kind, all dentists, all vets, and all lawyers have a doctorate degree.

It's just the name of the degree. The US calls it an MD and it's a second-entry degree after undergrad; the UK has an MBBS and it's generally an undergrad degree, but the degree conferred is at Masters level. All doctorates in the UK are third-entry degrees and are research based (though professional degrees such as MD generally have a taught component.)

Comparing education systems is fraught at best.

WomanStanleyWoman2 · 14/05/2022 01:48

As for being rude (you were rude first) , in your own words she said, '“Sorry Sandra, my name is Dr Brown. In future, you call me Dr Brown” She wasn't rude, she was assertive and direct and it caught you off guard. The mannerisms that you described..well we only have your word for it.

If she’s that bothered, she should have called OP Mrs/Ms Name instead of Sandra. Why does she get to be more ‘assertive’ than the OP?

As for ‘We only have your word for it’, welcome to every thread on MN ever.

WomanStanleyWoman2 · 14/05/2022 01:44

Why did you need to say her name at all?
Presumably you were looking at her, she knows who you are saying hi to

You've seriously never addressed anyone by name when saying hello?

jewishmum · 14/05/2022 01:35

My mother calls her dentist by her first name, she's like a family friend she's been her dentist so long.

Blimeyherewegoagain · 14/05/2022 01:35

I call my dentist by his first name. That’s how the receptionists refer to him too. It’s a friendly practice.

MMM3 · 14/05/2022 01:31

Hold up…

You have doctors that are not literally doctors? I’d heard of the lower education dentists before, and I think maybe solicitors can have only a bachelors, but I’m stunned that there are classes of people using “Doctor” as a courtesy title…

In the US, all doctors of any kind, all dentists, all vets, and all lawyers have a doctorate degree.

Cervinia · 13/05/2022 19:12

My dentist is wonderful, normal
and a lot of fun, we call him Tom, because that’s his name and he calls us by our first names. He’s a dentist, who went to the same medical school as DD, and a normal unpretentious person.

his name isn’t really Tom BTW

Saz12 · 13/05/2022 19:04

I’d guess that because you know her first name, it’s used in her workplace at reception etc “you’re appointment with Dr Barbera Brown is at 3pm” or whatever, rather than “an appointment with Dr Brown”.
It does tacitly give permission for you to think of / refer to “Barbera” rather than “Dr Brown”.

My dentist is referred to by receptionist as Jo Bloggs, but the GP receptionist would say Dr Bloggs. It gives a pretty clear indication of preferred names; if I then called either of them “Josephine” it’d be fair enough for them to correct me!

I’d not be happy to be corrected as rudely as you were anyway, a simple “Please call me Dr Brown. Nice to see you today” would’ve been just as clear.

Iamnotokifyouarenotok · 13/05/2022 18:41

SerialNameChanger2114 · 11/05/2022 19:45

Maybe I’m just in a minority, but I’ve worked in a hospital for 9 years, and unless I know the doctor well, I wouldn’t dream of calling them by their first name. (Most say call me Richard or whatever and then I will) that’s within the same hospital.

I wouldn’t Call a dentist or doctor by their first name. It seems too familiar and really rude! (I’m 35 btw in case that matters 🤣)

So what does the Dr call you ? All that hierarchical stuff disappeared many moons ago!!All my staff call me by my Christian name and I would feel so awkward if they called me any thing else !

cuppateaandabiccie · 13/05/2022 18:34

All she had to do was politely say to me “Mrs (surname), would you mind calling me Dr Brown please just so that we keep it professional? Thank you.”

I would have been fine with that. There was zero need for her to say it to be so abruptly.

i could tell she was already in a bad mood even before I opened my mouth and spoke to her, so I don’t think it was me. I get that she was maybe having a bad day, but she should try harder to control that and not show it to her patients.

she was really off and the atmosphere was very tense and odd. Not appropriate or professional at all.

OP posts:
LaMarschallin · 13/05/2022 08:44

Totally agree, Walkaround.
I didn't see the work colleague analogy either.
I was part of an a very friendly NHS team; of course we all called each other by first names (or nicknames), socialised a lot with each other (through choice, not because we felt we should) and got on really well.
However, if we went on a joint visit to a patient, we'd refer to each other as Title LastName and the patient in the same way.

Walkaround · 13/05/2022 08:06

gymNamaste · 12/05/2022 22:35

Really what jobs apart from teaching do people not use first names these days ? I have no idea what most colleagues surnames are unless I email them. I certainly don't introduce myself as Mrs Namaste

@gymNamaste What have work colleagues got to do with it? The OP is not the dentist’s work colleague? I don’t know the first names of the doctors at my GP practice and haven’t ever seen any of them often enough to feel the need to ask! When you make an appointment to see a doctor, do you get told “ your appointment will be with [person’s first name], today? Or if you see a solicitor, are you told your appointment is with [person’s first name]?! If writing to your MP, would you just use their first name? Would you address a judge by their first name when they were acting in their professional capacity? There are a great many contexts where just using someone’s first name without their explicit agreement is still considered wrong, rude or over familiar.

gymNamaste · 12/05/2022 22:35

SilverGlassHare · 11/05/2022 19:35

I wouldn’t call anyone I was seeing in a professional capacity by their first name, unless previously invited to do so. But in your situation I’d have said, ‘Actually, it’s Mrs/Ms/Dr/Rev Cuppa.”

Really what jobs apart from teaching do people not use first names these days ? I have no idea what most colleagues surnames are unless I email them. I certainly don't introduce myself as Mrs Namaste

LilacWines · 12/05/2022 18:35

I think you should have called her Doctor. As others have said, female HCPs often get their titles dropped, ignored or reduced to a first name. You also see it in politics where male politicians will refer to women by their first name not Ms or Mrs whoever, but never do it to me. I don't think she should have snapped at you but also she's human. I am amazed at the energy that most HCPs put into their interactions, i would find it utterly exhausting.

satelliteheart · 12/05/2022 18:26

Honestly I don't even know my dentist's surname. When I first saw him he introduced himself by first name and all the reception staff refer to him by first name only

I agree with pp, I'd have responded "in that case it's not Sandra, it's Mrs/miss/ms Smith"

BarrowInFurnessRailwayStation · 12/05/2022 18:16

I think people who have a healthy self esteem don't get hung up on titles or job status.

serenghetti2011 · 12/05/2022 18:14

I’m a nurse and worked for 15 years in the same ward. Fy2 etc and spreg would tell you to use their first names which is fine, if that’s what they prefer but the consultants were all dr whatever some of the other nurses who had worked with them since they were registrars would be on first name terms, however there are some who prefer their title and surname and that’s fine. They need to establish professional boundaries.

I hate dentists (not personally) so i go to a lovely one who is called Mary and it’s all very relaxed and she’s really caring as she knows I’m petrified - years of traumatic orthodontic work then oral surgery has had a v negative effect. But Mary has got me to the point I don’t need sedation so she’s really wonderful. The hygienist is brutal though I avoid like the plague. You caught dr brown on a bad day op, who knows why but I know even if there is a shit show going on at home I put my game face on at work and get on with it, it’s not the poor parents, babies and kids fault that I’ve got stuff going on at home. So for 12 hours I put it to one side. If I can’t then I don’t go to work. It’s hard but never have I snapped at someone.

Reallyreallyborednow · 12/05/2022 17:57

*thought dentists were allowed to call themselves dr, but it’s a courtesy title and they should never actually imply they are actually a doctor, as they are not. Well not unless they hold a different qualification.

so I think getting the arse over a courtesy title is odd as fuck. Because “courtesy” means pretend, let’s be honest*

it’s courtesy title for medics, too, unless they hold a PhD.

so only PhD or DPhil graduates should call themselves Dr? Everyone else, medics, dentists, vets, who “only” hold an undergrad degree are just playing pretend?

Jillyfernilly · 12/05/2022 17:57

As a female medical doctor I rarely get given my professional title by patients. I have a degree of sympathy with the dentist and agree with the poster up thread about using first names being a power game (I use it myself sometimes when senior male surgeons are being dicks e.g deliberately referring to the professor of surgery as Alan not prof! I do the opposite with the female prof I anaesthetise for. Always give her her title as it irritates me to watch the team fawning over her more junior colleagues by using their titles and then calling her Elaine.

I have lost count of the number of times patients/family members refer to me as a nurse.

It isn't just about my own status it's that I worry patients don't listen properly or give what I say enough importance as they are waiting for a mythical person with a penis to come and explain the same stuff. I care for some complex patients and not infrequently have to consent for risks of paralysis/ blindness/ death etc. I would hate for them not to listen properly because they don't think I'm the doctor.

Fullsomefrenchie · 12/05/2022 17:35

I thought dentists were allowed to call themselves dr, but it’s a courtesy title and they should never actually imply they are actually a doctor, as they are not. Well not unless they hold a different qualification.

so I think getting the arse over a courtesy title is odd as fuck. Because “courtesy” means pretend, let’s be honest.

Walkaround · 12/05/2022 17:23

Ha - I see you are actually calling her Barbara in your post. See how easy it is to let the wrong name slip out 🤣

Swipe left for the next trending thread