Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

10yo DD called a “fucking bitch”‘ at school

133 replies

northlundunmum · 11/05/2022 19:16

AIBU to think that the level of swearing at DD’s primary school is not ok? Usually this is boys, during playtime or PE…

Examples - Today’s PE lesson was Hockey DD tell me that one (partially unpleasant) boy (UB) repeatedly got her stomach and shins during the game - she felt on purpose. Her team won and at the end of the game (admittedly not her finest hour) she shouts out “ha ha we won!” - to which UB retorts to her “you fucking bitch”

She also tells me the boys regularly swear at her during playtime football (she plays on the girls football team) - they shout things like “kick the fucking ball!”

She learned the N word from another child at school.

Full disclosure: I do swear in front if my children when the situation call for it and talk to them about swearing. I always explain what swear words actually mean and how adults use them. I discourage swearing at home, but have said if they need to use a swear to acturately describe a shitty situation that that is ok but I strongly discourage using swear words to describe people or show off.

I’m sure there wasn’t this kind of language when I was at primary school - but is this just the norm now? Genuinely interested to know - how much swearing is there at your children’s primary school? We are in London - does that that make a difference?

YABU - swearing insults at each other is normal for 10yo these days - suck it up
YANBU - this is unacceptable - complain to the school

thank for your advice!!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
JennyJumpup · 13/05/2022 12:36

It was the norm when I went to primary school in the 1970s. I think a lot of the time we didn't even know what the insults we were saying to each other meant… e.g. "Blow me" was a popular one used by both boys and girls!

Iamnotthe1 · 13/05/2022 12:22

nowhere at all did I say that this behaviour originates in the school. The school is not giving lessons in misogynist name-calling, is it? Of course a child learns this at home and/or amongst peer groups. But the school also has a responsibility to act against poor behaviour and to prevent pupils being verbally abused on the premises.

But you did say that it's on the school to fix it. Schools cannot fix it, only address the symptoms, because they are not the cause of the problem. As a society, we need to have higher expectations of parents and their role in who the child becomes, but we also need to be giving more support and advice to enable parents to rise to those expectations.

Tamzo85 · 13/05/2022 11:50

@honeybushbunch

You say that as though plenty of girls aren’t using just as foul language that would be unacceptable in an adult workplace and directing it at boys - but they are. Boys swear at boys, boys swear at girls, girls swear at girls, girls swear at boys.
Punishbit at school at the time I say, but it’s not part of some big social agenda because the reality is if you make it one then the next day some mouthy girl will say something abusive to a boy and then what?

BusyMum47 · 13/05/2022 09:18

I'm a yr6 Teacher & sadly, it appears to be a sign of the times; can't tell you the amount of times I've been on the receiving end of the F word!! I'll never get over the shock of being told to go F myself by a very small person!! 😕

honeybushbunch · 13/05/2022 08:54

@Tamzo85 Don’t be daft; there seems to be a shortage of reading comprehension on this thread. I certainly didn’t say that he should be charged. My point is just that ten plus isn’t just a small child any more, and harassing behaviour that goes unchallenged in a boy of ten sets a pattern for later life when it’s not just kid behaviour, but seriously abusive behaviour — just dismissing it as “oh that’s just what kids are like” perpetuates the fact that boys and men can just get away with misogynist, abusive and aggressive behaviour towards girls and women with no comeback. How often do you read on the Relationships board about women stuck in an abusive relationship with a man who belittles them and calls them names? Verbal abuse is now covered in the new domestic abuse act. It’s not just something trivial.

Why should a ten year old boy be made excuses for when he’s starting in a pattern of that behaviour? That’s how abusive men start off, and how they perpetuate their behaviour into the next generation of boys who learn it and more importantly then learn that this behaviour goes unchallenged when they copy it.

@Iamnotthe1 nowhere at all did I say that this behaviour originates in the school. The school is not giving lessons in misogynist name-calling, is it? Of course a child learns this at home and/or amongst peer groups. But the school also has a responsibility to act against poor behaviour and to prevent pupils being verbally abused on the premises.

Tamzo85 · 13/05/2022 05:24

@honeybushbunch

Ten is the age of criminal responsibility

You actually want a ten year old charged with a crime for calling another ten year old a name in school? Talk about an overreaction, if everyone thought this 99% of the school would have criminal records by the time they graduated. When (and it’s when not if) OP’s child swears at another kid shall she also be criminally charged or just this boy?

Iamnotthe1 · 12/05/2022 21:11

Saying it’s the responsibility of schools to tackle this doesn’t mean either that parents shouldn’t be tackling it too; OR that schools being asked to take action is remotely “exactly why the problem exists”.

I agree that schools have a role to play here and should (and do) address these issues. I've already said that further upthread. However, the emphasis being on schools rather than parents is contributing to issue not being solved. The cold, harsh reality is that if a child has grown up in an environment where, for example, racist language is commonplace, it's not the school's fault when the child turns out to be racist. It's the parents.

If you actually read all the Ofsted and government material on this, it’s very clear that harassment of girls by boys within schools and the ignoring of this by schools is a huge problem.

I have read the published materials on this and, again, schools should be (and are) addressing issues in this area. However, again, suggesting that misogynistic and even abusive attitudes and behaviours originate in schools and not within the home /digital exposure is short-sighted at best.

honeybushbunch · 12/05/2022 20:44

Iamnotthe1 · 12/05/2022 19:10

Nothing changes unless schools step up and deal with this rather than handwringing about it not being their problem.

And, unfortunately, statements like this are exactly why the problem exists. As a society, we have already transferred too many responsibilities away from parents and onto schools.

I get that schools are supposed to be the equaliser and, through their work, make up for those parents who don't do a good enough job. However, at the end of the day, a child's school is not their parent yet is seemingly becoming more responsible for the type of person that child becomes than parents are.

If you want to solve an issue, it needs tackling at the root. Unfortunately, it's become almost taboo to suggest that a parent isn't doing a "good enough" job or even communicate clearly with them about their child. Everything is wrapped up in fluffy language and knowing glances.

Saying it’s the responsibility of schools to tackle this doesn’t mean either that parents shouldn’t be tackling it too; OR that schools being asked to take action is remotely “exactly why the problem exists”. If you actually read all the Ofsted and government material on this, it’s very clear that harassment of girls by boys within schools and the ignoring of this by schools is a huge problem.

It is part of the school’s responsibility to tackle this, just as it would be a workplace’s responsibility to deal with harassment in the workplace. That doesn’t mean that parents shouldn’t also be responsible. But legally and morally a school ought to have responsibility to address harassment that occurs on the premises of children who they have a safeguarding responsibility towards.

Ten is the age of criminal responsibility, so a boy of ten needs to know harassment isn’t acceptable — otherwise the boys shouting “fucking bitch” at the girls at ten are more likely to be the teenage boys sexually harassing girls, and the men sexually assaulting and abusing women later on.

Blueeyedgirl21 · 12/05/2022 20:35

My nephew is in year 6 and reports one boy repeatedly says ‘your mums a fucking slag’ to several of the other boys during footie matches. Apparently some gaming streamer he likes uses the phrase. Teachers seem unconcerned but probably because there’s much worse to deal with and they’re picking their battles, can’t blame them .

Hollygolightly86 · 12/05/2022 20:28

JollyWilloughby · 12/05/2022 09:18

@Hollygolightly86

He sounds like a hoot, I kinda like people with no filter 😂.

It can definitely be amusing at times especially as an adult..my brother & I always say ‘send Daddy in’!

northlundunmum · 12/05/2022 19:53

Unpleasant Boy

OP posts:
Iamnotthe1 · 12/05/2022 19:10

Nothing changes unless schools step up and deal with this rather than handwringing about it not being their problem.

And, unfortunately, statements like this are exactly why the problem exists. As a society, we have already transferred too many responsibilities away from parents and onto schools.

I get that schools are supposed to be the equaliser and, through their work, make up for those parents who don't do a good enough job. However, at the end of the day, a child's school is not their parent yet is seemingly becoming more responsible for the type of person that child becomes than parents are.

If you want to solve an issue, it needs tackling at the root. Unfortunately, it's become almost taboo to suggest that a parent isn't doing a "good enough" job or even communicate clearly with them about their child. Everything is wrapped up in fluffy language and knowing glances.

carefullycourageous · 12/05/2022 18:50

It isn't acceptable and it needs to be dealt but I with disagree with 'there wasn't this type of swearing when I was a child' - maybe you didn't hear it, but I heard all sorts of swearing at primary school.

honeybushbunch · 12/05/2022 18:47

northlundunmum · 12/05/2022 17:11

DD didn’t tell a teacher in this occasion but it has happened before and she did raise it. She says he was told off but his behaviour hasn’t changed.

It’s interesting to ask though “what more would I want?” - this has been a helpful trigger for me to think through… Perhaps a concerted effort by staff to engage the children in a conversation about swearing, the difference between swearing about a situation and verbal abuse, the impact that has, what is acceptable and unacceptable - an agreed “zero tolerance” approach to verbal abuse the children can sign up to - with consequences?

in short a more mature approach than ineffective attempts at discipline on individual occasions which will never work because of the kinds of factors other posters refer to (difficult family life, behaviour difficulties, poor examples from other adults, movies, games, etc…)

Absolutely — in my day this would have warranted a serious talk from the Head to the whole school at assembly, plus a visit from the Head to each classroom in the relevant year group, with a strongly worded talk about verbal abuse and poor language/name calling/treating others with respect, plus reiterating penalties for swearing at other children.

Absolutely no reason why a Head can’t do that today. Most especially in the context of the recent Everyone’s Invited Ofsted report, which found incredibly high incidences of sexual harassment and assault against girls in both primary and secondary schools.

Nothing changes unless schools step up and deal with this rather than handwringing about it not being their problem.

Tamzo85 · 12/05/2022 18:16

@Iamnotthe1

And don’t forget they also often do it because they don’t think it’s fine but know it’s wrong - and kids often want to be edgy or for boys what they see as “hard” or a rebel.

You can’t really stop it, but at the least this particular boy could be made aware that if he yells at that girl again the punishment will increase from the last time. At least that way he will get the idea of only swearing around the kids who want to be like that (and plenty do).

Iamnotthe1 · 12/05/2022 17:32

The majority of children of this age swear when they are out of an adult's earshot but, oddly, most parents would say their particular child doesn't, sometimes even when they have been confronted with evidence.

Across my time as a primary teacher, I have overheard the use of every of swear word and the majority of prejudiced language. Every time something is heard or reported, it is investigated, dealt with and several steps taken in order to try to address this as part of our curriculum.

However, reporting it to the school and whatever they do in response is only treating the symptom and not the root cause. This isn't a single child who believes that swearing is fine because a teacher has taught them that it is. After all, a teacher creating or promoting that kind of cultutr in their classroom or school would likely be sacked. Children think it's fine because other influences in their life show them it's fine, whether that's parents, friends, social media, entertainment, etc. That is the root cause.

northlundunmum · 12/05/2022 17:11

DD didn’t tell a teacher in this occasion but it has happened before and she did raise it. She says he was told off but his behaviour hasn’t changed.

It’s interesting to ask though “what more would I want?” - this has been a helpful trigger for me to think through… Perhaps a concerted effort by staff to engage the children in a conversation about swearing, the difference between swearing about a situation and verbal abuse, the impact that has, what is acceptable and unacceptable - an agreed “zero tolerance” approach to verbal abuse the children can sign up to - with consequences?

in short a more mature approach than ineffective attempts at discipline on individual occasions which will never work because of the kinds of factors other posters refer to (difficult family life, behaviour difficulties, poor examples from other adults, movies, games, etc…)

OP posts:
Jayne35 · 12/05/2022 16:20

I agree with you, I suspect social services were already involved (which did no good as the boy is in prison now!) but the teacher had no interest in speaking to him. I was really angry, and disappointed in the teacher/school.

Momicrone · 12/05/2022 15:51

*that was to jayne 35, deedee, I agree

Momicrone · 12/05/2022 15:50

I disagree, if a kid has a difficult homelike and is being called a cunt at home, surely it's up to the school to show the kid its not normal or acceptable

DeeCeeCherry · 12/05/2022 15:49

Good luck with getting anything done about this. I used to teach school workshops and a 9 year old boy called a girl a fucking dumb bitch in class. The class teacher was present and didnt even flinch. It was as if she didnt hear - but he yelled it so of course she heard.

I told teacher class wouldnt continue unless he was removed. Which he was but, reluctantly. I also suggested a word with the head and his parents but I doubt that happened.

The girl was in tears so I brought her up front with me and class carried on. She joined back in eventually.

I remember thinking is this the kind of repugnant sexism thats acceptable at school these days and girls must put up and shut up? is that what we're teaching girls to do, accept and don't make a fuss?

Its bullshit and should never be excused

Jayne35 · 12/05/2022 15:47

My DD26 was called a fucking c**t (excuse the stars but I really dislike the word) as she was leaving class at age 8 by a boy, I overheard and went straight in to complain to the teacher, her answer was that he has a difficult home life and his parents speak to him like that so there really was nothing she could do about it.

In this case too, there is little school can do about it I imagine, most kids swear, unfortunately.

Bluevelvetsofa · 12/05/2022 15:12

Did you say that your daughter told a teacher and the teacher told the boy off? If so, I’m wondering what else you feel would be appropriate. Of course his aggression should be prevented and there should be a sanction for that.

elle1005 · 12/05/2022 15:02

What does UB mean?