Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not understand the point of SATS?

88 replies

SweetSakura · 11/05/2022 19:15

I'm lucky I guess, DS has tended to do very well on past papers etc so has been quite relaxed about them. But he has been bemused by the fact teachers /TAs have been going round giving a lot of help with answering the questions!
In two cases he said the TA definitely got it wrong as well. (his friend from another school, also very able was over and agreed with DS about the question and the correct answer )

Surely they are pointless if this happens in some schools (DS friend didn't see it happen in his school to be fair)

OP posts:
SheSaysShush · 11/05/2022 20:16

I vaguely remember them being introduced in the mid 80s? I was at primary school and some sort of official exercise took place. Then afterwards (days or weeks later?) we were gathered in the school hall to be told that what took place was a complete flop and to forget it ever took place.

MistressBoleyn · 11/05/2022 20:15

Definitely cheating. Report.
It may be a rogue ta, it may be a schoolwide issue(the fact they were giving incorrect advice makes me think the ta was doing it rogue, any school cheating would at least want the HUGE risk to pay off.

BogRollBOGOF · 11/05/2022 20:15

SATs are a way to generate data out of children to breed more data through secondary school based on false assumptions that children are equations not humans with lives.

This data is then used to beat teachers with because the targets are unrealistic. If the little humans don't perform adequately acording to the equations, then the jobs of teaching staff are on the line/ academy takeovers.

It's nothing to do with quality learning.

I've not done any revision with DS1 who has SENs because if he does too well now, he'll cop the consequences with unrealistic GCSE targets. Just because he's had SPAG drummed into him in y5 & 6, it doesn't mean that he'd match the corresponding target grade in MFL in 5 years time.

I don't object to a low-key standardised, comparable assessment, but it should be about supporting struggling schools, not a battle of political survival resulting in heavy coaching for 2 years.

SweetSakura · 11/05/2022 20:11

Examples include telling them what parts to multiply with each other when working with fractions (my son explained it far more clearly) and telling a child that a quarter of 60 was 20 (my son found this hysterically funny!)

OP posts:
MistressBoleyn · 11/05/2022 20:10

They can explain some vocabulary used in the questions
Depends on the paper, explaining adjectives as describing words in the spag one for example would definitely be cheating.

cansu · 11/05/2022 20:07

Teachers are allowed to read questions in maths and in the grammar. They can explain some vocabulary used in the questions. This could well be what is being described as helping. The answers are not discussed until after this week as a child could take the test late.

MistressBoleyn · 11/05/2022 20:04

Cheating really isn't normal, every school I've ever worked at has stuck rigidly to the rules and the people I trained with have the same experience.
You need to report the school if this is what happened today and not in the practise sessions.
Tas are allowed to read the questions without emphasis as long as they follow the rules in the paper(eg not reading formatted words or substituting words or rewording them) schools are very strict on this as they have to be. All staff are trained in what they can and can't do.
Today was maths, so a reader would've helped those who are gifted mathematicians yet struggle with reading enormously, although only the reasoning paper as the arithmetic one is so straight forward a reader only makes sense for pacing.
Readers really help many children achieve their true potential if used effectively, but what you describe is cheating, not reading.
And yes, sats are basically a stick to beat schools and teachers with and a tool to justify the micromanaging of teachers.
Most secondaries still assess year seven anyway, but as the sats are the first tests children come across I wouldn't want them being unprepared and being put off tests for life. Unfortunately, because they are used to measure the success of the school the teachers need to get the children to do well and some respond badly to the pressure.
It's not fair on the kids, the children or the parents who (falsely) base their assessment of a school on results.
But we're stuck with them until people start valuing teachers and teacher assessment.

Fredthefrog · 11/05/2022 20:03

There should be no help at all. Adults can read questions in maths and spag and explain context like where to put the answer but nothing else. Sounds like maladministration and is very unfair on the schools doing things correctly.
The point if SAT is supposed to be to ensure childrn go up to secondary with a standard level of literacy and maths. They are all about school accountability, OFSTED use them to judge schools and can end up narrowing the curriculum becuase a school will get in to trouble if their results are poor.

SweetSakura · 11/05/2022 19:54

It just seems mad that in reality the league tables then just represent how prepared school staff are to bend the rules

OP posts:
BadgeronaMoped · 11/05/2022 19:30

DS is doing these at the moment, it's not how I remember it in the early 90s when we were just bundled into the hall one morning. I remember my teacher saying the head didn't like us all worrying about the "exam".
DS was in tears as he'd had a TA sitting with him, chivvying him on when he'd not finished the question he was already working on. I assumed the TA was there as he struggles with writing, but he found their presence/help just made it worse. There have been weeks of practice tests and all sorts, it sounds horrible for everyone.

Poppitt58 · 11/05/2022 19:23

You need to contact the LA and inform them of maladministration.

For context, a school local to me were found guilty of this, the head resigned and all results were null and void.

SATs are a crap indicator and narrow the curriculum, however it’s not normal or common for schools to cheat. Teaching staff can’t even discuss question content until June.

APurpleSquirrel · 11/05/2022 19:23

DD is in Yr2 & doing her SATs atm (obviously not quite the same as the Yr6s). Her teacher is livid that they're having to do them & apparently they (gov't) aren't giving any leeway due to Covid/lockdowns etc.
Essentially they want to know how badly effected these children have been by the past 2 years of disruption. Which I imagine will then be used as a stick to beat schools & teachers with - but maybe I'm too cynical? Hmm

Needmorelego · 11/05/2022 19:18

On the whole....they are pointless. It's for the league tables. Which in themselves are nonsense.
No benefit to the actual children.