Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not understand the point of SATS?

88 replies

SweetSakura · 11/05/2022 19:15

I'm lucky I guess, DS has tended to do very well on past papers etc so has been quite relaxed about them. But he has been bemused by the fact teachers /TAs have been going round giving a lot of help with answering the questions!
In two cases he said the TA definitely got it wrong as well. (his friend from another school, also very able was over and agreed with DS about the question and the correct answer )

Surely they are pointless if this happens in some schools (DS friend didn't see it happen in his school to be fair)

OP posts:
PipsM · 11/05/2022 21:01

That makes me so frustrated. My school, and many others, have worked so hard to make sure we follow the rules and then a minority of schools break them. It is maladministration and needs to be reported. We have two members of staff in each room to prevent this from happening.

I’m personally disgusted that sats are taking place, especially in year 2, and the fact ks2 ones are in mental health awareness week sums up the lack of understanding the dfe have.

They are a stick to beat us with. Our y2 data is already lower than normal. We know where each child is working and their areas for development, and testing children isn’t going to change our teacher assessment.

www.gov.uk/guidance/how-to-report-maladministration-at-key-stage-1-and-key-stage-2

LorenzoVonMatterhorn · 11/05/2022 20:57

It was the teacher who got the answer wrong not the child, that's why he found it funny! In the classroom he spends lots of time patiently helping teach others once he has finished his own work. He would never laugh at a child struggling. He was cross the teacher gave his friend a wrong answer.

In two cases he said the TA definitely got it wrong as well. (his friend from another school, also very able was over and agreed with DS about the question and the correct answer)

was it the TA or the teacher?

BerryPieandCustard · 11/05/2022 20:56

my DD has had an absolutely awful experience in year 6 because of SATS and how her school has decided to handle them. She used to enjoy school and she achieves well but any joy of school she had has been lost.

From the start of YR6 there have been regular SATS practice questions a week of practice tests in Feb and then just before Easter but with no real feedback on where they went wrong and how to correct it. These practice test weeks had all other things like art, PE, music cancelled and the days were test, biscuit, break, test, biscuit, lunch, test biscuit, home. So my child managed to consume upwards of 3 biscuits per day at school as reward (bribes for doing tests) while the school send out info on what kids should/should not bring in their lunch/snack

the 3 weeks prior to SATS everything was cancelled to spend those weeks doing practice tests (followed by biscuits). My daughter has become so anxious about the tests to the point her heart races, she feels sick, can’t sleep and cry’s. She spent all of last week off school as she could not cope with all the practice tests with no actual teaching/ showing her how to make corrections.

this week has been absolutely terrible. She has not been able to go in with the rest of the classes to take the SATS as I cannot physically get her to school short of dragging her kicking and screaming. She has had to go in separately at 12:45 to go into a room with 2 staff to take her test. Today she very nearly couldn’t do that, was late going in. Had to have a 15 min break between tests and had to pause her time during the 2nd test (and close her paper) to drink, eat an apple and compose herself.
I’m silently dreading tomorrow. But it’s ok because they are getting Dominos pizza tomorrow afternoon!

I now have a child who is a ball of anxiety and stress and I’m annoyed at the school using food as a bribe/reward. I’m hoping that once SATS are over she returns to her usual self but I am thinking that I need to seek some support for her going forward. I do feel that if the school had handled them differently my DD would not be at the point that she is now 😞

toomuchlaundry · 11/05/2022 20:52

Our school has governors come in to observe the SATs. I also think about 20% of schools have spot checks done by officials

I would report to HT what your son says he heard

Pipkin1234 · 11/05/2022 20:51

That's maladministration and needs reporting. It especially needs to be flagged up in these difficult times. The SATs results need to reflect and highlight just how much these poor kids have missed. I can't believe they have to do them.at all but if they must, the results should at least be accurate.

justfiveminutes · 11/05/2022 20:50

Well I think you've got your answer :

It's not allowed. It will be taken extremely seriously. Talk to the head.

SweetSakura · 11/05/2022 20:49

Of course I am concerned about the point of them. All that stress for teachers and students and then some schools follow the rules and others cheat, rendering them even more meaningless

OP posts:
SweetSakura · 11/05/2022 20:48

@lethimhaveit he's just very able. He finished all the practice tests far earlier than everyone else too and the worst mark he got was one less than full marks. But yeah, attack my son rather than focusing on the issue in hand.

OP posts:
justfiveminutes · 11/05/2022 20:47

There is very strict guidance around administering the tests.

You are absolutely not allowed to help the children. In fact, I know of a Head who was sacked for turning a blind eye to it.

Children can have someone to read the question (apart from the reading tests of course) and other adjustments, but not help.

It is possible they were working through the papers who had been excused from the tests. In our school, they are allowed to do them if they want to but their results won't be submitted. But discussing the answers within earshot of others is not allowed.

I think you must talk to the Head. I doubt you will be the only one if this is true, and as blatant as you describe.

Flavourflava · 11/05/2022 20:47

You don't seem too concerned about the point of SATs so much as concerned we are all aware of the observational skills of your child - so, congrats on that. He sounds a peach.

SweetSakura · 11/05/2022 20:46

It was the teacher who got the answer wrong not the child, that's why he found it funny! In the classroom he spends lots of time patiently helping teach others once he has finished his own work. He would never laugh at a child struggling. He was cross the teacher gave his friend a wrong answer.

And no Chinese whispers here, straight from my son who was able to explain what happened in detail.

Wondering why there is a mean spirited (defensive?) tone creeping in from some answers? I haven't done anything other than express disappointment that it happens.

OP posts:
Vinniepolis · 11/05/2022 20:41

@Lonelyplanetif not published, will the results still be shared with secondary schools? My DD’s school has been going on and on about how the local secondary will use SATs to stream them etc, so if you do badly you will end up in the dullards class (paraphrasing)… then had the gall to email through this poem the night before they started:

SATS don’t see your beauty
SATS don’t see your worth
SATS don’t see the reason
You were put upon this earth…

Too little too bloody late!

LetHimHaveIt · 11/05/2022 20:40

SweetSakura · 11/05/2022 20:30

Definitely today, not practice sessions! DS is very switched on and will have just breezed through the papers which is why he had time to pay attention to what was going on around him

But surely one of the staff would have spoken up?!

I would've told him to go back over his paper and check his work, or that he hadn't accidentally turned over two pages and missed a whole section. It's often the swivel-headed ones finding the tribulations of others 'hilariously funny', who cock things up 🙄

Aroundtheworldin80moves · 11/05/2022 20:39

I can see another child describing my DD as "cheating".... she has had extra time and a scribe in one paper.

Seashor · 11/05/2022 20:34

Well it certainly sounds like a severe case of Chinese Whispers with bells on!
‘He said, she said’.

It’s rigidly controlled with spot checks, training and administration. You weren’t even there for goodness sake! Get back behind your curtain.

fUNNYfACE36 · 11/05/2022 20:33

To monitor the effectiveness of the school

SweetSakura · 11/05/2022 20:30

Definitely today, not practice sessions! DS is very switched on and will have just breezed through the papers which is why he had time to pay attention to what was going on around him

But surely one of the staff would have spoken up?!

OP posts:
Fredthefrog · 11/05/2022 20:29

Often groups for SATS are ability groups as some kids might be entitled to extra time or have been taught in ability groups for year 6 so they stay with adults they know. They need to be spread out so are often in a variety of rooms around the school as well as classrooms. The instructions are clear abiut levels of support /help and do not include subject level info.

Lonelyplanet · 11/05/2022 20:29

I am a year 6 teacher and feel very strongly that SATs should not have happened this year and certainly not this week. We have had to rush through the curriculum, especially in maths, which has been so unfair on children who need to catch up and spend a little longer on areas they missed during lockdown.

However staff cheating is not acceptable in any test and sends the wrong messages to children. The results are not even going to be published this year so I'm not sure why they would do this. There are very tight statutory regulations in administering the tests.

cansu · 11/05/2022 20:26

Agree that you can paraphrase questions hence saying you can explain some vocabulary. You can't explain subject specific words so you can't tell a child what a semi colon is or what it is for but you could tell them the question is asking them to place it in the right place. Most schools have two members of staff in each class to evidence that the rules are followed. What is also true is that if a child asks is this right you cannot tell them if it is right or wrong.

Karwomannghia · 11/05/2022 20:24

Yes you can Google access arrangements if you want to see what is allowed. You can rephrase instructions just not explain the assessed parts.

Karwomannghia · 11/05/2022 20:23

That is not normal. But yes they’re pointless.

LetHimHaveIt · 11/05/2022 20:21

I mean, OP's example strongly suggests maladministration, but some of the responses on here are plainly wrong. You are allowed to paraphrase the questions, and you can explain certain words - I believe the very example given in one of the papers I proctored this week, was that in the direction 'insert brackets into the following sentence . . . ' you can't tell them what 'brackets' means, but you can explain 'insert'.

SweetSakura · 11/05/2022 20:19

My suspension is that it wasn't a rogue TA. He heard chatter from friends in other classrooms of similar happening. But surely at least one of the teachers should have called the others out for doing this?

They seemed to have peeled the children off into ability groups as well to do the tests, with the most able children going first.... (My son's assesment but by year 6 they are all pretty aware of this)

OP posts:
Fredthefrog · 11/05/2022 20:17

If that happened during the test today and not in revision sessions before hand them thatbis cheating and would be a serious problem for the school. I'd ypu report it the local authority would have to investigate. All pupils results would be voided and they would get 0. It will have a negative impact on the teachers and head as the investigation takes months and depending on outcome could cause people to loose their jobs