Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not understand the point of SATS?

88 replies

SweetSakura · 11/05/2022 19:15

I'm lucky I guess, DS has tended to do very well on past papers etc so has been quite relaxed about them. But he has been bemused by the fact teachers /TAs have been going round giving a lot of help with answering the questions!
In two cases he said the TA definitely got it wrong as well. (his friend from another school, also very able was over and agreed with DS about the question and the correct answer )

Surely they are pointless if this happens in some schools (DS friend didn't see it happen in his school to be fair)

OP posts:
PoorMegHopkins · 11/05/2022 22:51

@Littepinkyogapants I’m a year 6 teacher and I don’t cheat or manipulate my data. I think you’ve obviously been unlucky. Most of us don’t.
We do practice- why is that so awful? And I give them biscuits before as some of ours don’t get breakfast.
I think the tests aren’t the problem, it’s what that data is used for. If we used it just to assess then all well and good. But a primary can only really be good if their results are good, so in comes Ofsted.

maddy68 · 11/05/2022 22:50

Noone does. Least all teachers

SweetSakura · 11/05/2022 22:43

@lynn I couldn't give a monkeys about his sats results. I would rather he could have spent the past months learning more broadly!
I don't understand the veiled hatred of very bright people. He can't help it. I don't push him. It just comes easily to him. He has plenty of health battles so life isn't all sunshine and roses for him if that helps you feel less resentful. I just feel lucky for every year he gets to live to see another birthday

OP posts:
SweetSakura · 11/05/2022 22:39

@litte that sounds awful. It must have put you in a horrible position

OP posts:
Littepinkyogapants · 11/05/2022 22:07

Teacher here .
our head teacher and deputy were rubbing out answers and correcting them / dropping huge hints / hunting to answers

I feel awful saying this now - I’ve just handed in my notice but it was absolutely a farce ! People were too scared to whistleblow .

It was the same for the phonics screens !

I imagine most school data is heavily manipulated by teachers sunder pressure ! I will say no more .

JohnPrescottsPyjamas · 11/05/2022 21:59

Having worked as a TA and seen the amount of teaching to the test that goes on, I’m amazed that the DfE are still using such a clumsy tool. My school spent months doing endless past papers in preparation rather than focussing on a broad curriculum. The children that didn’t do so well in the practice papers were then ‘hot housed’ to fill their gaps rather than because they needed help in a broader area. The whole class was even sent home with additional papers as homework. There was a definite air of pressure in the weeks before and noises made about how ‘disappointing’ it would be if anyone was off sick because - and I’m not sure if this is still the case - a registered pupil not sitting a paper on the day was recorded as a nil, which would pull the overall school average score down. Unwell children were encouraged to come in for the hour or so and do their SATs in a separate room with another member of staff.

SATs were supposedly brought in to ensure that pupils were meeting a satisfactory standard of education at particular stages. If that was the case, why are pupils even required to put their names on the papers, why not an anonymous number? Surely, if OFSTED inspections were truly fit for purpose, SATs tests would be irrelevant and redundant? Ironically, as others have posted, my DD is a secondary school teacher and has said on numerous occasions that the SAT scores many new Y7 pupils arrive with, have no reflection on their true ability.

Karwomannghia · 11/05/2022 21:44

Singleandproud · 11/05/2022 21:31

They can be quite useful for predicting grades and to help setting in Yr 7. Students that get between 80-90 are likely to need more support and can be identified early which is particularly useful if no learning needs have been identified officially at Primary. Children getting between 110-120 need alot more challenge and can be put into specific sets.

Generally, but not always the Sat's results track all the way up to Yr 11. Exceptions tend to be children who speak English as a second language who hadnt picked it up enough in Primary but make great improvement in secondary. It's also quite obvious who has perhaps been given more help than they should have in Yr 6 Sat's as they simply never perform to that level during their time at high school. Those students then need extra input as previous high achievers who are under performing.

It would be better to use wider ability range standardised assessments though. SATs are so narrow and don’t give a lot of helpful information apart from 3 broad groups.

Karwomannghia · 11/05/2022 21:40

Lynnthesearesexnotgenderpeople · 11/05/2022 21:24

We all know by now that the SATs are to see check that most children are performing 'above average'. And if most children are not 'above average' then that is entirely the fault of teachers who need to be hauled over the coals and have their schools turned into academies.

Exactly. Shame the Dfe don’t understand statistics and expect more than 50% of children to be above average.

User65412 · 11/05/2022 21:38

I don't think it's ridiculous to suggest reporting it. I've worked so hard with my class all year and it breaks my heart their results will be affected by others cheating. And no - it's not about the reflection on us as a school.
They should absolutely be scrapped. For the last 6 years my pay and appraisal targets have been based on my class' sats results. It's so unhealthy.

cantkeepawayforever · 11/05/2022 21:37

Just ring the school in the morning and mention it - exactly and precisely as your son reported it. the school will investigate, and it will either be proved or disproved, and the integrity of the SATs (if such a test is to be useful at all, it at least has to be fair) will hopefully be maintained.

We have had parents ring in with things their children have said, in a 'my child said this, not sure if it's true, knew you'd want to know' way. Carefully, fully and quickly investigated and sorted. Not a particularly fun thing to have to deal with, but just part of the job. Much better to mention it rather than continue to snipe from the sidelines about what might have happened.

Lynnthesearesexnotgenderpeople · 11/05/2022 21:33

Obviously she is not going to report it because its her sons school and she wouldn't want her own sons SATs publicly undermined, especially if he is getting full marks on everything....

On balance of probability your son has probably got his wires crossed anyway - very few schools would risk cheating, and if they were going to take that risk they wouldn't allow a TA to be giving the wrong answers!

Singleandproud · 11/05/2022 21:31

They can be quite useful for predicting grades and to help setting in Yr 7. Students that get between 80-90 are likely to need more support and can be identified early which is particularly useful if no learning needs have been identified officially at Primary. Children getting between 110-120 need alot more challenge and can be put into specific sets.

Generally, but not always the Sat's results track all the way up to Yr 11. Exceptions tend to be children who speak English as a second language who hadnt picked it up enough in Primary but make great improvement in secondary. It's also quite obvious who has perhaps been given more help than they should have in Yr 6 Sat's as they simply never perform to that level during their time at high school. Those students then need extra input as previous high achievers who are under performing.

Dajeeling · 11/05/2022 21:27

Yes I know. Just responding to the posters itching for you to do so!

SweetSakura · 11/05/2022 21:25

I haven't suggested I will report it. I just came on here to express suprise that it was happening.

OP posts:
Lynnthesearesexnotgenderpeople · 11/05/2022 21:24

We all know by now that the SATs are to see check that most children are performing 'above average'. And if most children are not 'above average' then that is entirely the fault of teachers who need to be hauled over the coals and have their schools turned into academies.

SweetSakura · 11/05/2022 21:23

I'm going to ignore the negative comments about my son. They say far more about the people making them. He can't help that he finds this work easy, any more than a child who is struggling. And it is pretty ridiculous if children are being given incorrect answers.

As to the suggestion it is made up - I have better things to do with my evening than troll people.

OP posts:
Dajeeling · 11/05/2022 21:23

Don’t report it ffs. As we have all agreed they don’t matter anyway. Honestly some posters on here just look for any reason to make others’ lives difficult. Worst case scenario if they are found ‘guilty’ of this is that the school will be without a head for a while and probably go down the pan.

2Hooves · 11/05/2022 21:22

My daughters school haven't hugely pressured them about SATs but he parents seem to be taking it very seriously.
DD broke her hand last week and the playground is now rife with gossip of cheating as she's had to have a scribe.

Olsi109 · 11/05/2022 21:19

nutellingyou · 11/05/2022 21:11

My son's school have been doing past papers regularly since February. Even this week they've had the proper tests in the morning and continued doing practice papers in the afternoon. He's totally burnt out. It's ALL for the school as the local secondary school don't use SATs results to stream, they use their own assessments as we're on the border with Wales who don't do SATs.

He asked me today what would happen if he fails...
I said "nothing" and explained that it doesn't have any effect on anything. Poor DS.

This.

Most secondary schools don't even use them we use assessments of our own at beg of year 7 or on transition days.

They are basically as some PP's have said for statistics and data to determine what the average child is scoring NW, and if primary's don't come near to those scores then why?

Lynnthesearesexnotgenderpeople · 11/05/2022 21:18

SweetSakura · 11/05/2022 20:46

It was the teacher who got the answer wrong not the child, that's why he found it funny! In the classroom he spends lots of time patiently helping teach others once he has finished his own work. He would never laugh at a child struggling. He was cross the teacher gave his friend a wrong answer.

And no Chinese whispers here, straight from my son who was able to explain what happened in detail.

Wondering why there is a mean spirited (defensive?) tone creeping in from some answers? I haven't done anything other than express disappointment that it happens.

Well, cheating is strictly forbidden in the SATs, so if you believe your son is 100% correct and cheating was going on at his school today, you need to report don't you?

nutellingyou · 11/05/2022 21:11

My son's school have been doing past papers regularly since February. Even this week they've had the proper tests in the morning and continued doing practice papers in the afternoon. He's totally burnt out. It's ALL for the school as the local secondary school don't use SATs results to stream, they use their own assessments as we're on the border with Wales who don't do SATs.

He asked me today what would happen if he fails...
I said "nothing" and explained that it doesn't have any effect on anything. Poor DS.

LucilleBluth · 11/05/2022 21:08

So your son is smarter than the TA, he’s just so bright and amazing. He finds it funny that the TA is thick, meanwhile he’s teaching the lower ability kids.

😀😀😀😀😭

SweetSakura · 11/05/2022 21:06

@lorenzo TA I meant.

OP posts:
LetHimHaveIt · 11/05/2022 21:06

'It was the teacher who got the answer wrong not the child, that's why he found it funny!'

Yes, thank you, my own comprehension skills are pretty well-honed - although I've never performed so well that my worst mark was 'one less than full marks'. But the child was moved to - allegedly - ask the TA for the - apparently wrong - answer to a pretty straightforward question, so was clearly struggling.

I strongly suspect this is all bollocks, anyway.

Onlyforcake · 11/05/2022 21:03

They are pointless, they dont tell you much about the school, they encourage teach to test approach rather than learners who have a clue how to use resources etc.

I suppose its almost directly inverse to the hallmark of a good school. So useful in where to avoid.