Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not understand the point of SATS?

88 replies

SweetSakura · 11/05/2022 19:15

I'm lucky I guess, DS has tended to do very well on past papers etc so has been quite relaxed about them. But he has been bemused by the fact teachers /TAs have been going round giving a lot of help with answering the questions!
In two cases he said the TA definitely got it wrong as well. (his friend from another school, also very able was over and agreed with DS about the question and the correct answer )

Surely they are pointless if this happens in some schools (DS friend didn't see it happen in his school to be fair)

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Iamnotthe1 · 13/05/2022 17:23

I had no standardised ‘this-will-determine-the-rest-of-your-life vibe’ kind of exams ever (literally not even our equivalent of A-levels was that crazy). I went to uni in the UK and had nothing but distinction. Am educated to doctoral level. I am so glad I did not have the fun in learning tested out of me age eleven.

It doesn't have to remove the fun aspects of learning nor does it have to have a "rest of your life" approach. It's about balance in education and openness about what the tests are and how they work. Unfortunately, it's the external pressures from the DfE, the Government and Ofsted that prevent some schools from being able to find that balance.

AlmondyCookie · 13/05/2022 15:04

Iamnotthe1 · 12/05/2022 21:18

No, parental consent is not required for the SATs. If your child is in school during the test week or the week after, they will have to sit the papers.

However, hot housing isn't something that has to happen. As a Y6 teacher, I have never narrowed my curriculum and absolutely would not do it.

SATs do have an impact on the child as their GCSE targets are set from them. A child without results will still sit their GCSEs, of course, but they won't count towards the secondary school's progress scores so, unfortunately, when the school is allocating resources such as teacher time etc. a child that "doesn't count" will not be seen as a priority.

Wow that’s awful. What a messed up system. I did not move to the UK till university and am thus not familiar with how things work here, but it sounds so sad. No wonder every second child on mumsnet seems to have an anxiety disorder. I will seriously have to think through what I’m going to do once my kids hit school age. I don’t want this for them. I had no standardised ‘this-will-determine-the-rest-of-your-life vibe’ kind of exams ever (literally not even our equivalent of A-levels was that crazy). I went to uni in the UK and had nothing but distinction. Am educated to doctoral level. I am so glad I did not have the fun in learning tested out of me age eleven.

DietrichandDiMaggio · 12/05/2022 22:12

Lonelyplanet · 12/05/2022 18:21

You are wrong about this. Most schools follow the rules to the letter. Staff know it wouldn't be worth losing their job over and that is what would happen if they were caught cheating. The tests have to stay within vision of at least 2 members of staff or be in a secure locked cupboard at all times. Moderators can and do drop in without notice. If your school has 2 SLT who are so unprofessional then I think you should whistle-blow, not post on social media and suggest that all schools are doing the same. They most certainly are not.

We had a moderator come in this morning and there was a brief moment of panic, but because we know we do everything correctly we just did what we have done all week and she left very happy with what she had seen (including the breakfast we serve).

Iamnotthe1 · 12/05/2022 21:18

AlmondyCookie · 12/05/2022 20:20

This whole SATS thing sounds awful. Can parents opt their children out of this? I see zero benefit of this to a child and if at all preventable would not want my child hothoused for pointless exam at such a young age. So can you as a parent say to the school, sorry DC will not be sitting this exam and keep them off?

No, parental consent is not required for the SATs. If your child is in school during the test week or the week after, they will have to sit the papers.

However, hot housing isn't something that has to happen. As a Y6 teacher, I have never narrowed my curriculum and absolutely would not do it.

SATs do have an impact on the child as their GCSE targets are set from them. A child without results will still sit their GCSEs, of course, but they won't count towards the secondary school's progress scores so, unfortunately, when the school is allocating resources such as teacher time etc. a child that "doesn't count" will not be seen as a priority.

CraftyGin · 12/05/2022 21:02

Retired secondary teacher here...

I have been helping with SATS at my DIL's school this week.

I was in the main hall with the bulk of the students so not involved with those with access arrangements.

We were straight up with the rules. We could read the question in the Maths and SPAG papers, but nothing else, and we genuinely did follow the rules.

I see the value of SATS. I have taught almost exclusively in small independent schools and used SATS papers for end of year assessments (which we marked ourselves). It gave us a very important benchmark against national standards.

toomuchlaundry · 12/05/2022 20:53

Schools are usually very supportive of Y6s whilst doing their SATS, and they normally give breakfast/snacks. The only thing DS remembers about his SATS are the snacks!

AlmondyCookie · 12/05/2022 20:20

This whole SATS thing sounds awful. Can parents opt their children out of this? I see zero benefit of this to a child and if at all preventable would not want my child hothoused for pointless exam at such a young age. So can you as a parent say to the school, sorry DC will not be sitting this exam and keep them off?

Remmy123 · 12/05/2022 19:43

My son has just done his year 6 SATS. He wasn't bothered in the slightest and nor was I.

some parents got their kids tutors for ten - totally pointless!!!!

justfiveminutes · 12/05/2022 19:26

No upset Y6 children at our school.

The pupils don't practise and we tell them they are of no importance.

They all know that if they can't answer a question, it's probably a stupid question.

Each day is about an hour or 90 mins of tests, then wall-to-wall fun.

If your kids are stressed, they're at the wrong school.

Iamnotthe1 · 12/05/2022 19:21

SweetSakura · 11/05/2022 21:25

I haven't suggested I will report it. I just came on here to express suprise that it was happening.

Please report it.
Things like this have a knock on effect on the rest of the children on a national level. Actions like those of the staff in your child's school will lead to some children missing out on achieving what they deserve as they affect the grade boundaries.

LondonQueen · 12/05/2022 19:11

It's awful and we should transition to teacher based assessment. I've seen upset Y6's all week.

BorisJohnsonatemyhampster · 12/05/2022 19:09

Cheating isn’t normal and you should report it. One of my DC did theirs this week and the process was very strict. There was no cheating. Cheating is a terrible message to show to children. I don’t agree that league tables show which schools are prepared to cheat at all.

thebellagio · 12/05/2022 18:51

My child is year 2. I’m absolutely fucking disgusted that the DFE think it’s appropriate to implement national tests for a cohort that have yet to have a full year of school

Pinkflipflop85 · 12/05/2022 18:50

Titsflyingsouth · 12/05/2022 18:24

I used to be a secondary school teacher back when they had year 9 SATS. 'Teaching to the test', which all teachers are pretty much compelled to do, was the most soul destroying part of my teaching career.

SATS are utterly pointless - not only do they measure a ridiculously narrow range of skills/knowledge but there is no like-for-like comparison of grades over the years. Some years we found the grades ridiculously inflated, other years the grading was overly harsh.

My son is 2 years away from SATS and I'm seriously considering withdrawing him from school for test week and just sucking up the fine.

Depending on your school that may prove challenging.

KS1 sats don't have a fixed week with tests on specific days. There is a bigger window for assessment. We do ours over 3 weeks in groups and absent children get theirs done before the deadline.

wonderstuff · 12/05/2022 18:38

I work in secondary and part of my job is looking at data and although I’m really not a fan of SATS for all the reasons already mentioned, I have missed having the data. No one test can be relied upon to measure a child’s ability or potential, we to a cognitive assessment test battery when kids join in year 7 and in normal years we look at this alongside SAT scores and teacher assessment to assess progress and decide on what intervention work is needed. Without SAT we’ve just had the CAT and teacher assessment and I’m afraid sometimes teachers assessments are not at all reliable in KS3.

WindyKnickers · 12/05/2022 18:34

They have a purpose for sure; to measure the effectiveness of the school in certain areas, to ensure the curriculum is being taught, to get children used to working in exam conditions. The popular suggestion that they are pointless and of no benefit is false. I'm sure we could all do a better job of education secretary blah blah blah but schools do need to be held to account in some form or another.

I'm not a fan of SATS but I can see a need for some sort of standard assessment at year 6.

Plantstrees · 12/05/2022 18:32

My DC was excluded from doing SATS as he couldn't read well enough - we were just told he should not attend school on the day of the exam. Makes the whole exercise pointless in my view.

cecilthehungryspider · 12/05/2022 18:29

You should report it! This is the second thread I've read today about schools cheating on SATs. It does make it pointless if that is widespread but it wasn't my experience of being in school. Where I worked it was taken very seriously and a staff member got into loads of trouble for helping a child in KS1 SATs (she was just soft-hearted and didn't like seeing the child struggle). It was a huge drama with people coming into the school to check everything.

www.gov.uk/guidance/how-to-report-maladministration-at-key-stage-1-and-key-stage-2

Fairislefandango · 12/05/2022 18:27

On balance of probability your son has probably got his wires crossed anyway - very few schools would risk cheating

Some schools absolutely do cheat. It is then quite apparent at secondary school when kids from certain feeder schools consistently have data which doesn't match their ability.

Titsflyingsouth · 12/05/2022 18:24

I used to be a secondary school teacher back when they had year 9 SATS. 'Teaching to the test', which all teachers are pretty much compelled to do, was the most soul destroying part of my teaching career.

SATS are utterly pointless - not only do they measure a ridiculously narrow range of skills/knowledge but there is no like-for-like comparison of grades over the years. Some years we found the grades ridiculously inflated, other years the grading was overly harsh.

My son is 2 years away from SATS and I'm seriously considering withdrawing him from school for test week and just sucking up the fine.

Lonelyplanet · 12/05/2022 18:21

Littepinkyogapants · 11/05/2022 22:07

Teacher here .
our head teacher and deputy were rubbing out answers and correcting them / dropping huge hints / hunting to answers

I feel awful saying this now - I’ve just handed in my notice but it was absolutely a farce ! People were too scared to whistleblow .

It was the same for the phonics screens !

I imagine most school data is heavily manipulated by teachers sunder pressure ! I will say no more .

You are wrong about this. Most schools follow the rules to the letter. Staff know it wouldn't be worth losing their job over and that is what would happen if they were caught cheating. The tests have to stay within vision of at least 2 members of staff or be in a secure locked cupboard at all times. Moderators can and do drop in without notice. If your school has 2 SLT who are so unprofessional then I think you should whistle-blow, not post on social media and suggest that all schools are doing the same. They most certainly are not.

Horst · 12/05/2022 17:08

They are pointless. The first thing they did when I started secondary was retest all of us in every subject to set us as sats where seen as taught to rather useful, same for my brother 4 years later and my sons secondary did the same.

there is a school locally that always get good results yet the secondary admit that the majority of children couldn’t of possible of got the scores given.

macbethany · 12/05/2022 16:57

I understand why people criticise SATS.

But the system has benefits as well, and personally I found it was very helpful for children like DD2. (DD1 missed out due to lockdown)

Why we liked the SATS process:


  1. It provided a set of age-appropriate learning objectives to master. Not a complete set; but a useful set.

  2. It was a challenge - especially because lockdown interrupted school for a year - but a challenge she was ready for.

  3. I started working with her in addition to what she was doing at school in January; and she learnt what it feels like to study regularly but gradually for an extended period of 4 months.

  4. Past papers showed her the benefit of studying as she could see her results improving.

  5. There were lots of useful free resources on the internet. And reasonably priced exercise books on Amazon.

  6. She learnt useful lessons about checking her work, pacing herself in a test, and reading questions carefully etc.

  7. She and I feel she is now better prepared for the challenges she will face at secondary school.

  8. She is happy and proud of herself this evening after finishing the final SATS paper. She is also proud of other things she did this year.

  9. She is looking forward to the celebratory party the school has organised tomorrow afternoon.

  10. The week was well-organised. Tests in the morning in the school hall. Usual break times. And other activities in the afternoon.

  11. She won't receive results until July, when they will be of mild interest. She already believes the tests went well.

  12. Her results will (roughly) reflect what she can achieve when she applies herself and be one (of several) indicators of her potential at secondary school.


Like most public policies, SATS suits some better than others.
The question is whether it is overall beneficial, and whether there are specific adjustments that would make it better.
Answering those questions would take quite alot of research.

DietrichandDiMaggio · 12/05/2022 00:30

Practising not practicing!

DietrichandDiMaggio · 12/05/2022 00:27

PoorMegHopkins · 11/05/2022 22:51

@Littepinkyogapants I’m a year 6 teacher and I don’t cheat or manipulate my data. I think you’ve obviously been unlucky. Most of us don’t.
We do practice- why is that so awful? And I give them biscuits before as some of ours don’t get breakfast.
I think the tests aren’t the problem, it’s what that data is used for. If we used it just to assess then all well and good. But a primary can only really be good if their results are good, so in comes Ofsted.

Agree with this. Yes, it's frustrating when you glance at a child's paper and they've misunderstood a question, but you can't tell them to have another look at it, because by doing so you would be telling them they have got the answer wrong.
Obviously we do some practice papers throughout the year (3 or4 of each), which means they are familiar with the format when they sit them, but don't send papers home for homework, or spend weeks practicing in lessons. This week apart from the tests, they have done art, PE or ICT lessons -certainly no English and Maths.
We open early and offer them breakfast, so they have a nice relaxed start to the day. Our children are not stressed, because they know all they have to do is try to do the best they can to show what they know. We know which children are unlikely to make expected standard and would not cheat to boost their marks.