Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think a week's suspension isn't enough for this ?

61 replies

milkyway100 · 11/05/2022 18:40

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10805247/Doctor-43-unlawfully-accessed-pregnant-ex-girlfriends-medical-records.html

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
WorriedMumofTeen16 · 12/05/2022 13:41

Sorry, work experience at 15

WorriedMumofTeen16 · 12/05/2022 13:40

TabithaTittlemouse · 11/05/2022 19:20

She is not his patient. He knew it was wrong.

One of my family members was referred to my team. I made it clear to the team that I was not to be involved in their care, excused myself from meetings where they were discussed and although I could easily have accessed their records the thought never crossed my mind.

When I was 15 part of my work was in the histocytology lab, mounting samples on slides. One came through with my aunt's name and it roughly matched her age. May have been her or may not but I alerted work experience supervisor and that one wasn't mounted by me. I knew it wouldn't be right for me to do that slide at 15 so he damn well knew what he was doing was far worse

WorriedMumofTeen16 · 12/05/2022 13:37

ODFOx · 12/05/2022 08:57

There was a story in the news in the last week about a woman (a ward manager I think) who was sacked for looking up the ward number of her son's ex and popping in to say congratulations and give her new baby a toy.
Looking up someone's details is totally forbidden. There should be no exceptions.

She then went on to manage to get a GP reception job, whether she's kept it since this has hit the press I'm unsure

Discovereads · 12/05/2022 13:31

It's a quote by Voltaire, and it does what it says on the tin. It is used all the time in writing to mean "setting an example"

But there’s a nuance to the phrase as to what sort of example is being set. This phrase means setting an example by punishing someone who didn’t do enough, not setting an example by punishing someone who did something wrong/committed a crime. Have a second look at the context, you’ll see.

Brefugee · 12/05/2022 12:20

So you think he should not only lose his job, but he barred from practicing medicine the rest of his life? You’re one of those no second chances type of people aren’t you.

No I'm not. But what he did isn't a bagatelle. It is huge. You can be struck off for a year or so. Just to drive a point home.

By the way your French is wrong you said “for encouraging the others” when I think you mean to discourage or deter others, which is pour dissuader les autres.

My French is fine, thanks. It's a quote by Voltaire, and it does what it says on the tin. It is used all the time in writing to mean "setting an example". Oh wait - are you the radiologist?

crashingagainandagain · 12/05/2022 10:33

A week’s suspension seems like a joke… !

I would have hated this. Wouldn’t want to be treated by him either!

DifficultBloodyWoman · 12/05/2022 10:25

I wonder if this could be used by the woman in question in a private prosecution?

I suspect that there might be a back story here as well and this might form a pattern of behaviour.

PutinIsAWarCriminal · 12/05/2022 10:22

His baby but more importantly her body. I don't believe he should have been sacked, it isn't as though we have an abundance of doctors, but there do still need to be stronger repercussions then just a week off work.
I wonder though how many people in privileged positions do this, council workers, HR staff, police, all have access to records of people they know. I bet sneaking a peak, however awful, isn't as uncommon as we like to think.

gothereagain · 12/05/2022 10:11

Disgusting behaviour. Final written warning and probation at the very least. That's what happened to a nurse I worked with who looked up a celebrities details. Admittedly she was possibly planning to sell the info however I almost think doing it to your own family is worse!

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 12/05/2022 10:08

CompostMaker · 11/05/2022 18:53

Was it his baby? If it was then I completely understand why he would want to look at the ultrasound. I think it was too harsh - he should have perhaps been spoken too by a supervisor. He hasn’t really done anything terrible, just looked at some ultrasound pictures and test results.

I can understand him wanting to look, but actually doing it? No.

If ‘because it’s his baby’ is a justification for this then it’s a slippery slide to ‘unless both parents agree an abortion can’t be had’. A woman’s body is her own and this is despicable behaviour. He should have been sacked at the least and would have been I reckon had it not been because of a pregnancy.

farmerboy · 12/05/2022 10:03

Final written warning would be more appropriate

Jellycatspyjamas · 12/05/2022 09:58

It’s not at all understandable. He accessed her confidential health records with no clinical cause, because he wanted to. Total misuse of power, disregard for her privacy and breach of legislation. Ethically and legally he doesn’t have a leg to stand on - I’d be sacked and struck off if I did the same in my non-medical job.

OnceAgainWithFeeling · 12/05/2022 09:58

There are so few experts on medical disciplinary processes. It is unbelievably hard (near impossible) to discipline a medic, never mind sack them. Believe me. It’s nothing like the usual disciplinary process you would expect and involves barristers from the off.

SaintJavelin · 12/05/2022 09:55

He should have been sacked.

godmum56 · 12/05/2022 09:53

I would sack but not strike off. Terry Pratchett wrote in one of his books "If you will do it for a good reason, you will do it for a bad one." Opinions on whether his reason was a good one or a bad one may vary but the consequence MUST always be the same. If its not then the system won't be trusted.

Jalepenojello · 12/05/2022 09:52

YANBU OP, That is really concerning. Can’t believe some people are so blasé about it. The thought that someone, anyone, can just access my medical records and be let off so lightly angers me. Its really not relevant that she was pregnant IMO.

SweetPetrichor · 12/05/2022 09:47

I don't think he should be sacked for a first offence. I can understand why he did it - although it was definitely wrong. But I'd rather have his skills available to people rather than sacking for doing something understandable. If it was a second offence, sure, sack them.

DisgruntledSloth · 12/05/2022 09:40

Sackable offence at my work (not NHS, Civil Service) and possible prosecution.

An absolute disgrace. He should be sacked at the very least.

ScrambledSmegs · 12/05/2022 09:34

Massive breach - he should have been sacked. He knew it was wrong, he'd had the training. Really not comfortable with an NHS that lets stuff like this slide.

Also why have previous posters stated that she broke up with him? I didn't see that in the article. It says they broke up on the same day she told him she was pregnant. It's a neutral statement but most of us know what breaking up on the same day you tell someone you're pregnant means.

SolasAnla · 12/05/2022 09:25

Discovereads · 12/05/2022 08:56

I repeat: he should be struck off. As punishment for him and pour encourager les autres as they say.

So you think he should not only lose his job, but he barred from practicing medicine the rest of his life? You’re one of those no second chances type of people aren’t you. One mistake and the person gets tossed into a human rubbish pile. By the way your French is wrong you said “for encouraging the others” when I think you mean to discourage or deter others, which is pour dissuader les autres.

He decided to stalk her
• after he decided to form a permanent relationship with another person
• after he decided to not inform her of his decision to create a formal relationship with someone who was not her.

He decided to use his job to gain access to her life.

He made that decision about his job (to stalk her, break and enter and steal from his job)
knowing that it is regarded as professional misconduct and that by his action he risked his professional qualifications too.

It was not one mistake it was a number of active choices which he made.

OnceAgainWithFeeling · 12/05/2022 09:12

Woah. Personal health information is as confidential as it gets under GDPR.

Discovereads · 12/05/2022 09:09

ODFOx · 12/05/2022 08:57

There was a story in the news in the last week about a woman (a ward manager I think) who was sacked for looking up the ward number of her son's ex and popping in to say congratulations and give her new baby a toy.
Looking up someone's details is totally forbidden. There should be no exceptions.

Poor woman. I still think sacking on first offence is draconian. It’s not like it’s classified information that you’ve shared causing people to die. It’s a breach of privacy, yes, but suspension without pay is similar to the fines that corporations pay when they do a GDPR breach. Corporations aren’t “struck off” as in forced to cease trading/working and close down the business. So why should a human person be held to a higher standard?

MiniatureHotdog · 12/05/2022 09:08

Urgh the misogyny in some of these replies. Like how it's his baby, he must've been upset. Will no one think of the poor manz feelz. Urgh.

The rules are clear. He broke them intentionally. A week's suspension is an absolute joke.

DifficultBloodyWoman · 12/05/2022 09:03

I’m stunned at the first two responses to this.

I have to ask, are you women and are you in the UK?

This is absolutely a sackable offence.

lancsgirl85 · 12/05/2022 09:03

This is a huge breach of confidentiality. I work for a mental health trust and it just so happens that I've also had mental health treatment under the same Trust (but a different team to the one I work in), as has one of my friends. If I looked up my friend's record, I'd be harshly disciplined and likely suspended. I'd also be in a lot of trouble for accessing my own record without going through the appropriate channels via the team who treated me. This sort of thing is really not OK and there is no excuse.