Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask my DH not to tell his friends about IVF treatment?

89 replies

AJKAnna · 11/05/2022 17:52

We have been TTC for 2.5 years. Got pregnant early on in the journey twice but both ended in miscarriage, the last one 15 months ago. We have decided to start IVF.

Two of my husband's closest female friends got married and started TTC at roughly the same time. One of them has two children and the other is 6 months pregnant with her second. We all live near each other and used to all meet up as a group of six and have dinner etc so it's been really difficult coping as they move on with their lives and are enjoying parenthood and we are still struggling. It was especially difficult with the first ones when we were all pregnant at about the same time but mine ended in miscarriage. I had dreams that we'd all push our prams round the park together and that's come true for them but not for me sadly.

I have pulled back a bit from socialising with them (of course it has been lockdown too as all this has happened so we were socialising less anyway). They have been completely sensitive and sympathetic to what we are going through and I would like to think I have behaved OK too, but it is obviously difficult for all of us. Also, while I have always got on well with them they are not my friends but DH's friends. I do have other friends who I was always much closer with and who are at different stages in their life so we haven't had the challenge of coping with different fertility journeys.

My husband still meets up with them individually. Next weekend he is going out for lunch with the two women and their children. He didn't ask me and in fact didn't tell me about until I asked. I asked him not to tell them that we are going through IVF but just to keep it vague and say we are still trying (they know about the miscarriages). I really dislike the idea of the three of them together discussing my fertility and medical issues. I actually feel a bit humiliated by it.

DH got very annoyed when I asked him not to talk about it with them. He said he is finding things tough too and he needs a support network as much as I do. I get that but he has other friends too and is close to his mum who knows all about it and has been supportive to both of us and who I get on very well with too. I am just asking him to not talk about it with two specific people where it is just really really awkward through no-one's fault. If I were them I'm not sure I would find it easy to talk about it with him either!

He made me feel like I was being an unreasonable jealous cow over it. I don't think I am being unreasonable, I think it's a perfectly fair request.

So AIBU?

OP posts:
Loopytiles · 11/05/2022 20:39

OP isn’t being ‘controlling’ and hasn’t ‘denied’ her H the opportunity to seek support for himself.

She’s upset that he’s lied (by omission) about and spoken to these female friends specifically.

Having experienced fertility issues and been OK about our partner discussing it with others shouldn’t mean we can’t appreciate that other women want privacy and some boundaries.

LetitiaLeghorn · 11/05/2022 20:35

Loopytiles · 11/05/2022 20:11

‘He told me of the failures, successes and the strain it puts on everyday life’ Those things concerned his wife, not just your friend.

‘I know his wife, I saw her during the treatment but I never said anything to her about it. It wasn't my business.’

And yet you talked to her H about her business.

Wonder if she knew. Wonder if he also talked to a male ‘close friend’ or just enjoyed another woman’s attention.

It's HIS business just as much as hers. They were his failures and successes just as much as hers. We talked about him not her. He can share with his friends what is necessary for him to get him through the difficult times. Someone above used the word 'emotional' and its exactly that. I listened to him but he didn't share clinical details and I wouldn't ask.

No, I didn't say anything to his wife because it's not my place to bring it up. I didn't bring it up with him either. We only discussed it when he wanted to.

He's my friend. There's nothing sexual or flirtatious between us. Why would you try to put that slant on it? I don't give him attention and he doesn't give me attention. We're just good friends who usually just talk about mundane things bu occasionally share other things too. I have mental health problems and he's been great with advice and support. He might have spoken to other friends, I don't know. I didn't ask.

I have another friend whose husband had terminal cancer. No secret to it. And she used to talk about the strain of it and the stresses of that too. Should she just keep it all in because she shouldn't talk about her husbands illness? She spoke of how it affected her not about his private matters.

Useranon1 · 11/05/2022 20:34

I think you're being a bit unreasonable.

Can you not draw the line he not talk about your medical info? So he can say that the two of you are doing ivf and talk about the last two years etc, without going into detail of your diagnosis or detail experience

BlueOverYellow · 11/05/2022 20:26

You are undergoing invasive medical procedures to get pregnant after miscarrying twice. I don't think it's unreasonable to request that it not be a fair game topic of conversation with just anybody. He is entitled to a support network, however. But these two women may not be the best choice from your perspective, and that's understandable.

You also need to talk to him about how it makes you feel and what you had envisioned. I would also gently ask him how he would feel if the IVF were necessary due to a low sperm count on his part and you wanted to share the difficulties 'for support' with the same two female friends whom you envisioned raising children alongside. Can he honestly say it wouldn't bother him? It's a perspective he might understand...

doingitforthegirls · 11/05/2022 20:19

Honestly.....I've been through several miscarriages and several rounds of IVF and I wish my DH had talked about it with his friends.

If the tables were turned and he had asked you not to discuss how would you feel? To be honest he would be labelled controlling amongst other things.

There are often threads about how our partners aren't emotionally involved or invested in fertility treatment but then you want to deny him to ability to talk about it?

If we don't talk about it we don't remove the stigma around it

It wasn't until I finally became pregnant after 5 rounds and I was open with male colleagues about how I conceived that they opened up about their own children coming from IVF and I could tell they actually found it cathartic talking to me about it

Mamai90 · 11/05/2022 20:16

You definitely aren't being unreasonable. There's no shame in IVF but as a women who suffered infertility myself I was ashamed, it was my issue but I couldn't help feeling how I did. Every time I was asked about children I felt I had to explain myself. It was horrible, and some people are awkward about it when you say you don't have kids, as if 'poor you' a lot of this might have been in my head though OP.

I can sympathise with your miscarriages too. When I did IVF it ended in miscarriage and what I didn't know that my best friend was doing IVF at the same time as me (she had a lot of fertility issues and was scared to tell anyone). Just when I had my miscarriage and about a week after my D&C she phoned me to say she was pregnant (sensitively). It was very hard as our babies were due a week apart.

Four years later I still hadn't had a baby and she rang me to say she was pregnant again. I was ok with other people's pregnancies but this brought everything back. I felt awful for feeling jealous as she deserved the happiness but I wished for a baby so we could be pregnant together. Two months later I got a shock surprise, I got my wish.

Sorry for waffling on but I totally get you and no, your husband shouldn't be discussing it. I have no problems with DH having close female friends as I have close male ones but I would have absolutely hated him discussing our fertility issues with them.

YANBU and wishing you well on your IVF journey.

Loopytiles · 11/05/2022 20:11

‘He told me of the failures, successes and the strain it puts on everyday life’ Those things concerned his wife, not just your friend.

‘I know his wife, I saw her during the treatment but I never said anything to her about it. It wasn't my business.’

And yet you talked to her H about her business.

Wonder if she knew. Wonder if he also talked to a male ‘close friend’ or just enjoyed another woman’s attention.

Justtobeclear · 11/05/2022 20:07

I think YABa little U. I’ve been through multiple cycles of IVF and the strain on your relationship will be immense. He’s discussing something significant in his life with people that he trusts and I think that’s really important. The process is invasive for the woman and this leads to us getting lots of support whilst the partners often get overlooked. Whilst they don’t do the physical side the emotional toll can be significant. He may find that by talking about it now he can lay the foundations for support from them when he has to be strong for you. Also, I found it much easier talking to my friends/sister at times because I could be brutally honest whereas we were constantly trying to stay positive for each other.

LetitiaLeghorn · 11/05/2022 20:06

Loopytiles · 11/05/2022 20:04

LetitiaLeghorn Unless you explicitly asked your male friend whether his wife was OK about him sharing information about their fertility issues, you did NOT ‘respect boundaries’.

He shared his issues not hers. He's entitled to look for support from his close friends.

Loopytiles · 11/05/2022 20:04

LetitiaLeghorn Unless you explicitly asked your male friend whether his wife was OK about him sharing information about their fertility issues, you did NOT ‘respect boundaries’.

Loopytiles · 11/05/2022 20:02

AnneLovesGilbert OP’s H HAS taken things away from OP: her privacy. And trust in him.

LetitiaLeghorn · 11/05/2022 20:00

Mally100 · 11/05/2022 19:13

I actually think the ops feeling after being through what she has trumps whatever her dh is feeling. What support and talking through does he need? It's the op going through ALL the invasiveness. IVF is such a private and difficult time. The ops ask is so tiny in comparison to him making her feel even more stressed out. His mum knows, can't he talk to her?

I'm sorry but I think this is quite unkind and shows a lack of understanding really. My friend went through a lot of mental stress. Of course it's not the same as the physical treatment his wife went through, but he had fears, worries, hope, disappointments too. And he could talk to his mum, yes, but there were things he didn't want to say in case she started to worry too. I was a bit of a silent sounding board really.
If I was with a partner who felt so little about the process that they needed no support, I'm not sure I'd want to have a child with them.

Loopytiles · 11/05/2022 19:58

Unless DH genuinely has no other reasonable options for his personal ‘support network’ his behaviour has been insensitive and selfish.

In the circumstances his desire for ‘support’ from these specific women is less important than yours for privacy and boundaries with them.

Has he also confided in male friends about this, or was there an undertone of seeking female sympathy?

ComDummings · 11/05/2022 19:58

There are some things I think you should be able to get support from your friends on, however, with things like fertility or health I think it should be with a professional rather than friends. The reason being this just doesn’t affect him so I think you are well within your rights to ask him not to share this with them. He should speak to a counsellor if he needs support.

showmethegin · 11/05/2022 19:53

AnneLovesGilbert · 11/05/2022 19:23

We had problems with recurrent miscarriage and I know my husband found it useful to chat to friends about it. They were technically my pregnancies, my drug regimes, my surgeries, my failures, but he was going through hell too, a different one but made pretty fucking awful by seeing what I was experiencing and not knowing how best to help me. I never resented him talking to anyone he wanted to because it was his pain too.

You’re not having ivf with a sperm donor. You’re doing it with your husband and I think you can allow him whatever support he feels he needs. It takes nothing away from you.

Same here. We had three losses which were obviously devastating but it was so important for my DP to be able to open up with his friends and talk about his feelings; regardless of the fact it was my body it was happening to. His experience was different to mine in that not only had he lost his babies but he had to watch me in mental and physical pain too.

We are so conditioned in our culture to keep quiet about pregnancy loss and infertility and it helps no one. I am so sorry for what you are going through but I do think it is unfair to unilaterally decide who your DH's support network is.

HaPPy8 · 11/05/2022 19:37

I do think you are being unreasonable sorry. He is seeking support from what sounds like very close friends. There is no competitive for who it is hardest for … it may well be that it is you but that doesn’t meant ots not hard for him at all. If my DH had told me I couldn’t discuss IVF with my friends I’d have been very put out by that. Good luck with your journey.

Ringo11 · 11/05/2022 19:29

YANBU, absolutely not. It's so personal and private.

When I was pregnant with my second last year, I had a really difficult pregnancy for various reasons and a lot of uncertainties. It was a scary time. I chose to keep it secret from the majority of our family and friends, apart from immediate family. As most of the pregnancy was spent in lock down, I didn't see people anyway. DH wanted to tell a few people but I said no and although he didn't agree, he respected what I wanted and supported me. The first people knew about my pregnancy was when dd was born!

So you do whatever feels right for you and wishing you all the best for your journey. Xx

AnneLovesGilbert · 11/05/2022 19:23

We had problems with recurrent miscarriage and I know my husband found it useful to chat to friends about it. They were technically my pregnancies, my drug regimes, my surgeries, my failures, but he was going through hell too, a different one but made pretty fucking awful by seeing what I was experiencing and not knowing how best to help me. I never resented him talking to anyone he wanted to because it was his pain too.

You’re not having ivf with a sperm donor. You’re doing it with your husband and I think you can allow him whatever support he feels he needs. It takes nothing away from you.

calmlakes · 11/05/2022 19:22

I had ivf and do understand some of stresses that go along with this.
But your DH should be able to get support for himself from his own friends, it does seem unkind to try and prevent him from having this.

Mally100 · 11/05/2022 19:13

I actually think the ops feeling after being through what she has trumps whatever her dh is feeling. What support and talking through does he need? It's the op going through ALL the invasiveness. IVF is such a private and difficult time. The ops ask is so tiny in comparison to him making her feel even more stressed out. His mum knows, can't he talk to her?

Runningupthecurtains · 11/05/2022 19:13

I only told a tiny handful of people when we were struggling to conceive/going through 3 rounds of IVF. It was really stressful and I didn't want the added pressure of people knowing, having questions about how it was going, having to listen to 'encouraging' stories about people friends/families and their IVF journeys.
I also didn't want my friend to feel that their pregnancies or their babies were a source of pain to us. I was genuinely thrilled for everyone that had a baby in the eight years we were trying but that doesn't mean it didn't also hurt like hell when someone announced their pregnancy or had a baby.
I was the worlds leading expert in looking happy for them and holding off my sobs until I was alone.
Since we had a successful round of IVF I have been completely open about it but I couldn't talk about it when I was in the thick of it.

Blanketpolicy · 11/05/2022 19:10

I would expect him not to share the ins and outs of the medical procedures you are going through without being asked, but I think you are being unfair to ask him not to discuss what he is experiencing and feeling. You are both going through this and it is healthy for you both to seek support from your individual friends.

LetitiaLeghorn · 11/05/2022 19:01

My male friend told me that he and his wife were having IVF. He never discussed the causes of the problems other than they needed help. He told me of the failures, successes and the strain it puts on everyday life. I just think he wanted to chat with someone he felt comfortable with but who wasn't family.
I know his wife, I saw her during the treatment but I never said anything to her about it. It wasn't my business. And I was there with presents for her when the baby had arrived.
I think I was just a safe space to offload. Obviously he didn't go through the physical stuff his wife did, but mentally it was tough, tiring and stressful for him too. I would always respect boundaries. I never told anyone they were trying and if it hadn't worked, I'd have never had told anyone they'd tried.

Franca123 · 11/05/2022 18:56

I've been through ivf and so understand how you are feeling. I don't think any of the feelings you described are unreasonable. However, I would say, being honest about what we were going through really helped my partner and I. I think ultimately you have to choose together whether you tell people or not. But I think your husband is right in wanting to share and have support from old friends. Going through what you're going through will test your relationship I'm sure. The aim is that you come out the other side a stronger couple. You need to work on ensuring your communication and understanding skills are up to the task. Best of luck with your journey.

LowlandLucky · 11/05/2022 18:44

Have you ever thought your DH might just need some support ?

Swipe left for the next trending thread