Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not get a job because I’m a sahm

293 replies

velvetcandy · 11/05/2022 17:10

So after 8 years being a sahm I’ve decided to go back to work. Had a very good interview last week, the role was actually half the salary I had before I had kids and a lower position but still the same area of work etc.

the feedback was, that I was perfect but they were worried because I’ve been out of work for so long so gave the job to a recent grad. I have over ten years experience plus a degree.

aibu to think this is unfair?

OP posts:
HaveringWavering · 11/05/2022 18:59

velvetcandy · 11/05/2022 18:58

@HaveringWavering that’s good! I haven’t replied to their email so will say that

Maybe try and out it a bit more diplomatically, but you get the gist! Good luck.

velvetcandy · 11/05/2022 18:58

@HaveringWavering that’s good! I haven’t replied to their email so will say that

OP posts:
redskyatnight · 11/05/2022 18:57

mirandasma · 11/05/2022 18:41

If they could see from your CV that you had a gap for childcare responsibilities why did they even bother to call you for interview? It wastes everyone's time and is really dispiriting. (speak from bitter experience!) I just don't understand why companies insist on doing this. Or, call you in for interview and then say you are "over qualified". Again, why ask you to turn up at all?!

Or... they were prepared to give her a chance on the basis of her past experience and OP didn't present herself well enough, or was simply not the best candidate.

HaveringWavering · 11/05/2022 18:56

It’s a shame that you didn’t push back when they gave you the feedback by saying “You knew before you invited me to interview that I had a long gap in employment. Can you please tell me what it was that I said in the interview that made you decide that the time away was a reason not to offer me the job?”

AffIt · 11/05/2022 18:52

@Dibbydoos

As a sahm, you are likely to be much more organised, efficient and high performing.

Oh, come ON - this is nonsense.

Everydaydayisaschoolday · 11/05/2022 18:51

Despinetta · 11/05/2022 17:49

My advice would be not to discuss small details (like needing to come in 30 mins late one day) at the interview stage. Wait until they offer you the job. Much better to do this stuff when they have already decided they want you.

Good luck.

This is excellent advice.

Dibbydoos · 11/05/2022 18:44

Do you have a trusted male friend? Ask them what they'd do.
I know several men who have taken time out fir whatever reason and they did nit apply fir more junior roles, they went for tge same or higher level jobs. They used their time off to explain all the other things they'd learned and skills they developed.

As a sahm, you are likely to be much more organised, efficient and high performing.

I'd suggest you consider that a near miss - if they are dumb enough to think a shame is ineffective they're probably sexist cos thinking that is def sexist!

Onwards22 · 11/05/2022 18:44

It depends what job it is but in almost 10 years lots of things can change and it is more likely the recent graduate is up to date with all of these changes.

They will also probably be cheaper if it’s anything like teaching and are easily molded to fit their way of working.

One of my teacher friends didn’t get a job because an interviewee got a 1st and she got a 2:1 at university. Even though she’d been teaching for over 5 years and the other person was only recently qualified.

Fortunately she got a job somewhere else and has been there for 3 years but the person they employed lasted less than 2 terms. And this has happened several times that I know of.
So it shows that being recently qualified isn’t always a good thing.

Don’t let this dishearten you though.
Many people will absolutely want life experience as well as job experience over someone who may use the company as a stop gap until their next job.

coffeecupsandfairylights · 11/05/2022 18:43

WimbyAce · 11/05/2022 18:09

If they couldn't be flexible on .5 hours on 1 day I think that's pretty rubbish. I do think some employers are quite discriminatory with people with kids although of course they would never admit to that.

But not all jobs CAN be flexible.

I know on MN, everyone seems to work jobs where you can be constantly flexible, but IRL it's just not always possible.

Many jobs require people to be in the business for set hours each day, or require you to be there when the doors open. If the business is only open for eight hours a day, and OP's contract is eight hours a day, she can't just come in late and stay late to "make up the time".

FairyCakeWings · 11/05/2022 18:42

Having experience i years ago doesn’t necessarily make you better placed for this job than the recent graduate that got it. There could be plenty of reasons why he or she would be a better fit than you are, and not just because they are available at the times the job requires. Often employers don’t want people who are over qualified because they might be moving on or expecting more money sooner.

You would probably need a similar level of support to get back into it properly as the other candidate, and if you’re both equally capable of doing the job, why wouldn’t an enthusiastic youngster who can work whatever hours are required be more attractive than someone who can’t work the hours and has other important commitments?

mirandasma · 11/05/2022 18:41

If they could see from your CV that you had a gap for childcare responsibilities why did they even bother to call you for interview? It wastes everyone's time and is really dispiriting. (speak from bitter experience!) I just don't understand why companies insist on doing this. Or, call you in for interview and then say you are "over qualified". Again, why ask you to turn up at all?!

BoredYummyMummy · 11/05/2022 18:40

Thats shit.
We recently took on a woman coming from a decade as a sahm - she’s fucking fantastic.

Exactly the same story as you too, our job is less than what she was on but she wanted to ease herself in. She’s doing really well and wouldn’t ever not choose someone on that fact alone in the future.

ThreeLocusts · 11/05/2022 18:40

It's hard to know what happened but brace yourself, in my experience workplace sexism goes into a whole different gear once you're a woman with kids.

My suspicion is that not everyone likes the proposition that women should be/are able to combine motherhood and a career. It's normal for men but seen as having ideas 'above one's station' for women.

It's not everyone though. Keep going, you'll find an employer who values your skills.

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 11/05/2022 18:40

So what is wrong with a bit of flexibility?

Nothing, and I agree that mothers tend to make great employees. But, for me, the flexibility would not be the issue: it's the assumption from the OP that she can just opt not to work the stated hours. That tells me that she had not considered that the change of hours might not suit the needs of the business or other employees - a big red flag.

There are two appropriate times to discuss variations to the stated terms of the job: before applying (especially if it's something major like only being able to work 20 hours when the ad says full-time) or after being offered the job. Not at interview.

StageRage · 11/05/2022 18:38

It’s the reality of sex discrimination by the back door.

I wonder if they even asked the graduate if they could do the hours. It is very poor Equal Opps practice to ask different questions of different candidates,

I’m not saying the points about keeping up to date are not valid, obviously it is important to get up to speed and be ‘employment fit’. Which includes making sure that your DC’s father, if present, understands that you can no longer be the only and default responder to those calls from school when a child falls ill etc. As an employer of a mostly female workforce I was always very fed up when it seemed I had to carry this whole burden while employers of the fathers of my employees’ kids carried on without inconvenience.

Applesonthelawn · 11/05/2022 18:37

I've posted this before, but it took me about 7 years to regain my previous level of seniority and salary after taking a break of 18 months when mine were small. Salary went to about 40% of previous salary (although still quite high, was previously well into six figures). This was 20 years ago. I'm sure the time it takes to recover is directly proportionate to how long you take off. Fair doesn't come into it - it's about an employer making a fair assessment of your ability to do the job. Your experience is 8 years out of date. My advice is take the job and show them how good you are.

ParsleyRosemarySage · 11/05/2022 18:34

In my industry and many others, 10 years of experience ending 8 years ago would be absolutely worthless.

Only in the context of a world with high competition, which ignores transferable skills. The number of jobs I have seen that require recent experience with a specific IT program: it’s not necessary if you know how to use thousands of programs and can learn a new one quickly, but employers can insist it is. Because they can get that, and pay peanuts for it too.

Silverswirl · 11/05/2022 18:34

It’s really unfair.
Being a mother and raising your kids without any outsourcing is so so under valued in our society. It is in fact one of the most important jobs there are.
All this does is give women less choice, not more.

Coldenough4snow · 11/05/2022 18:33

It is a horrid business coming back from being a sahm.

I have the right job for my family situation now, but it took a long time and I had to kiss a lot of frogs.

God, it was degrading! So many of my interviewers didn’t even get back to me.

The place I now work is full of older women who took time off to raise kids, so they didn’t see my career break as an indication that I was defective.

In addition to being viewed with suspicion, I also got offered work on an unpaid basis by some employers (!).

It was astonishing to me that I had such experience and expertise, and yet was not getting employed even in quite mediocre places. I wonder if they got a sense that I saw it all as a bit of a comedown.

What bridged the gap was that I went freelance for a bit. At least I know that I could do that if I am ever in that situation again.

Good luck, OP - you will YANBU and you will get the right thing in the end.

theadultsaretalking · 11/05/2022 18:32

Trafficblight · 11/05/2022 18:24

Well I mean technically they are, someone with children (well women let's be honest) are more likely to require last minute leave, annual leave at specific times of the year ie school holidays, have to leave part way through the day to pick up poorly children etc. I'm obviously not saying that means we should be discriminated against and not given chances because of this, but seems a bit naieve to think children have no impact on someone's working life. Again, mainly women. I doubt many men take years off and then say at interview one morning they'll come in later.

Yes, to a degree, but most working mums I know are also super efficient and get things done (personally I got cured of my procrastination tendencies, once I knew I needed to leave at 6pm on the dot, instead of hanging around in the office to finish stuff). So what is wrong with a bit of flexibility?

Also, and this is purely anecdotal, the worst 2 offenders I had in my teams were a single woman with two ageing cats and a new graduate, who seemed unable to get to work on time.

SareBear87 · 11/05/2022 18:32

Without sounding rude it's an employers market. We had over 100 applications for 1 job (science/medical degree needed), we interviewed 10 and were extremely picky.
It came down to tiny things the candidates said.

Tbh all the candidates could do the job, but we had the luxury of a lot of good candidates for a single position.

I wouldn't be disheartened, it's tough!

Witchcraftandhokum · 11/05/2022 18:31

Bluntly. It's not discrimation, you can't work the hours they need.

viques · 11/05/2022 18:30

AffIt · 11/05/2022 18:18

You may have had 10 years' prior experience, but if you've been out of the workplace for 8+ (which is a long time if you work in a field such as IT or professional services), then of course a recent grad is going to have more up-to-date skills, even if they don't have the 'hit the ground running' experience.

Have you maintained your CPD / professional certifications / qualifications?

I think this is the issue. You might have ten years experience, but you have been out of the workplace almost as long as you were in it so the two practically cancel each other out.

As I think someone mentioned upthread, you need to update your skills, work practices have changed massively in the last few years , and in the last two the changes have exploded. A recent graduate will be confident working in the new normal, your skills were first learned 18 years ago.

CaptSkippy · 11/05/2022 18:28

If they gave the job to a recent graduate that may mean you were over-qualified for the job. Companies are unlikely to hire someone who is over-qualified, as that limits growth potential.

OP, I think you need to start punching above your weight when it comes to applying. You might also consider volunteerwork to gain more recent experience for your resume.

MissChanandlerBong80 · 11/05/2022 18:27

I don’t think it’s unfair (or discriminatory) to want someone with more recent experience. In my industry and many others, 10 years of experience ending 8 years ago would be absolutely worthless.

It is potentially discriminatory to deny someone employment on the basis of their childcare obligations but it’s difficult to prove that’s the reason.

Rejoining the workforce after an extended period out can be extremely difficult and I think women are frequently led to believe it’s much easier than it is.