Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not get a job because I’m a sahm

293 replies

velvetcandy · 11/05/2022 17:10

So after 8 years being a sahm I’ve decided to go back to work. Had a very good interview last week, the role was actually half the salary I had before I had kids and a lower position but still the same area of work etc.

the feedback was, that I was perfect but they were worried because I’ve been out of work for so long so gave the job to a recent grad. I have over ten years experience plus a degree.

aibu to think this is unfair?

OP posts:
AMegaPint · 12/05/2022 09:13

@Everydayisabadhairday I never said they chose the 'best person'. I said they chose the person they wanted for the job. And I never said anything about discrimination not happening. I'm well aware of it thanks.

It's naive to think you would be automatically more suitable for a job because you have '10 years experience' over the chosen candidate.

Fullsomefrenchie · 12/05/2022 09:08

men don’t seem to do this’ well no, caus there’s usually a women run bloody ragged facilitating him to be 100% present in the work place, don’t you think? Especially when they are a married/partnered father.

then more fool the woman. I’m sorry but it’s true.

Chillyseadippin · 12/05/2022 09:07

Franklin12 · 12/05/2022 08:55

We have all worked with the women (men dont seem to do this) who always have issues and are clockwatching. As a PP said you do sound as though you are clock watching in 30 min slots. You will never be available to help out in an emergency - you could say that's fine you arent paid for that but I have worked over the years with women who are CONSTANTLY asking for flexibility i.e must have school holidays off, never around much in the run up to Xmas, I worked in a sector for years where it was not unusual for a tender to come in from the public sector (twats who did this!) on 24th Dec to be responded to by 1st Jan.

I then worked in retail where NO ONE was allowed Xmas/Easter off. I would definitely do some volunteer work. Being out of the workplace for nearly 10 years is huge. Has it been mentioned what sector it is? I have found even though I have never had a break in working that my Excel skills are nothing like my DS's. I manage but I am at the end of my career and have taken a step back and its lovely!

’..men don’t seem to do this’ well no, caus there’s usually a women run bloody ragged facilitating him to be 100% present in the work place, don’t you think? Especially when they are a married/partnered father.

I feel saddened that even working mothers expect other working mothers to work like they are not mothers… not everyone has the same ‘village’ or same flexible working/willing husband/Co parent.

why the op didn’t get the job, to be perfectly honest none of us know- but the narrative on display on this thread is so very out of touch with supporting mothers/primary care givers into the work place - which we should be doing, to avoid (let’s face it, mainly women) women losing all financial independence and completely burning out from the juggle.

I feel luckier at my place of work than I did before reading this thread.

InChocolateWeTrust · 12/05/2022 09:01

the more people we can get into the workplace who also have caring responsibilities, the better it will get for everyone.

There are loads of people in the workplace who have caring responsibilities. I work in a huge company and am surrounded by working mums in senior roles!

A childfree individual who took 8 years off work to go travelling would face the same problem OP has. A friend took an extended period away from work because she had an opportunity to represent her country as an athlete, and it took her ages to get back in properly when she returned to "normal" work.

Hairtryer · 12/05/2022 08:58

I have only heard of people negotiating times etc when they have been offered a job and before accepting. The main reason I suspect was exactly as they said- 8 years out of the workplace is a long time. Things change. If you'd have kept your toes in a bit or done something like volunteering that they could have sought a recent reference from then probably be okay.

Franklin12 · 12/05/2022 08:55

We have all worked with the women (men dont seem to do this) who always have issues and are clockwatching. As a PP said you do sound as though you are clock watching in 30 min slots. You will never be available to help out in an emergency - you could say that's fine you arent paid for that but I have worked over the years with women who are CONSTANTLY asking for flexibility i.e must have school holidays off, never around much in the run up to Xmas, I worked in a sector for years where it was not unusual for a tender to come in from the public sector (twats who did this!) on 24th Dec to be responded to by 1st Jan.

I then worked in retail where NO ONE was allowed Xmas/Easter off. I would definitely do some volunteer work. Being out of the workplace for nearly 10 years is huge. Has it been mentioned what sector it is? I have found even though I have never had a break in working that my Excel skills are nothing like my DS's. I manage but I am at the end of my career and have taken a step back and its lovely!

IcedPurple · 12/05/2022 08:55

InChocolateWeTrust · 12/05/2022 08:51

Oh and the starting 30 mins late will be a non point.

It will be the 8 year gap driving their decision, not the one day flexibility over 30 mins.

I'd say that depends on the job. The OP hasn't told us much about what line of work she's in, but some jobs really don't have much room for 'flexibility'.

Plus, as others have said, to bring it up at the interview stage might suggest that she'll be looking for more 'flexibility' down the line.

InChocolateWeTrust · 12/05/2022 08:53

^Most working mothers do all the stuff SAHMs do and do their jobs b
i wouldn’t be impressed by SAHM banging on about running their home etc^

This. I'm a working mum and I'd be bloody unimpressed by a candidate expecting me to consider running the home as in any way relevant in a job interview.

IcedPurple · 12/05/2022 08:52

Everydayisabadhairday · 12/05/2022 07:45

You're very naive if you think every job is always given to the best person and nobody ever discriminates against job seekers. Its illegal but it doesn't mean it doesn't happen.

But surely it's up to the employers to decide who is the 'best person'?

If they prefer a new graduate with current skills rather than someone who's been out of the workplace for 8 years, then that is their right.

I'm sure discrimination does happen, but there's no evidence that that is the case here.

InChocolateWeTrust · 12/05/2022 08:51

Oh and the starting 30 mins late will be a non point.

It will be the 8 year gap driving their decision, not the one day flexibility over 30 mins.

InChocolateWeTrust · 12/05/2022 08:48

I wouldn't call it "unfair".

Ask yourself this. 8 years after you did your GCSE maths, did you retain all that info & skills? Probably not 100%, because you were off doing different things, learning new stuff, not practising the maths etc.

Jobs are no different. 8 years is a hell of a long time. In my industry you'd struggle to get back in the door and you'd definitely pretty much have to start from scratch building experience.

It's why so many people recommend you keep something while you have young kids, even a day or two a week keeps your skills and experience valid.

Brefugee · 12/05/2022 08:42

but don't give up, OP, the more people we can get into the workplace who also have caring responsibilities, the better it will get for everyone.

Right now we have to work within the "system" we have, much as a lot of it sucks, because we aren't going to change anything by being outside looking in.

AngelinaFibres · 12/05/2022 08:36

LowlandLucky · 11/05/2022 19:11

So you have raised children, ran a home, managed accounts and done 100 other roles but they choose someone who has never held down a full time job. Brainless.

The graduate will do the stated hours and more. They have no one to drop off /pick up. No one is going to be ill, have sports day, nativity play etc etc. If you start bringing family issues in at the interview you have shot yourself in the foot. The whole business about running a home,doing accounts, managing multiple things just doesn't wash. Working parents do all this and work at the same time. I worked as a teacher for 20 years. There are an awful lot of parents ,sahm and working, who live in utterly chaotic, badly run homes. Just because you are a sahm doesn't mean you are automatically doing a good job .

AngelinaFibres · 12/05/2022 08:28

Trafficblight · 11/05/2022 23:01

if you do actually require flexibility and there’s no way around it you have to start at 9:30 you literally with as much authority and confidence as you can muster state the fact that you will need to start at 9:30 you do not apologise and you do not offer an explanation.

🤣

And no one will employ you.

Fullsomefrenchie · 12/05/2022 08:11

I can also see both sides for this, for them you are long term unemployed. A decade is a long time and without a doubt things will have moved on, plus you are not used to full time employment any more. Going back in can be a shock to the system,

the grad will have demonstrated an ability that,you didn’t, sometimes it’s not all about experience, which is what you seem to think, that the person with the most experience wins, that’s not the case. Many softer skills also apply. Inc ability to progress etc.

in addition by saying you would come in thirty mins late and leave thirty mins later that day you basically told them you work to rule, you do your hours and no more. To the extent you even count it in thirty min slots. Many employers now want more flexibility than that. And not someone who runs out at 5 on the dot.

it’s just one job, keep trying,and if this was a company that don’t employ parents/mothers then you have had a lucky escape.

Swonderful · 12/05/2022 08:11

Can you do agency work or freelancing to get some recent experience. I've done this after a much longer career break and it led to me getting a great role. I agree, don't mention anything "negative" in the interview, leave it to negotiations afterwards. Also don't mention kids as it none of their business why you took a career break and they shouldn't ask.

Don't let it knock your confidence. I had one great interview and one awful one within a few days.

GregBrawlsInDogJail · 12/05/2022 08:06

You've misread @Everydayisabadhairday . The email that was proposed to OP and OP thought it would be a good idea to send is what Misslucy is talking about. OP didn't say she has sent it, but she said it was a good idea and that she would. Hence the utility of advising her not to.

Asking for feedback is normal, but many employers flat won't give it because of the percentage of candidates who respond to it aggressively and/or try to argue that they are still the best person for the job.

worriedaboutmoney2022 · 12/05/2022 08:02

It's a difficult one if they need someone in at a particular time, then it's not do-able for them, can't you get a breakfast club that day??

I agree tho focus on getting the job then negotiate intricate details.

I've recently interviewed for an admin role at work it's 22.5 hours and we need this worked over 3 days as it's a jobshare with a 1 day overlap on Wednesday so the hours are Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday 8-4 with half an hour for lunch
I interviewed 6 people
4 of them wanted to do 9:30-2 kind of hours over 5 days
The advert clearly stated the hours and that it was a jobshare

Then as we got talking about it not really working I did point out to them all that if we did that, that would mean they had 5 days of childcare to cover in holidays as their annual leave doesn't cover all the holidays. I also said if it was a nursery situation it's only 3 days and some places won't charge for half days. None of them had clearly thought about that!!!
I was really nice about it and explained as a working Mum myself I understand the situation.
We offered to someone who read the advert, knew the hours and was happy to work them - who has 2 kids and has had 3 years out so it can work out but you just need to have a plan for childcare etc....

Andromachehadabadday · 12/05/2022 08:01

It could be asking for the time to be moved. It could also be that you failed to convince them an 8 year gap without keeping your foot in or doing additional training, wasn’t going to be a problem.

The graduate may have been able to demonstrate that better in an interview format. Just telling them you can do it ‘cause I did it 8 years ago’ or ‘well I catch on quick’ isn’t enough.

They would have wanted to see you have kept up with changes and their impacts. Like it or not the graduate probably could display and detail their knowledge.

They may have really liked you. The person may use ‘perfect’ all the time when not meaning that. You may have been the best person so far.

You would be better served looking at how you can improve for the next one.

Everydayisabadhairday · 12/05/2022 07:54

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 12/05/2022 07:23

Seriously, for the love of all that is holy don't do this, unless you want to become an anecdote the hiring manager tells for the rest of their career. It's whiny, self-absorbed and out of touch and would be further confirmation that they made the right choice in not hiring you. Every job candidate thinks they were the best person for the job; acting like you think you know better than the person who is hiring for the job and conducted the interviews merely gets you put on the mental Do Not Hire, Ever list

All of this. And managers move companies, and have friends in other companies. I'm often asked for informal feedback on job candidates.

The fact that the OP thought it was a good idea to send an aggressive email, demanding the manager's reasons, tells me everything about why she didn't get the job in the first place. I'd say it's the company that has dodged the bullet.

Don't make shit up.

She got an email with feedback. Where does it go into any detail about the wording of any email she sent to them? How can you possibly know she was aggressive?

Asking for feedback is completely normal as im sure you would know if you were actually at all involved in recruitment.

ChanceNorman · 12/05/2022 07:48

I said the hours are fine apart from one day a week I need to be in at work at 9 instead of 8.30

Yeah, this is probably what killed it. It doesn't matter what the specifics are - requests for flexibility may be met.

However telling the recruiter at interview stage 'I NEED [insert deviation from advertised terms]' is never going to go down well. As a recruiter, this would ring alarm bells from the off for me.

Brefugee · 12/05/2022 07:45

I feel for you OP and YADNBU. You have all the experience and qualifications that you need, plus maturity. It is utterly ridiculous to see how little mothers are supported and valued. It's not like you've been in a crack den for the last decade.

There is a lot of discussion in the SAHM conversations about how long to stay away from the workplace etc. And everyone has a different opinion. Here's mine: don't. Don't stay away from the workplace longer than necessary, because an 8 year break is a long long time. I'm not sure I'd employ someone with that big gap, who immediately started asking for adjustments for their kids, when i could give the job to a recent graduate. I know the statistics about working mums being super efficient, and returning mums are on average more loyal to a company.

The reality is, and a lot of us who have struggled working with small children, see someone come in saying "yeah, super organised as a SAHM" and think "yep, i do all that as well" and then the candidate immediately comes out with "and I'll need a late start on x day because kids" and - if i were the interviewer - that would be Game Absolutely Over. Because in all my years i have always made sure that i have watertight plans, watertight plan B and watertight plan C. Sometimes at quite high monetary and emotional (stress) cost. But i have never ever given an employer any excuse to say that i don't put work first. (even though i actually never have). After you've started and shown reliability - then you can come waltzing in with adjustment requests.

Everydayisabadhairday · 12/05/2022 07:45

AMegaPint · 12/05/2022 07:35

You weren't the right candidate for the job they were offering. That's how interviews work. Someone always looses out over the person they prefer.

You're very naive if you think every job is always given to the best person and nobody ever discriminates against job seekers. Its illegal but it doesn't mean it doesn't happen.

Everydayisabadhairday · 12/05/2022 07:43

If they're happy to discriminate against you because you have children, do you really want to work for them anyway? YANBU to be upset though. That was really shitty of them. Unfortunately a lot of employers don't want women with children or of child bearing age because it means they have to get their head out their arse and actually think about flexibility.

Id bet my house that they gave the job to a man.

AMegaPint · 12/05/2022 07:35

You weren't the right candidate for the job they were offering. That's how interviews work. Someone always looses out over the person they prefer.

Swipe left for the next trending thread