Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not get a job because I’m a sahm

293 replies

velvetcandy · 11/05/2022 17:10

So after 8 years being a sahm I’ve decided to go back to work. Had a very good interview last week, the role was actually half the salary I had before I had kids and a lower position but still the same area of work etc.

the feedback was, that I was perfect but they were worried because I’ve been out of work for so long so gave the job to a recent grad. I have over ten years experience plus a degree.

aibu to think this is unfair?

OP posts:
IcedPurple · 12/05/2022 10:13

OP hasn't said what kind of work it is, there are certainly jobs where that 30 mins is a no go. For example education, childcare, retail, customer or client facing roles, some healthcare. In any role where starting 30 minutes late would cause a problem and finishing 30 minutes late would add no or little benefit of course the employer wouldn't agree to it.

It's become very clear with all the WFH threads over the past two years that many MNers have jobs where precise timekeeping doesn't matter, or at least that's what they claim.

There have been so many posts along the lines of "Oh, my team are so flexible and don't mind if I take an hour out at lunch time to pick up the kids, or an afternoon off to attend little Johnny's sports day. I'm so much more productive WFH and as long as the work gets done, that's all that matters."

Which of course is fine if it's true for them. But only a minority of jobs are so flexible. In many if not most jobs, half an hour one day a week is a big deal. Would the OP be happy if she was late for work because the train driver wanted 'flexibility' on a Thursday morning?

Colliewobbles123 · 12/05/2022 10:12

@velvetcandy how are you feeling now? I had an interview yesterday and they said I was too old for maternity leave as if it was a bonus that makes me more employable….…. I’m 35!!! It’s so disheartening!

I am more than just my ovaries, I have a brain too

MajesticallyAwkward · 12/05/2022 10:10

velvetcandy · 12/05/2022 09:39

Wow I can’t keep up with all these messages.

so what everyone’s basically saying is go back to work asap after you’ve had kids even though the majority of your pay check will be spent on childcare, additionally if you do take some time out still somehow use/update your skills that you can’t technically access unless you’re at work and also give your services away for free by volunteering because obviously once you have kids that renders your experience as void. Love mums net

Not at all. But if you want to take 8 years out you have to accept that you will likely struggle to get back in to your chosen career. There are ways to stay up to date via training or even part time work but you made the decision to step away and now have to take responsibility for yourself.

You also need to accept that your children are not your employers or colleagues problem and no one owes you anything. Flexibility can be requested but a) will be accepted only when it's advantageous to the employer and b) there are rules around how long you have to be employed before you can request it. If you want flexible working from the off you'll need to research the company before applying and find some with the culture you want.

We have a fairly good maternity culture in UK workplaces. You can take a year off and in most cases return to you previous job.

I am also a working parent, took 9/10 months off after dc were born, did KIT days in the latter part of that and then dropped a day for the first year after that. I found a job that offers the flexibility I want while still offering progression opportunity, share childcare with my dh who does half of the drop offs/pick ups and sick days.

Choufleurfromage · 12/05/2022 10:08

StageRage · 11/05/2022 18:38

It’s the reality of sex discrimination by the back door.

I wonder if they even asked the graduate if they could do the hours. It is very poor Equal Opps practice to ask different questions of different candidates,

I’m not saying the points about keeping up to date are not valid, obviously it is important to get up to speed and be ‘employment fit’. Which includes making sure that your DC’s father, if present, understands that you can no longer be the only and default responder to those calls from school when a child falls ill etc. As an employer of a mostly female workforce I was always very fed up when it seemed I had to carry this whole burden while employers of the fathers of my employees’ kids carried on without inconvenience.

no it is not sex discrimination for god's sake

Choufleurfromage · 12/05/2022 10:04

Despinetta · 11/05/2022 17:49

My advice would be not to discuss small details (like needing to come in 30 mins late one day) at the interview stage. Wait until they offer you the job. Much better to do this stuff when they have already decided they want you.

Good luck.

unless that's a deal-breake, in which case they have to start the process again. That's just selfish to announce ones requirements after accepting job

Choufleurfromage · 12/05/2022 10:03

velvetcandy · 11/05/2022 17:30

Obviously I said all the hours were fine just that one day a week due to family circumstances I can be in half an hour later and work half an hour longer or not take a break that day. @

But what of everyone wanterd to do that? how do you run a company efficiently if you are bending over backwards to accommodate 'just a half-hour once a week...'

Choufleurfromage · 12/05/2022 10:01

rainbowmilk · 12/05/2022 09:49

I imagine all of those here saying that the company is mad to have hired a young person over an experienced mum will change their tune once it's their children trying to get their first job.

All I'm hearing from this thread is that it's unfair to not make a mum the first choice candidate for a job, even if her skills and experience are totally out of date and she can't actually work the hours stated. I think that's bonkers.

(Childless employee of 20+ years here, constantly covering the shit shifts, the post 5pm urgent tasks, the summer holidays, the Christmases... which is fine, I get it, but I'm not exactly seeing huge evidence of the supposed efficiency, loyalty and hard work that is apparently unique to mums!)

this!

Mary46 · 12/05/2022 10:00

I learnt you cant get back to work after massive gaps and expect good wages. Op its hard I had to take crappy work to build up my cv. Thats the reality of not working long term. Good advice on this thread

Choufleurfromage · 12/05/2022 10:00

velvetcandy · 12/05/2022 09:39

Wow I can’t keep up with all these messages.

so what everyone’s basically saying is go back to work asap after you’ve had kids even though the majority of your pay check will be spent on childcare, additionally if you do take some time out still somehow use/update your skills that you can’t technically access unless you’re at work and also give your services away for free by volunteering because obviously once you have kids that renders your experience as void. Love mums net

Cheque (unless you are American)

Choufleurfromage · 12/05/2022 09:56

velvetcandy · 11/05/2022 17:20

Hey, yea I get that etc but what they were asking I have extensive experience with and could go in and pick it back up. I can’t help but feel it’s the kids, I said the hours are fine apart from one day a week I need to be in at work at 9 instead of 8.30, only one day and they didn’t seem to happy. Even though I said I could work later that day. Oh well.

Onviously your requirements and lack of recent skills/experience was not apporpriate for this particular company, so don't blame them.
Your choice to have kids

PurassicJark · 12/05/2022 09:55

They sound shit because they didn't want to be flexible on one day. Think you had a lucky escape op. It's not like they got someone with experience either, they got a graduate, who despite knowing a lot perhaps hasn't worked in the environment and that's a lot different to uni. So they've taken someone easily persuadable basically over someone with commitments. Crap company, feel sorry for the graduate.

PradaOnaBudget · 12/05/2022 09:54

velvetcandy · 12/05/2022 09:39

Wow I can’t keep up with all these messages.

so what everyone’s basically saying is go back to work asap after you’ve had kids even though the majority of your pay check will be spent on childcare, additionally if you do take some time out still somehow use/update your skills that you can’t technically access unless you’re at work and also give your services away for free by volunteering because obviously once you have kids that renders your experience as void. Love mums net

That's how a lot of us kept our career going. I went back to work when my child was 4 months old, and yes, my entire pay check and more went to pay for childcare for a couple of years. It made sense as a long term strategy and it paid off.

Your long term strategy was different and I'm sure your children have loved having you at home. You just have to deal with the consequences and accept that you'll have to put more effort in now to get a job. You will manage but it would be illogical to think you are going to find it easy

Hairtryer · 12/05/2022 09:53

Depending on the job there are also free courses you can do online that show a refresh of skills.

Andromachehadabadday · 12/05/2022 09:52

velvetcandy · 12/05/2022 09:39

Wow I can’t keep up with all these messages.

so what everyone’s basically saying is go back to work asap after you’ve had kids even though the majority of your pay check will be spent on childcare, additionally if you do take some time out still somehow use/update your skills that you can’t technically access unless you’re at work and also give your services away for free by volunteering because obviously once you have kids that renders your experience as void. Love mums net

No. One of those is preferable if you want a higher chance at being employed quickly when you return.

You can keep a foot in by keeping up with your industry. You could do additional training in preparation to go back.

No one said being a mum renders your experience void. And if that’s the attitude you have, you will struggle.

Being out of the workforce for 8 years means your experience is less relevant and, often, outdated. Nothing to do with being a Mother.

Hairtryer · 12/05/2022 09:52

velvetcandy · 12/05/2022 09:39

Wow I can’t keep up with all these messages.

so what everyone’s basically saying is go back to work asap after you’ve had kids even though the majority of your pay check will be spent on childcare, additionally if you do take some time out still somehow use/update your skills that you can’t technically access unless you’re at work and also give your services away for free by volunteering because obviously once you have kids that renders your experience as void. Love mums net

Well no, but similarly you can't expect to walk back into a job 8 years later without them wanting a bit of recent experience. It's not having children that makes it so, as a previous poster said someone who had been out of the workplace for any reason for that period of time is unlikely to be more favourable than someone with recent experience and qualifications. It's not their issue if you feel volunteering (in any capacity not even in a workplace) is beneath you.

Its also a bit of an incorrect assumption that having skills above and beyond a job role means its likely you'll get it. For starters there's actually a lot of competition for lower paid jobs as there's a bigger pool of people who can apply for them, as appose to a well paid and desirable job that requires x, y and z to apply; that pool will be smaller. Experience doesn't necessarily relate to the role either, we have a lot of people who have done professional jobs who want a step back but haven't actually ever done the admin type work. Yes I'm sure they're capable, but I'd prefer a candidate who has done the job before.

FlowerArranger · 12/05/2022 09:50

I think you may need to read through all these many messages again to truly get it,@velvetcandy .

You come across as having a bit of an attitude, and that MAY have across in your interview.

rainbowmilk · 12/05/2022 09:49

I imagine all of those here saying that the company is mad to have hired a young person over an experienced mum will change their tune once it's their children trying to get their first job.

All I'm hearing from this thread is that it's unfair to not make a mum the first choice candidate for a job, even if her skills and experience are totally out of date and she can't actually work the hours stated. I think that's bonkers.

(Childless employee of 20+ years here, constantly covering the shit shifts, the post 5pm urgent tasks, the summer holidays, the Christmases... which is fine, I get it, but I'm not exactly seeing huge evidence of the supposed efficiency, loyalty and hard work that is apparently unique to mums!)

Lastqueenofscotland2 · 12/05/2022 09:45

Keeping your skills up to date is not impossible while not working and if you’ve not done it you’ve no business to see your arse about a graduate with more up to date skills being offered a job over your historic experience

IcedPurple · 12/05/2022 09:44

velvetcandy · 12/05/2022 09:39

Wow I can’t keep up with all these messages.

so what everyone’s basically saying is go back to work asap after you’ve had kids even though the majority of your pay check will be spent on childcare, additionally if you do take some time out still somehow use/update your skills that you can’t technically access unless you’re at work and also give your services away for free by volunteering because obviously once you have kids that renders your experience as void. Love mums net

No.

People are saying that if you take an extended period out of work, then that is going to have consequences for your future desirability to employers, as you are now finding out.

Nobody owes you a job. I'm starting to wonder if you understand that.

Andromachehadabadday · 12/05/2022 09:44

feel saddened that even working mothers expect other working mothers to work like they are not mothers… not everyone has the same ‘village’ or same flexible working/willing husband/Co parent.

But in essence you are saying employers need to offer lots of flexibility to women, who are mothers so those women can accommodate their partners and run round even more.

Thats not helpful for women. Surely it should be employers of father that are being pushed to offer flexibility and have cultures where it’s viewed as positive in their employees. That would actually help women, who are running round because the father is shit.

Flexible working should be offered wherever possible to everyone possible. Kids or no kids.

But when you are what op requested at interview, along with lack or recent experience and inability to demonstrate they have kept up to their industry, it’s going to put people off.
My company employs returning Sahms all the time. When they are the best fit for the job.

We aren’t going to employ Sahms just on the basis that they were Sahms or give them something we can’t offer others in the same job.

velvetcandy · 12/05/2022 09:39

Wow I can’t keep up with all these messages.

so what everyone’s basically saying is go back to work asap after you’ve had kids even though the majority of your pay check will be spent on childcare, additionally if you do take some time out still somehow use/update your skills that you can’t technically access unless you’re at work and also give your services away for free by volunteering because obviously once you have kids that renders your experience as void. Love mums net

OP posts:
MajesticallyAwkward · 12/05/2022 09:38

So you have raised children, ran a home, managed accounts and done 100 other roles but they choose someone who has never held down a full time job. Brainless

And a working parent doesn't run a home, raise children, manage their finances (it's not accounts, it's your own money) or do any of the other things a SAHP does?

Banging on about these imagined 'jobs' a SAHP does is ridiculous and makes them sound infantile. If I was interviewing and someone came in talking about 'oh I've been a cook, a cleaner, chauffeur, managed accounts, coached sports because I've been a stay at home mummy' tinkly laugh they wouldn't be shortlisted. Every day tasks that are done by everyone regardless of working status aren't jobs.

In OPs case the graduate was deemed better suited by the employer. Whether that's because the OP asked for flexibility, droned on about her dc or the graduate simply had more experience we don't know. Work placements are common for graduates so they could have had recent experience.

OP hasn't said what kind of work it is, there are certainly jobs where that 30 mins is a no go. For example education, childcare, retail, customer or client facing roles, some healthcare. In any role where starting 30 minutes late would cause a problem and finishing 30 minutes late would add no or little benefit of course the employer wouldn't agree to it.

Franklin12 · 12/05/2022 09:33

To the PP. I spent years and years and so did my colleagues 'supporting' other working mothers who massively took advantage. So - No - you cover and support them. I am done with being used like that!

PS: I am a working Mum. Children are grown up now but 100% I know what its like!

melcalfe · 12/05/2022 09:30

Franklin12 · 11/05/2022 18:00

I am going to be honest and say you sound quite entitled as though they couldnt possibly turn you down due to your experience but that was 8 YEARS ago. Everything has moved on especially technology. Did you say how you have kept up?

Agree. Plus your degree would be classed as quite dated - I have recently started a second degree and they didn't even take my first one into consideration as any degree from over 10 years ago is not very relevant to some organisations.

Chillyseadippin · 12/05/2022 09:14

Fullsome… in theory, I agree. In reality it is much more nuanced.

ultimately if both parents ‘stand firm’ and don’t respond to collect a sick child for example? who actually suffers. The child.

a good first step in supporting women to not be expected (at a society and family level) is for BOTH parents (and all those with caring responsibility) to be supported and it not be a mammoth task to fit work life and home life together.

Swipe left for the next trending thread