Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not get a job because I’m a sahm

293 replies

velvetcandy · 11/05/2022 17:10

So after 8 years being a sahm I’ve decided to go back to work. Had a very good interview last week, the role was actually half the salary I had before I had kids and a lower position but still the same area of work etc.

the feedback was, that I was perfect but they were worried because I’ve been out of work for so long so gave the job to a recent grad. I have over ten years experience plus a degree.

aibu to think this is unfair?

OP posts:
Copperpottle · 12/05/2022 16:58

It is, but keep trying. I was out of work for 10 years. Retrained in tech 5 years ago and no one's ever even asked about the gap in the CV. Plenty of forms won't be dicks about it.

MountainDewer · 12/05/2022 16:58

Liorae · 12/05/2022 16:24

In my experience the decision to be a sahm and for how long is all too frequently short sighted. Women are so often their own worst enemy.

Having kids is necessary for society. But wanting to spend all day at home with them is a choice (unless they're disabled, etc). There's nothing inherently virtuous that you more deserving of a job. Compared to anybody else who has spent the past X years doing something else.

Part-time and flexible working isn't a social service btw. It actually benefits businesses that suit it. Retention of talented staff, better coordination/working practices, more motivated employees.

Hiring someone with no recent experience? By itself no benefit. It really depends on the candidate pool.

Franklin12 · 12/05/2022 16:57

100% agree with Mountain. I have worked in an office and worked at home for many many years for a large corporate depending on what the flavour of the month was. They went too far on many occasions and you werent allowed to even visit your clients - you were constantly reminded that you should be using SKYPE as if we didnt know that already. It really wasnt the same and these clients were spending often millions.

I was customer facing and there really is no where to hide. There are late night phone calls ocassionally and at weekends. All part of the role which was well paid. As long as you didnt take advantage it was fine, HOWEVER there were a considerable amount of women who did take advantage. Who were never available between 1530-1630 and who claimed to make up the time but never did. Women who refused a conference call at say 1700 because they knew it was going to be noisy. There were an awful lot of dentist appointments but please bear in mind that no one is really that concerned whether your child is feeling under the weather or that you need to leave early to attend sports day/school play where they have part etc because THEY then need to cover for you.

I am thinking of one shocker of a women who took and took everything she could and the rest of the team just had to manage without her. Her own manager was scared of her and there were so many reorganisations they knew it wasnt worth taking her on.

MountainDewer · 12/05/2022 16:43

@IcedPurple well you won't know whether jobs with flexible hours are the 'majority' or 'minority' unless you did a statistical survey and worked out exactly what proportion of jobs needed punctuality.
But to simplify matters further.. 10 years of experience, graduate is hardly going to be a retail, train driver or similar job is it?

It's really irrelevant without knowing the industry. Flexible working etc is very possible with mine. But it also means me logging in after hours if something goes wrong. Or getting up early/late for various timezones. Goes both ways.

Someone who gives the impression of taking flexibility... but not giving any isn't an attractive candidate.

Liorae · 12/05/2022 16:24

Allthe4s · 12/05/2022 14:57

Everyone is basically saying go back to work asap after you’ve had kids even though the majority of your pay check will be spent on childcare

For a finite number of years during which time you’ll have had pay increases, contributed to a pension, learned more skills, better chance of promotion etc. What an incredibly short sighted post .

In my experience the decision to be a sahm and for how long is all too frequently short sighted. Women are so often their own worst enemy.

QuebecBagnet · 12/05/2022 16:06

so what everyone’s basically saying is go back to work asap after you’ve had kids even though the majority of your pay check will be spent on childcare,

absolutely.

I spent three years working for nothing due to childcare costs. I’m now head of my dept and on a good salary. No way would I be here if I’d taken time out.

the number of women I know who are stuck either can’t get a job or doing min wage stuff way below their capabilities is unreal. And some of those have been really fucked over when their husband leaves them.

Allthe4s · 12/05/2022 14:57

Everyone is basically saying go back to work asap after you’ve had kids even though the majority of your pay check will be spent on childcare

For a finite number of years during which time you’ll have had pay increases, contributed to a pension, learned more skills, better chance of promotion etc. What an incredibly short sighted post .

HaveringWavering · 12/05/2022 13:34

Colliewobbles123 · 12/05/2022 10:12

@velvetcandy how are you feeling now? I had an interview yesterday and they said I was too old for maternity leave as if it was a bonus that makes me more employable….…. I’m 35!!! It’s so disheartening!

I am more than just my ovaries, I have a brain too

Wow. Was it a man or a woman who said that? Their minds would have been blown by my maternity leave when I was 43..

WimbyAce · 12/05/2022 13:20

Colliewobbles123 · 12/05/2022 10:12

@velvetcandy how are you feeling now? I had an interview yesterday and they said I was too old for maternity leave as if it was a bonus that makes me more employable….…. I’m 35!!! It’s so disheartening!

I am more than just my ovaries, I have a brain too

Wow this is hideous!

melcalfe · 12/05/2022 13:01

Everyone is basically saying go back to work asap after you’ve had kids even though the majority of your pay check will be spent on childcare

Yes. *
*
Or you have another option: get a better job/build a better paid career - before you have children.

Orangello · 12/05/2022 12:39

so what everyone’s basically saying is go back to work asap after you’ve had kids

Nobody said that. You made your choice, chose a path and yes this means that affects how your life goes and what other choices you have available. Other women decided to go back ASAP - we also didn't have some options like you had. Honestly, what were you expecting, that a large gap during which you didn't keep your skill sup to date will have no effect at all?

InChocolateWeTrust · 12/05/2022 12:38

I think OP you are mixing up what is relevant.

It is not that fact that you have kids that has held you back in your job search. Millions of parents work.

It is the 8 year gap in your work history. You could be child free and male and experienced.... and an 8 year gap will be an issue. It is 8 years. It is a really, really long time.

redskyatnight · 12/05/2022 12:36

velvetcandy · 12/05/2022 09:39

Wow I can’t keep up with all these messages.

so what everyone’s basically saying is go back to work asap after you’ve had kids even though the majority of your pay check will be spent on childcare, additionally if you do take some time out still somehow use/update your skills that you can’t technically access unless you’re at work and also give your services away for free by volunteering because obviously once you have kids that renders your experience as void. Love mums net

That's a choice a lot of women make, yes. You've made a different choice, which is perfectly fine, but you have to accept that you are therefore not in the same position as another person who hasn't had a career break.

Most people find there is more to volunteering than "giving your services away for free".

And having kids does not render your experience as void. It renders it 8 years old (in your case). I've stayed in the workplace but if I tried to get a job doing what I'd been doing 8 years ago, I would also be out of touch and deskilled. I have other skills that suggest I might be able to transfer back, but that requires me to convince an employer to take a chance on me, not for them to automatically think that I am amazing.

You are not the same person you were 8 years ago. You may or may not be able to do the same job you were doing then. None of us know that. Have a read round MN and see how many women struggle with doing their old jobs after just a year of maternity leave.

SirChenjins · 12/05/2022 12:35

so what everyone’s basically saying is go back to work asap after you’ve had kids even though the majority of your pay check will be spent on childcare, additionally if you do take some time out still somehow use/update your skills that you can’t technically access unless you’re at work and also give your services away for free by volunteering because obviously once you have kids that renders your experience as void

Yep - unless you're in a role where it doesn't matter if you take 1, 10 or 20 years out that is the reality. Why do you think so many parents go back to work after the children are born?

MolliciousIntent · 12/05/2022 12:24

velvetcandy · 12/05/2022 09:39

Wow I can’t keep up with all these messages.

so what everyone’s basically saying is go back to work asap after you’ve had kids even though the majority of your pay check will be spent on childcare, additionally if you do take some time out still somehow use/update your skills that you can’t technically access unless you’re at work and also give your services away for free by volunteering because obviously once you have kids that renders your experience as void. Love mums net

Well, yeah! It's common knowledge that being a SAHM makes it much, much harder to re-enter the workforce. People don't want to employ people with no recent experience or qualifications.

Brefugee · 12/05/2022 12:17

so what everyone’s basically saying is go back to work asap after you’ve had kids even though the majority of your pay check will be spent on childcare,

Everyone has different priorities. From the absolute beginning of my working life i have had one eye on my pension, my career progression and where i want to be in 5, 10, 15 etc years. It hasn't always gone to plan, but one thing i have ALWAYS been keen on (my mum is one of the women who misses pension because of the half-stamp nonsense in the 70s) is that i remain relevant and attractive to employers. Not because i love working (i don't) but because i don't want to face an old age of potential poverty. My main way of investing in that was getting back to work asap and seeing the childcare costs as part of that investment.

And it has been a bloody hard slog with a lot of tears and stress along the way.

additionally if you do take some time out still somehow use/update your skills that you can’t technically access unless you’re at work

Well, you can't sit back and expect all this knowledge to fall in your lap. It could be as easy as keeping up with industry developments by treading the trade mags, or investing in freshening up your Office skills. Whatever. You know what your industry needs because you did it for 10 years. Being pro-active is what employers love.

and also give your services away for free by volunteering because obviously once you have kids that renders your experience as void. Love mums net

Mumsnet can offer loads of really good practical advice. Volunteering is a way of showing that you can commit, that your timekeeping is good, that you have a system in place for when you are not at home etc etc.

You do seem quite passive for someone who is looking for work, OP. Perhaps that came across in the interview?

G5000 · 12/05/2022 12:15

I'm a recruiting manager and I want to stress again that just because you're the most experienced candidate does not mean you're also the best fit for the job.

I'm recruiting for a junior to mid-level roles at the moment. And I have people with 20,30, even 40+ years of experience applying.
Could they do the job? I'm sure they could. But they would also get bored and frustrated with tasks they could do with their eyes closed. So the graduate might have simply been a better fit for the job.

And also, we don't know what the job is. I've also worked in roles where you need to take over the shift on the dot and it really simply isn't possible for someone to start half an hour later.

SmugOldBag · 12/05/2022 11:59

LowlandLucky · 11/05/2022 19:11

So you have raised children, ran a home, managed accounts and done 100 other roles but they choose someone who has never held down a full time job. Brainless.

Someone with 10 years of experience from 8 years ago is actually of less value to my team than a recent grad. More likely to be stuck in 'old' or outdated ways of doing things and unwilling to change. The world in my area has moved on significantly. Knowledge and skills needed are totally different. The grad would have learned these at University and the ones we hire have done extensive research beyond their studies and have interesting and creative opinions and ideas for new opportunities as well as ambition, focus and drive.

I have no idea what industry you work in but if it relies on theories that have moved on in that time and you haven't shown you've kept up it's clear why you weren't chosen over the grad, kids or not.

Franklin12 · 12/05/2022 11:32

Both my children were graduates. They had plenty of work experience before graduating. There was no way I was letting either of them not work during the endless holidays. One took a gap year and travelled and then when the pandemic hit took a role in a food factory as an essential worker.

The grad could have had the equilivant of 2 years experience in the world of work plus all the Excel, Word, Powerpoint skills that I certainly dont have. I can get by of course but looking at how one of my sons handles a spreadsheet is very impressive.

Franklin12 · 12/05/2022 11:27

The Op has had a number of suggestions and observations from people actually in the world of work now and people who have recruited.

I am not sure she is getting it and thinks because she worked over 8 years ago and wants some flexibility on the hours from the get go that she will be snapped up.

If we knew the sector it might help. I stepped down from the corporate world. After 35 years I felt I was done. The money wasnt so important. I now work part time and draw my work pension and STILL people tell me I am lucky as though my decision making was all luck.

We make decisions based on what is best for us. Some work out and some dont. All I would say is never turn your back on the world of work or expect people to be interested in why you need to go at 1530 every term for parents afternoon or that your son isnt very well and needs you to be there.

I also suspect having been out of work for such a long time that they have forgotton the right way to do things which is wait until they offer you a role, or even better start at the stated hours and then find an opportunity to see whether you can make some changes. Certainly dont start telling them what you can and cannot do when the hours are stated in the jd.

And for gods sake please no more CEO of the Home etc

hettie · 12/05/2022 11:10

Was your profession/ role previously not that competitive?
I say that because you don't seem to understand that the jobs market is a market... You are in competition with other candidates, often thorougout your career.
I paid (well the family finances paid- it was a net loss me working after childcare) for me to to return to work after maternity because I knew taking 3 to 5 years out would make it incredibly hard for me to return. I would have been out of date in skills terms and out of practice with my existing skills. Of course I could have made that decision like you did, but I do think you need to accept it and week out how you can become competitive for the roles you would like.

IcedPurple · 12/05/2022 10:57

PradaOnaBudget · 12/05/2022 10:52

Why? running a house was not a required skill for this job. The other candidate simply had the skills or attitude which were more suitable, so they were offered the job. Fresh graduated can be very good at time-keeping and other life skills. It is not exclusive to people who have run a household!

I graduated when I was 27, and had been living on my own since I was 16. Not every fresh graduate comes without life experience!

And even if 'running a household' were a required skill, we have no idea how good the OP is.

For all any of us knows, her house could be a mess, with bills unpaid, children sat in front of the telly all day, dishes piling up in the sink. I'm sure that's not the case, but we just don't know. Just because a person happens to be a mum who doesn't work, doesn't mean that you're super efficient.

PradaOnaBudget · 12/05/2022 10:52

LowlandLucky · 11/05/2022 19:11

So you have raised children, ran a home, managed accounts and done 100 other roles but they choose someone who has never held down a full time job. Brainless.

Why? running a house was not a required skill for this job. The other candidate simply had the skills or attitude which were more suitable, so they were offered the job. Fresh graduated can be very good at time-keeping and other life skills. It is not exclusive to people who have run a household!

I graduated when I was 27, and had been living on my own since I was 16. Not every fresh graduate comes without life experience!

PradaOnaBudget · 12/05/2022 10:33

StageRage · 11/05/2022 18:38
It’s the reality of sex discrimination by the back door.
I wonder if they even asked the graduate if they could do the hours. It is very poor Equal Opps practice to ask different questions of different candidates,,,

but they didn't ask the OP either. She volunteered the information and tried to change the working hours during the interview. I would be weary as well if I was the employer. By the time she got to the interview, she should have made plans about who was going to take care of the child during those 30 minutes. IMO, the time to ask for flexibility is when you are already part of the company and you've had time to prove yourself, not before you even join them.

Astrabees · 12/05/2022 10:15

I've recently been recruiting for someone new in my department, an interesting admin post with prospects (I'll be retiring soon). I've been through this exercise before so I have experience of the process. I have noticed that if you recruit someone who is over qualified for the job they tend not to stay for long and the whole expensive and inconvenient process has to be repeated. This time I've interviewed a number of applicants who could do the job but their experience is in something a little different. One swanned in like lady bountiful and said that now she had left the corporate world she had a passion for organising people like me ( third sector) others seemed taken aback at having to learn a new software system. I offered to one of the younger and less experienced applicants because she was genuinely enthusiastic, her IT skills were really good and bang up to date and she had the right attitude. She turned down the job and we then took on a very capable older person who did exactly the same job for another organisation. I'm sure it wasn't OP's SAHM status that scuppered her, she was probably just not the best fit and saying anything about your family in interview is not a good idea. Recruitment is not riddled with prejudice, we just want to get someone in the post we think will stay, will do a good job and be a valued member of the team. For this job the hours are written in stone, I have to have the office manned at all times, I have agreed slight variations for people who have been with us a while but asking for something different in interview would really put me off the applicant.

Swipe left for the next trending thread