Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To go to a child's birthday party without a gift?

285 replies

Slagertha · 11/05/2022 15:38

Dc has been invited to a birthday party, I've never not taken a gift when it's been a child's birthday party but currently have no money whatsoever. Would it be unreasonable/cheeky/embarrassing to still take dc? They really want to go but I feel put off because of this! X

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Lost2010 · 19/05/2022 16:17

Hello @Slagertha how was the party ? Did you go ? Hope your DC and the Birthday child had a great time

SleepingStandingUp · 15/05/2022 17:25

PumpkinsandKittens · 13/05/2022 23:08

I wouldn’t turn up to a party without a gift tbh and being honest I do think other parents will gossip about it

Meaning "I'd slag you off behind your back if I saw even if it wasn't my party"

SleepingStandingUp · 15/05/2022 17:23

londonrach · 14/05/2022 08:21

What I'd do. Get my daughter to make a card then look through her toys and regift something she has that's in very good condition eg small car etc. More that your child has something to hand over for your child. Honestly the birthday child and mum wouldn't mind especially if you explain. Hope things improve op

I'd be horrified if I thought a financially hard up family had given me one of their own toys in order to come to the party

Fridgeorflight · 14/05/2022 23:35

We've got my DD's party coming up and I'd be gutted if a child didn't attend because their parents couldn't afford a gift. I want all of her friends there to have fun with her. She won't notice who she gets gifts from and she has plenty of stuff already. I'd also be really sad if someone borrowed money for a gift - it just isn't necessary.

All of that aside, our party is paid per child, so it's a waste if someone doesn't come and we've paid for a space. I don't care about gifts, but I will be miffed about no-shows that are avoidable.

Blondeshavemorefun · 14/05/2022 23:08

Sorry you felt you had to borrow off family

or Hope that was for food and not a present for the party

seems all including myself , bar 2 posters would much prefer you to come without a present

Blarting · 14/05/2022 23:07

NRRK28 · 14/05/2022 23:06

Personally I wouldn’t mind. But if you wanna bring something ana your children to draw something. I will very appreciate if some children makes my boy nice drawing.

That's a lovely idea Smile

NRRK28 · 14/05/2022 23:06

Personally I wouldn’t mind. But if you wanna bring something ana your children to draw something. I will very appreciate if some children makes my boy nice drawing.

Fromthebirdsnest · 14/05/2022 23:03

make a card with your child and go , they won't care about no present most parents would be grateful for no tat and a lovely handmade card x sorry your without at the moment your not alone due to the rise in bills and fuel lots of people are struggling...if your struggling for food and electricity then there is help at the food bank , speak to your local children's center if you need to x

QueenoftheNimbleFlyingCat · 14/05/2022 22:41

I wouldn't even notice, or care if you didn't bring a gift for my child. If you are worried, why not wrap a favourite book and make a card explaining why the book is so special? I'd absolutely love that!

ChocolateHippo · 14/05/2022 22:26

Applegreenb · 14/05/2022 20:25

If I was the parent I wouldn’t care and be grateful not to have some tat around my house. I have been tempted to say no presents before but feel sorry for my DC.

please don’t buy the plastic toys that are 3 for £1 I just put them in the bin. If you have to take anything a £1 chocolate bar and 29p card would be sufficient. Or a £1 book

Absolutely. My DC doesn't get sweets very often so a cone of cheap pick and mix, one of those small tubs of sweets from Poundland or even a little bag of haribo or other gummies would be extremely popular with him 😁! And I would be thankful not to have my house cluttered up with "worthy" craft kits, tbh.

Applegreenb · 14/05/2022 20:25

If I was the parent I wouldn’t care and be grateful not to have some tat around my house. I have been tempted to say no presents before but feel sorry for my DC.

please don’t buy the plastic toys that are 3 for £1 I just put them in the bin. If you have to take anything a £1 chocolate bar and 29p card would be sufficient. Or a £1 book

MuddlingThrough1724 · 14/05/2022 19:51

We hosted a class party last year, and I absolutely promise you that nobody cares about presents, it is the birthday child enjoying celebrating with their friends that is the important part. We specifically asked for no gifts as are mindful of space, cost and waste, but inevitably some people did bring gifts, which although appreciated by my child were not necessary and had no bearing on her enjoyment.

Go to the party, maybe have a quiet word with the parents or ping them a text if you feel you want to, but nobody will notice or care. If your child can make a card or do a picture then I'm sure that would be lovely, and the idea of including a playdate invite if that is something that works for you and your child is a really nice one.

Ultimately please don't feel pressure or anxiety or stressed, that isn't the aim of anyone hosting, and am sure they would be horrified of they thought that the invite had made you feel that way.

Lots of love to you, times are tough for lots of people at the moment and you shouldn't feel any shame or embarrassment at all for having to prioritise spending in far more important areas.

Blarting · 14/05/2022 14:38

ChocolateHippo · 14/05/2022 14:00

I agree @Blarting . I would much rather someone who was struggling spent the money on their own child rather than mine.

I also wish (for both environmental and clutter reasons) that it was acceptable to say, "Presents absolutely not necessary, but if you do want to give something, a few quid (up to a maximum of £5) towards this thing my child is saving for would be great". But I don't think that's socially acceptable so am dreading the influx of presents at the whole class party we're having next month!

I'd want to do the same!

Blarting · 14/05/2022 14:38

cigarettesNalcohol · 14/05/2022 14:35

Poundland sell books for £1

Have you read the OPs posts? She's borrowing money to feed her child!

cigarettesNalcohol · 14/05/2022 14:35

Poundland sell books for £1

ChocolateHippo · 14/05/2022 14:00

I agree @Blarting . I would much rather someone who was struggling spent the money on their own child rather than mine.

I also wish (for both environmental and clutter reasons) that it was acceptable to say, "Presents absolutely not necessary, but if you do want to give something, a few quid (up to a maximum of £5) towards this thing my child is saving for would be great". But I don't think that's socially acceptable so am dreading the influx of presents at the whole class party we're having next month!

Blarting · 14/05/2022 09:00

Slagertha · 14/05/2022 08:11

Didn't realise this was still going! I'm quite shocked that people would see it as rude to go without a gift. The general rise in the cost of living has really affected us to the point where we have a nothing left in the fridge this weekend, the cost of gas and electric, food, travel for work, school lunches or dinners and every other bill that we have to pay for has been a real stretch. Life is expensive! I don't expect sympathy but can't believe that people truly can't believe I couldn't afford even a cheap gift. I really couldn't! Luckily I had a family member to borrow from, but some of you need to enter the real world. I would never see it as rude if someone came to my child's birthday celebrations empty handed because I appreciate how much of a struggle it is to get by myself!

Thank you for all your input, it's been an interesting read!

Tbh you want your child to play with like minded nice children, the grabby ones who think it's rude to not bring a present because they can't afford it are not the ones you want to nurture relationships with.

U can't understand the mentality of "just bring something that's a couple of quid" mentality either, surely if a family is struggling that much and they have a spare couple of quid, you'd rather they bought their own child an ice cream or pencils etc.

Lwren · 14/05/2022 08:41

Not read the replies but please go!

Loads of mums told me they couldn't come as they felt cheeky but were too broke so I made it very clear we just wanted their company not gifts my son was just as every kid is, was happy to run riot with his pals.

edenhills · 14/05/2022 08:36

I would try to make a card and regift something. But if you absolutely cannot bring anything then still go. Most people wouldn't even notice, especially if a big party. Your presence is always worth more than your presents x

zaffa · 14/05/2022 08:31

If I were the parent throwing the party, I wouldn't care. It's not about presents, but about DD having her friends there. She wouldn't know there was no present (I haven't had a party yet but see the norm is to put things on a table for opening after everyone went home) and all she would care about is having fun.
I would hate for someone not to come for this reason!

londonrach · 14/05/2022 08:21

What I'd do. Get my daughter to make a card then look through her toys and regift something she has that's in very good condition eg small car etc. More that your child has something to hand over for your child. Honestly the birthday child and mum wouldn't mind especially if you explain. Hope things improve op

Slagertha · 14/05/2022 08:15

Tanfastic · 14/05/2022 07:50

When ds was small and if I were in this situation I'd have been able to find something he had to regift. There was always something lurking in the cupboard that I'd put away for a rainy day. I personally wouldn't feel comfortable sending him with nothing to hand over, even if was a 99p book from home bargains. I'll never forget when I stood my ground on teacher's presents and his face when he came home from school and said he was the only one that didn't give a gift but the teacher understood Confused.

I'm more concerned that you have zero pence in your account and payday isn't looming. That's very concerning.

Yes it's shit, the gas and electric rise has really affected us but I start a new job after half term so hopefully won't ever be in this situation again! X

OP posts:
Slagertha · 14/05/2022 08:11

Didn't realise this was still going! I'm quite shocked that people would see it as rude to go without a gift. The general rise in the cost of living has really affected us to the point where we have a nothing left in the fridge this weekend, the cost of gas and electric, food, travel for work, school lunches or dinners and every other bill that we have to pay for has been a real stretch. Life is expensive! I don't expect sympathy but can't believe that people truly can't believe I couldn't afford even a cheap gift. I really couldn't! Luckily I had a family member to borrow from, but some of you need to enter the real world. I would never see it as rude if someone came to my child's birthday celebrations empty handed because I appreciate how much of a struggle it is to get by myself!

Thank you for all your input, it's been an interesting read!

OP posts:
Tanfastic · 14/05/2022 07:52

Sorry I've obviously not read the whole thread before replying, didn't realise it was so long!

Tanfastic · 14/05/2022 07:50

When ds was small and if I were in this situation I'd have been able to find something he had to regift. There was always something lurking in the cupboard that I'd put away for a rainy day. I personally wouldn't feel comfortable sending him with nothing to hand over, even if was a 99p book from home bargains. I'll never forget when I stood my ground on teacher's presents and his face when he came home from school and said he was the only one that didn't give a gift but the teacher understood Confused.

I'm more concerned that you have zero pence in your account and payday isn't looming. That's very concerning.