Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask dog owners to be extra vigilant around younger children?

318 replies

ponderingthisthing · 11/05/2022 12:17

At the weekend, we were out in the meadows and having our family photos taken by a professional photographer.

A dog came near us and started jumping on the DC, who are 2 and 4. DH tried to fend it off until the owner came and dragged the dog away with some difficulty. By this time both children were extremely scared and upset and were screaming and crying. The owner may have muttered a quiet "sorry" before leaving quickly. No genuine apology or word to check if DC were OK, even though they were obviously extremely disturbed at that point with tears flooding down their faces. She just didn't seem to care.

For us though, it really put a damper on things and unsurprisingly the photography session did not go well. Both children felt unsafe following this (there were other dogs around, many not on lead) and clung to us.

It's not the first time that it's happened, DD was already afraid of dogs due to similar episodes in the past. We try to reassure her that dogs don't normally harm people and that she should just behave normally around them, but I wonder if we should also think more now about safety. Just yesterday, I came across a photo on social media of a little girl who was mauled in the face by a dog. Of course no physical harm came of this episode involving DC, thank goodness, and the dog was probably just over excited. However, the incident is making me feel somewhat uneasy about taking DC to places where dogs can run free.

AIBU to ask that dog owners be extra vigilant with small children around? And obviously, if the dogs are likely to jump up at people, to keep them on lead around small children in public places?

OP posts:
Giraffesandbottoms · 11/05/2022 17:18

I've also seen a high pitched screaming toddler cause a horse to bolt Kids can be just as problematic as dogs I'm afraid

god, this. I’m at a child free yard for this exact reason (and take my children to ride somewhere else!)

collieresponder88 · 11/05/2022 17:16

Arenanewbie · 11/05/2022 13:56

Dogs should be on a lead unless at home or in a designated dog field.
^this 100%

Ridiculous Hmm

Giraffesandbottoms · 11/05/2022 17:14

I’ve had a lot of problems with unruly dogs as well, don’t get me wrong. When DS was just 2, a schnauzer ran across the park, put his front paws on DS’ shoulders and barked in his face. Nothing triggered this, owner didn’t apologise and I was absolutely terrified/it happened so quickly that even though I was 1m away I couldn’t intervene. The thing is DS isn’t scared because we have a dog so I’m trying to instil in him the appropriate amount of caution (eg not touching or going near strange dogs but not running screaming like an idiot/many children do when anywhere near a dog. Just riles them up)

but people on here saying “Human rights trump dogs” are missing the point. If you let your child come over to my dog and pet him without asking and he bites, it’s your problem. You are supposed to protect your child. There are some seriously shit parents as well as dog owners

ObjectionHearsay · 11/05/2022 17:13

JusticeForWanda · 11/05/2022 14:44

Dogs without proper training should be on leads and children should be properly trained to behave around dogs - not approach without permission and not be hysterical if a dog approaches them.

If people did this everything would be fine.

Im reminded of a time a small child ran up to my Uncles giant breed, was told the dog doesn’t really play and to please leave it alone…small child totally ignored instructions, parent didn’t recall small child, dog turned it arse on the child (he thought he was much too good for playing!), child got knocked flying and banged its head. Parent kicked off, when it was entirely their fault!

This is my fear with my giant breed.

He really has no concept of his size. He tries to sit on my lap like a puppy, thinks he can fit in small places like the cat does and destroys things with his arse.

I am so worried if a small child decided to approach he'd unknowingly knock them over by turning to heal.

However I am lucky in that all the children in the street adore him and they like to dress him up during street parties. For VE day he was sporting sunglasses and a bonnet from one of the girls dolls 🤦🏻‍♀️ he just sits there and slobbers on them all and they think it's hilarious. They also decided to paint his nails with chalk they were drawing on the floor with. There's a reason this breed are referred to as "nanny dogs" 😂

collieresponder88 · 11/05/2022 17:08

Howaboutnope · 11/05/2022 13:33

YANBU but cue all the dog owners who just don't get it at all! Particularly if they don't have children themselves. Don't even get me started on the ones who jump up at horses and get in the way of bicycles etc. But they're "just being friendly" even though it caused the horse to bolt and lose its rider (who was injured) and the dog to be kicked by the horse. Also the bicycle to stop sharply when it appeared from no where causing whiplash to the toddler in the back seat...Dogs off the lead in non dog park areas should be illegal.

I've also seen a high pitched screaming toddler cause a horse to bolt Kids can be just as problematic as dogs I'm afraid

WeRTheOnesWeHaveBeenWaitingFor · 11/05/2022 17:01

I call my dog to come close to me if I can see people are not confident with dogs. He doesn’t jump up though.
However, friendly dogs are a really normal everyday thing and your children screaming in terror is an unusual reaction. Most children love dogs. Can you expose you children to a friends dog in a controlled way so they become more comfortable around them?

Penguinevere · 11/05/2022 16:51

YANBU people can’t handle their dogs.

I was at a family friendly and dog friendly event at the weekend and a guy walked so close to us with his husky that he had to yank it back when it went for my toddler. Twice. I don’t really mind dogs but they’re dangerous, keep them away from children and keep your children from approaching them too.

IncessantNameChanger · 11/05/2022 16:22

There will always be dog owners who just dont care if their dogs jump up at you.

I was 8 months pregnant and someone watched their lab run and jump up with it paws on my chest. Again I had the do t worry hes friendly. . But if hed jumped at force feet my bump it wouldnt need to bite me to seriously harm me and my baby.

Because their dogs play trumps your boundaries everytime.

stuntbubbles · 11/05/2022 16:19

Minimalme · 11/05/2022 14:26

You need to be more aware of your surroundings.

If there were lots of dogs off lead then you chose a popular dog walking field and the inevitable happened.

Nice victim blaming.

UndertheCedartree · 11/05/2022 16:13

I agree but not just young children. My autistic DS had a dog run right up to him loudly barking when he was about 8. He was really scared of dogs for many years after that.

ThatAnnoysMeToo · 11/05/2022 16:09

Ugh. So many dog owners are awful.
My poor elder child loved dogs, until at 2 a dog tackled her down whilst owners shouted 'it's okay, he's friendly!' Whilst leisurely strolling down. Obviously picked up the toddler instantly, owners seemed to think it was funny. Still petrified over them years later.
Now I just say, don't worry, if it comes any closer I'll whack it with that stick. Dogs are now retrieved promptly as they ought to be. I would as well.

Children should be able to play and run ahead in the woods without worrying about dogs! I wish there were dog-free woods like there are dog free beaches.

Fairislefandango · 11/05/2022 16:05

YANBU. I'm lucky in that my dog isn't remotely interested in approaching people he doesn't know, and is quite wary of small children. It would be good if adults and their small children would refrain from approaching dogs without asking too.

luxxlisbon · 11/05/2022 16:05

YANBU unreasonable. I was out for lunch recently and someone’s dog was constantly under my baby’s highchair and jumping at her. She was screaming her head off because it was in her space and touching her feet, I was trying to shoo the dog away and the owners just didn’t give a shit.
I was absolutely furious.

blubbebubba · 11/05/2022 16:04

MadameCholetsDirtySecret · 11/05/2022 13:50

Whilst I empathise with the OP and dogs should be under control at all times, I can reverse this scenario. When my girl was a young dog, we were at our local pub. We were sitting outside, she was on a lead and sleeping at our feet. A delightful child ran passed her, stopped and spat on her.

the delightful child’s father was too busy boasting to his friends and drinking champagne to care.

That is awful @MadameCholetsDirtySecret, I'd be really furious, very nasty. But luckily, children like that are few and far between, but most of us can recall being jumped on or ran up to by a dog. (I'm fine and don't mind, but for someone who's afraid it's unpleasant)

AlrightHarry · 11/05/2022 16:02

YANBU my DC are scared of dogs after similar experiences.

So many dog owners seem blind to the fact that if their dog doesn't return to them when called, it is out of control. These are the dogs that should be on leads. But these are the clueless owners who let dogs jump all over small children.

I'm so over the "just being friendly" line. If I wanted a dog to jump up and slobber all over me I would get my own.

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 11/05/2022 16:02

if a dog comes up to me and jumps up, licks me, puts its filthy claws on my chest, I go up to the owner, put my hands on her chest, lick her face and mouth and pant my foetid breath into her face.

And that’s fine because I am being friendly.

KevinTheKoala · 11/05/2022 16:01

YANBU my youngest is petrified of dogs (we have no idea why, she has always been scared of them) to the point that if she sees on she screams and clings to me, it is slowly improving but every time a dog comes bounding up to her, sniffing and wanting to play it sets her back. I completley understand that the dog is probably just very friendly and excited, my elder DD loves dogs and she has been taught how to behave around them and to ask for permission before talking/stroking dogs. We can understand that some dogs are nervous so why can't owners understand that some children are nervous?

My DD has been too scared to walk in the park because of other dogs, I don't expect there to be no dogs obviously but if you can't trust your dog to come back when called then it should not be off the lead - at least not near play grounds.

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 11/05/2022 15:58

Why quote me and then make a point I have said I agree with. I see that quite a lot od dog threads. It's like anyone who owns a dog and says that they too see badly trained dogs behaving bady are re-written, interpreted out of anything they have actually said.

Stop it!

Nobody disagrees that poorly trained dogs are a bloody nuisance.

Eastlyne · 11/05/2022 15:58

Small children bugging dogs is unacceptable and I would never allow my child to do it, but dog owners seem to think it's fine for their dog to run up to my kid uninvited, and that their lack of control over their animal is somehow adorable. However much you say it's a "two way street", though, the fact is the rights of a human trump the rights of your dog.

I love dogs. But I hate a lot of dog owners. The amount of shit around these days proves to me that crappy owners are not as rare as people on here would like you to believe.

The "you can't let your kid go round being scared of dogs" thing makes me. laugh, because so often it's an experience with a uncontrolled dog with a shitty owner that causes that fear in the first place. Of course parents are then cautious because they don't want that fear to be intensified by more bad experiences. No-one can tell your dog is a softy by looking at them, or that it's actual under your control despite appearances.

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 11/05/2022 15:56

Me personally @DaSilvaP

I am not the dog owner the OP is writing about!

And I have posted abou thow I keep my dog under control!

chisanunian · 11/05/2022 15:52

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 11/05/2022 13:37

If that was a question for me you misunderstood. I don't think either were more or less 'valid' and didn't say anything to suggest I did!

I just pointed out that in the real world dogs will be off lead in places they are allowed to be off lead in, some will be better trained than others. So a public space may not be the best place for a formal, paid for photo shoot!

Less well-trained dogs should not be running about off the lead in a public place when there are other people about.

Labscollie · 11/05/2022 15:47

StrawberryPot · 11/05/2022 15:32

YANBU BUT it’s a two way street. I also get irritated by children running up and petting/pulling at my dog without asking/parents not asking. He actually won’t bite but how do they know?

^^ This in spades. I had my young well-behaved Labrador on a lead one day in a public space and a young child toddled up to her and started hitting her hard on the head with his toy car. As I remonstrated the child's father glanced up from his phone and said, "don't do that it might bite you".

On another occasion, when she was off lead and sitting nicely at a sports game, a boy of about 12 saw her and started running away screaming. She thought it was a game so started running alongside him, whereupon the boy flung himself on the ground and my dog just sniffed him and looked puzzled. Cue dad to appear, accuse me of having an out of control dog that had attacked his son, demand my name and address and tell me he would be taking his son to hospital for a full check up. Fortunately, the club captain intervened to say he'd seen the whole thing and told the man to stop being so ridiculous.

Yep, plenty of irresponsible parents, who don't supervise their children, but dogs are the easiest targets. Say anything about irresponsible parenting and all hell breaks loose.

CaptainMyCaptain · 11/05/2022 15:41

YANBU but I would also like people to stop their children from approaching dogs they don't know. My dog would never voluntarily go up to a child as she has been frightened by small children grabbing her in the past. She is small and cute and children often want to touch her. It's worse when she is on a lead as she can't escape from them if she was loose she would run away from them.

DaSilvaP · 11/05/2022 15:37

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 11/05/2022 13:27

I don't disagree with your sentment OP but

At the weekend, we were out in the meadows and having our family photos taken by a professional photographer.

And the dog owner was using those same meadows equally legally, I would assume!

You were all observant of ground nesting birds, protected plant species, etc, etc.

As it was the dog owner was lacking in observation, but you were also - you did say that there were many off lead dogs, not the best spot for a photograhpy session, the photograher should have known better. Which is always the problem when anyone uses public land for private purposes.

Equally there is a legal obligation to keep your dog under control in public spaces AT ALL TIME. I don't think that letting your dog jump all over other people's kids counts as "being in control of your dog".
Also, if let your dog "be friendly" to people who don't want it, be they adults or kids, and you have the bad luck that they know the law and won't think twice before using against you, you could be sued on no other grounds then "I / my kid felt threatened by this dog" and potentially have you dog taken way. Check it for yourself if you don't believe it.

StrawberryPot · 11/05/2022 15:35

Not sure where my paragraph breaks went!