Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask dog owners to be extra vigilant around younger children?

318 replies

ponderingthisthing · 11/05/2022 12:17

At the weekend, we were out in the meadows and having our family photos taken by a professional photographer.

A dog came near us and started jumping on the DC, who are 2 and 4. DH tried to fend it off until the owner came and dragged the dog away with some difficulty. By this time both children were extremely scared and upset and were screaming and crying. The owner may have muttered a quiet "sorry" before leaving quickly. No genuine apology or word to check if DC were OK, even though they were obviously extremely disturbed at that point with tears flooding down their faces. She just didn't seem to care.

For us though, it really put a damper on things and unsurprisingly the photography session did not go well. Both children felt unsafe following this (there were other dogs around, many not on lead) and clung to us.

It's not the first time that it's happened, DD was already afraid of dogs due to similar episodes in the past. We try to reassure her that dogs don't normally harm people and that she should just behave normally around them, but I wonder if we should also think more now about safety. Just yesterday, I came across a photo on social media of a little girl who was mauled in the face by a dog. Of course no physical harm came of this episode involving DC, thank goodness, and the dog was probably just over excited. However, the incident is making me feel somewhat uneasy about taking DC to places where dogs can run free.

AIBU to ask that dog owners be extra vigilant with small children around? And obviously, if the dogs are likely to jump up at people, to keep them on lead around small children in public places?

OP posts:
lovesT · 11/05/2022 21:26

@hellrabbitishere just in case you're referring to my comment, when I say about having a blanket on the beach which a dog comes and tramples all over we do not have food, just me and my daughter playing with the sand. Great that you've never had a problem with them, doesn't mean no one else has. I'm sorry but I just don't want an unknown dog coming over to me and my daughter, how do we know it's okay?! Even if it is friendly, I don't want it all over us (without any food to tempt it ...) 🐶

GuyFawkesDay · 11/05/2022 21:17

A park is a very different proposition to a meadow.

Mine is very definitely on lead around parks and play areas. Harmless buffoon but typically enthusiastic spaniel who wants everyone to love him as much as he loves people and clearly that's not right.

I do let him off lead in the park near us at 6am. I say "park", it's a couple of acres with wood at one end and play equipment the other. Plenty of space for a game of fetch in the early morning away from the play stuff.

If I was the dog owner in OPs situation I'd have been mortified and apologised profusely whilst getting dog away as fast as possible.

AlrightHarry · 11/05/2022 21:02

If you are sympathising with the dog and its owner over the OPs children here, you are probably one of the lazy owners who hasn't bothered to train their dog to come when called.

I've seen it so many times, a half hearted call to the dog when it's getting in the middle of a picnic or licking a kids face. Then the owner walks on hoping the dog will follow. Basically they are embarrassed that their dogs are untrained and behaving badly. If anyone says something like come and get your dog, they get all defensive. (Like blaming the children)

And to all the fur baby parents saying I've never experienced unwanted attention from a dog, take a small child to a park and give them a snack, then you'll see what we're talking about.

underneaththeash · 11/05/2022 21:01

StrawberryPot · 11/05/2022 19:28

Any dog that harasses my child will just be kicked away as hard as possible.

Can I do the same to any child that harasses, hurts or scares my dog?

Difference is that your dog can kill/maim a child and a child cannot. You would also be criminally liable if they did.

surreymum89 · 11/05/2022 20:59

Yes in the past year I have had this happen much more frequently than I have ever noticed before , just the other week we were at the park and in the space of 20 mins a woman walked past with her dog on a long lead not paying attention and the dog jumped up with its paws on my 3 year old DD chest then 20 mins later 2 dogs came running up way in front of their owner , they started barking aggressively at DD she backed off and they then proceeded to literally chase her in circles round a rubbish bin until I grabbed her off the ground , first owner didn't even look to notice , second owner did look mortified and profusely apologised , none of the dogs were particularly big or scary looking but to a 3 year old they would seem pretty huge.

collieresponder88 · 11/05/2022 20:54

StrawberryPot · 11/05/2022 19:28

Any dog that harasses my child will just be kicked away as hard as possible.

Can I do the same to any child that harasses, hurts or scares my dog?

You sound like a lovely mum strawberry pot Confused

LC84 · 11/05/2022 20:49

feelingsareweird · 11/05/2022 13:38

Responsible dog owners should indeed be doing this already but unfortunately there are plenty of irresponsible and ignorant ones about.

I always keep my dog well away from children when out and about, but that’s more because I’ve had several incidents of kids running up and grabbing my nervous (and very large!) on-lead rescue dog without asking while their parents watched and laughed. So it very much works both ways and there are irresponsible fools in both camps…

Can relate to this! Our big rescue dog runs a mile when she sees small children as her only experience of them is being mauled and prodded, so thankfully we dont have to worry about her running up to them (its more the problem of coaxing her back from her hiding place once the kids are gone!)

Just wondering if its more a problem with smaller breeds? E.g. the owners assume noone will be scared of them and they wont do any harm?

Im really conscious that my dog is big and so if she ever ran towards someone it would be scary so am perhaps more vigilant than some of my friends with small breeds who just assume everyone will be ok with it...

But like people have said there will be good and bad owners 🤷🏽‍♀️🤷🏽‍♀️

avocadotofu · 11/05/2022 20:43

I totally agree with you. We live in London and our DS has been really frightened by dogs in parks. I love dogs and hope to get one when my little one is older. I grew up around dogs and our dogs were trained not to jump on people and had really good recall. We were also taught how to behaviour respectfully around dogs and it terrifies me to see how some people let their children approach strange dogs and touch/bother them. I feel there needs to be better education so dogs and children can coexist peacefully.

GregoryFluff · 11/05/2022 20:42

nearlyspringyay · 11/05/2022 13:43

There are two sides to this and I totally get your point op.

But I'd ask parents of younger children to keep them away from my on lead, blind, deaf, dog who is wearing a fluro jacket, fluro lead and bandana with his issues on it you could see them a mile off. He gets terrified and will jump up because he can't see and a small kids comes out to stroke him front on.

maybe all dogs and all small children should be on leads!

It is very important to teach your kids not to approach a dog without permission from the owner.

Sorry to derail.

No I completely agree

Not personally a dog person at all, but at the crux of it, it's the owners shouting 'oh, she's friendly, just wants a stroke' that is the problem. Toddlers don't know the difference, that's why I teach mine that you don't approach or engage any animal you don't know. But no wonder they get confused

The amount of kids killed recently, then random passerby wants her to stroke unknown animal at face height to her, genuinely turns my stomach, hate it, I pick her up as soon as one approaches

And the poor dogs that get grabbed too by these very kids that are getting mixed messages and think it's okay. Wish there were more dog parks tbh, that would help

underneaththeash · 11/05/2022 20:40

ObjectionHearsay · 11/05/2022 20:31

Are you ok?

What are you going to do if you start aggressively approaching a dog and it bites you? You are asking for a bite with this behaviour 🤦🏻‍♀️

No the dogs shouldn't be running up to you, but honestly this behaviour you think is amazing is actually putting you in more danger.

Dogs aren't stupid, if you start waving aggressively at it and threatening it with an object it could bite you!

Rethink your coping strategy here, please for your own safety.

I agree (and we have a dog), if you can't control if you put it on the lead when there are people nearby. My poor DD was sent flying 3 times when she was aged 3-4 and flattened and I just used to boot any dog which came near her after that.

DO NOT LET YOUR DOG JUMP AT SMALL CHILDREN

cuparfull · 11/05/2022 20:38

AbuelaGetTheUmbrellas · 11/05/2022 13:36

YANBU. Yesterday I was walking in the park with my 2 year old, and saw 2 women chatting to each other whilst their dogs were running around. I stayed close to my daughter but didn’t hold her hand( she likes to walk on her own in the park). We had to cross in between the women and their dogs. Rather than call her dog back, one of the women shouted very aggressively at my daughter to “be careful as the dogs are excited”! She was almost telling her off! I think if your dog does not have good recall or you can’t trust them around small kids, the onus is on you not to let them off the lead in public areas.

IMO Dogs should be on a lead when outdoors at all times unless specifically in a dog only park.
Small children are excitable and move erratically thus are enticing to a prey animal like a dog.
Owners should remember that if the dog bites, it will be destroyed. And they will have only themselves to blame given the law states the owner is in control of the animal. You cannot have total control off lead.

ObjectionHearsay · 11/05/2022 20:31

Lesserspottedmama · 11/05/2022 19:20

The thing is, people are getting sick of it. I’ve taken to aggressively protecting our space in these situations and proactively shouting, aiming a (fake) kick a the dog, waving my arms etc. Usually deters them. Owners can see them approaching us a
mile off and they look the other way, even though the kids are visibly scared. But start shouting and making like your going to kick the dog away and they then start scurrying over suddenly. Most of them then grab the dog and rush off without a word looking scandalised/horrified/mortified. Some can get a bit abusive but nothing too bad so far. I never would have behaved like that years ago, would’ve been shocked at the thought, but I’ve found it’s the only way. Lady on the beach nearly started crying when I chased her dog with a spade but the thing had just bounded straight at my 2 year old for the third time. Not the dogs fault, silly old bag of an owner. Hopefully she’ll think
again next time. My husband took his flip flop off and chased a lab recently after redirecting it twice already in a good natured way, from our picnic. Owner called (bleated inadequately) a couple of times but as soon as the flip flop came off then they suddenly got a bit more pro active.

Are you ok?

What are you going to do if you start aggressively approaching a dog and it bites you? You are asking for a bite with this behaviour 🤦🏻‍♀️

No the dogs shouldn't be running up to you, but honestly this behaviour you think is amazing is actually putting you in more danger.

Dogs aren't stupid, if you start waving aggressively at it and threatening it with an object it could bite you!

Rethink your coping strategy here, please for your own safety.

BreakfastClub80 · 11/05/2022 20:26

Wow! What a thread! Undoubtedly there are poor dog owners and good dog owners, we’ve all come across both. Likewise parents, though I don’t think that’s the case with the OP.

Also, some people lie dogs, some like children, some like both, some like neither. It’s a free country, we’re allowed to be different.

OP, I don’t think you’re being unreasonable and I’m sorry this spoilt your photo session. Very probably, the dog owner thought the best thing to do was remove the dog as quickly as possible rather than engage in lengthy apologies etc but we’ll never know. I might be being too generous.

I personally have a small dog who will jump up at people sometimes, I have tried and tried to stop this behaviour and she’s often on a lead because of it. So I don’t subscribe to the view that dogs rule! Equally, they aren’t robots, just as children aren’t, and I don’t have X-ray vision, so it’s difficult to ever be 100% sure the coast is clear. Personally I take the same view of dog owners as I do of parents, if they are willing to take responsibility and try to correct any bad behaviour, then I feel better than if they ignore it.

I hope your children are ok and grow more confident as they get bigger and older. A healthy fear is always good, of course, which is what I teach my child.

OnceMoreWithoutFeeling · 11/05/2022 20:23

@hellrabbitishere

and i also wonder how many of these posters who are moaning about how terrified their kids are of dogs dislike dogs themselves and dont want them anywhere near them and then that transfers to their kids

Me, me! I don't like dogs! They're stupid, smelly, dribbly, unpredictable, unhygienic and ugly. Okay not all dogs will tick every box but pretty much all of them will tick at least two, with ALL of them ticking "unpredictable". I really, really dislike them.

I don't want them in my personal space, I don't want them sniffing at or licking me with the muzzle they've just been sniffing another dog's arsehole / licking their own dick / burrowing in the corpse of a nearby dead rabbit / eating their own sick with; I don't want their slobber or their mud on my clothes or possessions; I categorically do not want them touching my DC; and I see absolutely no reason why, if their owner has them suitably under control, this should ever be an issue. The problem is the owners don't have them under control, and earnestly believe that because THEY don't mind being covered in their dog's saliva anyone who does is being unduly precious.

That leaving completely aside the danger if they do attack or bite.

Sadly my DD still likes the bloody things, my open and unabashed hatred of them notwithstanding, but knows by now not to approach them and to stand still with her arms down if (well when) they approach her uninvited.

paddingtonstares · 11/05/2022 20:21

I've never managed to come across these antisocial dogs like all the posters on here. I've never been jumped on, picnics wrecked etc.

My dog is on lead unless we go to enclosed fields as she is a boisterous twat dog whose recall goes to pot if she so decides. 95% reliable, 5% ignore..so leads and longline are used.
I do get people pulling DC to avoid, but fine, she is big, so probably looks like a shire horse would do to me. The ones that make me smile are the children who ask if she is friendly and can they stroke her and the parents look horrified 😁..she is very friendly and prefers humans to other dogs, she thinks everyone wants to be friends.

We get far more people wanting to say hello than avoid.

XelaM · 11/05/2022 20:06

Zeus44 · 11/05/2022 18:02

Dogs near children are just a big no no. Their owners who let them run loose need castrating then the dogs should be dealt with.

Any dog that harasses my child will just be kicked away as hard as possible. Simple as.

You need mental help.

I hope a dog bites you when you kick it.

If you kick my dog, you'll be the one sent flying.

ComDummings · 11/05/2022 20:06

Fairisleflora · 11/05/2022 13:46

Your dog, your lifestyle choice, your responsibility to keep it the heck away from each and every other member of the public. Dogs don’t have rights to be let off the lead. They are animals. If you can’t control your dog and want to let it off the lead, get a garden.

Totally agree

KevinTheKoala · 11/05/2022 20:02

I think people should teach their kids not to be scared of dogs and certain breeds should be banned to ease parents fears

How do you suggest teaching a toddler to not be afraid of dogs though? My DD has always been phobic around dogs despite never having had a bad experience with them, the rest of our family liking dogs and a family member having 2 large dogs that she has been exposed to since she was tiny (and has never gone well, she's always shown a fear response and obviously that is distressing for both her and the dogs so we cant really prolong that). My eldest loves dogs and asks every passing dog walker if she can say hello to their dog, but every child is different and when they have a genuine phobia it's not as easy as just teaching them not to be afraid.

RedRobyn2021 · 11/05/2022 19:59

There is nothing worse than people who can't control their dogs and dogs that jump all over you. It's not the dog, it's the lazy owners. I'd be fuming.

hellrabbitishere · 11/05/2022 19:57

and i also wonder how many of these posters who are moaning about how terrified their kids are of dogs dislike dogs themselves and dont want them anywhere near them and then that transfers to their kids

i love dogs although i dont own one and from a young age as in only a toddler my daughter has seen me ask to stroke dogs , fuss them and shes wanted to do so herself . my love of animals has rubbed off on her and she knows me well enough to know if a large muddy spaniel came running up to me in a park and proceded to slather all over me id be giving it a good old fuss and babbling away with the owner .

unlike i suspect most of the posters on here who would be madly flapping at it ,shooing it away and then complaining their kids are terrified of dogs 🙄

ballsdeep · 11/05/2022 19:44

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 11/05/2022 13:27

I don't disagree with your sentment OP but

At the weekend, we were out in the meadows and having our family photos taken by a professional photographer.

And the dog owner was using those same meadows equally legally, I would assume!

You were all observant of ground nesting birds, protected plant species, etc, etc.

As it was the dog owner was lacking in observation, but you were also - you did say that there were many off lead dogs, not the best spot for a photograhpy session, the photograher should have known better. Which is always the problem when anyone uses public land for private purposes.

Thos doesnt give the dog owner to let his dog jump all over the ops children though does it? What ridiculous reasoning

hellrabbitishere · 11/05/2022 19:41

its good to see all the nut jobs are out in force on this thread anyway , i find myself pondering the fact that i live in a large open plan city with tons of green spaces and parks , the city is abundent with dogs and they are seen being walked everywhere on redways , in the small towns and villages on outskirts of the city , and in all the parks as well , somehow despite all this i managed to get raise my daugher through toddler hood and the younger years to now and to this day shes never been jumped on , slathered on , had food snatched from her pram by these maraunding off lead dogs , how weird that , and as for the picnic mumsnet lot , do people really sit in a public park on grass with food all spread out for flies and wasps to land on and everybody and his brother walking past or around i didnt know , and as for the beach does the sand not get in all the food ?

its all very odd to me i must say . and if your going to sit having a picnic in a park or on a beach where its likely dogs may be its really common sense to know that dogs are attracted to food , even on a leash one can still pull its owner over to the site you are eating

lovesT · 11/05/2022 19:40

YANBU ... To be honest I'm starting to really dislike dogs and wouldn't mind if I didn't come across one again, but of course that's impossible 🙄 my mum has two and they're her babies and we live in an area where sooo many people have dogs. I hate when we are on the beach (with my 2yo) and a dog comes bouncing over all over our blanket and the owner doesn't give a 💩. Might get a "sorry" like you said but I don't say "oh that's okay" anymore as I'm really fed up of it. Not everyone wants a dog pouncing up to them, especially with their muddy paws and especially with young children! I totally agree with you and sorry that it ruined your photo shoot ☹️. A couple of months ago I was walking from the park with my daughter and was going to be meeting a friend at a café and a dog ran over to us and jumped up at me leaving my jeans all muddy 🙄 again barely an apology from the owner. 😠

Lesserspottedmama · 11/05/2022 19:35

@Grumpybutfunny just because a dog hasn’t threatened to attack does not mean its not a problem. I don’t want dogs urinating on my blanket, bounding up to my children who are just about nose level with it, licking our food. You may find this acceptable, I do not.

Grumpybutfunny · 11/05/2022 19:29

Ours are on the lead not because they would hurt someone (they would roll over for a belly scratch given half a chance) but because I don't trust other people with them! This thread of people chasing dogs with spades, kicks flip flops when the dog hasn't even threatened to attack disgust me.

I think people should teach their kids not to be scared of dogs and certain breeds should be banned to ease parents fears.

Should a dog who needs exercise sometimes miles a day be restricted to a lead in an open woodland so a scared toddler can run free I would say no.

Take the toddler to area that is dog free and leave the areas that are dog friendly to kids who aren't scared. Our DS would have played with the biggest dog on the planet yes sometimes he got knocked over (no more than he tripped himself) the poor dog would go check he was okay and then they were friends again.