Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask dog owners to be extra vigilant around younger children?

318 replies

ponderingthisthing · 11/05/2022 12:17

At the weekend, we were out in the meadows and having our family photos taken by a professional photographer.

A dog came near us and started jumping on the DC, who are 2 and 4. DH tried to fend it off until the owner came and dragged the dog away with some difficulty. By this time both children were extremely scared and upset and were screaming and crying. The owner may have muttered a quiet "sorry" before leaving quickly. No genuine apology or word to check if DC were OK, even though they were obviously extremely disturbed at that point with tears flooding down their faces. She just didn't seem to care.

For us though, it really put a damper on things and unsurprisingly the photography session did not go well. Both children felt unsafe following this (there were other dogs around, many not on lead) and clung to us.

It's not the first time that it's happened, DD was already afraid of dogs due to similar episodes in the past. We try to reassure her that dogs don't normally harm people and that she should just behave normally around them, but I wonder if we should also think more now about safety. Just yesterday, I came across a photo on social media of a little girl who was mauled in the face by a dog. Of course no physical harm came of this episode involving DC, thank goodness, and the dog was probably just over excited. However, the incident is making me feel somewhat uneasy about taking DC to places where dogs can run free.

AIBU to ask that dog owners be extra vigilant with small children around? And obviously, if the dogs are likely to jump up at people, to keep them on lead around small children in public places?

OP posts:
80sMum · 12/05/2022 01:16

FourChimneys · 11/05/2022 13:42

Dogs should be on a lead unless at home or in a designated dog field.

I am in complete agreement with this statement! Off-lead dogs should not be permitted in public places, such as parks, or in private places to which the public has legal access, such as common land, National Trust land and on public footpaths and bridleways.

There is a growing trend towards dog-fields nowadays - designated, safely fenced, large areas where dogs can be free to run around off the lead. I think that such places should be encouraged, maybe even subsidised, to help deter people from taking dogs to nature reserves, commons, parks and the like and letting them roam free off the lead.

XelaM · 12/05/2022 01:11

Good luck with that. Having tried to call the police for a number of actual crimes recently, I can rest assured they will do exactly nothing.

ThatAnnoysMeToo · 12/05/2022 00:55

I'm starting to think we should start calling 999 every time. It is illegal to have an out of control dog, one of the writers is 'makes someone worried that it might injure them'. An untrained dog running up to you, not leaving you alone, not following commands like 'sit' qualifies.

I used to think it was against the law to have a dog off the lead in public unless land owners permission. It wouldn't be a bad idea really....

Or a handful of woods available where dogs are allowed... so actual children can enjoy spending that time in nature in safety.

It might be worth starting a petition. Realistically more people are fed up with wild dog 'pets' racing around the woods than arrogant owners who think their dog is just so friendly....

DysmalRadius · 12/05/2022 00:54

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 11/05/2022 14:53

The dog owners always say don’t worry they are gentle or friendly. This annoys me so much.

Again, I will say something like this, trying not to reinforce any fear. I am not trying to negate any jostling, bouncing, jumping up my dog has done. Just trying to help the child, parents deal with it in a calm manner.

Long ago I stopped saying "Don't worry" though, That seems to be a large proportion of the red rag...

For me the issues with this approach are twofold:

  1. I am not scared of dogs, but I am allergic and the fact I don't want them jumping on me is unrelated to their friendliness or otherwise.
  2. My son is scared of dogs because of numerous encounters with out-of-control pets and I have to deal with the consequences of that. As such, all I really want from anyone that contributes to my itchy hands and laboured breathing and his ongoing nervousness around dogs is to get their dog away from us and apologise for allowing it to approach us. I honestly assume that nobody would be so stupid as to yell 'Careful - he'll probably bite you' so after a few dozen such encounters, it does sound a lot like an excuse, although I do appreciate your intentions. Smile
I do sometimes feel bad, because every dog owner that we encounter gets a little bit of the ire that has been built up slowly over hundreds of similar encounters. Individually, they may feel that I/we have over-reacted, but if they knew how often we are accosted by poorly trained dogs (usually in places where dogs are explicitly not supposed to be or areas that are specifically shared use) they might understand why I am less inclined to be accommodating and tend more towards 'Please just get your dog away from us' these days.
XelaM · 12/05/2022 00:39

Imaginary · 11/05/2022 23:13

I was bitten by a dog on a lead last year. The bloody thing attacked me from behind for no reason at all. The owner just said "sorry" and quickly went away.

Keep your filthy animals away from me and my children.

Dogs are excellent judges of character 😀

stevalnamechanger · 12/05/2022 00:26

girlmom21 · 11/05/2022 13:28

I completely agree no dog should be allowed to approach anybody without their owner first checking it's ok, at the very, very least.

No child should be approaching my on lead dogs and touching it without my consent either ...happens way too much

OP I agree with you , too many idiots have out of control dogs

OnceMoreWithoutFeeling · 11/05/2022 23:40

BetsHilton · 11/05/2022 22:22

Sadly my DD still likes the bloody things, my open and unabashed hatred of them notwithstanding, but knows by now not to approach them and to stand still with her arms down if (well when) they approach her uninvited

wow, well done trying actively to give your daughter a fear of dogs she will have to live with forever due to your odd obsessive complex (err rabbit corpses??). The arms down thing is so weird. If she likes them why can’t she pet them if they’re friendly and the owners are ok with it? How bizarre to force her to keep her arms down. @OnceMoreWithoutFeeling

It's not fear (as in an irrational fear) - it's quite rational disgust. I tell her to stand still and keep her arms down if a strange dog approaches her uninvited because by definition if it is approaching her it is either not under control or owned by an idiot and therefore likely badly trained, and therefore may be dangerous. I'd rather let their owner catch up to them/recall them before she engages with them so I can assess how likely it is to be well behaved based on how the owner behaves.

However I'd really prefer her not to pet strange dogs in any case because they're filthy dirty creatures that sniff each others arses, that do stick their faces into all sorts of disgusting things, and dribble. My MIL's dog's specialty is finding dead rabbits in the ditches of country lanes (she lives rurally) and carrying them around, it's fucking repulsive. But all dogs are dirty. I've seen them eat their own and other dog's shit. Bizarrely I don't want my daughter being licked by a dog, same as I won't want her being licked by a human only x 1000000.

Imaginary · 11/05/2022 23:14

BetsHilton · 11/05/2022 23:13

@Imaginary I have a dog years and am yet to see children freeze with their arms down when they see a dog. I’d be worried something is wrong with the child tbh.

THere's nothing wrong with the child.

Imaginary · 11/05/2022 23:13

I was bitten by a dog on a lead last year. The bloody thing attacked me from behind for no reason at all. The owner just said "sorry" and quickly went away.

Keep your filthy animals away from me and my children.

BetsHilton · 11/05/2022 23:13

@Imaginary I have a dog years and am yet to see children freeze with their arms down when they see a dog. I’d be worried something is wrong with the child tbh.

Imaginary · 11/05/2022 23:11

BetsHilton · 11/05/2022 22:22

Sadly my DD still likes the bloody things, my open and unabashed hatred of them notwithstanding, but knows by now not to approach them and to stand still with her arms down if (well when) they approach her uninvited

wow, well done trying actively to give your daughter a fear of dogs she will have to live with forever due to your odd obsessive complex (err rabbit corpses??). The arms down thing is so weird. If she likes them why can’t she pet them if they’re friendly and the owners are ok with it? How bizarre to force her to keep her arms down. @OnceMoreWithoutFeeling

You think it's bizzare to keep her arms down when near a dog? Then you shouldn't own one. You clearly know nothing about dog behaviour and safety around them.

safclass · 11/05/2022 23:10

We have a large, boisterous, super friendly lab cross pup. However he is loopy meeting people and all his training goes out of the window . When we are out he is on a lead unless I know there is no-one about contained area, or we are at the dog park.
He wouldn't be aggressive but I have great concerns he'd knock over a child /elderly person causing serious damage or creating fear.

Since we got him we've had a few kids stroking him but they have ALWAYS asked first, allowing me to control the situation.

Btw I love him to bits, wouldn't be without him, he is part of our family but he is most certainly NOT our 'fur baby'!
Hate that term

Giraffesandbottoms · 11/05/2022 23:08

@lovesT

sure but if your toddler goes over to a dog it doesn’t know, even on a lead, and pets it without asking, she is also at risk and it’s your fault.

bellebeautifu1 · 11/05/2022 23:07

I dont think there should be a blanket ban on dogs off leads. If I was walking my small dog who called be easily recalled (the first was a jack russel and second a fox terrier) at 7am before work or at 7pm at night on a fairly deserted beach (aside from the only other dog walkers) I would let my dog off the lead, and the odd time if there was a kid I would call it back.

On a Saturday on a sunny day with lots of young families? No way. Even though neither were jumpers, and only like a sniff I understand that some kids are scared / dislike dogs. Its called being considerate, but I think dog owners are entilted to let their dogs off leads if they are out at less busy times on public places.

FlyingPandas · 11/05/2022 22:53

I agree with those who have pointed out that respect is necessary on both sides.

DC should be taught to respect a dog's boundaries without encouraging them to fear dogs.

Equally, dogs should be taught not to jump up. And dogs who have not yet learnt not to jump up - or who prove themselves incapable of learning the lesson, for whatever reason, should never be off the lead in public.

The problem is that many parents don't parent properly and many dog owners do not train their dogs properly.

I like dogs and have owned labs in the past - but ours was trained not to jump and in the 'unpredictable' phase was kept on the lead.

Now, if any dog jumps up at me then I will raise my knee sharply and push it away, not hard enough to hurt but hard enough to make it absolutely bloody plain that I don't like it and I'm not accepting this kind of 'friendliness'. Any owner who allows their dog to jump up at people is a shit dog owner and should be deeply ashamed of themselves.

Googlecanthelpme · 11/05/2022 22:35

Another day another dog thread.

You purposefully went to an area where dogs will be off their leads then don’t like it when dogs are off their leads.

i agree dogs jumping up kids can be quite scary for them and in an ideal world dogs wouldn’t jump up anyone unless invited but they do because that’s what they do when excited and kids are exciting to dogs. It’s a fact that dogs are part of life in our society. It is part of our society and culture to let them off leads in fields and parks where we are permitted to. Not everyone likes it but not everyone likes everything, I hate bikes and would happily ban cyclists but I can’t because I understand it’s just part of our culture and cyclists are permitted to cycle where the law allows it.

Rather than keeping your children away from dogs you’d be better to find a friend or relative with a dog who is used to small children and let them be slowly introduced so that your kids can get used to them, because dogs aren’t going anywhere and being scared of them is detrimental.

BetsHilton · 11/05/2022 22:35

XelaM · 11/05/2022 22:34

No wonder so many kids suffer with anxiety and general mental health issues when their parents teach them to be terrified of everything

Agreed! Some shocking posts here of parents actively trying to give their kids a problem.

XelaM · 11/05/2022 22:34

No wonder so many kids suffer with anxiety and general mental health issues when their parents teach them to be terrified of everything

ginghamstarfish · 11/05/2022 22:28

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Waitingforbabyno1toarrive · 11/05/2022 22:23

We actually have the opposite problem 🙈 I can't tell you how many parents have let their very young children (under 3) approach us from behind, a few times to the point the child had grabbed my dogs back leg or tail. The parents have been 20ft plus away. Sometimes my dog will be on the lead when this happens, sometimes off, but I really can't understand what goes through the parents minds. Luckily my dog adores young children, so on each occasion when she has heard them/felt them grab her, she's turned around and licked them rather than growling, but she happens to be nervous of children aged 8ish-early teens and would be more likely to bark if they did it.

People in general just need to respect others, keep your dogs away from strangers, keep your kids (or your own dog) away from strange dogs, unless mutually agreed to let them say hello.

BetsHilton · 11/05/2022 22:22

Sadly my DD still likes the bloody things, my open and unabashed hatred of them notwithstanding, but knows by now not to approach them and to stand still with her arms down if (well when) they approach her uninvited

wow, well done trying actively to give your daughter a fear of dogs she will have to live with forever due to your odd obsessive complex (err rabbit corpses??). The arms down thing is so weird. If she likes them why can’t she pet them if they’re friendly and the owners are ok with it? How bizarre to force her to keep her arms down. @OnceMoreWithoutFeeling

Wineat5isfine · 11/05/2022 22:17

Dog owner of 2 x big crossbreeds. Both ridiculously soft and friendly. Both trusted by us 99%, because there is always 1% of us that knows they are still animals at the end of the day.

Always kept on the lead even though recall is excellent. Kept on leads when friends / children come round. Kept in separate rooms during play dates with our children etc.

What is equally important is to ensure that children are told to NEVER approach a dog without asking it’s owner.

One of my eldest sons friends (11!) despite being told so many times, climbed on my eldest dogs back a few weeks ago. Nothing happened…the dog just laid down and rolled over wagging his tail, but this was completely unacceptable in my eyes. Had a word with his mum, she said “no harm done!” Ffs. It’s not the point!

Responsibility and respect is always needed on all sides.

lovesT · 11/05/2022 21:32

@Libertaire I'm sorry but it's not the same, especially when it comes to toddlers. When a massive dog comes running up to my toddler (who likes dogs but is too young to know they COULD hurt her) my toddler is more at risk than the dog. She can't run as fast so she is no danger to the dog and to be specific about my daughter she is good with dogs and asks to stroke them and is used to my mum's dogs but a dog could cause so much more harm to a young child than to your dog. Yes maybe older children need to learn to be gentle ect but still.

Flaminggflames · 11/05/2022 21:29

this absolutely does my head in. Some dog owners have no idea of the effect of a jumpy dog that has no boundaries on young children. It’s bonkers and so entitled

BorisJohnsonatemyhampster · 11/05/2022 21:27

These dog threads are boring now. I used to laugh at the frenzy people would whip themselves into because a dog looked at them or their kids funny. It was quite entertaining but it’s froth by numbers now. Same responses from the same posters.