Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is not my fault. Kids savings accounts etc.

62 replies

User63638264829432 · 11/05/2022 11:16

I am oldest or 5. Dm had me and db when she was really young and neither of us had our dads around. My mum was a skint single mum and obviously couldn't afford to save much. My grandparents were in their very early 50's at the time, in full time work and they opened savings accounts for us knowing my mother couldn't afford it. When me and DB reached 18 we had maybe 2 grand each. But we didn't get it all in one hit. I was grateful, my grandparents didn't have to do this at all and I appreciated it so much. It helped out with a few things and furniture when I rented my first place at 18.

anyway, my mum re married and had 3 more kids in her thirties. Much more stable position with a husband. Me and db were teens + by this point and my grandparents were pretty much retiring age and I believe they said that they couldn't afford to save as much for the younger 3, so apparently they always said that they wouldn't get quite as much but would get something, never nothing. My grandparents also helped out with other things too for my mum, stepdad and my younger siblings. Paying for days out, computers, holidays, school trips etc as my mum/stepdad were and still are terrible with money. My younger siblings never went without, in fact probably had more opportunities than me and db did.

so it's come to the time my younger siblings will have access to their savings account. My mum is furious they've got less than me and db did as it's not fair according to her. This doesn't sound like me problem until my dm has directed her annoyance at me - like it's my bloody fault!! This is not my fault. My grandpa sadly died not too long ago and isn't here to talk about it. He wound have never of intentionally hurt anyone. He was a very generous man.

there's a few factors here

  1. my grandparents age meant they had less money by the time siblings were born. They couldn't afford to save so much.
  2. They helped them out financially otherwise paying for other things. They bought siblings a computer each at one point amongst lots of other things. So rather than putting money into a savings account they had a computer each etc.
  3. she was a single mum to me and db when we were but my siblings have a dad. A dad who actually owned a house but sold it to move in with my mum into her rented house.after the mortgage was paid he was left with £100,000. My stepdad could have put some away for his kids but did not and they just spent it all on crap - my mum included so not putting the blame fully on stepdad. They just had holidays with the money to be honest. My grandpa probably assumed that their dad would have put some of his house sale money away for them. Me and db did not have a dad to provide for us, my grandparents felt like they were looking after us I think.
aibu to think this not my fault? A few times dm had directed her anger at me saying well you had more money!! Like it's my fault. I've never told my younger siblings I got more or anything daft like that, would have no reason too. I wouldn't have known how much they got if she hadn't of told me. It had never really crossed my mind til she mentioned it.

On another note, my grandma - who hopefully has many more years left in her yet has shown me her will and the house sale will be split totally equal. It's just the savings accounts that were not exactly the same due to varying amounts of money over the years! My siblings still have some money from them just not quite as much as me and db did. My grandpa was working throughout my childhood until I was about 17. Maybe he didn't anticipate that my mum was going to re marry and have more kids when he was retiring.

there are no other grandchildren. My mums brother does not have children.

OP posts:
user1471538283 · 11/05/2022 12:23

We all had small savings accounts from my DGPs and it was so lovely knowing they thought of us each week. All the DGGC had some too. My DS had more because my DF paid into it too.

None of this is your fault. Your DM would have known the other 3 would get less so she could have stopped it up.

KnitPurlKnitPurl · 11/05/2022 12:16

Of course it's not your fault.

Your mum clearly feels very guilty that she did not provide for your younger sblings in the way your grandparents provided for you and your brother.

PeppoPigg · 11/05/2022 12:02

User63638264829432 · 11/05/2022 11:46

She is just good at making me feel bad 😪 she's brought it up a few times! She's very similar in a lot of other ways too!

Tell her to stop going on about it? It's odd she's talking so much about her finances with you.

Georgeskitchen · 11/05/2022 11:54

What does your DM expect you to do about this?

User63638264829432 · 11/05/2022 11:46

She is just good at making me feel bad 😪 she's brought it up a few times! She's very similar in a lot of other ways too!

OP posts:
flipperdoda · 11/05/2022 11:45

Your mum is being ridiculous. My grandparents opened savings accounts for us - except I only found this out when mum had to tell me at about 16 that the others had one but my grandparents had forgotten/never got round to doing one for me 😂of course there was a bit of jealousy because I was 16 but it was never mega money (just seemed it at that age!) and it passed within about two days. I had plenty growing up and I was very aware of it. These things just happen. None of it is down to you!

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 11/05/2022 11:39

Your Mum is being ridiculous, as PPs have said.

Your grandparents were kind to give anyone anything. Sounds like your younger siblings have had more advantages overall as well.

PleasantBirthday · 11/05/2022 11:36

How could it be your fault? It was your grandparent's decision, you could hardly force them to open you an account as an infant and I'm pretty sure if you'd told them not to put as much away for the others (and they did that on your say-so for some reason that I can't imagine), you'd have mentioned it.

Whisp3r · 11/05/2022 11:30

Your mother is ungrateful. She should say thanks to her parents for saving money for her children particularly as it sounds as though she could have saved money for them herself and didn't.

Also, your siblings have a father and that father has money. It isn't equal. It isn't 'fair' . And the advantages are all theirs, not yours. It doesn't matter if your grandparents did put a bit more money in your savings account. It does not level the playing field. It was lovely of them to try. I'd be telling my mother to clear off if she was acting like that with me.

MinnieGirl · 11/05/2022 11:21

Your mum is being very greedy. She should be lucky her parents gave any of you a penny. I would point out that your younger siblings had a father who could have saved for his children but didn’t. And that your grandparents gave them things you didn’t have like computers so that evens up the balance.
She really is being very unreasonable. Especially when her husband spent his house sale money… can’t do that and expect others to provide for your kids!

PeppoPigg · 11/05/2022 11:20

She is being absolutely ridiculous. My siblings and I all had savings accounts with the same amount put in at one point but due to age differences we all got differing amounts once we were able to access them. No ones fault. Just a nice thing the grandparents did. As you said, they could have saved for their other children. Your mum is being well out of order to even drag you into this.

GiltEdges · 11/05/2022 11:20

What's your AIBU OP?

Ultimately, none of the context is really relevant here. Your grandparents tried to do a nice thing. Whether it was exactly equal or not is really neither here nor there. Nor is it your problem. So when your mum tries to discuss it with you, I'd tell her exactly that. I'd also tell her she's incredibly ungrateful and money grabbing, but that's just me.

Swipe left for the next trending thread