Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is not my fault. Kids savings accounts etc.

62 replies

User63638264829432 · 11/05/2022 11:16

I am oldest or 5. Dm had me and db when she was really young and neither of us had our dads around. My mum was a skint single mum and obviously couldn't afford to save much. My grandparents were in their very early 50's at the time, in full time work and they opened savings accounts for us knowing my mother couldn't afford it. When me and DB reached 18 we had maybe 2 grand each. But we didn't get it all in one hit. I was grateful, my grandparents didn't have to do this at all and I appreciated it so much. It helped out with a few things and furniture when I rented my first place at 18.

anyway, my mum re married and had 3 more kids in her thirties. Much more stable position with a husband. Me and db were teens + by this point and my grandparents were pretty much retiring age and I believe they said that they couldn't afford to save as much for the younger 3, so apparently they always said that they wouldn't get quite as much but would get something, never nothing. My grandparents also helped out with other things too for my mum, stepdad and my younger siblings. Paying for days out, computers, holidays, school trips etc as my mum/stepdad were and still are terrible with money. My younger siblings never went without, in fact probably had more opportunities than me and db did.

so it's come to the time my younger siblings will have access to their savings account. My mum is furious they've got less than me and db did as it's not fair according to her. This doesn't sound like me problem until my dm has directed her annoyance at me - like it's my bloody fault!! This is not my fault. My grandpa sadly died not too long ago and isn't here to talk about it. He wound have never of intentionally hurt anyone. He was a very generous man.

there's a few factors here

  1. my grandparents age meant they had less money by the time siblings were born. They couldn't afford to save so much.
  2. They helped them out financially otherwise paying for other things. They bought siblings a computer each at one point amongst lots of other things. So rather than putting money into a savings account they had a computer each etc.
  3. she was a single mum to me and db when we were but my siblings have a dad. A dad who actually owned a house but sold it to move in with my mum into her rented house.after the mortgage was paid he was left with £100,000. My stepdad could have put some away for his kids but did not and they just spent it all on crap - my mum included so not putting the blame fully on stepdad. They just had holidays with the money to be honest. My grandpa probably assumed that their dad would have put some of his house sale money away for them. Me and db did not have a dad to provide for us, my grandparents felt like they were looking after us I think.
aibu to think this not my fault? A few times dm had directed her anger at me saying well you had more money!! Like it's my fault. I've never told my younger siblings I got more or anything daft like that, would have no reason too. I wouldn't have known how much they got if she hadn't of told me. It had never really crossed my mind til she mentioned it.

On another note, my grandma - who hopefully has many more years left in her yet has shown me her will and the house sale will be split totally equal. It's just the savings accounts that were not exactly the same due to varying amounts of money over the years! My siblings still have some money from them just not quite as much as me and db did. My grandpa was working throughout my childhood until I was about 17. Maybe he didn't anticipate that my mum was going to re marry and have more kids when he was retiring.

there are no other grandchildren. My mums brother does not have children.

OP posts:
fUNNYfACE36 · 11/05/2022 13:21

Life is not fair, and certainly not equal

LemonSwan · 11/05/2022 13:15

2k is fuck all in the grand scheme of life.

That might sound flippant, as that amount of money could make a big difference to a single mum or someone with dependents, bills or debt really struggling in later life.

To a 16/17/18yo with no responsibilities - wouldn’t last a year. Likely to piss it up the wall on a few nights out, a couple pairs of trainers and a new iPhone.

Drinkingallthewine · 11/05/2022 13:13

She's one of those ones for whom everything is always someone else's fault or responsibility.

So it became your GP's responsibility when she chose shit head men to have her first two kids with and ended up raising them with no dad in sight. It became someone elses' fault when your stepfather pissed away the proceeds of a house sale and they are left with fuck all. Only due to your GPs careful planning and kindness did you get anything at all starting out adult life.

Now her three kids are wondering where their savings pot might be and why there isn't one (when clearly there was plenty of cash at one point to set up even a modest one and she's deflecting again - this time onto you.

Stand your ground here.

JennyAct3 · 11/05/2022 13:09

Not your fault, you’ve done nothing wrong. Your Grandparents sound lovely, you sound lovely, your mum sounds mean.

I think you should distance yourself from your mum and concentrate on building your life with supportive people around you. Some of us are lucky and have great parents and some of us have horrible parents.

Sceptre86 · 11/05/2022 13:06

Your mum is being grabby and selfish but probably has always been like this. Single mum or not it was never up to your grandparents to save for you though I can understand why they did and it was a lovely thing to do. There should never have been an expectation on them to help put buy computers or any of the other things they did, lovely of them of course but unnecessary. Your mum unfortunately has gotten used to having a helping hand and is entitled. That won't change.

I'd change the subject each time she raises it and if she keeps on at you say she is being rude. Is she actually pleasant to you because her just being your mum isn't a good enough reason (in my eyes) to have her in your life.

Discovereads · 11/05/2022 13:05

User63638264829432 · 11/05/2022 11:46

She is just good at making me feel bad 😪 she's brought it up a few times! She's very similar in a lot of other ways too!

Your mother is being ridiculous and I think she is directing this anger and spite at you because she is trying to make you feel bad enough to then give money to your half siblings. Just wait and see. She will suggest that you “owe them something because you got more and that’s not fair”

Dont even entertain it. She is gearing up to manipulate you.

Manekinek0 · 11/05/2022 13:05

Your mother is being unfair. She should be grateful that her parents have helped so much and put money aside for her children. It may not be an equal amount but your childhoods don't sound equal at all.

£2k isn't a life changing amount of money, it works out at under £10 a month over 18 years. She could have spoken to your grandparents and contributed the shortfall.

Kennykenkencat · 11/05/2022 13:03

Until your mother can tell you why this is your fault. Then I would disengage.

Ultimately her and her Dh had opportunity to save for the 3 younger ones as well as you and your older brother but didn’t despite having opportunity to do so.

That is up to her and her Dh

I can’t get over this guy selling his bought and paid for house and not buying another. Not even renting it out.

The only reason why this is even a problem is because your mother and your younger siblings father were idiots with money and thought nothing of theirs or their childrens future.

CannaeRemember · 11/05/2022 13:01

Neverreturntoathread · 11/05/2022 12:55

Yanbu. Sorry your mum’s a bitch. My guess is she’s angling for your gran’s will to be changed and trying tonlay groundwork for that, but hopefully I’m wrong.

£2k is an exciting amount to get as a teen but it’s nothing compared to having the financial support of a father / the house sale money etc. Your mum needs to focus on how she supports her children and stop bitching at you.

This is very true. £2k compared to having a father is nothing. I'm sorry your mum is being so horrible to you. Do you feel able to tell her to stop going on about it and that it's not your problem?

Sapphirensteel · 11/05/2022 13:01

What you seem to be able to understand, and your mother doesn’t, is that
Your grandparents gave you, your dc and half siblings what they planned and saved for.
Theres a difference to what dgp could put aside when working and when retired.
Your dgps explained this to your mother.
No one is ENTITLED to money from dgp.

You are obviously more mature and sensible than your mother.

Dixiechickonhols · 11/05/2022 12:59

Your mum sounds awful. It was a lovely thing your grandparents did and entirely their decision. If she brings it up again I’d say it was grandma and grandads decision I’m not discussing further. I wouldn’t entertain any talk of you giving money to half siblings or will being altered.
I wonder if she also thinks it was a lot more than £2000.

LookItsMeAgain · 11/05/2022 12:58

DockOTheBay · 11/05/2022 12:26

I'm guessing she wants you to offer to top up your siblings savings to match what you got. Which is ridiculous, obviously.

Maybe she could ask your grandma to change her will, so that you and your DB get £2000 less each from the sale of herhouse so it will eventually be "fair".

I wouldn't even do that.

The OP's mother sounds really materialistic. It's not the grandparents role to provide for the grandchild, it's the parents role.

The way I see it is that your grandparents made up the difference between what you were getting from your parents at the time. Your parents weren't able to provide this for you and your brother. Now, your mother and/or father, when they were in a better position to provide for your younger siblings, should have started small savings accounts for them. You see they weren't able to provide the savings for you and your brother in the same way. It should be those savings that make the difference between what your grandparents put away for the younger siblings.

I would, however, shut down the conversation if your mother brings it up again by saying something on the lines of the above and then finish by saying "now that I've said my piece, I really don't want to hear any more moaning or complaining about how granny and grandad treated me and John differently to Mary, Elizabeth and Mark. That's enough on the subject and if you mention it again, I'll either not respond or I'll have to leave" (fake names used in the previous sentence)

Go broken record "Mum, I've given you prior warning about what I'll do if you mention the savings that granny put away for me and John. Now, will I put the kettle on for a nice cup of tea?". Change the subject. Don't engage.

Neverreturntoathread · 11/05/2022 12:55

Yanbu. Sorry your mum’s a bitch. My guess is she’s angling for your gran’s will to be changed and trying tonlay groundwork for that, but hopefully I’m wrong.

£2k is an exciting amount to get as a teen but it’s nothing compared to having the financial support of a father / the house sale money etc. Your mum needs to focus on how she supports her children and stop bitching at you.

RealBecca · 11/05/2022 12:55

I'd shut that shit down straight away. Given your mum I'd probably say well it's all spent now anyway so all in the past. Dont get drawn in. Shes shit with money and looking for someone to blame or get a handout from.

Bootothegoose · 11/05/2022 12:52

whumpthereitis · 11/05/2022 12:51

i imagine she’s mentioning it to you because she thinks it’s now your responsibility to equalize it.

It’s not, so don’t.

Also this.

Hugasauras · 11/05/2022 12:51

Seems like a lot of stress and nonsense over a relatively small amount of money. It's £2000, nice to have but not a life-changing amount at all, so incredibly petty to quibble over what must amount to a difference of a few hundred quid. If she was that bothered about it then she should have saved for them.

Bootothegoose · 11/05/2022 12:51

Whilst very kind of your grandparents £2000 is not a life changing amount of money. In fact it is far outweighed by the benefit of childcare, token gifts, days out etc.

I suspect your mum hides behind the belief you and your brother had more financial opportunities ‘because of your grandparents’ as opposed to recognising the benefits your siblings have done. Regardless this is nothing to do with you and her resentment/anger is most likely a projection of her guilt/jealousy.

Be honest and say you really don’t understand how this is your fault, nor responsibility. Also point out the benefits your siblings have had. If she continues to bring it up say you really don’t want to talk about it any more.

it’s not your fault at all. Ignore her.

whumpthereitis · 11/05/2022 12:51

i imagine she’s mentioning it to you because she thinks it’s now your responsibility to equalize it.

It’s not, so don’t.

ElegantlyTouched · 11/05/2022 12:47

I wonder if your mother told your siblings they'd get the same as you (whilst conveniently ignoring what she'd been told) and they're now moaning at her, so she's passing the buck on to you? If so pass it back and tell her you won't be engaging with her on the matter again.

Out of interest does your DB get the same grief from her?

Fairness about money in families can get ugly. My mum got stressed she wouldn't be able to give me the same opportunities as my sister had had when I was a child after our father died, so my uncle opened a savings account for me to make sure I wouldn't lose out. He gave me the money when I went to university. My sister was fuming and tried to demand I returned it, because she'd not had the same. The fact that, due to the age gap, she'd had ten years more with our father than I had, plus the same uncle had contributed greatly to her wedding, was immaterial. All she could see was the unfairness.

Walk away from any conversations about the money and don't feel guilty in the slightest.

Ferngreen · 11/05/2022 12:42

She is being ridiculous. Just ignore her. She is a spendthrift and wont' benefitt from more money.
Very selfish of her. She is her mother's daughter so I'm afraid she needs to speak to her mother (even if you don't liek the idea) if she isn't happy, not you.

ChocolatRaisins · 11/05/2022 12:33

It's 2K, not 20K or 200K. It is not a vast amount of money.

In fact, I bet if you totted up all the babysitting, days out etc. etc. that your GP's have done for your mum and younger siblings, it is way more than 4K.

Your mum would be better fixed looking into her own parental failings, including having to be funded by her parents as an adult, rather than blaming you.

sjxoxo · 11/05/2022 12:32

Inheritance doesn’t have to be equal…
i expect your grandparents did this because they thought your mum would struggle. I doubt they thought she’d go on to have more kids.

not your problem and your mum is being unreasonable.. especially as we are talking about a couple of grand!! X

NotAScoobyToBeSeen · 11/05/2022 12:28

Totally not your fault at all and ridiculous that your mum is blaming you or db in any way! How were you to know what would happen in the future?!

DockOTheBay · 11/05/2022 12:26

I'm guessing she wants you to offer to top up your siblings savings to match what you got. Which is ridiculous, obviously.

Maybe she could ask your grandma to change her will, so that you and your DB get £2000 less each from the sale of herhouse so it will eventually be "fair".

TokyoSushi · 11/05/2022 12:24

Of course it's not your fault, and if you and your DB only received about £2K at the end of it, we're not really talking about life changing sums of money.

Your DM sounds rude and grabby tbh.

Swipe left for the next trending thread