Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU that her ashes can be divided?

80 replies

Flowerseverywhere · 10/05/2022 22:01

My sister has recently died after a long illness. She was 52 and had no husband or kids of her own. It was incredibly sad of course but it wasn’t a shock and so her remaining family had time to come to terms with it before she died. Her remaining family are principally me and our brother (and our families). My sister was the eldest then it’s me in the middle (48) and our brother is 46.
Our sister stated in her will that she wanted to be cremated but did not provide any details about where she wanted her ashes scattered. The Norfolk coast always meant a lot to her, she spent lots of idyllic holidays there, childhood and otherwise and so I think she should be scattered there. Our brother thinks that she should be scattered under a tree in the woods near our childhood home where our parents ashes are also scattered. We are in conflict about this and my solution, which I see as pragmatic, is that half of the ashes are scattered under the tree and the other half in Norfolk. My bother thinks that is not acceptable and that she should be scattered in her entirety, as it were. I see my solution as a practical compromise whereas he thinks I’m heartless and cruel. So AIBU to suggest we divide up my sister’s ashes?

OP posts:
AuntieMorag · 10/05/2022 22:07

We split up the ashes for my father in law and my father. Different bits went to different places they loved, with different people who loved them. Each place meant different things to different people, and they all get their own place as a memorial with their memories.

leeds2glasgow · 10/05/2022 22:07

Third of my grandad is in New Zealand, third under a tree in my aunts garden and a third in a sandwich bag in a biscuit tin in my mums wardrobe 🤷‍♀️

DoloresOnTheDottedLine · 10/05/2022 22:06

I’m very sorry for your loss. I’m with you - both places have significance and sound appropriate so no one is wrong here. Just divide her ashes and scatter in two places. If your brother feels particularly strongly that her ashes should be kept “together” (which is a bit illogical given what happens when you literally “scatter”), then I think he should be the one to compromise on location. Hope you can resolve without falling out - tough all round.

redskyatnight · 10/05/2022 22:05

Neither of you are wrong - you both feel what you feel.

Maybe you should postpone scattering the ashes for now, until the grief is not so raw, and you can come to an amiable agreement?

Keepingthingsinteresting · 10/05/2022 22:03

I don’t think so OP, but then I suspect his reaction is not rational. Sorry for your loss

Swipe left for the next trending thread