Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not tell parents when i’m in labour?

157 replies

Grapes89 · 10/05/2022 21:25

We have told our parents we won’t be telling anybody when I’m in labour/go in to hospital and they seem upset - didn’t say much but went very quiet. I explained my reasoning of just wanting to focus on giving birth and not updating people. What if it takes days and they’re constantly messaging and my Mum is a massive worrier and I’m not going be in a position to deal with that!

We’d tell both sets of parents first. I said that we’d be in contact the morning/
afternoon/evening baby arrives to let them know and they can come round after we’re home (probably the next day). I’d love to say a few days with no visitors as just can’t imagine trying to establish breast feeding with an audience but feel too guilty to ask them to wait that long!

The only person we intend to tell is the person who’s agreed to look after our pets.

OP posts:
RocketsMagnificent7 · 11/05/2022 08:49

Pinklemonade1 · 11/05/2022 08:19

Your choice but I'd be v upset if my daughter's didn't tell me. I guess it boils down to the relationship you have with your mother. If you're close then she is understandably going to feel hurt.

Genuinely, why?

I'd be more upset if I thought my daughter felt under pressure to keep me updated and wasn't able to labour in the way she wanted, even if that meant I'm not told until baby is here. My feelings really don't come into it.

It's not about how close the relationship is, it's individual personalities and dynamics. I'm very close to my mum but she is a worrier, who flaps and fusses. Telling her would have caused immense stress as she'd be unable to help herself in needing regular updates. We just told her when the baby arrived and trust me, it hasn't impacted her relationship with them at all. They are all extremely close and she's adored by all of her grandchildren, none of whom she was told their mum was in labour.

Calphurnia88 · 11/05/2022 08:49

As others have said, your labour your choice, but I can empathise with your parents reaction to being told you wouldn't be telling them when you go into hospital.

If it helps, I informed my parents before the birth that DP would be in charge of updates via his WhatsApp once I'm in hospital, and managed expectations that since he'll be busy supporting me, as well as updating his own family, he won't be able to engage in back and forth, and replies might be delayed. They were all fine with this.

We also managed to have very few visitors for the first couple of weeks and I really appreciated this time to recover, establish BF and try to work out WTH we were doing! We set out our stall quite early on this, and didn't face any issues, but if we had have down I would have been polite but firm.

stuntbubbles · 11/05/2022 08:39

Pinklemonade1 · 11/05/2022 08:19

Your choice but I'd be v upset if my daughter's didn't tell me. I guess it boils down to the relationship you have with your mother. If you're close then she is understandably going to feel hurt.

Or you can be close to your mother and she can not feel hurt at all. Not all people are the same. My mother would have cared if I hadn’t told her I’d given birth; she couldn’t have given a hoot about when and where I went into labour. And we were extremely close. People have different values and needs.

CurbsideProphet · 11/05/2022 08:35

@Pinklemonade1 can I ask why you would be upset to not have regular calls during labour to give you up dates? Wouldn't you just be happy get a call to say your grandchild has been born and everyone is safe and well, without spending possibly days and days sending endless texts wanting updates?

Youseethethingis1 · 11/05/2022 08:33

Better Granny is upset than the labouring mother.

Pinklemonade1 · 11/05/2022 08:19

Your choice but I'd be v upset if my daughter's didn't tell me. I guess it boils down to the relationship you have with your mother. If you're close then she is understandably going to feel hurt.

Rosebel · 11/05/2022 08:16

I didn't tell anyone when I was in labour with DD1 on DS. The only person I told with DD2 was my SIL as she was looking after DD1.
One of my friends didn't tell anyone until she'd been home for 3 days as she didn't want calls /texts/visitors until she was ready. It's totally up to you what you do.

RufustheFloralmissingreindeer · 11/05/2022 08:07

I assume this whole devastation of not knowing whether your daughter is in labour has only started since the advent of mobile phones and social media and being able to be in constant contact

actually i was just thinking that

ds1 is 23 and obviously back then mobile phones weren’t quite as common

CurbsideProphet · 11/05/2022 07:47

Keeping family.updated during labour (yep still in labour, no baby not born yet) is all well and good if you're in a hospital with good mobile signal. Some hospitals have such poor signal inside the maternity unit you need to go out into the car park. I won't be sending DH on 15 mins round trips to make calls when I need him to be with me.

All the replies just show how different family relationships are. Some are "devastated" that they wouldn't know their daughter was in labour and be kept up to date with every contraction / cm of dilation. Others think it's over dramatic to keep it a secret and it means that family will never be close again. While others think it's for every woman to decide for herself, based on what would be most helpful and least stressful. Also, if you don't see or phone your mum every day (like me) she really won't notice if you're not active on WhatsApp for a few hours, so that's a really silly argument.

Youseethethingis1 · 11/05/2022 07:43

Because they said they want to know and keep calling for updates @girafffesandbottoms

Oh look at that @girafffesandbottoms , you've already been personally assured by OP that there was no "announcement". The question was asked and answered.

It's not your place or mine to presume anything about how close OP is to her parents or how she should therefore feel about them wanting to be informed of the onset of labour.

3luckystars · 11/05/2022 07:35

I suppose like all babies being different, all grannies are different. Some are lovely and supportive, and some are the complete opposite and make situations really stressful.

giving birth is one time where you need to put yourself first to concentrate on the job.

itssquidstella · 11/05/2022 07:22

We're not telling anyone when I go into labour. We'll update people (parents first) once he's here safely. Neither DH nor I want to be sending updates and responding to messages asking if the.M baby has arrived when we need to be focused on getting him out!

toomuchlaundry · 11/05/2022 07:18

@girafffesandbottoms I have a very close relationship with my parents but they didn’t know I was in labour as it all happened in the early hours in the morning, so no radio silence as I don’t normally call them at 3am.

I assume this whole devastation of not knowing whether your daughter is in labour has only started since the advent of mobile phones and social media and being able to be in constant contact.

Oysterbabe · 11/05/2022 07:15

It's up to you but I'd feel a bit sad if it was my daughter. My husband kept our parents updated during labour and it didn't have any effect on me at all, I wasn't even aware of it.

mycatallowsmetolivehere · 11/05/2022 07:15

Unfortunately all your mother heard from this message was

" when your beloved grandchild is finally coming .. I'm not telling you till it suits me and you are not coming round till I say you can "

I get why you wanted privacy and time but I think you should have just kept quiet and then called or face timed and said look what I've been doing for the last 10 hrs or whatever !

vdbfamily · 11/05/2022 07:10

Personally I don't think it takes too much effort to send quick message when en route to hospital with a promise you will update as soon as there is news. I left all this with DH as I was in no state.
I would however insist there was no phoning for updates, with the assurance that as soon as there was news, they would be told.

girafffesandbottoms · 11/05/2022 07:09

@Youseethethingis1

if you have a close enough relationship with your family to announce to them you won’t be calling them then presumably you are close enough to just let them know. As a PP said they will know anyway due to radio silence.

Howaboutnope · 11/05/2022 07:06

Feckingfeck · 10/05/2022 21:36

This.

Its also a bit precious to need to break the news that you wont tell them.

You wont be the first or last person to give birth so this is all a bit PFB really ....

This.

Squeekybummum · 11/05/2022 07:06

I didn't tell anyone when I started labouring. Only because my 1st took 2 days before actually going into hospital. I just text in family group saying going into hospital now. Be in touch...... And just left my phone if people text and asked how we were. My mil was the worst. Constant texts, asking any signs yet every bloody day.

Youseethethingis1 · 11/05/2022 07:05

A birth is actually very much NOT naturally a medical procedure
Nothing is "naturally" a medical procedure are we used to just die of stuff going wrong, particularly during childbirth.
All the emotional blackmail on this thread is disgusting.
"Oh if you don't tell your mum when your foof starts to twinge, she might not love her grandchild, do you really want that? Do you???"
Give me a fucking break.
Birth is one event in a woman's life when she can put herself, her feelings, her needs top of the pile. God knows the average woman spends most of the rest of the time pushing herself down the pile, especially once she is a mother.

girafffesandbottoms · 11/05/2022 06:56

A birth is most of all a private medical procedure and IMO no woman should feel compelled to share any information about it with others not actively involved in it

no, it’s not. A birth is actually very much NOT naturally a medical procedure. It is private, although in most natural states as humans other females of the tribe etc would be around to support and help. I understand why birth has become medicalised but pretending it’s a medical procedure is incorrect.

everyone who thinks it’s fine to tell parents only when they need childcare is pretty horrible IMO. Talking about using someone.

the PP whose birth was “ruined” by the phone ringing should have just put it on silent - it’s not hard

Luckystar1 · 11/05/2022 06:28

We lived abroad for DC1 & 2 so thankfully didn’t have to tell anyone who was family. Our neighbour looked after DC1 while I was in labour and we didn’t hear a peep.

DC3 was born in my home country and my parents looked after the older children. They had us absolutely tormented for info and ended up telling the older DC when the baby was born and what it was (which we had expressly told them we wanted to do), so I think you are doing the right thing!

LaBellina · 11/05/2022 06:13

A birth is most of all a private medical procedure and IMO no woman should feel compelled to share any information about it with others not actively involved in it, if that makes her uncomfortable. Nobody is entitled to know when you’re going into labour OP, I certainly didn’t tell my mother or my MIL, just like I refused to answer questions afterwards that made me uncomfortable (MIL asking ‘how many stitches)

Hyvsvaar · 11/05/2022 05:22

I think because there is an element of risk with childbirth they will want to know that you are okay too.

stuntbubbles · 11/05/2022 05:00

Lol at it being “precious” not to announce you’re in labour. It’s not a fanny free-for-all, women are allowed some privacy and to focus on themselves. Even if it leaves a bunch of very dramatic grandparents “devastated”.

FWIW OP my DP let my dad know I was in labour and he was annoyed at being woken up Grin