Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that if you are ill (self certified) & main decision maker for a department you should respond to emails wherever possible?

110 replies

strivingtosucceed · 10/05/2022 17:33

Genuinely have no idea where the opinion of this will sway but i'll give a bit of context.

We have a project about to go live in 3 weeks, I own this project. A particular sub-department is in charge of one part of the project and is headed by a woman who also happens to be the only person in that sub-department. Unfortunately, she fell ill and seems to have not told anyone that she had remained ill past the original day she called in sick. It's now been a week since the original day of illness and neither me nor my boss (who she reports to) has an idea of whether it's something long term(eg broken bone/mental health) or something more short term like the flu.

Unfortunately the part of the project her sub-department is on the critical path, this means there are strict timelines that need to be adhered to and quality sign offs that need to happen before we can move to the next step. I want to email her to ask 1) when she'll be back & 2) who I can delegate her work to in the meantime so we stay on track. However, I've been told by some other colleagues that i'd be badgering them if I did so.

So AIBU to expect an answer from my colleague if she feels better for 5/10 minutes during the day or should I expect radio silence until they're fully back and well.

OP posts:
lugeforlife · 10/05/2022 20:57

Generally speaking I don't expect to be contacted when sick and don't do it to my team.

However we all have work phones so I do sort of expect them to at least put an ooo on with an alternative contact unless they are seriously ill, ie more than flu. Plus you have to contact your line manager - if you have like chicken pox and know you'll need the week then you communicate that asap so your work can be covered.

It is bad though - we do expect our bosses to check emails once or twice a day which isn't fair really.

gothereagain · 10/05/2022 20:41

Jaxhog · 10/05/2022 19:24

Unless I was in a coma, I would expect to try and hand over to someone else. Or inform my boss, that I can't. I would NOT be allowed to be home sick without my boss having some idea of what was wrong and how long I might be sick. But then I work in the private sector.

It IS up to your boss to deal with this, not you. That's his/her job.

This is the same in every public sector job I've had as well- I've had to report in by 9am each day I'm sick explain why and how long I expect it to go on for. Or get a sick note with a review date on and send it to my boss, then follow up on the review date. Barring severe hospitalisation/ emergency situation this stands.

alltheteeshirts · 10/05/2022 20:38

Totally unreasonable to expect her to check. And unreasonable of your boss to make you the person who crosses the line and harasses an ill person.

I'm private sector. If one of my team is sick, I expect them to get in touch with me on day one (or another colleague if I'm unavailable) indicating what's wrong with them. I've always said that if they don't feel comfortable disclosing for whatever reason, they're welcome to speak to HR instead, but someone in the company must know what's the matter with them.

I don't force people to call me like it says in our staff handbook. If they're vomiting at 4am, I don't expect them to stay awake for another 5 hours and call me at start of business; they can send me a text and go back to sleep, then text or call when they're awake to let me know what they think is wrong. Every company I've ever worked for has had the same stupid 'you must call us at 9am so we can hear in your voice if you're lying' policy and I've always exercised discretion.

I want to know why they're off for two reasons.

  1. In case it's disability/pregnancy related so I can make sure their absence isn't held against them.
  2. So I know which of their tasks need to be covered, and I can immediately make arrangements to do so.

The people running your company seem like a shit show. You don't contact people when they're sick. Because they're sick. If they feel well enough to pass on a status update on their tasks before crawling back under the duvet or to grab a bucket to throw up into, that's always helpful, but I don't demand it from them. I also send them 'are you feeling any better?' texts when I think they should be on the mend from their initial self-assessment, but there's no expectation or obligation for them to immediately reply. Because sick people are often in the bathroom or asleep.

In my experience, if you treat your employees well and don't expect them to do anything other than get better, they're more inclined to try their best to pass on a status update when they can, rather than to exercise their statutory right to radio silence.

In your case, I'd be inclined to innocently say to HR, 'My boss has asked to me to contact So and So for a status update on work as she's been off for more than a week now. Do you have her home phone number?' Assuming they're not as terrible as her manager or your manager, that should prompt them to get involved and tell you not to do anything.

ButtockUp · 10/05/2022 20:37

Do not call her. At all.
Do you actually know why she's off ?
This is a senior management issue.

donquixotedelamancha · 10/05/2022 20:29

So interesting, the vast variation in experiences. I've never worked anywhere where i wouldn't expect (and be expected) to make at least a basic plan B for a critical piece of work that I was delivering, and that would involved getting and sending emails.

You've presumably worked for pretty good organisations.

Many companies don't pay people who are sick and many organisations don't have capacity/procedures to enable work to be covered easily.

OP's organisation doesn't seem that competent to me.

WinterDeWinter · 10/05/2022 20:21

So interesting, the vast variation in experiences. I've never worked anywhere where i wouldn't expect (and be expected) to make at least a basic plan B for a critical piece of work that I was delivering, and that would involved getting and sending emails. I do agree that work has infected non-work time to an insane degree - but really, this is just being an adult. Unless it's really really serious.

donquixotedelamancha · 10/05/2022 20:20

I think everyone answering this should state if they are public or private sector. Would be quite illuminating I think.

You get good and bad bosses in both. The worst boss I ever worked for in this respect was public sector.

Some MNers seem to have a bizarre idea that the entire private sector work harder than public- my experience has been the opposite.

VodselForDinner · 10/05/2022 20:10

neither me nor my boss (who she reports to) has an idea of whether it's something long term(eg broken bone/mental health) or something more short term like the flu

This none of your business.

You’re being very unreasonable for expecting someone on sick leave to check email.

If you’re managing a project and have a single point of failure, you need another job.

Abraxan · 10/05/2022 20:09

It's now been a week since the original day of illness and neither me nor my boss (who she reports to) has an idea of whether it's something long term(eg broken bone/mental health) or something more short term like the flu.

Do you mean that you and your boss don't know, or do you mean no one at work knows?
Has the person she has to report illness to been information of the absence, continued absence and if there is an estimated return date.

If it's been a week then a fit note will be sent in now anyway, as you can only self certify for 7 days (was temporarily changed to 28 days but think that stopped a while back now) so someone will find out soon.

Although your boss may be the person she needs to report to re the work, it may not be the same person she is required to contact and update regarding her sick leave.

BritInUS1 · 10/05/2022 20:05

YABU she is off sick

It's up to the company to work things out and cover

OurChristmasMiracle · 10/05/2022 20:03

I don’t think she should be checking work emails or responding when off however she should be providing a sick certificate if she’s been off for more than 7 days and an indication of what is wrong and when she hopes to return

I would suggest HR contact her and ask for the relevant information

Abraxan · 10/05/2022 20:02

strivingtosucceed · 10/05/2022 17:38

Her boss is my boss who has asked me to email because "she should be keeping an eye on her emails even while sick". I'm wondering if it's normal or reasonable to expect this.

Whilst many people do, it should never be expected or seen as the norm.

If someone is off sick they should not be having to work in any way. They certainly shouldn't be being chased through lots of emails, messages or whatever.

Thepeopleversuswork · 10/05/2022 19:57

I agree she shouldn't be having to check emails while off sick... but I also think its fairly bizarre for the expectation to be that there is total radio silence from her until she is out of her self-certification period and damn all anyone else can do.

As a PP mentioned its very odd for her to be the only person in this team and for the project to be set up so there are no other employees working on this workstream at all.

Also, and someone will be along to shoot me for being a ruthless bastard, but unless she is critically unwell I can't believe she couldn't find it in herself to send one single blanket email to the relevant people informing them of her illness, stating that she doesn't have visibility on her recovery and asking them to delegate to others.

I get that its unpleasant for people to be asked to be "always on" when sick but I think sometimes people take this to extremes. You'd have to be very unwell to be unable to send a single short email or text informing people of the situation. She must have done this initially in the process of informing her line manager she was sick so presumably she could have followed up.

Agree with others though that its really for your boss to sort and not you.

SafelySoftly · 10/05/2022 19:55

If she’s highly paid and working on a key project then let’s be honest it is expected for people to be checking emails in the corporate world.

linerforlife · 10/05/2022 19:53

You can't email her but your:/her boss should contact her to find out how she is as they have a duty of care towards her. Your boss should also be finding the solution in terms of who to delegate her work to etc.

LetitiaLeghorn · 10/05/2022 19:53

MMAMPWGHAP · 10/05/2022 17:53

I think everyone answering this should state if they are public or private sector. Would be quite illuminating I think.

I've worked in the public, private and charity sectors. Never have I just been allowed to go off sick and not keep up to date with sick notes, without telling someone what was going on. And I would always pass back work. I mean if I was on resus in hospital, that would be different but my partner would be informing my manager or hr on what was happening. This woman's sick note has run out and is effectively AWOL if she hasn't informed someone what's going on.

Minimalme · 10/05/2022 19:50

strivingtosucceed · 10/05/2022 17:38

Her boss is my boss who has asked me to email because "she should be keeping an eye on her emails even while sick". I'm wondering if it's normal or reasonable to expect this.

You do know that your 'critical' project is most likely to be completely unimportant to the rest of the world don't you?

It's nice you take your job so seriously but unless you are deploying people to a war zone or talking someone off a ledge, it will be less important than you imagine.

nocoolnamesleft · 10/05/2022 19:44

Probably public sector. I remember being called to ask me to sort out a patient. When I myself was already an inpatient in the same hospital. Luckily I happened to know who was covering me, so could tell them who to call.

AnneLovesGilbert · 10/05/2022 19:43

Your boss is her boss. It’s his responsibility to deal with her sick leave and any fallout from it.

What would happen to the project if she was hit by a bus and died? Your mutual manager would have to cope.

Push back hard, this is not yours to sort, he’s taking the piss.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 10/05/2022 19:38

MMAMPWGHAP · 10/05/2022 17:53

I think everyone answering this should state if they are public or private sector. Would be quite illuminating I think.

Ok, I'll bite.

Public sector.

You're not allowed to be properly sick unless you're calling in dead and then you should have already ensured that everything was done at least six weeks in advance so that nobody else has to do it. You will be expected to work from home or your hospital bed until HR tell your manager to leave you alone.

GooglyEyeballs · 10/05/2022 19:30

It's not acceptable to expect someone to work when they're off sick even if it is 'just keeping an eye on emails'. That's a really unhealthy work expectation. Her boss should be able to deal with it. I do think though unless it's an emergency (ie she has a cold rather than is in hospital for example), she should have indicated some sort of handover. But the team should be able to cope with a man down, it's part of being a team.

Jaxhog · 10/05/2022 19:24

Unless I was in a coma, I would expect to try and hand over to someone else. Or inform my boss, that I can't. I would NOT be allowed to be home sick without my boss having some idea of what was wrong and how long I might be sick. But then I work in the private sector.

It IS up to your boss to deal with this, not you. That's his/her job.

Dazedandconfused10 · 10/05/2022 19:22

Down to your boss to manage her own employee and ensure there is no single point of failure in a team.

LetitiaLeghorn · 10/05/2022 19:19

If she's had her 5 self-certified days off and still hasn't returned, she should have told someone at your company that she's taking more sick time, even if she hasn't managed to get a doctors note yet. People can't just go off sick and then not be heard of again until they decide to walk into the office a few weeks later! What offices work like that?
I'd refer it to HR and get them to contact her to ask her where she is because her sick note has run out.

BornBlonde · 10/05/2022 19:09

It's your boss problem to deal with. I would refuse to call or email her while you know she's off. It's completely inappropriate