Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that if you are ill (self certified) & main decision maker for a department you should respond to emails wherever possible?

110 replies

strivingtosucceed · 10/05/2022 17:33

Genuinely have no idea where the opinion of this will sway but i'll give a bit of context.

We have a project about to go live in 3 weeks, I own this project. A particular sub-department is in charge of one part of the project and is headed by a woman who also happens to be the only person in that sub-department. Unfortunately, she fell ill and seems to have not told anyone that she had remained ill past the original day she called in sick. It's now been a week since the original day of illness and neither me nor my boss (who she reports to) has an idea of whether it's something long term(eg broken bone/mental health) or something more short term like the flu.

Unfortunately the part of the project her sub-department is on the critical path, this means there are strict timelines that need to be adhered to and quality sign offs that need to happen before we can move to the next step. I want to email her to ask 1) when she'll be back & 2) who I can delegate her work to in the meantime so we stay on track. However, I've been told by some other colleagues that i'd be badgering them if I did so.

So AIBU to expect an answer from my colleague if she feels better for 5/10 minutes during the day or should I expect radio silence until they're fully back and well.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
strivingtosucceed · 12/05/2022 18:11

noblegiraffe · 12/05/2022 16:16

On the public v private sector thing, as a teacher I’m expected to phone in by 7:30am on every day of absence if I’m going to be off sick. I’m expected to email in a full set of cover lessons and resources for the day by 8am (this is why many teachers struggle in when sick as it’s easier to go in than set cover work in a rush first thing in the morning when you feel ill).

We’re then expected to phone in again around 1pm to say if we expect to be in the next day so they know whether to book a supply teacher.

I’d probably also check emails, particularly if I’ve set work for sixth form as they might have queries.

Was the insinuation that it’s easier to be off sick in the public sector?

This sounds very OTT for someone who is presumably too sick to work although I understand the implications to the kids.

@Thepeopleversuswork ive only briefly worked in public sector but found that for most companies people don’t mind responding to the odd email or two while sick or answering a quick text on holiday.

I don’t think it should be an expectation but I guess everyone has their own ideas of how these things go.

OP posts:
Thepeopleversuswork · 12/05/2022 17:20

@noblegiraffe

I agree that public vs private sector is irrelevant. There are public sector roles which require high levels of organisation and delegation and private sector roles which are very relaxed about sickness etc.

I think it’s a factor of the seniority of the role, the level of workload and the urgency of the project.

But I do think the idea that contacting someone during a period of sickness is an absolute no no is quite a public sector culture thing.

There’s a massive spectrum between badgering a sick employee to do work and sending a very short considerate message asking who to delegate the work to.

Maybe I am being naive but I don’t think that’s so awful.

Fuuuuuckit · 12/05/2022 17:11

My company policy is to call in every day for the first 5 days (so someone at least knows why I'm off) and then the doctors note covers anything after that.

That said, when my mum died I called on the first day and told them I wouldn't be calling back for the rest of the week, and that was understood.

I would not expect to read or respond to any emails iff I was off sick. I WOULD respond to colleagues' WhatsApp messages if they were checking in on me but I wouldn't expect them to be asking about work.

10HailMarys · 12/05/2022 16:20

strivingtosucceed · 10/05/2022 17:38

Her boss is my boss who has asked me to email because "she should be keeping an eye on her emails even while sick". I'm wondering if it's normal or reasonable to expect this.

It's not the best company culture if they're expecting people to monitor emails while they're sick (unless, of course, the sick person has indicated that they would like to do that). In general, it's best practice to leave people alone if they're off sick.

If there are elements of the project that can't be moved on until one person and one person only has signed them off, that's a flaw in the process. There should always be an agreed contingency plan or delegation/escalation plan in place for this kind of thing, and I think your boss should have thought of that. What would happen if your sick colleague was in a coma or something?!

noblegiraffe · 12/05/2022 16:16

On the public v private sector thing, as a teacher I’m expected to phone in by 7:30am on every day of absence if I’m going to be off sick. I’m expected to email in a full set of cover lessons and resources for the day by 8am (this is why many teachers struggle in when sick as it’s easier to go in than set cover work in a rush first thing in the morning when you feel ill).

We’re then expected to phone in again around 1pm to say if we expect to be in the next day so they know whether to book a supply teacher.

I’d probably also check emails, particularly if I’ve set work for sixth form as they might have queries.

Was the insinuation that it’s easier to be off sick in the public sector?

strivingtosucceed · 12/05/2022 15:28

Oh gosh, I promptly forgot about this as soon as I finished work. Thanks for your opinions. Just some things to note.

  1. My boss asked me to confirm who the woman's work was supposed to be delegated to, not to ask them to continue work. But I take on board that's his role, not mine.

  2. I'm new to the organisation & project so had no part in resourcing and/or planning. Plus, I'm sure most of you know that highlighting a resourcing risk doesn't mean that it gets solved immediately.

  3. Unless I was ill to the extent of needing hospitalisation or I was completely out of it, I don't think i'd mind forwarding work/documentation to a colleague with a short description of what was happening and next steps. Not even for the company's sake, but to make my own work easier when I come back.

  4. I'm not 100% on the company's sick policy but I would have thought that even self certifying, you'd have to call in and give a rough date of return and then call in again if that date passes or is likely to pass.

Ultimately i've passed this over to my boss for him to raise with his own boss. If the person doesn't return, there's really nothing I can do and the deadline will be missed. It could cost me my own job even though it's not my fault but I appreciate the concern from posters implying i'm some sort of massively unreasonable person for being concerned.

OP posts:
Watermill · 11/05/2022 10:23

Agree with PP - You are being unreasonable, and your boss is a total cheeky fucker asking you to call her and ask questions.

Just keep batting everything back to him. It's his job to support the project in the absence of his staff member. I can't understand why you think she would be responsible for deciding who her work should be delegated to - it all sounds horribly unprofessional.

The person who took the original call from her should have asked how long she would be off, and set parameters for when/how she would communicate regarding her absence. Not much point in calling in every day to say "Yeah, both my arms are still broken."

rookiemere · 11/05/2022 09:16

As others have said your issue is with this ladies Line manager who unfortunately is also your LM.

I would say to your boss that you don't feel
Comfortable emailing a colleague who is off sick. Keep redirecting it to your project and what suggestions she has for alternative resource.

Not your job to decide if colleague
Is ill or not and should be responding to emails- that's her bosses job.

HairyScaryMonster · 11/05/2022 08:44

Her boss should call her. He's not asking her to work, only to clarify cover.

Snowiscold · 11/05/2022 07:46

I’m appalled that anyone would expect her to read her emails. Absolutely not. But there should be a proper policy on reporting sickness.

ChoiceMummy · 11/05/2022 03:45

strivingtosucceed · 10/05/2022 17:38

Her boss is my boss who has asked me to email because "she should be keeping an eye on her emails even while sick". I'm wondering if it's normal or reasonable to expect this.

Not reasonable at all.

If she isn't following the sick policy re notification that's the line manager's job to chase up.

They need to follow their sick policy re contact.

There should have been contingency plans in place, surely 2.5 years of a pandemic has taught that. The info should have been shared with the project owner by the project lead instilling this ethos.

Sounds like the project lead has some learning points from this episode. I wouldn't be contacting the employee at all, not your role, when she's said she's sick.

Notcreativeatall · 11/05/2022 01:34

I'd expect her to read her emails esp if there is something urgent due- but you shouldn't be relying on that. She should have an out of office protocol that says who should be contacted - either her boss or her team. If i'm sick and there is something urgent i'd normally just say who to speak to or get a delay.
Does seem very badly managed -surely you'd have backups in place any way- and at the very least her boss should be able to step in/

Simonjt · 11/05/2022 01:21

FairyCakeWings · 10/05/2022 18:13

I’d expect my boss to be rightly pissed off with me if I called in sick for a day then made no contact whatsoever for a week and ignored emails as well.

She’s a shit, unreliable employee.

You sound like my old boss, he had the same attitude, including when I nearly died of sepsis. I do hope you aren’t anyones boss.

PlasticineMeg · 11/05/2022 01:10

strivingtosucceed · 10/05/2022 17:38

Her boss is my boss who has asked me to email because "she should be keeping an eye on her emails even while sick". I'm wondering if it's normal or reasonable to expect this.

Christ no wonder the poor woman is off with this shitty attitude from her boss.

Its not her problem, she’s off sick, a good workplace means work is transferable if the worst happens to someone. Definitely don’t ask her when she’s coming back, you really aren’t supposed to do that

Snowiscold · 11/05/2022 00:54

FairyCakeWings · 10/05/2022 18:13

I’d expect my boss to be rightly pissed off with me if I called in sick for a day then made no contact whatsoever for a week and ignored emails as well.

She’s a shit, unreliable employee.

That is an appalling thing to say. Someone from my workplace called in sick one day, and the company then didn’t hear from her for a few days. They definitely would have tried to contact her. Turned out she’d had a heart attack and died in her flat - a young woman in her 30s.

madasawethen · 11/05/2022 00:45

Maybe she found a better highing paying job that wasn't such a disorganised mess.

InChocolateWeTrust · 10/05/2022 23:39

I’d expect my boss to be rightly pissed off with me if I called in sick for a day then made no contact whatsoever for a week and ignored emails as well. She’s a shit, unreliable employee.

Or something fucking serious has happened?

I've seen this happen on several occasions. One where a guys wife literally fucking dropped dead, unexpectedly. Another where a woman was in a car accident and was seriously ill in hospital (eg fully sedated and hooked up to machines)

InChocolateWeTrust · 10/05/2022 23:34

It's nice you take your job so seriously but unless you are deploying people to a war zone or talking someone off a ledge, it will be less important than you imagine.

Having had to go completely offline with zero notice at all, I can confirm this is absolutely true. There are barely any jobs where it is literally life or death if this happens - they tend to have seriously good contingency plans. What happens is usually a bit of money gets lost on a corporate level and actually no one gives a fuck a month later.

InChocolateWeTrust · 10/05/2022 23:32

Unreasonable.

Her boss needs to step in given she's off, and delegate out as needed.

If there's literally a situation where she has deliberables or information no one can access without her, there's been a monumental fuck up with key man dependency and your department leadership need to learn from that.

SausagePourHomme · 10/05/2022 22:43

Minimalme · 10/05/2022 19:50

You do know that your 'critical' project is most likely to be completely unimportant to the rest of the world don't you?

It's nice you take your job so seriously but unless you are deploying people to a war zone or talking someone off a ledge, it will be less important than you imagine.

you can't say that when you have absolutely no idea what this person's job entails.

MordredsOrrery · 10/05/2022 21:08

Expects, not redirects 🙄

WindyKnickers · 10/05/2022 21:07

And this was never a thing prior to the big WFH push. I only had the technology to WFH from about 2018 onwards. Prior to that you were ill and that was it. We had to have systems in place to manage staff sickness then that didn't involve the ill person working

MordredsOrrery · 10/05/2022 21:07

Whilst she should let her manager know how long she redirects to be off for, she absolutely shouldn't be working while off sick, that includes answering work emails.

In our place we have to complete an online form confirming we haven't worked while off sick. That said, we are expected to keep in touch with the office. I've just had an extended period of sick leave and my boss and I had a call every 7-10 days just to check in.

Her boss doesn't sound very caring about the employees wellbeing or interested in the project/actively managing resource.

Thepeopleversuswork · 10/05/2022 21:05

So one of two things has happened:

a) she has self-certified sick beyond the initial day and has informed either HR or another line manager but for whatever reason this information hasn't been passed on to you or,
b) she informed of her illness on the first day and hasn't seen fit to follow up

If a) whoever was told of her absence should have informed you and your boss, who should have delegated or found cover. It should have been incumbent on your boss or another boss to have instigated a back-up plan at this point. If that hasn't taken place then your company is a mess.

If b) and unless she is really critically ill, I think the colleague who is sick is in the wrong. If you inform your employer of a day's sick leave on day one I think the expectation is that on subsequent days if you don't return to work, you follow up to let your employer know you are going to be taking a more extended period of leave. At which point they find cover.

It's very rare for someone, as long as they haven't been hospitalised, to be incapable of sending a five word text message once a day to their line manager to keep them informed and I don't think its "totally unreasonable" or "harassment" for someone to send a brief, courteous and compassionate message saying "are you ok? shall we hand this on to someone else?"

WindyKnickers · 10/05/2022 21:04

I'm in the public sector and I keep an eye on emails when I'm sick and outside my contracted hours. But that's because I care about the client group and don't like to think of my colleagues struggling to manage my work when a quick email from me could cover it. But crucially this is NOT expected in my public sector department and I never expect it of my colleagues. In fact I do it very much on the sly because I don't want it to become part of the work culture. I'm just a control freak and like to know what's going on.