Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is Starmer seriously going to resign???

788 replies

Swayingpalmtrees · 10/05/2022 09:51

I have been waiting for a thread to come up about this, but I can't see one to date. I can't believe Keir Starmer has now said he will resign (and Angela Rayner as well) Potentially leaving the Labour party with no leader at all!

Looking at the 'evidence' that is well known and has been published, it appears the Indian takeaway was pre ordered (due to its size) and pre planned according to the staff at the Indian and the leaked memo, it did include quite a number of people and bottles of beer etc and drinking. It was late into the night, so not work related, and no one is suggesting anyone continued to work afterwards as it was so late. I don't see how this is any different to the No10 arrangements! So how on earth will they avoid a fine??

Sir Keir's speech was so wobbly I actually thought he was resigning there and then, and although I appreciate the sentiments of integrity and honour, where on earth does that leave the LP with under two years to the election or less?

Who would replace him? Do we have any thoughts on a plan of any kind?

I am kind of aghast, we are in the middle of a European war, on the cusp of potentially WW3, I am not sure this is a responsible action given the seriousness of our predicament with Russia whom are threatening us on a weekly basis with nuclear war. At the very very least, we need a firm hand on the tiller, so to speak, we do not have time to be squabbling over beer and cheese.
AIBU?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
stuntbubbles · 10/05/2022 10:34

They were not 'working' at the time, they can clearly be seen standing around and chatting, drinking beer.

Breaking for food during work would include sitting at the desk for five minutes and eating and for most companies a soft drink. There would be no need to stand around in a group drinking beer if you are claiming to be working!!
Oh god, you’re Jack Warner standing outside the writing room yelling if you can’t hear them on their typewriters. You really can’t conceive that:

• They were standing around talking about work
• They were standing around taking a quick food and stretch break after having been hunched over documents and speeches for several hours
• People have different jobs and work expectations and that yes, a surgeon couldn’t stand over a patient and swig beer, or a 9-5 admin role wouldn’t work til midnight, but plenty of industries do

Rookiemistake · 10/05/2022 10:34

I don't think he'll be fined. This was a stitch up from the start. The Tories put pressure on Durham police to investigate. It has backfired on them now as Starmer has said he'll resign if fined. This would be even worse optics for Johnson so my guess is they'll tell the police to back off from a fine. This will leave Starmer with a dent in his reputation but will draw a line under everything.

Swayingpalmtrees · 10/05/2022 10:34

The central argument and defence is incredibly flawed, Starmer will know this too. His voice was shaky and uncertain and all he was keen to do was to make a point, that at least he is a man of his word, but personally a man of his legal experience will know that the police are very unlikely to turn a blind eye to the dinner and drinks, and if they do they will be accused of corruption and dishonesty.

There are no grounds to avoid a fine, given no work was conducted during or after the dinner and drinks party.

OP posts:
nancy75 · 10/05/2022 10:34

Starmer is obviously confident he can show he did continue working, which will be pretty easy if he sent even 1 work related email

TheKeatingFive · 10/05/2022 10:31

In my job - if we work late on a project we're ordered food to the office and there are beers in the Facilities cupboard we'd be able to take a limited number of.

While that's true of me too, it doesn't apply to the vast majority of jobs.

The PP is right, most people would not be familiar with working after curry and a beer. It sounds like horseshit.

whether they think he should resign over it or not is another thing. I doubt enough people care about the exact status of what happened post 9pm, post beer. But Starmer's made his choice.

catsonahottinroof · 10/05/2022 10:31

I couldn't care less about these 'parties' of either political party, although I do understand why some people are upset. The worst thing about the Labour one is the lying about Angela Rayner being there. I thought the police had said a few weeks ago that they wouldn't be fining any Labour party members though.

3WildOnes · 10/05/2022 10:30

I would be surprised if he gets fined. Ordering a takeaway whilst you work late into the evening is pretty common in lots of jobs.
Lots of offices in London have beer fridges or rooftop bars with free drinks for staff on certain evenings.

Swayingpalmtrees · 10/05/2022 10:30

My point is I think he is definitely going to be fined.

I don't know how Starmer imagines he will avoid it, there are photos and memos and personal accounts confirming the fact there was no work completed during the dinner, and no work completed afterwards. It starts and ends with that fact. So it can no longer be considered a work related break? The beer drinking compounds this.

That is the issue the police now have. A work related break for food would mean that work continued after the dinner and drinks, and it did not.

OP posts:
SleeplessInEngland · 10/05/2022 10:29

Swayingpalmtrees · 10/05/2022 10:26

And yes, polling shows the public don't give a shit about this

Quite the contrary, people do care very much about hypocrisy when they see it.

Right. The actual data versus your partisanship.

Sorry, but I'll stick with the former.

BlanketsBanned · 10/05/2022 10:28

What is the point of a politician if they are not responsible for keeping their citizens alive and well.

Cornettoninja · 10/05/2022 10:27

I think he nailed his colours to the mast long before beergate and unlike other nameless politicians understands integrity. I hope that if he is fined he keeps his word and resigns.

sadly I think BJ&Co won’t care about what that exposes about them and are brazen enough to turn a display of honour into something to scoff at. It’s very sad to watch what this countries parliament has turned into.

Regarding ‘wars in Europe’, cost of living crisis, climate emergency etc. being a barrier to removing politicians from office. Raise your bloody standards, an untrustworthy or incompetent leader is worthless in a crisis. Certainly internationally our leading politicians need to be credible not a bunch of second hand car salesmen.

If you’re going to be crooked in politics you at least have to be good at it.

SickAndTiredAgain · 10/05/2022 10:26

To answer your title, of course he will resign if fined. He wouldn't say so otherwise, it would be completely ridiculous. There's no way he said "if fined, I'll resign" while thinking "nah I won't, hopefully no one will notice". He'd be dead in the water if he didn't resign.

But I'd be surprised if he said it without being pretty confident that he wouldn't be fined.

Swayingpalmtrees · 10/05/2022 10:26

And yes, polling shows the public don't give a shit about this

Quite the contrary, people do care very much about hypocrisy when they see it.

OP posts:
SleeplessInEngland · 10/05/2022 10:26

Swayingpalmtrees · 10/05/2022 10:24

The issue as far as I can see it:

They were not 'working' at the time, they can clearly be seen standing around and chatting, drinking beer.

Breaking for food during work would include sitting at the desk for five minutes and eating and for most companies a soft drink. There would be no need to stand around in a group drinking beer if you are claiming to be working!!

There is no mention of work continuing in the memo, only the 'dinner at Miners Hall' and then a walk back to the hotel. Had the memo also included resuming work/meeting/campaign planning then I think they would fair much better with the police investigation. The memo goes into great detail - and there lies the problem. There is NO mention of working/another meeting etc

Most people can see that this looks very much like an end of campaign dinner!! People are not stupid despite what the LP might think...

For the third time, because apparently it's really difficult to grasp: the data shows people don't care.

If you're a boris supporter trying to fan the flames then fine, but stop pretending everyone's mortified by this and that no-one could possibly work late.

Swayingpalmtrees · 10/05/2022 10:26

Sorry OP but you are being really naive. Plenty of jobs involve working late and/or pre-planned eating and drinking at 9pm

Not in a pandemic.

OP posts:
nancy75 · 10/05/2022 10:24

Also often missed when Starmer bashing - the rules were very different from when Boris had his gatherings. The photo of Downing Street when they are all in the garden was taken on my birthday, so I remember those rules very clearly. I was allowed to sit in a garden with EITHER my mum OR my dad NOT both. There are about 40 people in the Downing Street garden photo

Swayingpalmtrees · 10/05/2022 10:24

The issue as far as I can see it:

They were not 'working' at the time, they can clearly be seen standing around and chatting, drinking beer.

Breaking for food during work would include sitting at the desk for five minutes and eating and for most companies a soft drink. There would be no need to stand around in a group drinking beer if you are claiming to be working!!

There is no mention of work continuing in the memo, only the 'dinner at Miners Hall' and then a walk back to the hotel. Had the memo also included resuming work/meeting/campaign planning then I think they would fair much better with the police investigation. The memo goes into great detail - and there lies the problem. There is NO mention of working/another meeting etc

Most people can see that this looks very much like an end of campaign dinner!! People are not stupid despite what the LP might think...

OP posts:
TulipsGarden · 10/05/2022 10:22

BlanketsBanned · 10/05/2022 10:17

If they are fined they both have no choice but to resign after all he and AR said about partygate. How many other jobs are there where you can drink alcohol and carry on working, have bars to meet up in, can you imagine a doctor or nurse sitting down with a curry and lager midway between their shift, the whole set up is a disgrace.

In my job - if we work late on a project we're ordered food to the office and there are beers in the Facilities cupboard we'd be able to take a limited number of. And actually, a lot of working lunches with clients feature alcohol (although less so than 10+ years ago, when you'd basically put your out of office on and plan to get the last train home. Times change!).

Of course a doctor doesn't have a beer halfway through a shift, but politicians aren't doctors, they're not responsible for keeping people alive, they were just working late.

DorritLittle · 10/05/2022 10:21

Do you honestly think the British public will believe that he was working, even though they can see people standing around at nearly 9pm drinking beer and eating curry?

Sorry OP but you are being really naive. Plenty of jobs involve working late and/or pre-planned eating and drinking at 9pm.

BlanketsBanned · 10/05/2022 10:21

TulipsGarden · 10/05/2022 10:17

It's wildly different to the No. 10 parties, and everyone with half a brain knows it. They were working very late and everyone needed feeding - that's normal when campaigning, and in any job where you work late. Some of those people chose to have beers to drink. It wasn't a pre-arranged party, after work - they were just feeding the people who had worked late.

And as for not changing leaders - I'm sure it'll be fine. I very much doubt Putin or Zelensky really care either way.

When I was working late, unpaid, in the nhs I needed feeding too, usually a snickers or a packet of crisps, if I was feeling very rebellious I might even steal a cup of nhs tea and a few digestive biscuits out the ward tin.

worriedatthistime · 10/05/2022 10:21

Op on here they will always justify it as ok or not as bad as xyz , the reality js , they never needed to meet in large numbers like that or have beers however you look at it , most of is were still even avoiding the office and having teams meetings etc still

MarshaBradyo · 10/05/2022 10:20

AbleCable · 10/05/2022 10:01

He said he would resign if fined. I think he would - but not sure that he will be fined.

I dont think he or any party leader should resign during a war in Europe. I think his threat to do so is about how it looks, and not about what is best for the UK.

He’s being advised pretty well on how to politically make it work for him

SleeplessInEngland · 10/05/2022 10:20

"Do you honestly think the British public will believe that he was working, even though they can see people standing around at nearly 9pm drinking beer and eating curry?"

They have to eat. Doesn't mean they weren't working into the wee hours afterwards.

And yes, polling shows the public don't give a shit about this.

TheKeatingFive · 10/05/2022 10:20

it just makes Johnson look more and more like an untrustworthy bounder.

There isn't a person alive who doesn't know that already. Those who support him don't care.

nancy75 · 10/05/2022 10:19

It’s interesting the war in Ukraine means we can’t change leader, Churchill wasn’t the PM at the start of WW2 & we were definitely more involved with that one