Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is Starmer seriously going to resign???

788 replies

Swayingpalmtrees · 10/05/2022 09:51

I have been waiting for a thread to come up about this, but I can't see one to date. I can't believe Keir Starmer has now said he will resign (and Angela Rayner as well) Potentially leaving the Labour party with no leader at all!

Looking at the 'evidence' that is well known and has been published, it appears the Indian takeaway was pre ordered (due to its size) and pre planned according to the staff at the Indian and the leaked memo, it did include quite a number of people and bottles of beer etc and drinking. It was late into the night, so not work related, and no one is suggesting anyone continued to work afterwards as it was so late. I don't see how this is any different to the No10 arrangements! So how on earth will they avoid a fine??

Sir Keir's speech was so wobbly I actually thought he was resigning there and then, and although I appreciate the sentiments of integrity and honour, where on earth does that leave the LP with under two years to the election or less?

Who would replace him? Do we have any thoughts on a plan of any kind?

I am kind of aghast, we are in the middle of a European war, on the cusp of potentially WW3, I am not sure this is a responsible action given the seriousness of our predicament with Russia whom are threatening us on a weekly basis with nuclear war. At the very very least, we need a firm hand on the tiller, so to speak, we do not have time to be squabbling over beer and cheese.
AIBU?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
Swayingpalmtrees · 10/05/2022 10:47

here is time stamped evidence of work continuing until after 1am

We need a link to that post Ilovesooty and Starmer is able to prove that they all stayed at the venue post 10pm drinks and dinner can he?

This is simply untrue and you know it. Starmer has already confirmed he went straight back to the hotel at 10pm, they have already confirmed those facts that no work continued collectively post beer/Indian.

Starmer sitting in his bed sending emails at 1am can not be used as a defence, because the police will have expected work to continue in the venue with the rest of the group if the defence is going to be a 'work related' break.

OP posts:
SickAndTiredAgain · 10/05/2022 10:46

There are no grounds to avoid a fine, given no work was conducted during or after the dinner and drinks party.

What is the point in saying something like this when you (and the rest of us) have no idea whether work was conducted? Presumably that is part of what the police are currently looking at.
They were working, they then ate, it's hardly inconceivable that work conversations just continued while that happened. This was an campaign related day - so I imagine a fair amount of work is just talking through things, rather than a more tangible "I was obviously still working, here are the physical things I made".
I've worked in jobs where takeaways have been ordered late in the evening, and while eating work is still discussed, even if people aren't physically sitting at laptops typing away. Does that count as working?

I'm not saying they definitely were working by the way. Just that if you can so confidently say "well the police have to fine them as no work took place" you could probably save the police time by letting them know how you're so sure.

Besides, he's said he'll resign if fined - how are people still complaining at that? Surely that's what you want?

Comefromaway · 10/05/2022 10:46

You are allowed to eat during or at the end of your shift.

VanGoghsDog · 10/05/2022 10:46

Swayingpalmtrees · 10/05/2022 10:38

It is going to take a lot more than one email sent from his hotel bed nancy he will need to prove the entire group continued to work together at the venue post beer at 10pm.

That is the point, and they didn't! And no one is suggesting that they did, least of all those present at the dinner party.

It has already been confirmed they returned to the hotel.

A works break is a break from work, what they will need to prove is that they collectively continued working afterwards, and indeed the work was 'essential' which is also questionable - as most meetings were taking place on zoom at that time. Social distancing was not observed due to the size of the room.

I think he has a big problem, and by extension the LP could be thrown into crisis.

Nothing in the law, at any point at all, said that any work had to be "essential". This is something that was misunderstood by so many from the start.

So, no, no-one has to prove the work was essential.

badgermushrooms · 10/05/2022 10:46

@Swayingpalmtrees You're going to have to at least pretend to engage with the many, many people talking about their own experiences having food ordered in when working late if you want to be convincing. And of course you know from your own experience that working late on a political campaign is extremely normal - though perhaps you're not used to seeing your leader putting the hours in?

FreddyVoorhees · 10/05/2022 10:45

Swayingpalmtrees · 10/05/2022 10:09

I agree able that we have a war raging in Europe, having a coherent opposition party is incredibly important at the moment. Starmer may not be PM but the opposition are expected to partake in many decisions made across all parties to do with security etc.

I think there is a very real chance of a fine actually.

There are photos of the people drinking inside, there is evidence of Indian food to the tune of 200gbp being pre ordered, so clearly for a large gathering at least. How would the police not fine for this? The memo concludes the party was organised in advance, they were drinking and there are photos to support.

I am wondering how the police can come to any other conclusion given the rules at the time?

It's an absolute gift to the Tories. It may NOT be the same as the No10 event but if you're relying on semantics after constantly lambasting the PM for such things it's not good.

Personally, I feel Starmer has been a fairly useless opposition leader. They may have won a few London councils on god awful turnouts but when you're losing former mining areas to the Tories, you are not making progress.

nancy75 · 10/05/2022 10:45

BigWoollyJumpers · 10/05/2022 10:39

The fine that Boris has been given though is EXACTLY the same, if not slightly less so. He was out at a school visit in the morning, came back to the office, where all his own staff were working, people he worked with all and every day. Had a piece of cake and a drink, then sat down with the self same people for a cabinet meeting. His "party" was a break in the middle of the day between meetings.

The big garden party after work, was obviously against the rules and all those attending got fined.

I personally don't get care who gets fined, but I do care that the same rules have to apply whether you are in Durham or London. By the way, I don't think Keir should resign either, I think he has just painted himself into a corner, and the far left will take the opportunity with glee.

All those attending the big garden party did NOT get fined, unless Johnson has been fined twice & we have not been told?

CoalCraft · 10/05/2022 10:45

Isn't he an extremely experienced lawyer? I'm sure he has a good idea of the risk of being fined and reckons its unlikely.

stuntbubbles · 10/05/2022 10:44

You're just making up rules now. There was no rule that said people couldn't work late. No rule that said people were not allowed to go to work. No limit on the number of people at work at any time. No rule that said you can't break fur food or drink.
Ah, remember the glory days of lockdown one and everyone on here making up the rules? Cake is not an essential! You can’t order online deliveries! Only one hour outside the house! Don’t sneeze in your front garden!

HummingQuietly · 10/05/2022 10:43

As former DPP he is better able than most to judge when he's broken the law. He only mentioned resigning because he's confident he won't have to. He was election campaigning, he'll have been up working for hours after 10pm.

Funny how you're untroubled by the hypocrisy if Durham fine Starmer, given their reason for not fining Dominic Cummings is that their policy is not to issue fines retrospectively.

MarshaBradyo · 10/05/2022 10:43

BigWoollyJumpers · 10/05/2022 10:39

The fine that Boris has been given though is EXACTLY the same, if not slightly less so. He was out at a school visit in the morning, came back to the office, where all his own staff were working, people he worked with all and every day. Had a piece of cake and a drink, then sat down with the self same people for a cabinet meeting. His "party" was a break in the middle of the day between meetings.

The big garden party after work, was obviously against the rules and all those attending got fined.

I personally don't get care who gets fined, but I do care that the same rules have to apply whether you are in Durham or London. By the way, I don't think Keir should resign either, I think he has just painted himself into a corner, and the far left will take the opportunity with glee.

I don’t know if he will get a fine but I agree with the rest

Fairisleflora · 10/05/2022 10:43

I certainly hope the NHS staff who were working (I know, working!) after 10pm were able to stop for food too, before carrying on working. I’m wondering if the OP has ever worked a day of her life?

if this was a party (it clearly isn’t!) it looks like a shit one.

Journeybacknorth · 10/05/2022 10:43

There are so many differences between a late night work dinner (and yes, a dinner with a local MP and her team after a day’s campaigning with said team in a large space suitable for social distancing does not scream party to me) and multiple, flagrant breaches of the rules in the first weeks of the pandemic and onwards are innumerable. I’m glad Starmer has said he will resign if fined, however I don’t think he will be as the evidence is just not there (despite the best efforts of the son of a right wing journo).

I’m also pleased that Starmer is taking personal responsibility and not placing the blame on advisers and staffers such as with Johnson and the ‘resignation’ of Allegra Stratton. It would have been easy for him to say he had no idea it was breaking the rules and he was merely assaulted with a curry…

The whole thing reeks of government desperation and I think a lot of people can see that.

Swayingpalmtrees · 10/05/2022 10:43

You are either choosing not to get it lonely or you actually don't get it.

Starmer and the rest of the party need to PROVE that they were working collectively post beer and Indian at 10pm - they need to PROVE they were having a break. This is the issue, they did not carry on working and returned to the hotel.

Therefore this dinner and drinks can NOT be considered a 'work break' because it was a post working dinner and drinks party, because everyone went back to the hotel afterwards. Therefore the reasons stretching their legs/having a break/everyone deserves to eat or the deflection simply does not and can not stand up as a defence.

The police know this which is why they resisted reopening the case
Starmers knows this, as his legal experience informs him that the evidence does not stack up

So who is primed to replace him???

That is the question?

Emily Thornberry?

OP posts:
ilovesooty · 10/05/2022 10:42

Swayingpalmtrees · 10/05/2022 10:24

The issue as far as I can see it:

They were not 'working' at the time, they can clearly be seen standing around and chatting, drinking beer.

Breaking for food during work would include sitting at the desk for five minutes and eating and for most companies a soft drink. There would be no need to stand around in a group drinking beer if you are claiming to be working!!

There is no mention of work continuing in the memo, only the 'dinner at Miners Hall' and then a walk back to the hotel. Had the memo also included resuming work/meeting/campaign planning then I think they would fair much better with the police investigation. The memo goes into great detail - and there lies the problem. There is NO mention of working/another meeting etc

Most people can see that this looks very much like an end of campaign dinner!! People are not stupid despite what the LP might think...

There is time stamped evidence of work continuing until after 1am.

And the OP and subsequent posts are ridiculous.

VanGoghsDog · 10/05/2022 10:42

Swayingpalmtrees · 10/05/2022 10:26

Sorry OP but you are being really naive. Plenty of jobs involve working late and/or pre-planned eating and drinking at 9pm

Not in a pandemic.

You're just making up rules now. There was no rule that said people couldn't work late. No rule that said people were not allowed to go to work. No limit on the number of people at work at any time. No rule that said you can't break fur food or drink.

As fir jobs where you can drink and work afterwards - any financial services job, frankly. And construction, the drinking culture is massive. I've been in several jobs where the kitchen had beer fridges.

And your assertion that they can't have been working because it was 9pm (clutch your pearls dear) is hilarious! It was in the run up to the election, they work all night!

Also, it was 2021, not 2020 which is when the No10 parties were, the rules were different. The rules (law!) that the police will need to reference.

Of course he's not "looking for an out", how ridiculous. And of course we can have leadership changes when there's a war, there's always a war somewhere. And there'd be a caretaker leader while a leadership election was run. Not a big deal at all.

ValerieCupcake · 10/05/2022 10:40

I actually think Keir doesn't want the job anymore. This is a way of getting out.

Comefromaway · 10/05/2022 10:40

Swayingpalmtrees · 10/05/2022 10:10

If I were caught drinking bottle of beer at work, I would be sacked immediately. They were clearly not working, it was 10pm at night!

That is your workplace. In my workplace it is very common to have a bottle of beer as long as you are not driving or operating machinery etc.

And LOTS of people work after 10pm at night.

BigWoollyJumpers · 10/05/2022 10:39

The fine that Boris has been given though is EXACTLY the same, if not slightly less so. He was out at a school visit in the morning, came back to the office, where all his own staff were working, people he worked with all and every day. Had a piece of cake and a drink, then sat down with the self same people for a cabinet meeting. His "party" was a break in the middle of the day between meetings.

The big garden party after work, was obviously against the rules and all those attending got fined.

I personally don't get care who gets fined, but I do care that the same rules have to apply whether you are in Durham or London. By the way, I don't think Keir should resign either, I think he has just painted himself into a corner, and the far left will take the opportunity with glee.

CloudPop · 10/05/2022 10:39

Swayingpalmtrees · 10/05/2022 10:18

Do you honestly think the British public will believe that he was working, even though they can see people standing around at nearly 9pm drinking beer and eating curry?

It will look like a police stitch up if they do not fine. There will be an uproar and a huge backlash if the police are not seen to be acting fairly and treating both parties equally.
If he is double bluffing that is a huge risk to take and one that might see the end of his career now.

Loads of jobs involve eating and drinking alcohol in the evenings on occasion. Mine does.

Swayingpalmtrees · 10/05/2022 10:38

It is going to take a lot more than one email sent from his hotel bed nancy he will need to prove the entire group continued to work together at the venue post beer at 10pm.

That is the point, and they didn't! And no one is suggesting that they did, least of all those present at the dinner party.

It has already been confirmed they returned to the hotel.

A works break is a break from work, what they will need to prove is that they collectively continued working afterwards, and indeed the work was 'essential' which is also questionable - as most meetings were taking place on zoom at that time. Social distancing was not observed due to the size of the room.

I think he has a big problem, and by extension the LP could be thrown into crisis.

OP posts:
Lonelycrab · 10/05/2022 10:38

They were not 'working' at the time, they can clearly be seen standing around and chatting, drinking beer

oh fgs when you’re eating your lunch at work, are you still using a computer, or writing, or serving customers, or whatever it is you do, at the same time?

Of course you don’t, you stop and eat.

SleeplessInEngland · 10/05/2022 10:37

There seems to be a lot of naivete on the working hours of Westminster higher-ups and their advisors/assistants, where stopping before midnight would count as 'an early one'.

GrendelsGrandma · 10/05/2022 10:36

What a load of partisan crap OP, they were working then they had some food.

It's not anything like as bad as multiple boozy parties with music, dancing etc in Downing St. Which mixed people from outside government with multiple teams working within government. They should have been siloed off to make sure everyone supposedly running the country didn't come down with Covid at once.

I think Boris Johnson should resign because he's taken a huge amount of cash from Russian donors, but one way or another he's finished.

TheKeatingFive · 10/05/2022 10:36

What's the definition of 'working' anyway?

Does checking email count? Responding to an email? Reviewing comms? What would be enough work to count as work?

its all getting a bit farcical