Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is Starmer seriously going to resign???

788 replies

Swayingpalmtrees · 10/05/2022 09:51

I have been waiting for a thread to come up about this, but I can't see one to date. I can't believe Keir Starmer has now said he will resign (and Angela Rayner as well) Potentially leaving the Labour party with no leader at all!

Looking at the 'evidence' that is well known and has been published, it appears the Indian takeaway was pre ordered (due to its size) and pre planned according to the staff at the Indian and the leaked memo, it did include quite a number of people and bottles of beer etc and drinking. It was late into the night, so not work related, and no one is suggesting anyone continued to work afterwards as it was so late. I don't see how this is any different to the No10 arrangements! So how on earth will they avoid a fine??

Sir Keir's speech was so wobbly I actually thought he was resigning there and then, and although I appreciate the sentiments of integrity and honour, where on earth does that leave the LP with under two years to the election or less?

Who would replace him? Do we have any thoughts on a plan of any kind?

I am kind of aghast, we are in the middle of a European war, on the cusp of potentially WW3, I am not sure this is a responsible action given the seriousness of our predicament with Russia whom are threatening us on a weekly basis with nuclear war. At the very very least, we need a firm hand on the tiller, so to speak, we do not have time to be squabbling over beer and cheese.
AIBU?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
TheKeatingFive · 10/05/2022 11:10

Whilst this might not be a practice everyone is aware of or that other professions such as nursing etc don't do it is by the by.

This isn't actually by the by.

while everything you say is familiar to people who work in certain types of corporate environments, there are plenty whose working practises are a million miles away from this. Traditional Labour heartlands will be full of people who this is true of and Starmers position won't sound particularly credible to many.

So even if he doesn't get fined, his reputation will suffer in those areas where he most needs to win support.

Journeybacknorth · 10/05/2022 11:10

People can see the photos of Starmer drinking and smiling - not working - inside with a large group and eating Indian, before sauntering back to the hotel. That is what will stay with them. They have since learned that this was all organised in advance with a memo stating 'Dinner at Miners Hall' which is an invitation to all intents and purposes.

Well here is one person who doesn’t see that as an invitation and does not have that image sitting with them.

A Prime Minister having such a weak grip on his own office that his principle private secretary is organising BYOB drinks parties and acts as an apologist for that culture - that sits with me.

Because let’s be real, it’s not exactly about the parties is it? It’s about what the response and intentions behind them say about our leaders’ characters. And Johnson’s ducking and diving, non-existent relationship with the truth and willingness to blame those junior to him are not the personality traits I welcome in the leader of our country.

Tryhard40 · 10/05/2022 11:10

Well he should, he's completely useless and labour will never win with him at the helm (and for that reason I hope he doesn't resign!)

stuntbubbles · 10/05/2022 11:08

People can see the photos of Starmer drinking and smiling - not working - inside with a large group and eating Indian, before sauntering back to the hotel.
Show me the laws against smiling while working, or smiling during a pandemic. Ditto the laws against sauntering.

Honestly, eat a spicy pakora and calm down.

Fairisleflora · 10/05/2022 11:08

I’m glad to say I think the British public are far far more intelligent than you give them credit for OP. They see this ‘equivalence’ as the bullshit it is! Boris Johnson was wrong, very wrong. Starmer was not as the police will find in due course. Starmer knows this hence yesterday’s pledge.

Hospedia · 10/05/2022 11:07

Memo? Do you mean the heavily redacted meeting agenda? Because honestly, who would have a meeting without providing the participants with an agenda and approximate timings? I worked in the civil service for years and never once typed up an agenda or provided a schedule, we used to just wing it. Show up when you want, present your items whenever you want, leave when you want.

Hmm
Swayingpalmtrees · 10/05/2022 11:07

I am not 'outraged' at all, but I am slightly puzzled how resigning in the middle of what is brewing up to be the biggest war of our time is helpful in the least.

I absolutely believe he will be fined, because the optics are so bad and the public won't buy a white wash.

Who on earth would replace him? That is what I am concerned about.

OP posts:
Swayingpalmtrees · 10/05/2022 11:06

They've produced proof that they did indeed continue to work afterwards

Where is the link that proves that????

OP posts:
liliainterfrutices · 10/05/2022 11:04

Why are people getting so hung up on the idea that it was 9 or 10 at night? Lots of us in jobs that appear to be 9-5 have work events at night. I'm quite often working well beyond 10. I think it's entirely credible that they went back to work afterwards. I don't think this is odd at all. And I like to have something to eat if I'm working that late.

Swayingpalmtrees · 10/05/2022 11:04

The damage has already been done in my view.

People can see the photos of Starmer drinking and smiling - not working - inside with a large group and eating Indian, before sauntering back to the hotel. That is what will stay with them. They have since learned that this was all organised in advance with a memo stating 'Dinner at Miners Hall' which is an invitation to all intents and purposes.

It is clear as day what they were doing, more fool anyone attempting a smoke screen.

Resigning if was all so innocent looks a little heavy handed? If he genuinely believed it to be innocent why not stand by his claims? Regardless of fining or police action.

OP posts:
StColumbofNavron · 10/05/2022 11:02

In most large corporate companies food is provided not so that you continue working afterwards but because you have worked sufficiently late that it would be unreasonable or impractical for you to travel home and be able to pick up food/cook. In more than one place I have worked this is 8pm. If you work until 8pm you can order in on the company. Sometimes, this would be when you finish and you would take it with you; sometimes a number of people might pool and sit in the canteen space and have their food together with or without a beer (which is available). They might then go home, or they might carry on working.

Whilst this might not be a practice everyone is aware of or that other professions such as nursing etc don't do it is by the by. It is a practice, and it is actual policy in lots of places. The places where it hasn't been actual policy have done this in my experience because it is a nice and decent thing to do when people are working long hours.

The onus is not on working after the meal, it is on the fact that they have worked until a sufficiently late time to warrant the meal.

SleeplessInEngland · 10/05/2022 11:02

"So, he'll be fined and resign. Im not sure where your outrage is coming from"

The OPs outrage is coming from the knowledge that he may not be fined.

I suspect they're actually the same tory hq poster who haunts this forum, just with countless name changes. Very much the same 'never mention johnson but anything the opposition does is terrible' energy.

Luculentus · 10/05/2022 11:01

It was late into the night, so not work related, and no one is suggesting anyone continued to work afterwards as it was so late.

They've produced proof that they did indeed continue to work afterwards. It really is quite common when electioneering, hence the fact they built it into the timetable.

HerculesMulligan · 10/05/2022 11:01

WhatATimeToBeAlive · 10/05/2022 10:51

Working, with beer? OK then. I'd be sacked if I worked while drinking beer, never mind resign with "integrity".

In your job, but not in his or in mine. The Commons does lots of its business in Parliament's bars, as James Cleverly said last week. I work in publishing and on occasions where people are working late, it's very common for pizza and beers to be ordered in. I know in teaching (for example) the rules are rightly much stricter, but it isn't the case here.

MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 10/05/2022 11:01

< Sorry, not sooty >

MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 10/05/2022 11:00

MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 10/05/2022 10:54

Yes, even in a pandemic

Sooty - complete failure to quite the message I was responding to (Ie another inane message from OP to tbe effect tbat people didn’t work together late into the night - and eat - during a pandemic)

SickAndTiredAgain · 10/05/2022 11:00

He has not said at any point that he continued to work at the venue post beer and Indian, and nor will he because it is not true. They have got him over a barrel with the memo.

So, he'll be fined and resign. Im not sure where your outrage is coming from. The police haven't said they won't fine him (which you would clearly disagree with), and he will resign if they do.

From your posts, you are totally confident he'll be fined, and him resigning seems like something you'd want. You should be happy with the turn of events.

I also think he should resign if fined, I think it would untenable not to given what he has said about Johnson and Sunak. And now he's said he will, so it's all good.

Luculentus · 10/05/2022 11:00

I don't think he is going to resign because I can't see how any valid FPN can be issued against him. But I think he absolutely means it. Unlike Johnson, he is a man of his word.

Swayingpalmtrees · 10/05/2022 11:00

I think Starmer has had enough and wants an 'out'. I think Sunak will resign eventually too

I actually think there is something to this, given how badly the tories have performed in the last six months (and well before) with party gate, porn watching etc etc if Labour can not win a landslide on the backdrop of such incompetence then when can they? The local election results beyond London were pretty dire, it should have been a free win for the Labour but it was not.

There is a serious problem of another Islington suit running the party without the credentials to be able to win back the heartlands. They stand no chance in the election if the latest results are anything to go by, and perhaps Starmer is sick of flogging a dead horse? It is futile and an honourable resignation will preserve his next career move.

OP posts:
Hospedia · 10/05/2022 10:58

I can't attach the whole menu s its too many photos but here are some examples

Is Starmer seriously going to resign???
Is Starmer seriously going to resign???
Is Starmer seriously going to resign???
MarshaBradyo · 10/05/2022 10:57

elastamum · 10/05/2022 10:52

I suspect that Starmer's team have a way better grasp of the law than the op, who is sounding increasingly like a young Tory staffer desperate to impress. With the exception of frothing DM readers, nobody thinks this is anything like the 2020 Downing Street party season.

I just brought this up with a group of people (adhoc not same social circle) the key thing that came up was will he resign - and that he’ll have to if fined, painted in a corner etc

I don’t think people care that much at this stage re the nuance of it all unless invested politically

stuntbubbles · 10/05/2022 10:57

Ordering a sandwich/takeaway and sitting at your desk/or elsewhere eating it before resuming work is a 'work related' break
Is it the standing up that bothers you? You don’t have to resume work afterwards for it to be a break. And in any case if he resumed work back at the hotel he fulfils your imaginary criteria:

Did some work
Ate some food
Resumed work (at a new venue)

VanGoghsDog · 10/05/2022 10:57

WhatATimeToBeAlive · 10/05/2022 10:51

Working, with beer? OK then. I'd be sacked if I worked while drinking beer, never mind resign with "integrity".

But that's not the case in all jobs. Your individual experience has no impact on this issue.

TheKeatingFive · 10/05/2022 10:57

I didn't say it couldn't.

well I doubt many would think it justifies Johnson's actions, so I'd be careful using it to justify Starmers.

Although I doubt his interior designer or his baby were involved in those work discussions.

Not particularly relevant to this discussion. In Johnson's case his home is also a place of work, so bringing the baby into it is a red herring.

jaundicedoutlook · 10/05/2022 10:57

DH worked in politics a long time ago (actually for the Tories, when they were more sensible) and it is totally normal to arrange a takeaway / pizzas etc for the people who have been working. Lockdown didn't prevent this and campaigning was legal.

Starmer says he then worked afterwards, and I'd be fairly surprised if they couldn't prove this with emails, messages, etc.

BJ, on the other hand, appears to have just ignored the rules and did as he liked. Wine Fridays, Cummings leaving celebration, and so on and on and on.

Seems to me there is a good deal of difference between the two situations, but obviously benefits BJ to pursue a line that essentially drags everyone down to his level of mendacity and bullshittery.