Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is Starmer seriously going to resign???

788 replies

Swayingpalmtrees · 10/05/2022 09:51

I have been waiting for a thread to come up about this, but I can't see one to date. I can't believe Keir Starmer has now said he will resign (and Angela Rayner as well) Potentially leaving the Labour party with no leader at all!

Looking at the 'evidence' that is well known and has been published, it appears the Indian takeaway was pre ordered (due to its size) and pre planned according to the staff at the Indian and the leaked memo, it did include quite a number of people and bottles of beer etc and drinking. It was late into the night, so not work related, and no one is suggesting anyone continued to work afterwards as it was so late. I don't see how this is any different to the No10 arrangements! So how on earth will they avoid a fine??

Sir Keir's speech was so wobbly I actually thought he was resigning there and then, and although I appreciate the sentiments of integrity and honour, where on earth does that leave the LP with under two years to the election or less?

Who would replace him? Do we have any thoughts on a plan of any kind?

I am kind of aghast, we are in the middle of a European war, on the cusp of potentially WW3, I am not sure this is a responsible action given the seriousness of our predicament with Russia whom are threatening us on a weekly basis with nuclear war. At the very very least, we need a firm hand on the tiller, so to speak, we do not have time to be squabbling over beer and cheese.
AIBU?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
Luculentus · 10/05/2022 11:20

Swayingpalmtrees · 10/05/2022 10:10

If I were caught drinking bottle of beer at work, I would be sacked immediately. They were clearly not working, it was 10pm at night!

I wouldn't. I used to work in a place where they kept available a stock of beer and wine, mostly for entertaining clients, but quite regularly they would offer it round by way of a celebration or just because, say, it was a hot Friday afternoon.

I'm really amazed that anyone seriously believes no-one works at 10 p.m. Coming up to an election, everyone does whatever it takes, including working all night if necessary.

VanGoghsDog · 10/05/2022 11:20

Swayingpalmtrees · 10/05/2022 11:15

I think Starmer would have been wise to wait until the second police investigation has been concluded before making a decision and a statement.

Now most of us are simply waiting for him to go, and worried about the next leader and who it might be.

No we're not at all.

TitsInAbsentia · 10/05/2022 11:20

I've worked in many different industries where a late meal is provided if working past a certain time, and I've often pre-ordered them for the team before I leave for the day, but NEVER have I ordered alcohol for such a meal - that would be a no-no, I mean you are meant to still be working and alcohol even in small quantities can affect judgement (another reason why there should be no bars in the Houses).

BUT
It's report to be have been £200 for the order, with up to 30 people there...so that's £6.66 per person. That's not going to get you a bhuna let alone a beer, so things aren't adding up!

VanGoghsDog · 10/05/2022 11:19

A few emails fired off at 1am won't cut it.

Why not? Can you link to the law you are relying on here please? Remember, the police will be making their decision based on the law that was in place at the time. Not "fairness", "optics" or weird public perception.

You seem very sure of the "facts" you are spouting yet unwilling to back them up.

kirinm · 10/05/2022 11:18

Ha! @Swayingpalmtrees you can't hide your political leanings. £200 for a takeaway for 15 people (note that the good old Daily Mail have reduced the number of people supposedly there) is a good deal. Can easily spend £40 between two here.

Labour seem pretty confident that they did nothing wrong so I'll guess we will see.

The tories already looking like the shysters they are with Kit Malthouse suggesting that it was for Kier Starmer to set his own standards whereas apparently Johnson will set his own i.e. none. And moron Andrew Bridgen thinking that the Met should investigate ffs. He didn't shout that when Durham didn't find any wrong doing with Cummings driving up north for childcare with covid. The Tory party are a joke. An unprincipled corrupt joke of a party.

Jajana · 10/05/2022 11:18

OP we are not in a middle of a European war…

Luculentus · 10/05/2022 11:18

Swayingpalmtrees · 10/05/2022 10:26

Sorry OP but you are being really naive. Plenty of jobs involve working late and/or pre-planned eating and drinking at 9pm

Not in a pandemic.

That's just bizarre. Why does work that needs to be done late suddenly stop during a pandemic? My DB, for instance, works in an environment where he regularly has to deal with people in different time zones and was regularly working late. He and his colleagues were certainly permitted to eat together whilst doing so. The rules allowed for gatherings for work purposes precisely to meet that type of eventuality.

Furthermore, the rules specifically provided an exemption for gatherings that were "reasonably necessary for the purposes of campaigning in an election". How are the police going to make out a case for saying they know more about what was reasonably necessary for election campaign purposes than the people actually doing the campaigning?

SleeplessInEngland · 10/05/2022 11:18

"I think Starmer would have been wise to wait until the second police investigation has been concluded before making a decision and a statement."

You sound like the Daily Mail - their writers are currently furious that Starmer's called their bluff with the resignation pledge. "How dare he put pressure on the police, etc etc."

Journeybacknorth · 10/05/2022 11:18

As an aside, I am not too concerned if he does go. Unlike the Conservative party, I think there are good, competent people in high levels who could make strong leaders. Johnson has expertly led a government of such ineptitude to ensure that any question of him resigning is followed by the question of “but who could possible replace him?”.

Swayingpalmtrees · 10/05/2022 11:17

In Durham 10gbp per head is generous! You can see the menu for yourself. By your own calculations there were at least twenty present.

I am constantly amazed at the price differences in areas north of London, but that is a great deal of money for an Indian for six people, perhaps its Michelin starred! Grin

OP posts:
Fairisleflora · 10/05/2022 11:17

I’m not worried about him going. He won’t have to. I’m not worried about his replacement. I mean even Corbyn would be able to to a better job than Johnson, and he’s a complete and utter nutter.

TheKeatingFive · 10/05/2022 11:17

I'm sure the proverbial salt of the earth miners in their flat caps can tell the difference between a working dinner and full-on party.

Youre being a little naive if you think everyone will be accepting of beer and an Indian takeaway as a working dinner.

Slinkymalinky03 · 10/05/2022 11:17

Potentially leaving the Labour party with no leader at all!

The party won't be left without a leader. There will be another leadership contest to elect both leader and deputy.

Hospedia · 10/05/2022 11:16

Moonmelodies · 10/05/2022 11:12

Working? If his job is the MP for Holborn, in London, what aspect of doing that job caused him to be in Durham?

The local elections.... He is the Labour leader and, like all political parties, there was an election campaign going on.

SleeplessInEngland · 10/05/2022 11:16

"while everything you say is familiar to people who work in certain types of corporate environments, there are plenty whose working practises are a million miles away from this. Traditional Labour heartlands will be full of people who this is true of and Starmers position won't sound particularly credible to many."

I'm sure the proverbial salt of the earth miners in their flat caps can tell the difference between a working dinner and full-on party. They may not vote Labour for other reasons but let's give them some credit.

Swayingpalmtrees · 10/05/2022 11:15

I think Starmer would have been wise to wait until the second police investigation has been concluded before making a decision and a statement.

Now most of us are simply waiting for him to go, and worried about the next leader and who it might be.

OP posts:
Hospedia · 10/05/2022 11:13

Swayingpalmtrees · 10/05/2022 11:07

I am not 'outraged' at all, but I am slightly puzzled how resigning in the middle of what is brewing up to be the biggest war of our time is helpful in the least.

I absolutely believe he will be fined, because the optics are so bad and the public won't buy a white wash.

Who on earth would replace him? That is what I am concerned about.

During WW1 we had two Prime Ministers and two during WW2. Keir Starmer isn't the Prime Minister but even if he was, so what? We're not actually at war and there is a precedent set for changing leader when we actually are.

jaundicedoutlook · 10/05/2022 11:13

Moonmelodies · 10/05/2022 11:12

Working? If his job is the MP for Holborn, in London, what aspect of doing that job caused him to be in Durham?

Er, the job of being Leader of the Opposition...

VanGoghsDog · 10/05/2022 11:12

Swayingpalmtrees · 10/05/2022 11:04

The damage has already been done in my view.

People can see the photos of Starmer drinking and smiling - not working - inside with a large group and eating Indian, before sauntering back to the hotel. That is what will stay with them. They have since learned that this was all organised in advance with a memo stating 'Dinner at Miners Hall' which is an invitation to all intents and purposes.

It is clear as day what they were doing, more fool anyone attempting a smoke screen.

Resigning if was all so innocent looks a little heavy handed? If he genuinely believed it to be innocent why not stand by his claims? Regardless of fining or police action.

NO SMILING ALLOWED AT WORK!!!!

Moonmelodies · 10/05/2022 11:12

Working? If his job is the MP for Holborn, in London, what aspect of doing that job caused him to be in Durham?

RebelNotHon · 10/05/2022 11:11

It's grandstanding—more Starmer smoke and mirrors; no substance.

Luculentus · 10/05/2022 11:11

Swayingpalmtrees · 10/05/2022 10:09

I agree able that we have a war raging in Europe, having a coherent opposition party is incredibly important at the moment. Starmer may not be PM but the opposition are expected to partake in many decisions made across all parties to do with security etc.

I think there is a very real chance of a fine actually.

There are photos of the people drinking inside, there is evidence of Indian food to the tune of 200gbp being pre ordered, so clearly for a large gathering at least. How would the police not fine for this? The memo concludes the party was organised in advance, they were drinking and there are photos to support.

I am wondering how the police can come to any other conclusion given the rules at the time?

The rules at the time allowed for work-related gatherings.

How does £200 for Indian food plus drinks equate to "a large gathering at least"? Even at £10 a head (which would be very modest) that's only 20 people. Organising it in advance simply demonstrates that it was planned as a work event. Drinking doesn't make it any less of a work event.

A further factor is that this was part of the electoral democratic process. The police would be treading on very dangerous ground indeed if they want to say that what a major political party deemed necessary by way of preparations for an election was unlawful. Has anyone actually investigated what the other candidates were doing over the relevant period?

Swayingpalmtrees · 10/05/2022 11:11

The police investigation will look into proof that work was conducted during and after the drinks and dinner if the defence of a work related break is to be believed, and yes the Labour Party will have to provide proof. A few emails fired off at 1am won't cut it.

The underlying issue here is one of fairness and justice.
If you are going to fine one political party for food and drink consumption in a group etc then you have to apply the same measure to the other party.

There is no reason why the party should have happened at all, the safest decision would be for all members to return to the hotel and safely order room service. They choose to organise the beers, they choose to organise a group dinner - no collective work happened during or after... that is the core issue.

A fine is coming. For sure.

OP posts:
jaundicedoutlook · 10/05/2022 11:11

Swayingpalmtrees · 10/05/2022 11:06

They've produced proof that they did indeed continue to work afterwards

Where is the link that proves that????

According to the press, an email log and evidence has been provided to the police, rather than being published for random strangers on the internet.

Lonelycrab · 10/05/2022 11:11

I’m glad to say I think the British public are far far more intelligent than you give them credit for OP. They see this ‘equivalence’ as the bullshit it is!

This^