Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL didn't accept Mother's Day gift

258 replies

Gina97 · 09/05/2022 21:02

So I got my MIL a $25 Starbucks gift card for Mother's Day. We have a newborn so I wanted to get her something easy. She came by yesterday and when I went to give her the gift she told me and my husband that she didn't like Starbucks and didn't take the gift. I didn't make a big deal of it but am I right in thinking that this is insanely rude?

OP posts:
cocktailclub · 11/05/2022 06:57

Don't buy her a gift again. It's rude behaviour.
My in-laws were always rude about gifts tbh that I'd put lots of thought into such as a fancy tea set, a teasmaid and a blender. They would announce they'd given them to their daughter or say "what did you get that for?"
I stopped buying gifts and left it to my husband who mainly forgot.
Years later and they began to be more appreciative

NumberTheory · 11/05/2022 01:26

Needmorelego · 10/05/2022 22:30

@NumberTheory my mother in law is always perfectly happy with a cup of coffee and biscuits and really doesn't care who is the person that actually makes it.
Her relationship with her son (my husband) and her other son and daughter is amazing. They are a very close family.
They don't need big fancy gestures to show this.

But this thread isn't about your MiL loving a cup of coffee and some biscuits. It's about OP's MiL, who did not seem to appreciate the Mother's Day gesture she received.

LizzieW1969 · 11/05/2022 00:06

mathanxiety · 10/05/2022 22:36

Nobody is saying this is about the specific gift here, @SirChenjins.

The point is that the DH should have bought it (or anything else for that matter) for his own mother.

Leaving it to your wife who has just given birth, or in any circumstances, is lazy, entitled behaviour.

I agree with this absolutely. It would never occur to my DH to expect me to organise presents for his DM or for anyone in his own family. Similarly, I always take care of my family’s presents.

it clear, though, that the OP always organises her MIL’s presents, so it appears unlikely to me that this is the reason why she responded in the way she did to the voucher.

mathanxiety · 10/05/2022 22:36

Nobody is saying this is about the specific gift here, @SirChenjins.

The point is that the DH should have bought it (or anything else for that matter) for his own mother.

Leaving it to your wife who has just given birth, or in any circumstances, is lazy, entitled behaviour.

Needmorelego · 10/05/2022 22:30

@NumberTheory my mother in law is always perfectly happy with a cup of coffee and biscuits and really doesn't care who is the person that actually makes it.
Her relationship with her son (my husband) and her other son and daughter is amazing. They are a very close family.
They don't need big fancy gestures to show this.

SirChenjins · 10/05/2022 22:12

I’m surprised that so many adult women are so hung up on Mother’s Day that they weigh up the perceived value of a gift card and decide that there’s not quite enough thought gone into it and that only a present from their actual offspring will suffice (as opposed to the adult who happened to be at the shops that day or online). It must be utterly exhausting to be in some of your families - the utter drama over nothing.

So many surprising surprises on this thread - it’s a wonder we’re not all reading it open mouthed in amazement.

NumberTheory · 10/05/2022 22:04

Needmorelego · 10/05/2022 16:36

@NumberTheory making a couple of cups of coffee plus grabbing a pack of biscuits/cakes is 'skivvying' now is it? Blimey.
I made my late father in law a sandwich once. Oh the horror. How dare me 🤣
I was actually really excited because I made a lemon curd sandwich for someone other than me for the first time ever in my life. He probably would have got a sensible ham sandwich if my husband had made it. Father in law has a naughty sweet tooth so he was probably quite pleased that I happened to be the one who wandered into the kitchen and said "who wants a sandwich?".

If your DH's idea of treating his mum for Mother's Day is to invite her round and have you make a cup of coffee and open a pack of biscuits then skivvying probably doesn't apply, but it's certainly not something I would expect his mum to take as a gesture of his appreciation for her and her role in his life.

The point here isn't that OP sometimes does domestic stuff for DH's relatives. It's that this is supposed to be a Mother's Day gift. And MiL's child (DH) appears to have done fuck all about it other than nod assent when a gift card is suggested. So in the spirit of "it's the thought that counts" it's not surprising that many people seem to think that the thought that was supposed to be behind this gift was absent.

Sswhinesthebest · 10/05/2022 20:55

Evangeli · 10/05/2022 18:38

I am actually appalled at the people who "refuse gifts they don't like as they think it is a waste of money"
Wtaf
It is very rude.
Please do not refuse gifts you won't like. Be gracious about receiving the gift, and then re-gift or donate it. Do not tell the gift-giver: no- take this back- I don't like this and don't want to waste your money. Repeat: that is a very rude thing to do.

I guess it depends on your relationships.

I wouldn’t do it with friends but with my family, we love and respect each other, and we speak our minds. No one would take offence at this. Know your audience.

SirChenjins · 10/05/2022 20:07

mathanxiety · 10/05/2022 19:14

Happy for you and your H, @Needmorelego.

You seem to have found a respectful system that works for you, exactly as I would advise.
You talk to each other.
You don't take each other for granted.

Congratulations, you are adulting!

Or in other words, you are taking care of the grown up shit - the life admin, as it were - that grown ups take care of, either on your own or in respectful co-operation with each other.

@SirChenjins - maybe you have never experienced the corrosive effect in your life or your relationship if you have one of item after item being placed on a wife's To Do list by a so-called life partner.

If that is the case, I'm happy for you.

I assure you the effects of this phenomenon are both real and unpleasant for the person being taken for granted.

I am reassured by your assurances, I assure you @mathanxiety

I can only imagine you missed the bit about the OP being Starbucks in your desperation to explain ‘adulting’ to other posters.

Abraxan · 10/05/2022 19:51

I know SleepingStandingUp! Shocker.

To make it worse - it was a chocolate shop and I 'made' him buy me some for myself to eat that evening too, not even as a mother's day gift for me(I am not his mum after all Grin )
Though I was kind, once he got back from the detour I forced upon him I did let him have a little taste of my chocolate as a reward for doing the hard work for me! 🍫

Abraxan · 10/05/2022 19:39

GreenFingersWouldBeHandy · 09/05/2022 22:43

She's your DH's mother, not yours. Why are you buying the gift?

And if she didn't like it then use it yourself. But $25 on coffee? Blimey.

You don't have to spend it all in one go!

Dd loves getting Starbucks and Costa vouchers as part of her gift, usually one added from family for her especially since she went to university. She has them on her loyalty card thing and spends them gradually in the following weeks, on coffee, smoothie things, the odd snack. She also likes that she gains points from her voucher spends so gets a double benefit.

SleepingStandingUp · 10/05/2022 19:39

Abraxan · 10/05/2022 19:35

It's weird. Any men buying Mothers Day gifts for their MIL? I doubt it.

Dh was the one who called at the shop, bought and paid for my mum's MIL gift. He also got MIL's this year. The shops were in town near where he works.

The gifts were joint decisions and came from joint income.

Sometimes I will order and buy, sometimes dh will go to a shop and buy (he works in town, I tend to do online shops more than him.) Works for us and we aren't precious about mine/your jobs, we both just get on with it all.

Omg you're such a bitch. Buy your own mother a present. She GREW you and you can't even bother to trek to somewhere your husband is yo buy something he could easily have picked up because you're a terrible human being and your adding to his husband work. Poor man. I bet he doesn't even know which mother is his with all this stress you're piled on his shoulders with your thoughtless arrogance that there will be some man there to pick up the slack for your poor daughter ING.

SleepingStandingUp · 10/05/2022 19:37

A grown man whose wife has just had a baby buys his own mother a gift for Mother's Day. This saves his wife the bother of adding yet one more thing to her already hard-working-on-little-sleep-post-partum brain. you realise op was IN Starbucks tho, right? She likes it, it's the only coffee shop in town so she'd gone to visit Starbucks because wanted to. Decided to get the gift card for Mom. Literally all she did extra was drop hi ma text and say "make it two gift cards please" and then trek home with the extra Wight of the second gift card lying heavily on the pram. She didn't trek a mountain for yak milk jewellery.

Abraxan · 10/05/2022 19:35

It's weird. Any men buying Mothers Day gifts for their MIL? I doubt it.

Dh was the one who called at the shop, bought and paid for my mum's MIL gift. He also got MIL's this year. The shops were in town near where he works.

The gifts were joint decisions and came from joint income.

Sometimes I will order and buy, sometimes dh will go to a shop and buy (he works in town, I tend to do online shops more than him.) Works for us and we aren't precious about mine/your jobs, we both just get on with it all.

Abraxan · 10/05/2022 19:33

A voucher is a very normal gift, albeit not personal or specific to a recipient, and common courtesy says you accept very normal gifts with good grace. If you can't or don't want it, you discretely EPA's sit on to someone who will.

Basic manners cost nothing. MIL was rude.

OP was not rude. She gave her MiL a very normal gift. It was a 'quick gift' due to circumstances this year but she knew MIL went to Starbucks occasionally and has family who works there who have seen MIL there. So it's not a gift that would be an obvious concern or which would, in some way, offend the MIl.

Wouldn't mind, but this thread with people claiming it's a rubbish gift yet MN often recommends money or vouchers on present threads 🤷‍♀️

mathanxiety · 10/05/2022 19:14

Happy for you and your H, @Needmorelego.

You seem to have found a respectful system that works for you, exactly as I would advise.
You talk to each other.
You don't take each other for granted.

Congratulations, you are adulting!

Or in other words, you are taking care of the grown up shit - the life admin, as it were - that grown ups take care of, either on your own or in respectful co-operation with each other.

@SirChenjins - maybe you have never experienced the corrosive effect in your life or your relationship if you have one of item after item being placed on a wife's To Do list by a so-called life partner.

If that is the case, I'm happy for you.

I assure you the effects of this phenomenon are both real and unpleasant for the person being taken for granted.

Needmorelego · 10/05/2022 19:08

@mathanxiety well luckily me and my husband don't take it for granted that one of us will take on the others 'grown up shit year after year'.
We just talk to each other and don't care who does this/who does that nonsense.
You seem to really hate gifts though. One minute they're 'life admin', the next 'grown up shit'.
Funny... I always thought gifts were meant to be a nice thing.

airrrrAIRRRRiELLLL · 10/05/2022 19:05

Seeing as op actually handed over the thoughtful gift to mil (on Mother's Day) I'm now interested to know whether she wrote the card as well. Just wondered if that was another irritation to mil. Confused

SirChenjins · 10/05/2022 19:00

Knock yourself out.

mathanxiety · 10/05/2022 18:58

Wifework: What Marriage Really Means for Women, by Susan Maushart...
Combining her own personal experiences as a twice-married mother of three with extensive research and statistical evidence, a fascinating foray into history examines the theoretical and evolutionary reasons behind marital inequity.

www.amazon.co.uk/Wifework-Marriage-Really-Means-Woman/dp/1582342024

Highly recommended.

SirChenjins · 10/05/2022 18:57

Life admin - good grief. What a ridiculous over reaction.

mathanxiety · 10/05/2022 18:53

@Needmorelego is buying a gift a question of a thought popping into your head at the last minute and ducking into whatever shop you happen to be passing to get it, or is it sometimes more complicated than that?

You have clearly missed the entire point of my last few posts.

Again -

Planning, ordering/ buying gifts for your mother is something you should do yourself. (Aka, adulting).

Assuming your partner will take on this life admin task just because she has a vagina and a pair of tits capable of lactation is disrespectful.

It is the last word in laziness and entitlement to leave this detail of life admin to your partner when she has just had a baby.

A partner of either sex can of course ask their OH for help if it's needed when gift giving time comes around, for minor details like picking something up after the work of deciding what to buy/ordering has already been done.

It should never be taken for granted that a wife or husband will automatically take care of your grown up shit for you year after year - the planning and execution of details around gift giving for their own family of origin is up to each adult to do themselves.

Evangeli · 10/05/2022 18:38

I am actually appalled at the people who "refuse gifts they don't like as they think it is a waste of money"
Wtaf
It is very rude.
Please do not refuse gifts you won't like. Be gracious about receiving the gift, and then re-gift or donate it. Do not tell the gift-giver: no- take this back- I don't like this and don't want to waste your money. Repeat: that is a very rude thing to do.

Needmorelego · 10/05/2022 18:34

@mathanxiety or a husband and wife could just work together and whichever is the most convenient thing to do is the one that gets done.
The OP bought the vouchers. Big deal. Maybe a daily walk with the pram takes her past Starbucks.
Your theory that grown ups should do their own 'life admin' means that if I wanted to buy my mum a m+s voucher I should travel the half an hour (so an hour out of my day) or so it takes me to get to the nearest branch - of course that includes paying bus fare.
Or my husband could grab one on his way home from work because he passes a branch everyday on his commute. Oh but no... how dare he? That's MY 'life admin' 🙄
(Since when is buying a gift admin?)

mathanxiety · 10/05/2022 18:28

A grown woman is perfectly entitled to send a birthday gift or Mother's Day gift, or Christmas gift, whatever, to her MIL.

From herself.

Doing all the gift spadework on behalf of this woman's son - I would strongly advise her not to do that.