Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To consider private schools due to the longer school day?

135 replies

Workingawayfromhomenow · 09/05/2022 19:33

It isn’t the only consideration by a long shot but it is a consideration, as we would struggle otherwise. I realise people do manage of course but interested in knowing if this was a factor for anyone else when choosing a school.

OP posts:
Walkingthedog46 · 09/05/2022 21:20

The private school my daughter attended offered ‘daily boarding’ as well as full boarding. This involved dropping off before 8.00 am, then staying on after school for tea, then prep followed by music/clubs/sport, etc. Then supper and pick up by 7.00 pm.

Workingawayfromhomenow · 09/05/2022 21:20

Thanks @NameChange30 but no sorry - I don’t see being on AIBU as a reason / excuse / call it what you will to be really rude in response to a simple and polite question. I don’t mean you, by the way, but there have been some really sarky and ‘cutting’ responses and there has been absolutely no need.

OP posts:
NameChange30 · 09/05/2022 21:15

Sorry about your miscarriage OP Flowers
AIBU is really not the place to be right now!

Workingawayfromhomenow · 09/05/2022 21:12

And you know - I don’t normally do this but what the hell. I’m actually dealing with a miscarriage at the moment and am trying to take my mind off it by thinking about what’s best for the child I do have. So beg my pardon for not giving my full biography in the OP Hmm

And yes, that’s unfair of me as no one could have known that but some of this snippy, sarky, acerbic responses are really not what I needed (and no, being on AIBU is not a good enough reason for it.)

OP posts:
Zuma76 · 09/05/2022 21:11

AProperStinging · 09/05/2022 19:59

This just isn't true. I went to a private school from year 7 to year 11. School day ran from 8.35am to 4.00pm. With London travel, I was out of the house every single day from 7.25am to 5.00pm. Then hours of homework. It was shit. I hated it.

My kids go to our local state school. School day is 8.45am to 2.45pm. Their travel time is 5 mins on foot. they actually have a life outside school.

Lovely for all of you parents I'm sure. Utterly shit for the kids.

My DD goes to school 8am to 5.15pm most days and loves it. Her school day ends at 4.15 and then she has after school activities. It isn’t shit for all children having long school days.

Workingawayfromhomenow · 09/05/2022 21:10

And I don’t think posters ‘hate’ private schools but every so often you do get bristly sort of attitudes that it’s a ‘waste of money’ and stories of state educated children who have gone on to do fabulous things which is brilliant for them but not really what I am posting for!

OP posts:
Workingawayfromhomenow · 09/05/2022 21:09

@Hardbackwriter Normally, you’re fabulous, but on this occasion I’m going to disagree. I’m not on trial at the stand here.

The longer school day means I can drop off and pick up and not worry about childcare at either side. It really is as simple as that. It isn’t the only factor but it is a pretty important one.

OP posts:
Hardbackwriter · 09/05/2022 21:07

The reason that posters are responding to you as they are isn't because they hate private schools, it's because your phrasing is misleading. You're not considering private school 'due' to the longer day, you're considering private school and the longer day is one among a range of advantages that you think it offers.

NameChange30 · 09/05/2022 21:07

Workingawayfromhomenow · 09/05/2022 20:31

We live in a very small village. The village school only has 70 children in the whole school (which does put me off) and no wraparound care and the next nearest primary school is in the opposite direction to my workplace in a small town where the school isn’t great. I’m sure we could find a childminder there but I don’t really want to use that school anyway.

There is a private school around the corner to where I work, and there is wraparound care included in school fees between 8-5 which is perfect.

It isn’t purely money, but sometimes you do pay for an easier life. Cleaners, Amazon prime and the like.

Well if you'd put all that in your OP, I would have said I understand why you're leaning towards the private school. It's not just wraparound care, it's location too. And you don't like the state options. Although I do wonder where people get their opinions from because when I researched primary schools, there were a lot of out-of-date opinions based on past reputation and very old ofsted reports... things do change, especially if head teachers change.

Anyway, it's not just about the wraparound care, so it does seem strange to make the thread just about that.

RootinandTootin · 09/05/2022 21:06

I have had an awful experience with my DD private school. It’s very small and she’s in her final year. Was permanently excluded (won’t go into detail but for mental health issues). Their terms and conditions are unfair, they aren’t legally bound by Norma school rules/procedures and are free to make their own rules. For example any disciplinary in this private school was at the discretion of the head. She wasn’t required to investigate claims. If your child is excluded they don’t have any obligation to help you find another school or give school work to your child in the interim. As you can imagine this happening in the January your child is in their last year is horrendous. I know this is probably a very niche post but don’t fall into the pitfalls of private school!

bluebellwoods55 · 09/05/2022 21:06

Lots of parents at my dd's private school like the idea of the wrap around care. It's given by the same staff who are there everyday, including holiday clubs too.

SpringLobelia · 09/05/2022 21:05

Notthesportytype · 09/05/2022 19:39

Private day schools don't usually have a significantly longer day than state schools.
The holidays are usually longer though.

Our private school has registration at 8.30 and finishes at 4.30 as the core hours. After school clubs go to either 5.30 pm or 6 pm. Our local state school is 8.45 to 2.45 core hours. Not sure about afterschool arrangments though.

Workingawayfromhomenow · 09/05/2022 21:02

Thanks @vera16 - it does seem it’s a factor then, even if bizarre to some!

OP posts:
Workingawayfromhomenow · 09/05/2022 21:01

@Clymene we love our house. I don’t ‘hate’ the local school but am aware that very small schools can sometimes bring with them their own problems - and wraparound is an issue.

I certainly wasn’t thinking of changing to state at secondary: I think that would be very unsettling.

OP posts:
vera16 · 09/05/2022 21:01

Workingawayfromhomenow · 09/05/2022 20:01

No one is saying that private school is cheaper than wraparound care at a state school, but if you can’t get wraparound care at a good state school, then I was wondering if this was potentially a factor influencing anybody else’s decision?

Yes me. I would have turned down the state school place and gone private had I not got the wraparound place. It is massively over-subscribed (the wraparound) and there are hardly any local childminders who can pick up. Also with a longer school day you may be able to get away with less wraparound when they are a bit older and can entertain themselves for an hour after school.

OnceuponaRainbow18 · 09/05/2022 20:59

Mine stay til 4.30 for £6!!

Clymene · 09/05/2022 20:59

It seems pretty baffling to choose to live in a small village where you hate the local school provision when you clearly could afford to live somewhere else. Going from private at primary to state at secondary is hard so once you've committed to private, you're locked in for close on half a mill for 2 kids.

Workingawayfromhomenow · 09/05/2022 20:57

Thanks @Angrymum22 - it’s good to hear it was a factor that influenced other peoples choices too.

OP posts:
Workingawayfromhomenow · 09/05/2022 20:57

Of course it is about childcare. Sometimes, we would have no one to pick up or drop off and need help with this. Our local school don’t have wraparound care, and so we do need to find a school that does. The only ones that do within catchment distance go the opposite direction to where I work, so not a very practical choice (or great one in other terms) so am thinking outside the box a bit.

We can afford it but will notice it: we aren’t hugely wealthy. So it is a big decision.

OP posts:
Angrymum22 · 09/05/2022 20:56

Yes it was a consideration for us. The fees included wrap around care. I could drop DS off at 7.45am and pick him up at 5.45pm. He is an only child and loved the time after school to play out with friends. He built up a number of friends outside of his year who were regulars at after school club. He was also able to attend after school sports clubs.
I I turned up early I would have to wait for him to finish playing.
At senior school he also makes full use of after school sports clubs.
As a result he is pretty independent and has been happy to use the school bus, never worries if I’m running late and very sociable.
I was also able to make use of holiday clubs since it was usually the same children who attended late clubs. It was lovely to watch him with the little ones for whom he had a great deal of patience.

mummyrocks1 · 09/05/2022 20:53

They days really aren't that much longer but the holidays are.

Dibbydoos · 09/05/2022 20:51

Workingawayfromhomenow · 09/05/2022 20:48

You do ‘get it’ @Dibbydoos , so I’m not sure why you’re pretending you don’t.

What? No idea what subtext this even is!

I'm telling you tp be honest with yourself. Your post is not about childcare is it?

Workingawayfromhomenow · 09/05/2022 20:51

@Onwards22 if we went down the state route I would need to stay part time, compressing my hours. That’s not a problem but is a bit of a PITA as I’d really be doing the same work for less money.

Of course, private would eat the financial benefit of working FT! But I would be contributing more to my pension so could retire earlier, I suppose!

OP posts:
User0610134049 · 09/05/2022 20:50

Sounds like it’s a factor to consider.
at my dds (state) school you can book breakfast club and after school club ad hoc up to the night before which is great, and I’ve never had an issue getting a place. Or book a guaranteed session place week but then you do pay whether you use it or not. But I know not all schools are like that and some after school clubs are over subscribed.

Onwards22 · 09/05/2022 20:49

I wouldn’t have childcare as something to consider when I’m weighing up the pros and cons as like you say you only need it now and then so it’s probably easier to get a babysitter on those odd days.

Do you usually finish in time to pick them up from school?

I completely get what you’re saying and I chose a school which did have after school clubs and wrap around care but I needed it regularly but if you only need it now and then I wouldn’t base my decision on it.

However if you like the private school and you wanted them to go there anyway, then the longer day is a bonus.

Do they have lessons until 4pm?

This would put me off slightly. As I think that’s a long day to be sat in a classroom learning.
With wrap around care they’re often playing, so although it’s in the same building it’s not actually school.