Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To consider private schools due to the longer school day?

135 replies

Workingawayfromhomenow · 09/05/2022 19:33

It isn’t the only consideration by a long shot but it is a consideration, as we would struggle otherwise. I realise people do manage of course but interested in knowing if this was a factor for anyone else when choosing a school.

OP posts:
Workingawayfromhomenow · 09/05/2022 22:48

And thank you for the genuinely helpful posts. My child is still very young and we are a while off this but for obvious reasons I am focusing my mind elsewhere tonight.

OP posts:
Workingawayfromhomenow · 09/05/2022 22:47

fishonabicycle · 09/05/2022 22:14

These sort of threads are just a total waste of time. The OP obviously wants to send her children to private school. I actually have no idea why she has posted on here ...

And by contrast, that post changed the fucking world, didn’t it?

OP posts:
Bunnycat101 · 09/05/2022 22:33

I’d also say our after school provision largely seems to be led by students. So you sometimes get brilliant super engaging young people and sometimes those that are less so and stick on the tv. they’re not doing homework or clubs as such but it varies so much depending on who is on shift. Food is a bit naff as well. I’d imagine wrap around as part of a prep’s offering would be better.

fishonabicycle · 09/05/2022 22:14

These sort of threads are just a total waste of time. The OP obviously wants to send her children to private school. I actually have no idea why she has posted on here ...

SirSamVimesCityWatch · 09/05/2022 22:10

except spending 3h after school in a noisy environment with no real structure wasn’t great for them, it was difficult to make them do homework afterward

Yes this is a good point. After school club at my child's primary is unstructured and they won't support them to do work. The independent I worked in had timetabled after school enrichment activities, followed by supervised prep as an optional add on. The kids were picked up to go home having done the school day, had a snack, done an activity delivered by teaching staff, and then done all their homework. That's a big difference from picking up my DD at 6, who has been either running around on the field (summer) or playing on a computer (winter) since 3.30, and still has reading / spellings / maths practice to do as well as needing dinner.

Bovrilly · 09/05/2022 22:05

I think that the longer day is one of the big drawbacks of private school - I much prefer the idea of clubs outside school instead, where DC can mix with different people and make other friends. It's really helpful if/when things go wrong at school, as they often do, for the DC not to spend all their time there and have to do all their activities with the same people they are in lessons with. Plus when they first went to school ours were so knackered by 3.30pm that they wouldn't have coped very well with more stuff. DS used to fall asleep at 6.30pm when he was in reception, even though he could do 8-6 quite happily at nursery.

But facilitating an afternoon pick up and clubs after school does require a lot of effort and sacrifice on the part of the parents. We had to juggle our hours and work early / late to make it work, it was a pain but worth it, it's only for a few years. They have experienced a lot more people and places than if they'd been at school 8-6 every day.

LovelyLovelyWarmCoffee · 09/05/2022 21:58

Paying for private schooling is a very expensive form of wrap around care
It’s not the same as wraparound care though.

FWIW we like the longer school days and longer holidays. The state primary my DC were attending before offered BC/AFC 7:30am-6:30pm so all good on paper, except spending 3h after school in a noisy environment with no real structure wasn’t great for them, it was difficult to make them do homework afterwards or even have dinner and a shower without a tantrum.
And the food offered at both BC/AFC was far from healthy.

OneCup · 09/05/2022 21:55

Have you attended an open day at your local primary and at the independent school? I would keep an open mind until then as you may be surprised ( pleasantly or otherwise) by what you saw.
If you much prefer the indie, then it's a no brainer.
If you don't however,ci would explore other ( childminder, teaming up with another parent etc, condensing hours, wfh etc)

SirSamVimesCityWatch · 09/05/2022 21:54

I worked at a private boarding school and a lot of parents of the day pupils were very happy with the longer days. All pupils had a different activity each night. They could also stay a bit later and do prep (homework). It meant they could be picked up by parents as late as 6.30. Then there was the option of flexi boarding - adding odd nights as a boarder.

In theory my child's school has 7.30am - 6.00pm wrap around, but it reality I couldn't get her into any of the mornings this year when I went back to work and I can only book her in for one morning a week next year.

I don't think the op is stupid for taking it into consideration.

Dixiechickonhols · 09/05/2022 21:53

My DD went to a small private primary near where I worked. For various reasons but it definitely made life so much easy for me. It was a longer day as standard plus an on site aftercare no need to book - running late at work just call and they’d pop down and tell dd to go to aftercare. Hols were 2 weeks longer - we saved a lot by having our main school holidays in October as they got 2 weeks. It was very geared to working parents no expectations you’d be available in day, no random dress up days, only school open in town when it snowed etc. It was in northern town fees were £500 a month. Class of 15.

Workingawayfromhomenow · 09/05/2022 21:44

@BakeOffRewatch I’ve noticed it too. I think years ago you sometimes got posts with a caustic twinge to them that were often funny too, and I think some posters try to emulate this but in fact just end up being unpleasant for the sake of it.

Changing jobs is a consideration. I don’t want to be bound to my current workplace because of my child’s school. On the other hand, there is a bus service so worst case scenario he could continue to attend that school. However, the pickups and drop offs do matter to me as well!

OP posts:
BakeOffRewatch · 09/05/2022 21:41

Sorry about your miscarriage OP.

Just wanted to post and say I agree with you about the nasty posts. I’ve been reporting them and get the MN inconsistent reply “it’s an opinion”, when they clearly have a unwritten “spirit” some posts are not in. I was a lurker for years before creating this account on mat leave, and I have noticed that there are more posts that are just unnecessarily nasty, over innocuous things too.

With respect to your post, I think your child will have a lovely time whichever choice as you clearly take a lot of consideration into their wellbeing. If you go to the further school, driving to and from the school could be good quality chat time between you two. What if you moved jobs, would the private school location then be an inconvenience? Could you afford to send multiple children? I haven’t met anyone who sends to private school because of the long day as the main factor myself, for your canvassing.

Hope you recover well.

Workingawayfromhomenow · 09/05/2022 21:41

Thanks, @Bunnycat101 - it is a bit of a relief when others post similar problems and dilemmas! As you say, having the provision for wraparound care doesn’t mean that you can get it!

OP posts:
Clymene · 09/05/2022 21:41

Just send your kid to private school. I don't know why you're agonising over it.

Bunnycat101 · 09/05/2022 21:40

I don’t know why you’ve had a hard time. We’re at a state school with wrap-around but it was looking shakey post covid. If it had gone, it would have been the thing that tipped us into private. With no wrap-around we’d have needed a nanny and would likely need to pay for full day rather than after school given how hard it is to find an after-school nanny. That would have meant taking our youngest out of nursery which I really didn’t want to do.

I have a friend whose school offers ‘wrap around’. Her daughter is in year 2 and still on the waiting list she joined before starting school. Provision is not always what is claimed.

I can easily see how wrap-around could be the deciding factor between schools and sectors.

Workingawayfromhomenow · 09/05/2022 21:39

I don’t think the nanny route is as easy as it’s often made to sound on here - plus it’s still ultimately being reliant on one person, who may fall ill or choose to leave or be unable to get to work for whatever reason.

For the most part we wouldn’t need a nanny in any case. To be honest, the main downside is working FT! I’ve grown to like a day off …

OP posts:
Happyhappyday · 09/05/2022 21:36

Yup, keeping DC at private preschool through year 1 because we’re guaranteed full day with high quality wraparound + holiday care we can opt into if we need it. Local primary might provide this if we get a place but likely we’d need to sort it ourselves and where we live this would mean a nanny and part time nannies are INSANELY expensive and virtually impossible to find.

Workingawayfromhomenow · 09/05/2022 21:35

Yes, we’ve established you think I’m chippy. Can we get back to the thread, please?

OP posts:
carefullycourageous · 09/05/2022 21:32

Workingawayfromhomenow · 09/05/2022 21:26

@carefullycourageous you said on page 2 that you were going to leave the thread before I came and ‘got you’ or something similarly ridiculous, that might be best. Despite the sniping a lot of responses have been really helpful and I’d like to stay on topic. Or in other words, if you’re at liberty to tell me that AIBU isn’t for me, I can do likewise and ask that maybe you don’t keep posting. I have heard your view: it is a waste of money and there are an abundance of childminders. Thanks.

It is this type of chippiness that I was referring to and why maybe it isn't everyone else that is at fault here.

You are obviously having a bad time, but you have made your own thread go badly with your tone.

Workingawayfromhomenow · 09/05/2022 21:27

Thanks @surreygirl1987 , I did read a pretty horrible story at the weekend about an after school club, though would like to think this isn’t typical.

OP posts:
Workingawayfromhomenow · 09/05/2022 21:26

@carefullycourageous you said on page 2 that you were going to leave the thread before I came and ‘got you’ or something similarly ridiculous, that might be best. Despite the sniping a lot of responses have been really helpful and I’d like to stay on topic. Or in other words, if you’re at liberty to tell me that AIBU isn’t for me, I can do likewise and ask that maybe you don’t keep posting. I have heard your view: it is a waste of money and there are an abundance of childminders. Thanks.

OP posts:
surreygirl1987 · 09/05/2022 21:25

Actually I do see your point. I teach in a private school and it is one of the considerations for parents - among others. In one of the local state primaries, they have very few kids staying for WAC and it's run by the TAs who let them choose what they want to do, including ipads. By contrast, the local private school puts on heaps of activities and most kids stay. It's not just about the cost and existence of WAC, but the quality of it - 2 or 3 hours a day is a lot of time per week and I want to know what my kids will be upto in that time!

NameChange30 · 09/05/2022 21:23

Workingawayfromhomenow · 09/05/2022 21:20

Thanks @NameChange30 but no sorry - I don’t see being on AIBU as a reason / excuse / call it what you will to be really rude in response to a simple and polite question. I don’t mean you, by the way, but there have been some really sarky and ‘cutting’ responses and there has been absolutely no need.

I agree. It's not an excuse. But the unfortunate fact is that you always get a handful of complete and utter arseholes on AIBU. I try to avoid it but sometimes get sucked in (obviously Grin)

Hope you are getting some real life TLC.

carefullycourageous · 09/05/2022 21:23

Your thread did read funny from the off, if you are upset then I agree AIBU really isn't the place to be.

Post again in education some time.

But you will get views on private schools, because people have opinions on private schools. They are very divisive, that is just how it is, and in some ways that is worth thinking about as I think you have to be OK with that in order to send your child there.

Blondefancy · 09/05/2022 21:22

My school day used to be 9am-5pm at private school.