Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Scottish Power boss tells government to give £1000 to low income households. We can all pay it back later, he advises.

57 replies

flashbac · 09/05/2022 18:51

I think there has to be better ideas than this:

"Scottish Power has proposed that the government underwrites a “deficit fund” that could allow energy suppliers to cut £1,000 off bills for low-income households. The money would be paid down over a decade by adding £40 a year to all household energy bills. It is hoped that bills would come down over time as wholesale market prices fall back towards historic norms.

Anderson said he had presented his plans to MPs but so far not gained traction."

www.theguardian.com/business/2022/may/09/scottish-power-boss-urges-sunak-to-take-swift-action-on-energy-bills-crisis

I don't like that an energy boss, of a company making huge profits from the crisis, is suggesting something like this, and energy companies get away with it.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
FourTeaFallOut · 11/05/2022 11:20

But why should those who don’t work be able to sit in warm homes while those of us that do don’t have that luxury?

Among the people who don't work are the most vulnerable people in society when it comes to the health effects of cold homes, the elderly and those with chronic illnesses. I think we do need a buffer for those who are most at risk but I think we need to be more strategic about how we get money to those people than, say, picking out council tax bands.

LadyCatStark · 11/05/2022 09:20

CapMarvel · 10/05/2022 16:43

I don't necessarily think it's a terrible idea.

The fact is something has to be done to protect those at the absolute bottom from energy prices which have increased massively and will probably increase again in October.

Likewise, if those people are given help then that money has to come from somewhere. If not from a direct levy then from somewhere - be it increased taxation, a windfall tax or whatever. An energy tax, for want of a better term, is as viable a way to fund it than anything else.

At least it's a practical idea which is more than most have come up with.

But why should those who don’t work be able to sit in warm homes while those of us that do don’t have that luxury? People are working from home wrapped up in blankets and wearing hats and gloves or spending all their money on petrol to get themselves to work if they work outside the home… or both like me.

MichelleScarn · 10/05/2022 21:55

it can come from elsewhere, from taxing energy producing companies, or cutting government expenses or somewhere else: it’s certainly not coming from my pocket when I have to deal with rising prices too. Absolutely agree with this. Am fed up with this people who work should be so happy to pay more tax and take on more debt with a happy song in their heart!

Svara · 10/05/2022 20:22

flashbac · 10/05/2022 09:55

This is also my main concern. The cliff edge effect.

Being on a single low full time wage just feels like a continuous struggle with nothing spare but no help. Also a lot of help seems to be targeted at debt, such as grants for energy bills, from what I've read. If you manage to live within your means even though it means choosing between heating and eating then it seems you are on your own?

Overthebow · 10/05/2022 18:41

CapMarvel · 10/05/2022 16:43

I don't necessarily think it's a terrible idea.

The fact is something has to be done to protect those at the absolute bottom from energy prices which have increased massively and will probably increase again in October.

Likewise, if those people are given help then that money has to come from somewhere. If not from a direct levy then from somewhere - be it increased taxation, a windfall tax or whatever. An energy tax, for want of a better term, is as viable a way to fund it than anything else.

At least it's a practical idea which is more than most have come up with.

Well it can come from elsewhere, from taxing energy producing companies, or cutting government expenses or somewhere else: it’s certainly not coming from my pocket when I have to deal with rising prices too.

CapMarvel · 10/05/2022 16:43

I don't necessarily think it's a terrible idea.

The fact is something has to be done to protect those at the absolute bottom from energy prices which have increased massively and will probably increase again in October.

Likewise, if those people are given help then that money has to come from somewhere. If not from a direct levy then from somewhere - be it increased taxation, a windfall tax or whatever. An energy tax, for want of a better term, is as viable a way to fund it than anything else.

At least it's a practical idea which is more than most have come up with.

Neverreturntoathread · 10/05/2022 16:39

Not being funny but who asked him for policy advice?

Taxpayers already pay for thousands of civil servants and politicians, maybe ask one of them to like do their actual job and we might get a more sensible list of options.

Iwantitidontwantit · 10/05/2022 16:27

@FourTeaFallOut I am not sure where that article gets their facts from, but they are wrong. SSE and Ovo are two different companies now. SSE make big profit as they are on the generation side and Ovo are an energy supplier. The profits mentioned are for SSE. Ovo still uses the SSE name, as they bought the customers. Alistair Phillips-Davies is the ceo of SSE and Stephen Fitzpatrick is the CEO of Ovo.

MichelleScarn · 10/05/2022 16:15

As in the middle will never get to be classified as 'in need' just to be happy with getting to be taxed so hard. Even more so in Scotland!

MichelleScarn · 10/05/2022 16:14

tfresh · 10/05/2022 08:34

The middle are going to paying so much tax, and benefits out to others that they themselves will soon be classed as in need!

That's never going to happen, the middle will continue to be taxed and taxed and taxed and any utterance of a struggle with this will be heavily berated and called evil!

OversBo · 10/05/2022 10:02

EvilPea · 09/05/2022 19:30

I saw an interview with octopus energy’s boss. He explained how most suppliers barely break even and a lot don’t turn a profit.
its the energy creators that are making the money. Shell, BP etc.

There should be a windfall tax on them

flashbac · 10/05/2022 09:56

killerqueue · 10/05/2022 06:37

I suspect he will be getting nervous about unpaid bills and the cost of chasing payment in court screwing with the profit margin.

I agree, they are likely aware that people will just not pay their bills so are trying to ensure they get some money somehow.

Are they saying bills will be high for years then?!

He's talking about the rise in October. Winter will be a struggle for many. It won't just be 'low income' households defaulting on bills.

OP posts:
flashbac · 10/05/2022 09:55

liveforsummer · 10/05/2022 07:19

Yes I feel the same. I miss out on the school meal grant by a tiny amount which is pretty much the gateway to hundreds in extra help. Was better off on job seekers than I am working 5 days a week as a result. I feel I'd miss out on this too.

This is also my main concern. The cliff edge effect.

OP posts:
tfresh · 10/05/2022 08:34

The middle are going to paying so much tax, and benefits out to others that they themselves will soon be classed as in need!

BalloonsAndWhistles · 10/05/2022 07:41

Why on Earth should everyone have £40 added to their energy bills to pay back the £1000 that SOME people get? We’ve just had solar panels fitted to reduce our energy consumption and it’s not our fault that other people can’t afford to have them. I truly feel sorry for people that can’t afford things but we’re not loaded, we just choose to prioritise our money in different ways. We didn’t get furlough and we’re already having to pay that back yet we worked throughout that period. This would be another slap in the face. Some people just have to accept that others have more than them and that’s that.

liveforsummer · 10/05/2022 07:19

Svara · 09/05/2022 20:24

As a lone parent on a low income I am concerned about how vulnerable customers would be identified. I would be scared that people in similar circumstances to myself would just miss out but still have to pay back the money. I am on a tight budget but not in debt, I would live on porridge and dhal before I go into debt.

Yes I feel the same. I miss out on the school meal grant by a tiny amount which is pretty much the gateway to hundreds in extra help. Was better off on job seekers than I am working 5 days a week as a result. I feel I'd miss out on this too.

Kaibashira · 10/05/2022 06:43

I don't agree with what he's saying.

But let's at least acknowledge that it's an actual plan, so therefore by definition better than anything the government has come up with.

Remember, it was right here on mumsnet that Rishi said it would be "silly" to do anything right now. Because he doesn't know what will happen in the future.

Our government doesn't care about the general public. That's a harsh reality but we need to face it, call it put, and vote them out.

FourTeaFallOut · 10/05/2022 06:38

One thing to do would be to reflect inflation in benefits and pensions now, rather than in a year's time. If they could be more reflexive then they could recoup that money when inflation falls. It just means that people would have the additional money when they need it - not later to pay off debt with it later.

Fedupbuyer · 10/05/2022 06:37

I’m not paying for somebody’s else’s bills we already get taxed to death ,a lot of people know how to play the system!

killerqueue · 10/05/2022 06:37

I suspect he will be getting nervous about unpaid bills and the cost of chasing payment in court screwing with the profit margin.

I agree, they are likely aware that people will just not pay their bills so are trying to ensure they get some money somehow.

Are they saying bills will be high for years then?!

Overthebow · 10/05/2022 06:33

LadyCatStark · 09/05/2022 21:46

Fuck that. I’m sorry, we already give enough of our wages to fund other people!

Yep, no way am I paying an extra £40 per year over a decade, for a loan I don’t even get, to fun others. I’m not a charity.

And this is on top of the other £250 loan we’re all being forced to get and I don’t want.

Lovelydovey · 10/05/2022 06:21

Two things the government could do now: reduce tax on energy bills and put a cap on daily charges.

Then think longer term about how to become more self sufficient in energy production - nuclear or renewable fuels.

Newname1 · 10/05/2022 06:01

well some might welcome a spell inside as a way to guarantee a hot meal and warm accommodation.

SheilaWilcox · 09/05/2022 23:48

Are our prisons still overcrowded?
Can we get them producing energy?

Scottish Power boss tells government to give £1000 to low income households. We can all pay it back later, he advises.
ILoveAllRainbowsx · 09/05/2022 21:53

iloveyankeecandle · 09/05/2022 20:04

Energy companies do not have huge profits. No idea where people get that from. The petrol companies do.

Most people don't have a clue about economics but are allowed to vote. It is frightening the rubbish you read on here.

Most people on here are financially illiterate.

They haven't got a clue.