Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

NHS Refuses to Offer Surgery

111 replies

AchatAVendre · 09/05/2022 14:50

Wondering what people's thoughts are on this. My NHS healthcare trust is point blank refusing to offer me surgery for a condition that is normally fixed by surgery that almost everyone agrees that all the clinical signs are present for. They want to "do nothing". The problem is causing issues and pain and there is no way forwards from this opinion. I have reached the end point with my healthcare trust.

I have asked to be referred through patient choices for a second opinion but the issue is now causing so much pain and physical damage that I'll probably end up paying for surgery privately because its taken so long to get to this stage. Around £6k. I can afford it, but obviously I'd rather not take 6k out of my savings for something that just about anyone else would get surgery for. I should also point out that I'm not a smoker and not overweight, and even my GP surgery can't understand it. But no-one is doing anything about it. My GP is quite frustrated but can't really do anything. I had a private consultation and the surgeon said that the surgery in my case has a 99% success rate and he can't understand why I wasn't offered it by the NHS. It affects my mobility and therefore my ability to work. Yes, I will complain to the Ombudsman but realistically it will be many months before they even look at my case, never mind do anything about it.

What on earth do you do in practical terms if your NHS healthcare trust simply refuses to operate? I do think its probably a bit sexist as it appears that statistically men are more likely to get this (non-sex related) surgery than women in my trust and some of the written responses I have had display quite a bias and stereotypical thinking about women and at a couple of points, delve into the realms of fiction in inventing reasons for the issue (it occurred due to a an accident, they wrongly claim its because I'm peri-menopausal and I should just accept fractures and complications arising from them).

OP posts:
Saracenia · 09/05/2022 20:10

Can your GP refer you to another hospital trust? I'd google a specialist in that area and ask for a referral to them. The money follows the patient still, I believe.

Minimalme · 09/05/2022 20:02

That's so shit op Sad

I have been battling for my disabled son to have two procedures for the last two years. I am so tired and frustrated that we are selling our house and downsizing and plan to pay for it privately.

I have noticed such a decline in the last three years in my dc care, it's scary.

I would actually prefer a private healthcare system now than the NHS.

myceliumama · 09/05/2022 19:50

Trafficjamlog · 09/05/2022 18:50

You are completely mad to even give going abroad a moments though. If you have the money get it done by a surgeon you choose who is an expert and will offer you the proper follow up. It sounds like it’s a knee op, there are plenty of excellent knee surgeons around. Don’t go abroad, you simply don’t skimp on healthcare when you can pay to get it done here

The Turkish surgeons don't operate in caves without aesthetic you know. Their hostels are system is arguably better than our once great NHS. My dad and his wife lived in Turkey and she went the Drs with a persistent cough and had a terminal lung cancer diagnosis within 10 days. My Dad raves about the health care over there desire being an ardent fan of the NHS.

I have had similar issues with the NHS. I have several auto immune issues and my right knee has been very painful since I was 19. Diagnosed at 35. Told I need a knee replacement but the NHS won't do it until I'm at least 45 so I'm sat at home on benefits as I can barely walk. Now I need both knees doing and was told a few months ago it's a like 47 in my area and it's got to be really bad. I'm down to bone on bone and that's not bad enough?! I'm on the scrap heap. I wish I had enough money to go to Turkey and get it done. I want to live my life NOW, not in my fifties! I've got a lot of hip pain recently so it will be my luck I'll finally get my knees done and then they will need doing.

IrisVersicolor · 09/05/2022 19:36

Please don’t even consider going to Turkey OP, you need someone you can follow up with afterwards.

alltheteeshirts · 09/05/2022 19:19

I've seen other people - both male and female - be given a walking stick and a referral to a pain management clinic rather than have much needed surgery on their joints. I don't have a solution for you, because they went private, given the NHS suggestion was bloody ridiculous.

I think it's a bit like basic NHS dentistry, where you can either pay privately for expensive work, or they can yank the tooth out. Sometimes the NHS option is so barbaric that you have to go private.

I make a point of having health insurance for this reason, which on reading it back, sounds a bit like I'm living in America. I'm not, I live in the UK.

Sending you lots of sympathy. It sounds like a nightmare situation for you.

QuebecBagnet · 09/05/2022 19:17

I had my initial consultation for my second referral about three weeks after being referred. This was pre covid though.

i was then meant to have my surgery the week before the first lockdown and that was obviously cancelled. I only had the surgery done last year.

sadly it hasn’t fully worked. But that’s just one of those things. I’ve just had a further mri and ct scan done. If you’re in the Midlands and want a lower limb guy I can recommend Dr Dhar at nottingham.

AchatAVendre · 09/05/2022 19:10

Theheartandtheshape · 09/05/2022 19:06

Complaining that an expert consultant surgeon refuses to operate on you and going to Turkey for discount surgery is fucking mad.

This isn't some cosmetic surgery done for vanity, and NHS consultants are not gods. Its to save my joint because ONE bastard NHS consultant thinks women can just sit on their backsides baking fairy cakes for the rest of their lives while virtually every other consultant in the country would operate. However, in view of the fact that I pay a bloody fortune in taxes here already, I will consider any competent hospital and surgeon with a good record who will carry it out, rather than having my knee joint ruined. I really don't trust the NHS at all after this and I don't rely on the judgment of my particular healthcare trust.

OP posts:
AchatAVendre · 09/05/2022 19:08

QuebecBagnet · 09/05/2022 19:01

I had a similar issue pre covid and asked my GP to refer me out of area. The first consultant didn’t think the pain was that bad and that in my early 40s I could just get used to hobbling about and not been able to walk very far. 🤷‍♀️ Consultant 40 miles away operated no problem. And also discovered my leg was broken and I had a torn tendon!

Well, that is so similar to what has happened to me, I almost think you must be under the same healthcare trust authority as me! How long did you have to wait for the second opinion referral?

Those posters who have mentioned getting notes of my case management discussion, is it only PALS who can get it? They have been pretty useless so far for me.

OP posts:
Theheartandtheshape · 09/05/2022 19:06

Complaining that an expert consultant surgeon refuses to operate on you and going to Turkey for discount surgery is fucking mad.

truhamboys · 09/05/2022 19:05

On the topic of Turkey, it's only been a few days since the FCO warned against going there for medical treatment. 17 British people have died after treatment there since 2019
www.liverpoolecho.co.uk/news/uk-world-news/foreign-office-warning-brits-travelling-23884330

QuebecBagnet · 09/05/2022 19:01

I had a similar issue pre covid and asked my GP to refer me out of area. The first consultant didn’t think the pain was that bad and that in my early 40s I could just get used to hobbling about and not been able to walk very far. 🤷‍♀️ Consultant 40 miles away operated no problem. And also discovered my leg was broken and I had a torn tendon!

LIZS · 09/05/2022 18:58

If you feel you have not been given a fair consideration or explanation go back to Pals. Do you have copies of your notes r3cording the case conference?

Trafficjamlog · 09/05/2022 18:50

You are completely mad to even give going abroad a moments though. If you have the money get it done by a surgeon you choose who is an expert and will offer you the proper follow up. It sounds like it’s a knee op, there are plenty of excellent knee surgeons around. Don’t go abroad, you simply don’t skimp on healthcare when you can pay to get it done here

twinkletoedelephant · 09/05/2022 18:47

Had a similar problem

I was told the only effect treatment for me would be a total hysterectomy... But I was told that unfortunately this is no longer available on the NHS so I am be referred on to have a look at my options.. it was highly suggested I go private.

Unfortunately I don't have the funds

AchatAVendre · 09/05/2022 18:45

starlingdarling · 09/05/2022 18:43

Have you looked into having the surgery privately in France or Spain? I had cosmetic surgery in France when I lived there and it was quite a bit cheaper than the U.K.

Yes, I'm considering that too. But Turkey seems the best option so far. Also with Turkey I could literally get it done next week.

OP posts:
starlingdarling · 09/05/2022 18:43

Have you looked into having the surgery privately in France or Spain? I had cosmetic surgery in France when I lived there and it was quite a bit cheaper than the U.K.

Tiredmum100 · 09/05/2022 18:41

StopGo · 09/05/2022 17:27

Summer of 2020 my DS was assaulted at work by a patient. His nose broken and skull fractured. He needed urgent surgery, night before the surgery his operation was cancelled. They had Covid in the ENT surgical team.

His surgery has been postponed indefinitely, leaving him in considerable pain, anaemic due to the constant bleeding at the back of his nose, facial disfigured and with compromised breathing.

He works in the system and was injured on their time, still not now willing to operate. Bank of Mum paid for private surgery and he is leaving healthcare. The system is broken.

That is absolutely awful.

Trafficblight · 09/05/2022 18:28

Well it's in shit state, many surgeries are not being offered now that would enhance people's lives and save them living in immense pain unfortunately. Presumably if they had a board and no other medical professional challenged it then there must be a robust reason- unfortunately that reason won't be your healthy but will most likely be monetary. I'd write to PALS and ask for access to the minutes of the meeting or for the documentation relating to the decision. If they can't provide this then I'm not sure if a FOI is still workable for personal data but worth a go. In the meantime I'd pay for the surgery.

AmberHeardsTurd · 09/05/2022 18:15

I'm so fed up with the NHS. It's such a postcode lottery. There are some things our trust does well, but they just don't do grommets. My youngest DS, who is starting school in Sept, has severe glue ear, to the point he has hearing loss and speech and language impairment. We saw an NHS ENT consultant who basically lied and said his hearing and speech is improving and they won't take action.
Luckily for us, my lovely in laws offered to pay for us to go private and he had grommets put in today in a neighbouring county. It is literally a 5 min operation but is likely to have an incredible effect on our little boy's life. The private consultant says he sees a lot of kids from our area as they can't get the op on the NHS. I am so so grateful we could do this, so many can't and it is so unfair. So I feel your frustration OP, fingers crossed you find a solution. I understand that the decision to offer an operation, or not, can have such far reaching implications for people's lives.

AchatAVendre · 09/05/2022 18:08

SouthOfFrance · 09/05/2022 17:58

How about go to a medical negligence solicitor & claim for the pain you've been in, any loss of earnings, stress etc. Make sure you get copies of all the documents you might need to prove this first in case they mysteriously go missing...
Perhaps if you sue them it will stop this happening to someone else and you will get the surgery you need?

Because they had a case conference on it so he could get his colleagues to agree so I can't sue them for medical negligence as I can't prove its one doctor going against the grain (they do this deliberately I think) and because the standard in the NHS is so diabolical at times and so variable, it would be almost impossible to prove that no reasonably competent doctor would not have disagreed with the diagnosis. Its really very hard to sue the NHS and you need one of those no win no fee firms to take it on because they have near unlimited resources, and those firms only take on very easy cases.

OP posts:
AchatAVendre · 09/05/2022 18:01

Elsiebear90 · 09/05/2022 17:53

I wouldn’t pay too much attention to what the private doctors think tbh, I work with them and they make some very questionable decisions because they’re motivated by money. My fiancée was butchered by a private surgeon who convinced her to have surgery on her knees that she didn’t need on very tenuous grounds, her life has literally been ruined by it. The NHS refused the surgery and preferred the watch and wait approach, but she was convinced by the private surgeon she’d be in a wheelchair if she didn’t it have it done (which was absolutely not true). So that’s why I’m not telling you to ignore the NHS consultant, because I’ve seen the other side.

I would get a second opinion from another NHS consultant or just go privately if you really want it done.

Its very clear to see that there is a piece of bone/cartilage and a metal plate which have slipped out of position and are causing irritation to the joint and should be removed. I know other people who have had it happen to them and they have had it removed and it is causing my muscles to wear away on one side because its so painful that I don't use them, and this is now causing joint pain on the other side. It is not similar to removing part of a meniscus or "washing out a joint" pointlessly - it is to remove a piece of sharp bone or cartilage and a metal plate in the wrong place that is acting like a little knife cutting away at the underlying structures.

All of clinical indications are there that it should be surgically removed to retain function and prevent disability. The NHS consultant's idea is that I should just use the limb in question less and thats a solution! I am definitely ignoring that.

It really is unfathomable. I suspect there is a big problem in my particular NHS foundation trust.

OP posts:
scoobydoo1971 · 09/05/2022 18:01

I had an accident in lockdown. Developed a very serious condition as a result. NHS treatment and consultations in COVID-19 times were going to take months, even as an urgent referral. I asked the GP to refer me to a private consultant. This resulted in an appointment within two weeks. He did a provisional diagnosis and then referred me back into the NHS outpatients and radiology departments as an NHS patient for confirmation, and onward treatment. It is a queue jumper and identified a rare condition. His input has been helpful and enabled me to be under 3 clinical centres in the UK. I had four surgeries last year on the NHS, and I think I would still be waiting for the first NHS outpatient appointment if I hadn't opened my cheque book, and got the ball rolling. As surgery has been unsuccessful in my case, I paid to see another specialist last week privately. He spotted a new diagnosis missed by previous NHS doctors (he is an expert in my condition), and suggested a new surgical referral to get it sorted out that will be done on the NHS. Definitely worth going down this route if you need help quickly.

SouthOfFrance · 09/05/2022 17:58

How about go to a medical negligence solicitor & claim for the pain you've been in, any loss of earnings, stress etc. Make sure you get copies of all the documents you might need to prove this first in case they mysteriously go missing...
Perhaps if you sue them it will stop this happening to someone else and you will get the surgery you need?

Elsiebear90 · 09/05/2022 17:53

AchatAVendre · 09/05/2022 17:48

The consultant hasn't actually said that I don't need the surgery. They haven't explained it in any detail at all. They have just said they aren't offering me it but not explained why. It seems that they think I should go away and sit in a chair for the rest of my life and not mind. Lets just say this is a very, very obvious clinical case for surgery and of course the other surgeon, who works primarily in the NHS that I saw privately, thinks it should be done.

I wouldn’t pay too much attention to what the private doctors think tbh, I work with them and they make some very questionable decisions because they’re motivated by money. My fiancée was butchered by a private surgeon who convinced her to have surgery on her knees that she didn’t need on very tenuous grounds, her life has literally been ruined by it. The NHS refused the surgery and preferred the watch and wait approach, but she was convinced by the private surgeon she’d be in a wheelchair if she didn’t it have it done (which was absolutely not true). So that’s why I’m not telling you to ignore the NHS consultant, because I’ve seen the other side.

I would get a second opinion from another NHS consultant or just go privately if you really want it done.

AchatAVendre · 09/05/2022 17:48

Elsiebear90 · 09/05/2022 17:45

The problem you have is that your consultant doesn’t think you need the surgery, so you’re asking the hospital to go against your doctor and disregard his opinion, something they’re highly unlikely to do. It doesn’t matter what your GP or physio think, they’re not the experts, he is, and he is saying you don’t need it.

Your best bet would be to seek a second opinion from another consultant, preferably at a different hospital, or if you don’t want to wait then go private.

The consultant hasn't actually said that I don't need the surgery. They haven't explained it in any detail at all. They have just said they aren't offering me it but not explained why. It seems that they think I should go away and sit in a chair for the rest of my life and not mind. Lets just say this is a very, very obvious clinical case for surgery and of course the other surgeon, who works primarily in the NHS that I saw privately, thinks it should be done.

OP posts: