Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

NHS Refuses to Offer Surgery

111 replies

AchatAVendre · 09/05/2022 14:50

Wondering what people's thoughts are on this. My NHS healthcare trust is point blank refusing to offer me surgery for a condition that is normally fixed by surgery that almost everyone agrees that all the clinical signs are present for. They want to "do nothing". The problem is causing issues and pain and there is no way forwards from this opinion. I have reached the end point with my healthcare trust.

I have asked to be referred through patient choices for a second opinion but the issue is now causing so much pain and physical damage that I'll probably end up paying for surgery privately because its taken so long to get to this stage. Around £6k. I can afford it, but obviously I'd rather not take 6k out of my savings for something that just about anyone else would get surgery for. I should also point out that I'm not a smoker and not overweight, and even my GP surgery can't understand it. But no-one is doing anything about it. My GP is quite frustrated but can't really do anything. I had a private consultation and the surgeon said that the surgery in my case has a 99% success rate and he can't understand why I wasn't offered it by the NHS. It affects my mobility and therefore my ability to work. Yes, I will complain to the Ombudsman but realistically it will be many months before they even look at my case, never mind do anything about it.

What on earth do you do in practical terms if your NHS healthcare trust simply refuses to operate? I do think its probably a bit sexist as it appears that statistically men are more likely to get this (non-sex related) surgery than women in my trust and some of the written responses I have had display quite a bias and stereotypical thinking about women and at a couple of points, delve into the realms of fiction in inventing reasons for the issue (it occurred due to a an accident, they wrongly claim its because I'm peri-menopausal and I should just accept fractures and complications arising from them).

OP posts:
AchatAVendre · 11/05/2022 01:46

Does anybody know how to actually get a second opinion in England?

The letter I received from the consultant refusing to do any surgery stated that I was entitled to a second opinion and to consult my GP if I wished to arrange that.

I've now contacted my GP 3 times and each time they politely say that it is the Health Board who is responsible for arranging second opinions and that they "can't refer outwith their area".

So I phoned the musculo-skeletal service at my trust, and they said it has to be the GP that does it.

I actually feel like I'm harassing my GP now because I've sent 2 e-consults in the last week politely asking for a second opinion and been told he can't do it. I think if I keep trying they might ask me to stop because I'm being vexatious or something.

I honestly do not know how a system of healthcare can be so designed so as to be unhelpful to patients.

OP posts:
Rupertpenrysmistress · 10/05/2022 16:15

Sadly this is the state of the NHS. I am NHS nurse and see patients who have waited so long for surgery that they have deteriorated so much the surgery becomes an emergency this means the surgery is often more difficult and the recover is prolonged and not as successful, this often means these patients then need follow up or rehab/respite which they likely would not have needed. This costs more money in the long run.

The trust I work in is renowned for a certain speciality which is quick turnaround and highly lucrative, strange how these patients are admitted every week, this is not life threatening or prolonging by the way.

I have nearly had enough of how the surgical lists are put together. Another speciality on my ward is colorectal procedures, patients with IBD awaiting life changing procedures continuously cancelled, until they are so unwell they come in, in obstruction/dehydrated with kidney injury needing open surgery and sometimes stoma formation.
These are often, not always young people who need to work/support young families. This is not the NHS I can in good conscience work much longer. It is so broken it really upsets me.

I wish I had advice for you, I am scared for the future and the need to access healthcare.

AllLopsided · 10/05/2022 15:00

LakieLady · 10/05/2022 13:26

My orthopaedic surgeon told me that 90% of the time, patients who have arthroscopy on the knee end up needing at least a partial replacement soon afterwards anyway, and consequently he believes that in most cases they're a waste of time and .

He opts to go straight to partial replacement instead, which seemed reasonable to me, although I would have much preferred arthroscopy. I went ahead with the replacement.

Maybe your surgeon has a similar view, that it only provides a short-term fix.

Surely it depends what the arthroscopy is for? Arthroscopy is just a technique (keyhole surgery on a joint).

OP I hope you find a solution, even if it means going private. I moved abroad long ago and as a happy coincidence I have had the orthopaedic and other surgery that I needed. I am currently waiting for the right moment (for me) to have a total ankle replacement. My road to that surgery started with a cartilage tear and I know how painful it is to be walking round with foreign bodies in a weigh-bearing joint.

WakeWaterWalk · 10/05/2022 13:46

I was going to say shop around.
I recently went private for an operation and did decide to pay out to have it done locally. It was clear though from a bit of googling that I was going to be charged the most expensive rate out here in the (relative) sticks. I was lucky enough to have savings to cover it and it worked better for the family logistics of course but at one point when availability was still an issue I considered going to London.

AchatAVendre · 10/05/2022 13:36

Trafficjamlog · 10/05/2022 13:35

An all in price for an arthroscopy in an excellent hospital in and around London is £3k this includes anesthetist consultant hospital fees and operation. It’s obviously a fair amount of money but seems reasonable to me to get it done

Where? Can you pm me some names? Thats much cheaper than I've been quoted so far.

OP posts:
AchatAVendre · 10/05/2022 13:35

LakieLady · 10/05/2022 13:26

My orthopaedic surgeon told me that 90% of the time, patients who have arthroscopy on the knee end up needing at least a partial replacement soon afterwards anyway, and consequently he believes that in most cases they're a waste of time and .

He opts to go straight to partial replacement instead, which seemed reasonable to me, although I would have much preferred arthroscopy. I went ahead with the replacement.

Maybe your surgeon has a similar view, that it only provides a short-term fix.

Its true that arthroscopy used to be overused, however this is specifically to remove a body in the knee which is causing issue, not just a general "washout" or unnecessary arthroscopy. My knee is developing a medial lateral tilt as a result of being unable to weight bear on the anterior. That will damage the patellar femoral joint which in itself will lead to a knee replacement being required. There was no arthritis in that joint until this occurred and I think it can still be saved. This is not a "short term fix".

And to be frank, I'm not having my knee butchered for a knee replacement by my NHS trust once they've managed to cripple me in a few years time. It is far far better to preserve existing joint health.

OP posts:
Trafficjamlog · 10/05/2022 13:35

An all in price for an arthroscopy in an excellent hospital in and around London is £3k this includes anesthetist consultant hospital fees and operation. It’s obviously a fair amount of money but seems reasonable to me to get it done

LakieLady · 10/05/2022 13:26

My orthopaedic surgeon told me that 90% of the time, patients who have arthroscopy on the knee end up needing at least a partial replacement soon afterwards anyway, and consequently he believes that in most cases they're a waste of time and .

He opts to go straight to partial replacement instead, which seemed reasonable to me, although I would have much preferred arthroscopy. I went ahead with the replacement.

Maybe your surgeon has a similar view, that it only provides a short-term fix.

AchatAVendre · 10/05/2022 13:09

CharlotteUnaNatalieThompson · 10/05/2022 07:05

I've read the op posts.

I'm an NHS surgeon in an unrelated field so can't comment on the specifics of your case OP. And from what you've said it certainly sounds like your care hasn't been ideal, especially with regards to the communication.

But just because an operation CAN be done that doesn't mean it's the right thing. And I would leave the my job the day I was told I must operate when it went against my clinical judgement. The decision of the individual who is to operate must always be respected, because if things go wrong this is their responsibility so they must retain the absolute right to refuse if they think it's the wrong decision.

As you point out we most definitely are NOT gods, but we are human beings. Can you imagine being forced to cut someone up when you thought it was wrong? On the other side can you imagine (and do you REALLY want) to be operated on by someone who, for whatever reason, didn't want to do it?

On a handful of occasions i have refused to operate despite the patient wanting surgery, and stating they are happy with the risks I've quoted, which are often a 50% chance of making it worse. Some of them have been deeply unhappy, upset, and angry. The difference with your situation is that I've explained to them very very clearly why I'm not prepared to operate, been kind and empathetic to them, and offered them to be referred for a second opinion. Because sometimes things are not black and white, I'm not God, and someone else might agree to operate. I think you should be pursuing through PALS is a consultation with clear answers as to why in your case doing nothing is the correct approach. You really deserve opened and honesty.

You can still seek a second opinion or get this done privately (as you already are) while you try to get these answers, and then if you think your care has been unacceptable, especially if there is bias in the system, pursue a formal complaint against the surgeon and team who wouldn't operate.

I would strongly advise against going to Turkey though, even if it's cheaper, as there is no follow-up and no fallback if you have problems. You'll be back in a system you don't trust potentially under the care of the team who have refused to treat you so far. As someone who had said they can afford it pay the extra for peace of mind.

This is removal of an osteochondrial body in an easily accessible location which is currently causing damage to the joint due to abrasion. Its day case arthroscopy and I have always made it clear that being told to stop weight bearing on the affected limb (I'm in my forties!) is completely unacceptable. I've basically been told that I should just expect to suffer fractures because I have (a very small amount of quite normal osteoarthritis) for my age and to go away and be a good little unquestioning woman.

Its not acceptable not to do this particular surgery, its not a joint replacement, and all the clinical signs are met. I wouldn't actually let my own healthcare trust operate on me now anyway as I have lost faith in them and they have been awful so far - failing to diagnose a fracture for 5 months because of refusing me an MRI scan even though I was non weight bearing, failing to check that the fracture had healed, etc. The private second opinion I obtained was that there was a 99% success rate. That is from a far more renowned, more senior surgeon who is also a professor of medicine, than the one at my trust.

Ironically, as one poster pointed out, this surgery is frequently carried out on dogs and other animals because to leave the bone/cartilage chip in situ is too high risk for damaging the joint.

I suspect its a funding issue and the trust would rather concentrate on using their budget to bump up their joint replacement statistics, which they boast about on their webpage. Those of course have awful clinical findings for return to activity, because they wait until people's joints are so damaged and muscle weakness has progressed to such a degree that its well nigh impossible for a full recovery.

So, no, I am not going to be a good little woman and hobble about on a walking stick for an easily resolved issue, and then be all grateful for the eventual joint replacement surgery that will come once I've lost all ability to walk properly. I'd rather preserve my joints and I don't trust my NHS trust at all - they settle out of court all the time and their follow up for infections following joint replacement surgery is horrifying to read.

OP posts:
AchatAVendre · 10/05/2022 12:55

Springhassprung86 · 10/05/2022 02:14

If your GP is equally as confused and frustrated, they can refer you to another NHS trust for a second opinion.
ry find it difficult to believe that the consultant refused to give a reason for no surgery but ranted at you over it. Strange.

You have your facts wrong. Please don't make things up. I was given no reason for the surgery not being offered, I was simply told that "doing nothing" was the "way forward".

I then made an official complaint. Part of the complaint response, rather than addressing the question as to why I was not being offered surgery, consisted of 7 paragraphs of what I can only describe as waffle and having a go at me for using a technical term for the condition which the writer felt was incorrect.

I believe that part of the complaint response was written by a physio as it and other responses bear his rather characteristic, superfluous style, and I'm unsure whether any of the complaint was responded to by the surgeon. I know of the reputation of the particular physio involved and this would appear to be an accurate conclusion to draw.

As I have already explained, my GP has stated that my own healthcare trust has to give permission for a second opinion, and this will all likely take many months.

I hope none of this ever happens to you. You have very little idea how little you will be offered when your quality of life is at stake and how difficult it is to get anyone to treat you seriously, even when you are articulate as I am. I hate to think of the people who have been fobbed off and told theres nothing to do when this is a perfectly standard day case surgery offered as routine nearly everywhere else.

OP posts:
myceliumama · 10/05/2022 09:56

Honestly unless you have experienced long term serious pain and been refused any talk help, you can't possibly understand. It costs the NHS fortune to try to control my condition with biologics drugs and it seems to have slowed down the remaining disease but it doesn't reverse it. Why are they paying all this money (3-4K a Month apparently) but leaving me in this pain and unable to walk. Honestly, some days I've even looked into Dignitas so please don't tell me that paying for a a private surgery abroad is madness. What's mad is leaving actual real life Humans in so much pain that it would be unethical to do it too a dog.

myceliumama · 10/05/2022 09:52

Trafficjamlog · 09/05/2022 23:15

@myceliumama I agree the fact that the NHS won’t do it is totally unacceptable but to go ahead to get a cheap operation which can be done by excellent and experienced private surgeons here with proper follow up is madness. I’m sure that there are excellent hospitals in turkey but there are also outstanding knee surgeons here who can also operate almost immediately and will be on hand to follow up and you choose who you want to operate on you based on their skills and experience. No way would I have a random Turkish (or any other overseas) doctor I had never heard of and who nobody I knew had used go anywhere near me.

What is madness is to leave a highly educated woman say at home on benefits for the prime of her life. I've got three degrees, I'm qualified to teach, I've ran my own company before and have SO much to offer. But I'm in absolute agony with crumbled inflamed joints. My mental health is in the gutter from lack of sleep and this has caused my previously stable bipolar to be like a roller coaster. I'm not able to work. I don't have anything of a private pension. It's becoming almost impossible for me to drive my automatic adapted car.

To you, going to Turkey may seem bonkers but to me, at the very very end of my patience and pain limit, it seems the only viable option of I want to experience ANYTHING in the rest of my life. I'm only 43 for fucks sake. I'm never going to be the "right" age to get this surgery and to actually benefit from it. But I honestly don't expect you to understand right now if I went to Turkey and they operated and it got botched. So what? I'd get an above knee amputation on both legs. I'd be pain free. Not trying to walk bone on bone would likely save my hips. I could work.

LakieLady · 10/05/2022 08:19

My BIL saw an NHS consultant who confirmed that he needed both knees replaced. He was told that the wait would be 18-24 months, and that they would leave it a minimum of 9 months between operations.

He paid for a private appointment with a different consultant, who added him to his NHS list. He had one operation within 3 month, and the second approx weeks later. Both were done on the NHS but in a private hospital.

I did wonder if he paid for the surgery privately (they can afford it) and is trying to wind me up, but MIL is adamant that they didn't have to pay for the surgery.

CharlotteUnaNatalieThompson · 10/05/2022 07:05

I've read the op posts.

I'm an NHS surgeon in an unrelated field so can't comment on the specifics of your case OP. And from what you've said it certainly sounds like your care hasn't been ideal, especially with regards to the communication.

But just because an operation CAN be done that doesn't mean it's the right thing. And I would leave the my job the day I was told I must operate when it went against my clinical judgement. The decision of the individual who is to operate must always be respected, because if things go wrong this is their responsibility so they must retain the absolute right to refuse if they think it's the wrong decision.

As you point out we most definitely are NOT gods, but we are human beings. Can you imagine being forced to cut someone up when you thought it was wrong? On the other side can you imagine (and do you REALLY want) to be operated on by someone who, for whatever reason, didn't want to do it?

On a handful of occasions i have refused to operate despite the patient wanting surgery, and stating they are happy with the risks I've quoted, which are often a 50% chance of making it worse. Some of them have been deeply unhappy, upset, and angry. The difference with your situation is that I've explained to them very very clearly why I'm not prepared to operate, been kind and empathetic to them, and offered them to be referred for a second opinion. Because sometimes things are not black and white, I'm not God, and someone else might agree to operate. I think you should be pursuing through PALS is a consultation with clear answers as to why in your case doing nothing is the correct approach. You really deserve opened and honesty.

You can still seek a second opinion or get this done privately (as you already are) while you try to get these answers, and then if you think your care has been unacceptable, especially if there is bias in the system, pursue a formal complaint against the surgeon and team who wouldn't operate.

I would strongly advise against going to Turkey though, even if it's cheaper, as there is no follow-up and no fallback if you have problems. You'll be back in a system you don't trust potentially under the care of the team who have refused to treat you so far. As someone who had said they can afford it pay the extra for peace of mind.

cigarettesNalcohol · 10/05/2022 06:37

Report it to the press ? Get a journalist to write about it and emphasise on the sexist elements too ?

Vikinga · 10/05/2022 04:16

This is a chilling read. For so many people to have to live in pain in this country. I hope the Tories are posted asap and we can work to getting our country working again, for the many, not just for the rich.

splendidsue · 10/05/2022 03:49

You are also smart enough not to try and lie to an A&E consultant. They've seen it all before!

splendidsue · 10/05/2022 03:47

I'm laughing at the ridiculous conclusions people have jumped to about what your surgery is. It was clear from the near beginning what you were looking for.

Anyhow complain to the cqc as well as the CCG. I'm guessing you couldn't be seen by another consultant at the same hospital?

Nat6999 · 10/05/2022 03:34

I needed a hysterectomy & my CCG wouldn't fund it without me having tried a mirena coil for at least 2 years. I had endometriosis so bad I was unable to work & as a new single parent of a 6 year old was struggling to care for ds. They announced this 24 hours before I was due to go in hospital. I appealed with the help of my GP, Consultant & my MP, it took a month to go through all the stages of the appeal but I won. Are you unable to work because of your condition? If you are the fact that you may lose your job can be part of your reason to appeal. Other than that have you thought of presenting in A & E telling them you have fallen & hurt the area again? Maybe that could be a way in.

LetitiaLeghorn · 10/05/2022 02:37

A friend of mine was due an operation which the trust decided to withdraw from being offered. She was advised that if the pain affected her sleeping and therefore started to give her chest pains, they would do it because to not do so could be fatal. How's your sleeping and do you get chest pains?

Springhassprung86 · 10/05/2022 02:14

If your GP is equally as confused and frustrated, they can refer you to another NHS trust for a second opinion.
ry find it difficult to believe that the consultant refused to give a reason for no surgery but ranted at you over it. Strange.

Trafficjamlog · 09/05/2022 23:15

@myceliumama I agree the fact that the NHS won’t do it is totally unacceptable but to go ahead to get a cheap operation which can be done by excellent and experienced private surgeons here with proper follow up is madness. I’m sure that there are excellent hospitals in turkey but there are also outstanding knee surgeons here who can also operate almost immediately and will be on hand to follow up and you choose who you want to operate on you based on their skills and experience. No way would I have a random Turkish (or any other overseas) doctor I had never heard of and who nobody I knew had used go anywhere near me.

LIZS · 09/05/2022 21:55

No it is not only Pals who can access notes, you can submit a DSAR to the hospital. There should be information on the hospital website about accessing your information with a form and timeframes.

AchatAVendre · 09/05/2022 21:14

Really sorry to hear of other people's bad experiences and I hope you get treatment soon. This is a depressing thread. I honestly think if I was a doctor, I couldn't work in the NHS and as soon as I qualified I'd go abroad. I can tell by the way the letter suggesting that "doing nothing was the way forward" was written by the consultant that he was kind of ashamed about it. Still doesn't cancel the fact that if you're a man in that hospital trust, you are far more likely to get that kind of surgery than a woman (I did a FOI request and they very reluctantly gave me the figures).

The thing is, you can get an infection in an NHS hospital too and they can refuse to do anything about it. My healthcare trust usually settles out of court I believe but one nurse who sued them for her bungled knee replacement and subsequent MRSA infection which they refused to treat for months obviously refused to keep it quiet. So yes, on balance I think Turkey is a good option as long as I'm careful. Loads of Americans go to Turkey because its cheaper than the US.

Its a very simple operation to take something out which is clearly visible on the MRI scan and isn't major surgery. Its a day case in the UK so I certainly wouldn't be getting any follow up care here either. It is actually part of the package in most Turkish hospitals in the first week.

I don't hold out much faith in the NHS second opinion being done in a reasonable time, I requested that the request for the second opinion it be put in a couple of weeks ago and I've heard nothing at all. Then I would have to go on the waiting list for the second opinion and then on the waiting list for surgery. Probably 9 months or so minimum.

OP posts:
Evenstar · 09/05/2022 20:50

My friend’s grandson has been left infertile at the age of 8 due to the wait he had for a surgery needed ☹️ I am on week 4 for 2 week wait referral for a breast lump. The NHS is utterly overwhelmed and if you have the money I would go private. I could fill a page with all the problems I have had getting treatment in the last two years and I am still waiting for two other things as well as the 2 ww referral.

Swipe left for the next trending thread