Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DD's friend, worried about family's living conditions

38 replies

tanyaek · 09/05/2022 13:21

Not in my house, but the family of my DD's best friend from school.
Went to collect my DD from having tea at said house on Friday evening.
The little girl's parents seemed embarrassed when I went inside and saw all the damp, mold all over the living room. I didn't say anything but my face must have told a story. The mum then said follow me, showed me around the whole house, said they've been struggling with the landlord for a couple of years, but nothing being done.
The little girl (4 years old) and her older brothers (teenagers) suffer with asthma, as do the parents.
The landlord sounds a total rogue from what mum told me on Friday. Turns up to take payment every month but makes constant excuses not treat the mold and damp. Says it will cost too much, therefore decides not to bother.
The bathroom and parent's bedroom looked like those shown on ITV news a couple of months back. Completely black with mold.
When showing me round the house (I'd never been before as don't really know the family well, DS and the little girl have only been friends for a few weeks since we moved to the area), the mum seemed scared to report the landlord, says he's intimidating. TBH, didn't even sound like a properly -registered one, if he turns up to collect cash payments each month.
I think social services are aware of the situation as it was highlighted following a recent medical episode. The SS have told the family the house isn't fit to live in. But nothing seems to be happening... Why aren't SS getting on the landlord's case and forcing some action?
The couple seemed worried about the rent being increased to reflect repair costs, and don't seem keen to kick up a fuss.
I felt so helpless when seeing the conditions on Friday, how can the landlord get away with this?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
coffeecupsandfairylights · 09/05/2022 18:24

VintageGibbon · 09/05/2022 17:58

I haven;t rented for decades so this may be out of date but it used to be legal to withhold rent and spend it on necessary repairs if the landlord doesn't sort them in a timely manner. Worth checking if that's still legal and then not paying the rent until it is done, but holding it in a savings account to pay as soon as all remedial work has been signed off.

No, you can't just withhold rent. Not paying your rent will just result in eviction.

It's also the case that the landlord isn't responsible for repairs caused by the tenants' failure to look after the property correctly.

Your landlord doesn’t have to make sure your home’s fit for human habitation if you caused the problem by:


  • not looking after your home properly - for example not using the extractor fan after having a shower

  • doing something unreasonable - for example leaving candles burning when you go out


www.citizensadvice.org.uk/housing/renting-privately/during-your-tenancy/dealing-with-repairs/

coffeecupsandfairylights · 09/05/2022 18:18

The living conditions sound poor but mould is generally down to the tenants, not the landlord.

My ex and I used to rent a room in a flat and when our flatmate moved out, we took over the whole tenancy. We went into his room after he left and the mould was horrendous. We cleaned it up and aired the place, and then lived there for another two years without a single issue with mould. We also paid our rent in cash every month - dealing with cash isn't necessarily an issue.

People need to air their homes (especially when drying clothing indoors), invest in things like dehumidifiers, heat their homes adequately and open windows when doing things like cooking. If tenants are choosing not to do those things (or are financially incapable of doing so) it's not really the fault of the landlord as such.

Like PP have said, tread carefully here. You may not know the full story and you don't want to be responsible for them being evicted.

SleepingStandingUp · 09/05/2022 18:12

If they aren't prepared to contact Env Health etc then really there's nothing you can do.

Were the windows open when you went in? Was the property overcrowded with items against the wall? Did she suggest they're making any effort to wash the walls down etc?

I guess you could offer to help in a "was thinking about your mold situation, I remember Mom saying you could treat it like this, I'd be happy to give you a hand and the girls could play at mine" but difficult to know how it'll be taken

Lavapalaver · 09/05/2022 18:02

I’m amazed by how many people have landlords that turn up monthly for envelopes of cash.
They often exploit people whose credit history means an agreement with proper contracts is hard to obtain. It’s not rare as someone else suggested , it’s happening more than ever.

VintageGibbon · 09/05/2022 17:58

I haven;t rented for decades so this may be out of date but it used to be legal to withhold rent and spend it on necessary repairs if the landlord doesn't sort them in a timely manner. Worth checking if that's still legal and then not paying the rent until it is done, but holding it in a savings account to pay as soon as all remedial work has been signed off.

2bazookas · 09/05/2022 17:53

@MissusMaisel And what possibly could be the other side of this situation?>

MH problems, addiction.

Merryoldgoat · 09/05/2022 17:24

I had black mold caused my condensation a few years back as there was a quirk with the building that made it particularly susceptible.

Thet need to empty each room, scrub the walls with a light bleach solution to get rid of the mold and then clean the room thoroughly and get a dehumidifier in each room.

its horrible and the landlord could do more but black mold is likely condensation rather than damp.

elbea · 09/05/2022 17:14

@truhamboys if there is no room for a tumble dryer get a heated airer and stick it in the smallest room with a dehumidifier running. You sign an agreement to look after a property, the landlord doesn’t need to hold a tenants hand through everything because they don’t want to buy a tumble dryer.

The people here need to clean the house thoroughly with bleach or mould killer, get a dehumidifier, keep the windows cracked open and wipe down the windows in the mornings. They should also check the extractors are working. I say this as a surveyor. Although not a building surveyor I did have to study two years of construction at university and one of my qualifying competencies was Housing Repair and Maintenance.

MedievalNun · 09/05/2022 16:20

As a stop-gap, Astonish do an amazing mould & mildew spray - spray affected area, leave for 20 minutes & wipe off. It kills the mould spores, but if they have got into the plaster or the render outside has cracked then it's only a stop-gap (& it's really cheap in Home Bargains). I have it as hubs will only sleep with the windows closed and if the weather is too bad to open them then the room can get stuffy.

Other than that, unless you know of better rentals / can help find them then there isn't that much you can do, especially if, as you say, SS are already involved and advising them. That said, maybe host playdates at yours so that the child gets a break from the mould?

I get that you are concerned, and that's good, but with the chronic lack of social housing and affordable rented accommodation too many are in the same situation as this family, throughout Britain.

truhamboys · 09/05/2022 16:14

elbea · 09/05/2022 15:58

@truhamboys I’m sure cracked render is the cause of widespread damp, particularly concentrated in the bathroom.

I live in a rented house and bought my own tumble dryer, surely people need to take personal responsibility for themselves.

In my current rented flat there's absolutely no space for a tumble dryer in the kitchen or bathroom... unless you think I should put it next to the TV in the living room? In front of the fireplace? Or perhaps I should replace the bedside table with a tumble dryer.

And to be perfectly honest, I'm not paying out £300++, in addition to the running costs, for an item I may not be able to take with me when the landlord inevitably evicts, as they always do eventually, to protect someone else's property. If the landlord thinks a tumble dryer is necessary they should be providing one (and it would need to be a condenser tumble dryer, as vented ones will just release the moisture back into the room).

Funny how both my parents (owner occupiers, separate houses) have always dried all their laundry indoors and have never had problems with damp. Blaming damp on condensation is invariably a slumlord tactic to victim blame the tenant and avoid taking action to deal with the cracked render / damp proof course / cracked pipe / dodgy roof.

MissusMaisel · 09/05/2022 16:09

2bazookas · 09/05/2022 14:23

Never assume you know the full story or have been told the truth.

Just keep your children away from that house

And what possibly could be the other side of this situation?>

Bimster · 09/05/2022 16:07

Have they been in touch with Shelter? They are a great source of advice.

Walkaround · 09/05/2022 16:03

Howaboutnope · 09/05/2022 15:45

This

Speak to the mum about things she could do to sort it herself. A landlord can't help with cleaning, the tenant needs to do that themselves.

However if its a genuine damp problem I.e coming from the outside in and needs real damp proof repairs then YANBU. Or rather she is not being unreasonable. However inaction is achieving absolutely nothing so for the sake of her children she needs to sort this shit out. It's shameful she hasn't done something sooner TBH.

Basically, then, mould may just be because the tenants are alive… If they are barely able to afford the rent, they are not going to be able to afford heating or a tumble dryer, so not exactly many options for avoiding all of mould, damp and hypothermia for a large part of every year.

elbea · 09/05/2022 15:58

@truhamboys I’m sure cracked render is the cause of widespread damp, particularly concentrated in the bathroom.

I live in a rented house and bought my own tumble dryer, surely people need to take personal responsibility for themselves.

FAQs · 09/05/2022 15:50

@tanyaek if they follow the correct reporting procedure they can be protected from revenge evictions. More details here england.shelter.org.uk/housing_advice/repairs/revenge_eviction_if_you_ask_for_repairs

Howaboutnope · 09/05/2022 15:45

Villagewaspbyke · 09/05/2022 15:25

Yes I agree. Usually mould that is widespread like that is due to how the tenants are living (drying clothes inside, not heating house, not ventilating house). They need to clean mould with bleach and dry it off.

One patch on a wall or ceiling might be a building issue but widespread mould like that is because of how they are living.

This

Speak to the mum about things she could do to sort it herself. A landlord can't help with cleaning, the tenant needs to do that themselves.

However if its a genuine damp problem I.e coming from the outside in and needs real damp proof repairs then YANBU. Or rather she is not being unreasonable. However inaction is achieving absolutely nothing so for the sake of her children she needs to sort this shit out. It's shameful she hasn't done something sooner TBH.

truhamboys · 09/05/2022 15:43

Honestly, keep out of it.

If anyone kicks up a fuss on their behalf then the landlord can simply evict the family, and there is nothing anyone can do to stop him. A section 21 eviction notice can be given for any reason or none whatsoever and would (in England) give them only 2 months before court action commences. They would then end up having to find a new place to move to (difficult, the rental market is currently very overheated), and magic up money for a deposit.

I very much doubt they are staying there despite having better options.

There's some incredibly patronising advice about condensation on this thread. It's highly likely that there are some structural defects (e.g. cracked render causing penetrating damp). As for not drying clothes indoors - where exactly are you meant to dry them in the winter months if the landlord hasn't provided a tumble dryer? Plus tumble dryers are incredibly expensive to run.

LakieLady · 09/05/2022 15:39

Because of the dire lack of tenants' rights, people are often afraid to report repairs for fear of pissing off their landlords and getting a notice to quit. With rents going up and up, their chances of finding somewhere affordable could be very low, and a pissed-off LL would be unlikely to give them a decent reference.

And while social services might be concerned about the conditions the children are living in, they don't have the power to do anything about it. Housing disrepair is a matter for environmental health.

The wait for a visit from an EHO is currently 12-16 weeks here. The landlord could issue an NTQ and it would expire before the EHO came round.

The housing system in this country is broken, and tenants suffer because of it.

Villagewaspbyke · 09/05/2022 15:25

elbea · 09/05/2022 15:15

It’s really unlikely that if there is damp and mould in every room that it would be a building defect unless at a push there are faulty extractors. It sounds like poor ventilation. I would seriously doubt environmental health would do anything past telling them to clean it and keep the house ventilated.

Yes I agree. Usually mould that is widespread like that is due to how the tenants are living (drying clothes inside, not heating house, not ventilating house). They need to clean mould with bleach and dry it off.

One patch on a wall or ceiling might be a building issue but widespread mould like that is because of how they are living.

elbea · 09/05/2022 15:15

It’s really unlikely that if there is damp and mould in every room that it would be a building defect unless at a push there are faulty extractors. It sounds like poor ventilation. I would seriously doubt environmental health would do anything past telling them to clean it and keep the house ventilated.

HollowTalk · 09/05/2022 15:10

Landlords like this should go to prison.

Threebutterflies · 09/05/2022 15:08

cecilthehungryspider · 09/05/2022 14:10

As a landlord, I cannot get my head around why landlords do this (and I know they do). The property is an investment and as an investment, it needs looking after.

I guess the answer to how they get away with it is that the tenants are too scared to challenge the landlord. I'm assuming they want to stay there because the rent is cheap?

There's some good information here: england.shelter.org.uk/housing_advice/repairs/damp_and_mould_in_rented_homes

Yes this is why I don’t report many repairs. Our house needs a lot of repairs but he already wants me to pay more rent ! He said he could get more rent but he’d have to spend thousands doing it up. It’s embarrassing now as the front of the house needs painting and doing up . It’s the worst house on the street 😳

gothereagain · 09/05/2022 15:07

Unfortunately as rental start becoming rarer these landlords are only going to get away with it more.

gothereagain · 09/05/2022 14:54

Why aren't SS getting on the landlord's case and forcing some action?

Because they can't. Social Services have no powers over the housing department, landlord, environmental health or any other body. Social Services can advise the family of the actions to take (such as reporting to right council department) but cannot do that themselves. Should the family fail to take the recommended action this could be considered placing the children at risk.

The family need to contact the council, some councils have a private tenancy department set up for this sort of thing. Alternatively they could look for a new rental (challenging at the moment), register with the councils housing department for a housing association or council house (unlikely unless they also report the current property and are assessed as being inappropriately housed.

Landlords like this should be reported and enforcement action should be taken. The councils I have worked with have been pretty good at that but lots aren't and even more landlords get away with it because tenants are afraid they'll be evicted, usually because they don't know their rights.

Winter2020 · 09/05/2022 14:49

You need to tread carefully as the family won't thank you for getting them evicted. It sounds like they already have agencies involved helping them.

You could encourage them to sign up for Council Housing and Housing Association registration and they could try to get some priority for their poor living conditions.

If there were a reasonable amount of properties to rent and social housing then no one would be living in places like this but the family are finding no alternative at the moment.

I am surprised you allow your 4 year old to go to play dates with strangers in a strange house. Playdates as that age I stayed/ invited parent and child.