Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sold my car and buyer isn't happy

209 replies

monotonousmum · 09/05/2022 11:24

I sold my car at the weekend, and the buyer has messaged today to say she isn't happy.

Car is 13 years old. Only known issue is that the boot needs to be opened via remote button on the key. It's been like this for three years - and I showed her this before she took the car.

This morning I've had a text to say she's taken it to a garage and they've valued it at £900 under what she paid for it. Brakes need doing, wiper needs replacing, and apparently an electrical problem causes the boot issue.

She hasn't asked me for anything yet. Just told me she's not happy.

I've sent a polite response back to say its a good car, and she should maybe get another opinion. A dealer offered me £200 under what she paid for it last week, and it's a 13 year old car so not going to be perfect.

I offered her to test drive it, she didn't want to. She asked for a reduced price, which was agreed (slightly more than she offered, but £300 less than my asking price). The price was in line with the autotrader valuation, and similar cars for sale.

I feel bad for her if she's not happy, but I have no intention of giving her a refund or anything. AIBU?

OP posts:
Overthewine · 09/05/2022 16:15

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

KillingEvenings · 09/05/2022 16:13

OP priced the car £500 over the price a dealer offered last week. If this is a price jump from say £2000 to £2500, as could be with a car that old then sorry that is greed. Used cars don’t increase in value by that much in a week.

Sorry, that's not how it works. If you sell to a dealership you sell at less than you would get if you sold privately. (Because the dealer needs to be able to sell the same car at a profit.) Likewise if you buy a car privately, you pay less, partly because of the risk involved.

It is not greed, it's the market and it's how the market has always worked. Some people might choose to take the dealer's lower offer because it saves them the time and hassle of selling direct to a buyer. Some may want to get a higher offer from a private buyer, not because it's "gone up in value" but because they can get a better price and the buyer can get a better price.

This is the buyer's problem, not your OP.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 09/05/2022 16:07

Just to say - not sure where the requirement for the car to be roadworthy for a private sale that is mentioned in a couple of posts has come from but it's nonsense (in the UK at least) - there is no such requirement. You don't even have to draw attention to any defects - what you cannot do is tell lies about them.

gothereagain · 09/05/2022 16:01

Discovereads · 09/05/2022 12:11

@AchatAVendre

So why should a buyer take someone who knows cars with them if it’s nonsense that buyers do so to avoid being ripped off by unethical sellers? You said the buyer should have brought someone who knows cars…why should she have then if my reason is “nonsense”?

And as my reason is “nonsense” doesn’t that mean you believe every private seller of cars out there is 100% honest and trustworthy?

Because that assumes that the seller 'knows cars' and can spot that there are issues. I could say my car is totally fine - because to me it is. But I wouldn't know what I was looking at if I saw the brakes, I couldn't tell if they were good or not, all I can say is when I drive it there are no issues. So I wouldn't be lying, I'd be genuinely unaware of the issues. So I would take someone with me who knows cars, not because I don't trust the seller, but because I can't be sure the seller would know if there was an issue.

Time2ChangeName · 09/05/2022 15:54

@thedancingbear
Your fault is potentially selling a car that is unroadworthy, most plausibly because it has faulty brakes (if this turns out to be true, which is a big if). Fine if you tell your buyer that the brakes need looking at, not fine if you haven't.

If the new owners were stopped by the police and there was a fault, whether a bulb was out or the brakes weren’t working, the vendor would not be prosecuted. The onus is on the driver/purchaser.

Time2ChangeName · 09/05/2022 15:48

@Discovereads
It can be both. OP priced the car £500 over the price a dealer offered last week. If this is a price jump from say £2000 to £2500, as could be with a car that old then sorry that is greed. Used cars don’t increase in value by that much in a week.

It sounds as though the OP has allowed for bartering with whoever was going to purchase, they probably would have gone down to a similar price to what the garage offered but the purchaser agreed a price, I imagine shaking hands on the deal. They’ve not sold a cut n shut and if you look at any website regarding buying a car they recommend getting someone to look at the vehicle. The OP probably would’ve held the car for the buyer to have it looked over but they chose to hand over their £££ at a price they agreed.

What would you do if you were selling a house? It’s valued at offers near £85,000. Blind bidding, two people wanted it and there were two offers at the same time one cash buyer, no chain offers £87,500 and another homeowner, part of a chain of 5 other homeowners offer £87,000 would your conscience allow you to take the better offer, would that be greedy too, or would you say it’s ok you can have it for £85k?

Siht · 09/05/2022 15:43

thedancingbear · 09/05/2022 14:32

Your fault is potentially selling a car that is unroadworthy, most plausibly because it has faulty brakes (if this turns out to be true, which is a big if). Fine if you tell your buyer that the brakes need looking at, not fine if you haven't.

Of course whether your buyer can, as a practical thing, do anything about this, is the next question.

The buyer would have to somehow prove OP knew the brakes needed replaced and didn't tell her... It doesn't sound like OP knew, and it would be almost impossible to prove.
It's probably the shoes or pads that need replacing, not the brakes as a whole. Brake pads are ridiculously easy to change by yourself as well.

It is completely on the buyer for not inspecting and test driving the car. I've driven one that looked fine but as soon as I set off on the test drive I could tell the clutch was slipping, which would probably have cost the near enough the value of the car to replace. If the buyer couldn't tell this sort of thing herself, she should have brought someone who could.

PutinIsAWarCriminal · 09/05/2022 15:40

The phrases spring to mind of "sold as seen" and "buyer beware". You did your job in getting as much as you could for your car, she didn't do her job in making sure the vehicle was what she wanted. Realistically, what can she expect to gain from complaining?

Theunamedcat · 09/05/2022 15:35

Honestly when my brakes have needed doing my mot centre tells me these are fine now but change them in the next 6 months or whatever the last garage I had my mot done at said I needed a new tyre in the next 6 months or 12 if boris locks us down again that's standard isnt it? I call it work fishing but it helps me know when I need work doing because I'm clueless really

WhereYouLeftIt · 09/05/2022 15:33

I feel bad for her if she's not happy, but I have no intention of giving her a refund or anything. AIBU?

Stop feeling bad for her. She refused your offer of a test drive - weird. And she could have brought someone with her to check the car over before buying it. The AA do vehicle inspections, for example. Either she's trying to scam you or the garage is trying to scam her (assuming there is actually a real garage involved).

We recently sold a car, older than yours, and got much more for it than we would have a couple of years ago. It came as a pleasant surprise to us, but I had read about the increased prices in the second-hand market due to supply chain issues for new cars. We set the price according to Autotrader too. As has already been pointed out, IF she is now quibbling over money, it's because "She's probably had comments from a male member of her family or friend giving it the big talk and saying she was ripped off, when in reality it was fine for the price."

If she comes back to you looking for money (after all, she's already made you feel bad, hasn't she?) refuse and block. You're a private seller, she had every opportunity to have the car looked at before buying. She's owed nothing.

Itloggedmeoutagain · 09/05/2022 15:27

If I was selling a car I'd look on auto trader to get an idea of the price to ask
If I was buying a car I'd take someone who knows more than I do about cars to look it over
If I was buying a car I would test drive it.
Sold as seen.
OP has done nothing wrong

thedancingbear · 09/05/2022 15:19

I'm confused. This is exactly what I posted?!

IsabelHerna · 09/05/2022 15:02

If she contacts you again, reply her to her with something polite and end the conversation there.

Dixiechickonhols · 09/05/2022 15:02

She didn’t have it on for £500 over guide price it was £500 over dealer trade in. Woman haggled her down by £300.
so eg dealer offered £1500. Op advertises for £2000. Woman gets for £1800. Dealer would have sold it for £2500. A second hand car is worth what someone will pay.
No idea how you are supposed to know your car has brake issues if it passed mot no advisory 3000 miles ago. I drive an older car and wouldn’t have a clue. If I sold mine tomorrow it has a valid mot and drives fine - I’ve no idea what’s up with it or not.

MissConductUS · 09/05/2022 15:00

I think I'd be a bit upset if I'd bought a car and found out the brakes needed replacing. But they were fine less than 3k miles ago, so I can't imagine they could be that bad now.

With brakes, there's a standard thickness for the pads at which they are okay, and if thinner, you need to replace them. It's perfectly reasonable that they were okay three months ago but have now crossed the line into needing replacement.

LampLighter414 · 09/05/2022 14:47

Based on facebook/gumtree/eBay selling threads here and personal experience expect follow up messages in the coming todays and an insistence that it is your problem to solve, not theirs, demands for a refund etc. If refused expect abuse and if blocked for their family and friends to message you in similar fashion and statuses and posts on local groups deriding you.

Good luck.

TabithaTittlemouse · 09/05/2022 14:46

Why would you buy a car and then take it to a garage to have it checked and valued?

She’s having you on op.

tigger1001 · 09/05/2022 14:44

I have just bought a new car. The dealer was upfront and said I could a. Trade car in. B go to we buy any car or c. Sell privately. You get more if you sell privately. That's not a shock to anyone that's bought a car. He offered me around £200 less than we buy any car (had already done my own valuation before) but could have probably got 800 or so more for a private sale. It's not greedy to do that - you offer it at a price and someone either buys it or they don't. I didn't want the hassle so accepted the lower valuation.

If you buy privately, you have zero come back. Zero guarantee. You buy as seen. It's risky unless you know about cars.

I would block.

godmum56 · 09/05/2022 14:41

thedancingbear · 09/05/2022 14:32

Your fault is potentially selling a car that is unroadworthy, most plausibly because it has faulty brakes (if this turns out to be true, which is a big if). Fine if you tell your buyer that the brakes need looking at, not fine if you haven't.

Of course whether your buyer can, as a practical thing, do anything about this, is the next question.

@thedancingbear .... private cars sales are buyer beware. Car only has to be roadworthy and as described and the seller has to have the tight to sell the car and thats all.
Buying a used car privately

You won't have the same legal protection as you would if buying from a dealer
It's up to you to ask the right questions and inspect the car thoroughly before you buy.
It's a good idea to get a thorough car check to make sure there's no shady past.
Because your legal rights are more limited, unscrupulous dealers may masquerade as private sellers:

Be very wary if a private seller wants to meet you somewhere other than at their home, or if their name is not on the V5C registration document.
A dealer pretending to be a private seller is committing a criminal offence.
The only legal terms that cover a private sale contract are:

The seller must have the right to sell the car.
The vehicle should match the description given by the seller.
The car must be roadworthy – it is a criminal offence to sell an unroadworthy car and an MOT certificate from a test several months ago is no guarantee that the car is roadworthy today.

www.theaa.com/car-buying/legal-rights

Oblomov22 · 09/05/2022 14:40

FFS
I'm laughing at these people criticising OP for selling at £500 over guide price. Her audacity. Wink
She advertised, the woman bought. Did she negotiate? The price as agreed. End of.

Wexone · 09/05/2022 14:39

@Discovereads ah come on now everyone knows you get more selling a car privately than what a dealer offers you, that's the way it has worked for like forever.
OP - don't even engage, block her straight away

Mosaic123 · 09/05/2022 14:37

Last time I bought a second hand car I paid £100 to have it checked by the AA.

She should have done this.

CantHaveTooMuchChocolate · 09/05/2022 14:35

Discovereads · 09/05/2022 11:38

To take a car you just bought to a garage and find out you paid £900 over its value for a 13yr old car would be a shock. Most 13yr old cars are under £5k, so that’s a massive difference.

Why did you price the car at £500 over what a dealer offered you for it? How much % of an increase was this? You showed her the boot issue, and she could have seen the wipers, but why did you not mention the brakes?

Yes the law says caveat emptor (buyer beware) but part of me thinks you’ve been a bit greedy and taken advantage of a less well off person by deliberately charging them too high a price for your 13 yr old car and not disclosing expensive brake maintenance you knew was due.

I completely disagree. No dealer will ever offer the true second hand value of a vehicle, otherwise they’d make no money! It’s very easy to find out the value of a second hand car via various websites, etc. The buyer should have done her homework before seeing and offering on the car. Most 13 year old cars will need some sort of work done, my old Seat used to need hundreds spent at every mot. I don’t see anywhere the op says she knew about expensive brake maintenance?

Notanotherwindow · 09/05/2022 14:34

I have an 11 year old car and my brakes want doing every 18 months or so. Yes ok it's an auto so I expect a bit more wear than a manual but even so it's just maintenance isn't it. You expect it in any car you buy.

I got mine from a dealer and straight away I could see it needed new tyres and wipers as the previous owner hardly used it. She literally did under 2k miles a year so the tyres were cracking.

It's just the usual annual or so upkeep that she'd be doing anyway. Unless there is an urgent fault with the brakes yanbu. As long as you press the pedal and it stops, it's fine.

thedancingbear · 09/05/2022 14:32

monotonousmum · 09/05/2022 14:29

I'm wondering what my fault was? Selling it at the guide price, and not at dealer price?

I could have had it serviced before selling, but didn't really want to throw away £250. It was driving fine - and sounds like it still is.

I think I'd be a bit upset if I'd bought a car and found out the brakes needed replacing. But they were fine less than 3k miles ago, so I can't imagine they could be that bad now.

I haven't heard back from her. So hopefully she's got a second opinion and realised the price was fair.

Your fault is potentially selling a car that is unroadworthy, most plausibly because it has faulty brakes (if this turns out to be true, which is a big if). Fine if you tell your buyer that the brakes need looking at, not fine if you haven't.

Of course whether your buyer can, as a practical thing, do anything about this, is the next question.

Swipe left for the next trending thread