Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sold my car and buyer isn't happy

209 replies

monotonousmum · 09/05/2022 11:24

I sold my car at the weekend, and the buyer has messaged today to say she isn't happy.

Car is 13 years old. Only known issue is that the boot needs to be opened via remote button on the key. It's been like this for three years - and I showed her this before she took the car.

This morning I've had a text to say she's taken it to a garage and they've valued it at £900 under what she paid for it. Brakes need doing, wiper needs replacing, and apparently an electrical problem causes the boot issue.

She hasn't asked me for anything yet. Just told me she's not happy.

I've sent a polite response back to say its a good car, and she should maybe get another opinion. A dealer offered me £200 under what she paid for it last week, and it's a 13 year old car so not going to be perfect.

I offered her to test drive it, she didn't want to. She asked for a reduced price, which was agreed (slightly more than she offered, but £300 less than my asking price). The price was in line with the autotrader valuation, and similar cars for sale.

I feel bad for her if she's not happy, but I have no intention of giving her a refund or anything. AIBU?

OP posts:
ImAvingOops · 09/05/2022 17:47

The OP has no way of knowing what the brakes are like - she's had it MOTd which is what normal people rely on to know their cars are road worthy. Even if the buyer tried to take it further, the fact that they refused a test drive and didn't even look at the car, wouldn't bode well for them.

browneyes77 · 09/05/2022 16:59

It’s Sold as Seen. So it’s tough shit!

She can sell it herself and use the money to get something else if she’s that bothered.

Do not engage any further. She has no legal rights on this. So ignore and block.

Time2ChangeName · 09/05/2022 16:55

the fact is that, if the OP has sold a car with faulty brakes, and has not disclosed this, she has broken the law.

Says the buyer who’s refused to test drive. The buyer needs to accept that they are not blameless in this transaction.
If I sold my car now am I expected to get a mechanic to check everything? If it drives ok and there’s no squeaking or grinding of the brakes and the last service/MOT said they were all in order?
Presumably they were using the vehicle in the days/weeks leading up to the sale and it all seemed ok. She hasn’t broken the law if you have shown due diligence which the OP appears to have done.

AchatAVendre · 09/05/2022 16:53

thedancingbear · 09/05/2022 16:33

There are actually quite a lot of convictions under this provision - google it. It's usually dealers, I grant you, and, from memory, prosecutions have tended to be where dealers have sold multiple ringers and Trading Standards have evidence of deliberate wrongdoing.

But the provision applies to private sales too. A prosecution would be unlikely but not impossible - if the buyer drives off and is immediately involved in a serious crash, and the brakes are obviously faulty, then meeting the criminal standard isn't going to be difficult.

I don't have any particular agenda in posting this, but the fact is that, if the OP has sold a car with faulty brakes, and has not disclosed this, she has broken the law. Small claims route is much more viable than trading standards, of court, at least if her buyer has a mate in a garage who is prepared to give a statement.

Yes! Not of private sellers! That is never going to work with a car sold in these circumstances. The legislation isn't designed to protect non-consumer sales. It would a basic breach of contract action, and its too difficult to prove the OP breached her contract of selling a 13 year old car with a current MOT because all thats required under the contract is that it meets any description she has given.

Dixiechickonhols · 09/05/2022 16:52

There is no chance if any comeback on Op she’s done absolutely nothing wrong. How can buyer prove she knew it had faulty brakes when she sold it. Her evidence is it was driving fine and had recently passed mot. She’s a private seller not a trade dealer. Buyer could have damaged it, garage might be pulling a fast one.
I had a garage (main dealer) quote me £500 for a brake repair. It was very occasionally binding on if I went to go into reverse - once a blue moon if been left standing for days. Not unsafe just had to take foot off clutch and put in gear again. I was very suspicious as it was funny they picked it up just out of warranty. I’d asked about it in warranty and been told it was quite normal. Needless to say I didn’t pay, a mechanic friend hit it with a lump hammer and I had no more issues and it passed all future MOTs.

Tessasanderson · 09/05/2022 16:49

thedancingbear · 09/05/2022 16:33

There are actually quite a lot of convictions under this provision - google it. It's usually dealers, I grant you, and, from memory, prosecutions have tended to be where dealers have sold multiple ringers and Trading Standards have evidence of deliberate wrongdoing.

But the provision applies to private sales too. A prosecution would be unlikely but not impossible - if the buyer drives off and is immediately involved in a serious crash, and the brakes are obviously faulty, then meeting the criminal standard isn't going to be difficult.

I don't have any particular agenda in posting this, but the fact is that, if the OP has sold a car with faulty brakes, and has not disclosed this, she has broken the law. Small claims route is much more viable than trading standards, of court, at least if her buyer has a mate in a garage who is prepared to give a statement.

Dancing Bear you seem to be getting yourself in a muddle. You refer to rules that apply to dealers (Of course a dealer has a responsibility). But then you are tyring to imply that the same rules apply to joe bloggs. They dont.

The only glint of a situation is if the OP had taken her car into a garage a few days before, been advised the brakes needed replacing urgently and then proceeded to sell the car. EVEN THEN its still reliant on the purchaser asking "Are the brakes good" and the OP replying "Yes".

hellcatspanglelalala · 09/05/2022 16:42

I had this a few weeks ago - sold the car having passed the mot two days prior, and the buyer text me a week later saying his garage said it shouldn't have passed and he'd had to spend £500 on new tyres and brake pads. I did initially engage, just to say I fully trusted the garage who did the MOT, but didn't respond any further. I've not heard anything since.

As others have said, you're not a dealer and there's no guarantee on a private sale of a used car. I have to admit it did worry me though, and I did feel a bit guilty even though it was sold as seen (obviously I had no idea it was in need of new tyres, I assume it only just passed the MOT and his garage just advised him to get them replaced)

DeskInUse · 09/05/2022 16:42

Buyer beware I'm afraid, it's her issue.

DolphinaPD · 09/05/2022 16:41

3 words. Sold as seen.

LisaSimpson73 · 09/05/2022 16:35

If it mattered that much she should have got a mechanic to look before not after the sale.
It's her responsibility now so stop engaging.

Bettyboopawoop · 09/05/2022 16:35

Block her number.

thedancingbear · 09/05/2022 16:33

AchatAVendre · 09/05/2022 16:23

Dancingbear do you have any idea of the evidence required to prove a that a car was defective under s.75(1)? Do you imagine that there are criminal cases being brought all the time when someone sells a car which later has a defect or which suffers from wear and tear? Maybe you are trying to persuade us all to be gullible enough to take our cars to garages and get unnecessary work done on brakes which are simply somewhat worn but still not dangerous, just in case a seller somewhere might make a complaint to the police that their currently MOT'd car was taken to a garage who said they needed their brakes fixed?

So therefore, you would think that you could go away, have a little google and come up with some criminal case law where that has actually occurred.

Are you the poster who thinks there are fixed prices for cars as well, I find it hard to distinguish?

There are actually quite a lot of convictions under this provision - google it. It's usually dealers, I grant you, and, from memory, prosecutions have tended to be where dealers have sold multiple ringers and Trading Standards have evidence of deliberate wrongdoing.

But the provision applies to private sales too. A prosecution would be unlikely but not impossible - if the buyer drives off and is immediately involved in a serious crash, and the brakes are obviously faulty, then meeting the criminal standard isn't going to be difficult.

I don't have any particular agenda in posting this, but the fact is that, if the OP has sold a car with faulty brakes, and has not disclosed this, she has broken the law. Small claims route is much more viable than trading standards, of court, at least if her buyer has a mate in a garage who is prepared to give a statement.

Tessasanderson · 09/05/2022 16:31

I have 25yrs motor trade experience. OP please repeat this to yourself

YOU HAVE ZERO MECHANICAL KNOWLEDGE

In other words you cannot be expected to know one way or another if there is or isnt anything wrong with your car. If i ask "are the brakes ok", you dont bloody know. If i ask "Is the engine ok", You dont know. The only questions you can answer are

When is the MOT due
How much will it cost

If i asked you how to carry out frontal lobe brain surgery you would tell me to jog on. Why should you be able to answer mechanical questions about a car. Anyone questioning the price you charged hasnt got a scooby about selling a used car. A garage would buy your car, put it through their workshops, make sure it was roadworthy, mot it and put an element of profit way more than a few hundred quid. You did EVERYTHING correctly

AchatAVendre · 09/05/2022 16:28

I do actually know of where the police were involved in this type of thing though. An ex boyfriend sold a car and much the same thing happened, except the buyer actually got a real bargain and the car was slightly newer. The buyer had it for a week and then texted him to say he had taken it to his friend who was a car mechanic and he said it needed (I can't remember the exact figure) £xxx worth of repairs, so could he send him a cheque?

Ex boyfriend replied saying no, theres nothing wrong with it and you had a chance to inspect before you bought. Then followed a barrage of messages, increasingly threatening. Think up to 6 each night. It got so bad that ex messaged him to say just bring the car back and I'll give you your money back, but no, that wasn't good enough, because apparently the buyer had incurred expenses and wanted compensated. It was all a pack of lies. After a week, I urged ex to go to the police, who really dealt with it well. They made it quite clear that we shouldn't have to put up with that, that it was a well known scam and that they would phone the buyer and tell him to stop.

No more messages. No-one murdered us or vandalised our garden either.

GreenFingersWouldBeHandy · 09/05/2022 16:27

Sold as seen. You offered her a test drive. She declined.

Windscreen wipers are about £3 each.

Don't reply.

Lougle · 09/05/2022 16:25

I bought a car last year. The man said it was 'all fine' and that he was upgrading his car. In fact he had the new one outside his house. We took it for a test drive. It seemed ok to DH. We now realise that he's completely mucked up the electrics by fitting third party equipment. The clutch is on the way out. The gear box is on the way out. Did we go back to him? No. It's our fault and we've learned a good lesson. We'll drive the car to the ground, then replace.

I bought a car last month. There was a known fault and the (trade) seller offered me the option of buying it 'as is' for a lower than advertised price, or buying it with the problem resolved, for the advertised price (they thought they had fixed it but hadn't). We opted for them to fix it. It cost them £1100 to fix it, mostly because they kept chasing the fault and replacing bits until they found that it was a little tear on a hose. Now, we have the car, but I've noticed the air con and heater don't really work well. Will we go back to them? No. It's our fault and we didn't check.

zingally · 09/05/2022 16:24

She needs to re-think her strategy of privately buying a car if she doesn't know what she's doing.
I KNOW I don't know what I'm doing, so that's why every car I buy, even second hand, comes from a dealership.
Frankly, if you are up for buying a 13 year old car, you MUST know it's likely to be a bit of a banger, however much the seller bigs it up.

AchatAVendre · 09/05/2022 16:23

thedancingbear · 09/05/2022 16:18

It comes from Section 75(1) of the Road Traffic Act 1988:

www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1988/52/section/75

-which doesn't distinguish between private and trade sellers.

Ss 6(b) is basically 'the above doesn't count if it's sold for scrap' provision.

I await your apology.

Dancingbear do you have any idea of the evidence required to prove a that a car was defective under s.75(1)? Do you imagine that there are criminal cases being brought all the time when someone sells a car which later has a defect or which suffers from wear and tear? Maybe you are trying to persuade us all to be gullible enough to take our cars to garages and get unnecessary work done on brakes which are simply somewhat worn but still not dangerous, just in case a seller somewhere might make a complaint to the police that their currently MOT'd car was taken to a garage who said they needed their brakes fixed?

So therefore, you would think that you could go away, have a little google and come up with some criminal case law where that has actually occurred.

Are you the poster who thinks there are fixed prices for cars as well, I find it hard to distinguish?

Akods · 09/05/2022 16:21

Ignore her. If you want a warranty then buy from a dealership

thedancingbear · 09/05/2022 16:18

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 09/05/2022 16:07

Just to say - not sure where the requirement for the car to be roadworthy for a private sale that is mentioned in a couple of posts has come from but it's nonsense (in the UK at least) - there is no such requirement. You don't even have to draw attention to any defects - what you cannot do is tell lies about them.

It comes from Section 75(1) of the Road Traffic Act 1988:

www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1988/52/section/75

-which doesn't distinguish between private and trade sellers.

Ss 6(b) is basically 'the above doesn't count if it's sold for scrap' provision.

I await your apology.

Herejustforthisone · 09/05/2022 16:18

There’s some shocking ignorance on this thread.

Seraphinesupport · 09/05/2022 16:17

my wipers cost me £16 fitted from halfords.

Not sure why brakes and an electrical issue are your fault. you dont expect a second hand car to be perfect condition.

Herejustforthisone · 09/05/2022 16:17

“Sold as seen.”

It’s not your fault she didn’t have the wherewithal to check anything. You don’t get a guarantee with a private sale, if she was that cautious she should have gone to a dealership.

Jillyfernilly · 09/05/2022 16:16

I'm gobsmacked @Discovereads last time I sold a car (ages ago btw). Dealer offered me £800 trade in value.

I sold it privately for 2K (and bought my new car from a different dealer) who wasn't trying to rip me off and didn't try to stop me test driving the car i wanted on the basis of my biological sex. Apparently women don't drive Audi A3s....

I bought another Golf in the end.

19lottie82 · 09/05/2022 16:16

Why is it ok to assume the buyer is a
scammer but not ok to ask the OP why
they priced the car £500 over it’s market value

where are you getting this from?

the OP sold the car for £500 more than a dealer offered her for it. Dealers do not pay “market value” for second hand cars.

what they pay + their costs / profit = market value.

they would have charged more than the OP for the car if they had sold it on.

also, lol @ your claims of an unethical sale. Surely you’ve heard of the basic economic rule of supply and demand?

Swipe left for the next trending thread