Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Betrayed by a friend

38 replies

ItsAFriendshipThing · 09/05/2022 08:14

I’ve had a longstanding friend of 10 years. Socially we’ve spent quite a lot of time together and she’s stayed at my house on numerous occasions, always waxing lyrical about what a great time she has when here.

Several years ago I was diagnosed with a serious illness and went through a difficult time for a while.

Anyway, I found out quite by chance yesterday that this friend had taken it upon herself to mention to her mother who is a social worker that she was concerned that my children, had essentially been forced into the role of carers which is absolutely not the case and the mother subsequently put in a report to social services.

I never actually heard from them, so I don’t know what she said, but the person who told me thought I already knew which is why they mentioned it.

Now, if friend had been concerned about my children then she should have mentioned it to me, surely? Meanwhile she has been happily coming round here and enjoying my hospitality for all these years, and now I’m thinking that all the time she’s thought what an awful person I am.

The friendship feels as if it was a lie now.

I’m not one for confrontations, besides which there’s nothing to be gained from it now. SS never ended up on my doorstep, and my children are adults now.

But I just feel so hurt. I’m inclined to just drop all communication with this friend without explanation. As it’s been lockdown we’ve had less contact anyway so it would be easy to do.

But WWYD?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Jedsnewstar · 09/05/2022 18:55

This is hearsay. There is no evidence that this is true since social services did not come.

at least ask her. Or she will be posting on here wondering why her friend of a number of years ghosted her.

Ikeptgoing · 09/05/2022 18:46

You could put your mind at rest by ringing Social Services and asking if a referral was made, and what the outcome was. There will be a process to go through to have the information released.

Hmm PP don't understand children services at all

Children services will not disclose this information- not even under a SARs- as it is on children's file and of a Safeguarding nature. You have no way to have this confirmed by CSD nor find out details at this point. The only way you'd know is if a social worker had rung and spoken to you at the time but even then they wouldn't disclose exactly what was said, how it was said or by whom.

TreatTrimTame · 09/05/2022 11:52

With the relationship being long term and (seemingly) a good one, I would give friend the benefit of the doubt and ask her about it. Hear her out, explain how you feel and go from there. However if she has done this without telling you I would be tempted to step back as she should have come to you first to express her concerns, or (if shes such a good friend) offered help where she felt the DC were picking up too much.

Swayingpalmtrees · 09/05/2022 11:15

You don't need to confront your friend in a horrible way.

You could simply say 'I have heard that you spoke to your mother about my situation when I was ill, and that she put in a SS report. No harm done as the dc were fine, but I always wondered about that story'

And listen carefully, very carefully to what your friend says. If she admits it is true then you have the answer, but it could be entirely different from the story you are being led to believe or even completely inaccurate.

I would not end such a long and happy friendship on the back of second hand hearsay. You have nothing to lose by finding out the truth.

If it is true, you could be honest and tell her you are finding it very difficult to cope with what you see as betrayal and a total lack of support and loyalty.

If it untrue then you have learnt not to trust everything you hear.

You need to ask her gently what happened and work from there.

FabFitFifties · 09/05/2022 11:07

I would trust your longterm friend. You could put your mind at rest by ringing Social Services and asking if a referral was made, and what the outcome was. There will be a process to go through to have the information released. This sounds very unlikely to me. Has your other friend got the wrong end of the stick, and thinks a referral was made, when Infact advice was sort from the SW mum? A SW would know what to put in a referral to ensure it reached thresholds for enquiry/intervention. You would of been contacted. She would know that consent was needed too.

KrisAkabusi · 09/05/2022 10:54

You've heard a story second-hand about confidential information that may not be true. It is likely either completely false, or based on concern rather than malicious. You would be massively overreacting to drop your friend without getting her side of the story. That would be completely unfair on her.

AryaStarkWolf · 09/05/2022 10:53

Who told you this, who do you know they're telling the truth or have correct information about this?. Dumping her without letting her defend herself would be a mistake I think

If it is true though I would be disgusted with her and she would no longer be my friend

thisplaceisweird · 09/05/2022 10:48

I actually think it's the middle man who is stirring in this situation. Who are they to you?

Luculentus · 09/05/2022 10:46

I don't understand why you assumed she thought you were an awful person? If any of this happened at all - and I agree I wouldn't necessarily assume it did - it sounds as if, for a time, she was genuinely worried about how you and your family were coping during your illness. She may well have simply asked her mother for advice with no intention for it to go any further, only to find her mother took it out of her hands. Yes, she could have let you know, but maybe she realised that SS were highly unlikely ever to take it any further so there would be no reason to worry you.

CruiseCruiseBaby · 09/05/2022 10:05

I’ve said YABU because just dropping her with no discussion doesn’t seem like a reasonable reaction to me. I know you said you’re uncomfortable with confrontation, but could you write something down? Ask what happened and why and then make an informed decision when you have the details rather than a possibly incorrect story from someone else?

RampantIvy · 09/05/2022 09:30

IMO the person who told you sounds like a gossipy shit stirrer.

I would ask the friend in a non confrontational way what really happened. She may have had the best of intentions.

PaulaTrilloe · 09/05/2022 09:24

Invite the friend over for lunch.

Mention your illness
Ask her about that time
tell her about the third party

observe her reaction

YilingMatriarch · 09/05/2022 09:22

I think you'll have to say something to your friend or else the not knowing and distrust will sour your friendship in the long run. You also need to confirm the motives of the third party who may have their own reasons for dropping this gossip. It doesn't have to be a full blown guns a-blazing confrontation. Just say you have recently learned about a something that may have occurred years ago, that concerned you both, and you would like to find out if it's true or not.

BonnesVacances · 09/05/2022 09:21

I can understand why you're hurt and that you feel judged by your friend. But she obviously had your DC's best interests at heart so maybe focus on that, rather than the perceived criticism of how you handled it at the time.

It sounds to me that she was chatting to her mum with some concerns she had about whether your DC were picking up caring duties, who then had an obligation to refer the situation to SS. It may even have just been with a view to see if you could access some more support if you needed it or just to have a third party assess if everything was ok for peace of mind.

Addicted2LuvIsland · 09/05/2022 09:20

Have you ever thought that maybe the other person was lying and your friends mum never contacted SS? I would ask.

notanicepersonapparently · 09/05/2022 09:18

My thoughts on this would be that your friend was looking to see if there was any additional support available for you from SS ie help around the home. She didn't mention it as she didn't want to get your hopes up if there wasn't. Given that you never heard from SS it would seem that there wasn't. I think the 3rd party is got the wrong end of the stick in assuming the report was about child neglect. You need to check with your friend.

LemonTT · 09/05/2022 09:14

based on the OP, there is a third hand report of a conversation only two people were privy to🤔 Followed by a report about an formal action by SW that can only be described as totally confidential. Nobody apart from the SW and limited people in social services would know. None should be sharing it.

Unless the friend or mother relayed this story I can’t see how it could be taken at face value. If the mother is telling it she is betraying her daughter and professional standards. I would want to know why.

TBH I can’t see how this can be believed unless the friend said she did it. It is highly improbable tale for a third party to know.

totallyoutnumbered · 09/05/2022 09:11

I wouldn't be binning off a good friend unless I'd had a conversation with her first personally

Zilla1 · 09/05/2022 09:07

Did the friend offer any help with the children or just discuss with her DM?

KatherineJaneway · 09/05/2022 09:06

I'd find out what actually happened rather than listen to gossip and throw away a 10 year friendship.

DrStrangesWife · 09/05/2022 09:06

I wouldn't be friends with someone like that - she's clearly a shit stirrer.

Lunificent · 09/05/2022 09:05

Get a bit more info from the informer first.

Ikeptgoing · 09/05/2022 09:04

TalkingCat · 09/05/2022 08:53

Wait....don't SS have to let you know of any report?

Is it possible, just possible, that there NEVER WAS a report, and the person who told you this yarn has a grudge against your friend/is trying to make trouble?

If you were not told, then there was no report, and if there was no report, the person who told you this tall tale completely made it up.

This is not true in the slightest

CSD don't have to contact the parents at all to say there has been a SG report, unless it progresses to a full s.47 enquiry & even then they may delay telling the parent. They can contact GP and school/ nursery to make initial enquiries. As I explained, this can only be taken and acted upon if the initial referral contains safeguarding concerns.

Ikeptgoing · 09/05/2022 09:01

ElenaSt · 09/05/2022 08:39

The person who told you this is gossiping and may have an ulterior motive. You are blindly believing what they have told you as being true.

True that OP doesn't know if a safeguarding concern report was definitely made but clearly friend was gossiping negatively enough about her behind her back for this 2nd person to know and it's all rather specific.

I would want to know and would ask my friend 'did you talk to your mum and did your mum make a referral to children services about my children?'

As I said, the only grounds that could be done and taken by CsD without parental consent is a safeguarding concern (that might then be reclassified as CIN and OP would have been contacted) .

If it was to offer support as they wanted to help, a social worker friend would have spoken to OP first (unless it was safeguarding) and talked about what kind of help is potentially out there to encourage OP to contact CsD herself or talk to teachers about it.

A report made without parents knowledge is about SG concerns and in those grounds only . Consent is very important and CSD would have needed sufficient welfare concern grounds to have overridden that to accept a third party referral.

UnsuitableHat · 09/05/2022 09:01

I'd try to check out the veracity of the story before rushing to sever friendship.