Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Teacher training

114 replies

Princesselsa1 · 08/05/2022 18:49

Considering a career change. I have fallen out of love with my well paid but DULL job. I’m nearly 40 and still trying to figure out what I want to be when I grow up 😂I enjoy working with young people having volunteered with a youth group in recent years. I currently sit in my bedroom on a computer and work pretty much alone. It’s driving me crazy.

I was looking at teaching. I’m a biochemistry graduate so could teach science. I’d be interested in other subjects too. Not just the ones that pay a bursary.

i thought they were crying out for teachers. Why make the training so bloody complicated? I can’t travel an hour to my closest university! I have 3 kids of my own. Plus the training when you could be at a school of your choice for first term then after spring you get shipped off to a mystery school. The earliest I can drop my kids off is 8am.

plus lots of subjects YOU need to pay ridiculous fees. And the starting salary is awful!

Am I missing something here?

The way I would do it would be fully on the job plus remote “lectures”. And in one school, with short bursts at other LOCAL schools. I literally can’t see that this is a job that you’d want to train for as a mum with kids.

it’s such a shame because I think I’d be quite good and can see That it would be enjoyable.

OP posts:
Princesselsa1 · 09/05/2022 07:29

“But your contempt for the profession really does show. Would you want your kids to be taught by someone with your attitude?”

I disagree. What you are seeing is utter shock at the system! What attitude should a teacher have exactly?

Why would you want you kids taught by people that are “burnt out”, “crying with tiredness at 1am” and “unhappy”…. This isn’t right either. Surely there can be a happy medium. I know a few of you have found good schools but most of you are not happy.

it’s not a dig at teachers, it’s a dig at the system.

OP posts:
Justjoinedforthis · 09/05/2022 07:25

CaptainMyCaptain · 09/05/2022 07:20

Minimal marking perhaps but a huge amount of planning, record keeping and assessment.

The revised eyfs has aimed to hugely reduce planning and assessment, its just about knowing your children and being able to justify resources and learning experiences.

Mrsbadger77 · 09/05/2022 07:23

Don't do it. There are other jobs you could do if you want to work with or have an impact on young people. Maybe working on your current field but in a third sector organisation related to young people or education ? Teaching is for young people or people with no other commitments and a lot of stamina. It's also not something to be recommended for more than five years as you will burn out. Just my opinion from bitter experience.

CaptainMyCaptain · 09/05/2022 07:20

Justjoinedforthis · 09/05/2022 07:13

I’m starting a primary pgce with a 2 year old and a 6 year old this sept, I know it will be hard work but most things are in life.
I know a few teachers with young kids (I teach nursery kids currently) and they always picking them up at 4.30ish, not every teacher works these long hours, especially in the younger years where there is minimal marking. I will report back on how hard it was in a year haha

Minimal marking perhaps but a huge amount of planning, record keeping and assessment.

Justjoinedforthis · 09/05/2022 07:13

I’m starting a primary pgce with a 2 year old and a 6 year old this sept, I know it will be hard work but most things are in life.
I know a few teachers with young kids (I teach nursery kids currently) and they always picking them up at 4.30ish, not every teacher works these long hours, especially in the younger years where there is minimal marking. I will report back on how hard it was in a year haha

Moomeh · 09/05/2022 07:03

Princesselsa1 · 08/05/2022 23:32

Why do you teach then? I’m not sure I would even be leonardo dicaprios personal assistant for 21k! and trust me I would love to do that job 😀

I couldn't afford to live on that I’m afraid.

I am a professional and I have stress and long hours, shitty management Etc. but I do expect to be compensated properly.

I have complete respect for teachers but the system is broken and it’s so sad. I love kids and enjoy working with young people but I just wouldn’t be able to survive on that money.

Ive given up on the idea… I’d be crazy to go there based on all the negative feedback. But this thread has been very eye opening.

21k doesn't make sense because my starting salary, in a state school as NQT 11 years ago, was 25k. I earn more than double that now FTE (although I'm in an independent school, and 0.6 part time now).

I don't think pay is that bad as a teacher. And after my first three years or so it did become a fairly easy job, with long holidays.

But your contempt for the profession really does show. Would you want your kids to be taught by someone with your attitude?

onanotherday · 09/05/2022 06:50

OP as a science graduate you will be in demand. But remember you are looking at pay and conditions though the lens of a private sector employee.
Of course the money and hours are a total piss take! It is a very unfriendly career to those with young children, and remember whilst the summer holidays are great there is not grabbing a week off I you feel like a break, or even a day for wedding etc. But one word you have missed is its a vocation..hence the blood sweat and tears.
You said you love kids and have done some work with them. Could l suggest you contact your local.seconday and shadow a science teacher for a week to see if you feel the same.

frenchie4002 · 09/05/2022 06:41

OP, I’m not sure if you’re still interested but with some SCITTs there is no obligation to travel to a university as the training is at your school in the evening. There are also apprenticeship routes with no fees. The proposed plans are to raise the starting salary to 30k in the next few years and the bursaries for training are relative liveable - depending on circumstance - as they are tax free and you can still apply for a maintenance loan. The training is difficult and it then takes a couple more years to feel secure in the role but once you do, and if you find a good school with a positive outlook on work/life balance, the job is manageable and dare I say quite enjoyable for some. They will always be crying out for teachers so you don’t have to decide right now.

spanieleyes · 09/05/2022 06:38

For those asking why, given all the negative experiences we have spoken about, do we still do it? Because teaching itself is absolutely the best thing ever, the children, the subjects, the camaraderie ( in some schools) the rush that you get when a child says " oh, I didn't know that" and now they do. There is no better feeling in the whole world. It makes up for all the rest of the shit we have to deal with. ( and yes, we do know that other professions work as hard, have long hours and just as much crap to deal with!)
Off to make breakfast for my Yr 6s who have SATS this week😥

tulippa · 09/05/2022 06:24

in any profession, including my own, I wouldn’t feel comfortable working 7:30am-11pm (unpaid) in a high responsibility role that is stressful. Burning out every holiday etc. even if I LOVED my work… that’s a total piss take.

You're right - it is a piss take. You've summed it up completely.

I did a PGCE when my DCs were 10 and 6. It was doable because DH was at home so I could be completely flexible. The uni was in the north west and people in my cohort were sent as far as Whitby and Luton for their placements. I was spared that because I had DCs and it helped that I was able to arrange one of my own placements.

I gave up school teaching three years after qualifying as the hours you mention above are only sustainable for so long. The holidays aren't worth all the other crap. I still teach and am enjoying it again but I would never go back to teaching in a school. The bit you said before about people saying you're not worthy? As a school teacher you get that message from multiple sources (SLT, parents, government, OFTSED...) every day.

Hercisback · 09/05/2022 06:12

@DrDreReturns They're the hours of trained teachers too.

K0612 · 08/05/2022 23:33

Teaching is not family friendly. Teaching full time with young children is very stressful. Pre kids I was in work at 7:30 every day now I can't get in with 2 drops offs before 8:30 even though I have a short commute. I am coping as I've been teaching 20 years. I wouldn't recommend any parent went into teaching unless their kids were secondary plus age or have a very available and supportive oh. My dh is also a teacher with a longer commute 🙈. We have hols off though... but still have to pay for childcare as no term time places locally.

Princesselsa1 · 08/05/2022 23:32

Why do you teach then? I’m not sure I would even be leonardo dicaprios personal assistant for 21k! and trust me I would love to do that job 😀

I couldn't afford to live on that I’m afraid.

I am a professional and I have stress and long hours, shitty management Etc. but I do expect to be compensated properly.

I have complete respect for teachers but the system is broken and it’s so sad. I love kids and enjoy working with young people but I just wouldn’t be able to survive on that money.

Ive given up on the idea… I’d be crazy to go there based on all the negative feedback. But this thread has been very eye opening.

OP posts:
YerAWizardHarry · 08/05/2022 23:19

Bordesleyhills · 08/05/2022 19:46

Taught for 15 years- I love it but agree it’s not family friendly. I had a long commute to placement and university . Be a hard year with assignments, teaching and other stuff. Teaching is not 9-3 it’s long hours, yes the holidays are there but again work and marking. You will start at 21k and climb . Teaching is wonderful but it’s very stressful and takes it out of you. It’s not something you do for the money . Worth going to have a look at a teaching event

£21,000?? Surely not? Starting wage is around £28,000 in Scotland…

howtomoveforwards · 08/05/2022 23:10

The thing is, OP, you do really have to want to do it because it is all consuming. Every heard the phrase ‘Poundland pedagogy’?! That’s where when we’re doing the weekly shop we are looking at everything on offer with a ‘hmmm….how could I use that?’ head on. It never leaves you. Even if you’re not actually sat at a desk working, you’re running through up coming lessons in your head, remembering how it went last time you taught it and wondering what you can change to make it better, or whether bottom set year 9 will get it without you having to literally model the bloody thing with plasticine, lolly sticks and some hair clips…. It is not a 9-3 job. Never has been. You can do lots to ease the work burden but you work constantly because it’s the nature of the beast. I use Facebook and Twitter primarily for CPD purposes, not for my own leisure or interests.

You may find working in a huge MAT works for you where there are subject advisors and lessons are the same in every school. There are lots of cons to that but it makes for an easier first couple of years, I guess.

DrDreReturns · 08/05/2022 23:10

Why are these hours for trainees acceptable? Just because it happened in the past doesn't make it ok now. It reminds me of the hours junior doctors work.

theluckiest · 08/05/2022 22:56

It can be done. But at a cost. I was a career changer and went into primary.

I had a 3 yr old and a 1 yr old. I have no idea what I was thinking!!

The big thing was a support network. I basically sacrificed all the 'mum' stuff a lot of the time and DH picked up the slack. I still dropped off at the childminders and did everything when I got home but once the kids were in bed, I worked. I remember crying with tiredness at 1am as I wrote a lesson plan.

It was horrendous. But if you have the support, it's just about do-able. I'm a rare breed - I don't regret doing it and I'm now very happy with my chosen career.
but man alive, it was hard

Princesselsa1 · 08/05/2022 22:50

i do disagree with previous posts. I don’t think I would be doing the schools a favour.

I’ve not gone into my research blind either. A relative that is a teacher. Lots of research and volunteering with young people in my free time.

I think people need to be realistic that MOST people don’t just have a job because they love it. Money is a factor. As is hours, stress, location, convenience.

the posts on this thread are interesting and range from “don’t do it” to “you are not worthy, you wouldn’t last a second”

in any profession, including my own, I wouldn’t feel comfortable working 7:30am-11pm (unpaid) in a high responsibility role that is stressful. Burning out every holiday etc. even if I LOVED my work… that’s a total piss take.

OP posts:
EnidSpyton · 08/05/2022 22:50

If you do SCITT university days are few and far between. I was in maybe one day a term. Your second placement is about 6 weeks long so again not a big deal if it’s a long commute - it flies by. The school you’re employed in is where you’ll be 90% of the time. I was a mature (though no kids) trainee and the SCITT route (was called the GTP then) worked well for me as I was paid and I could choose where I worked.

My training year was the hardest year of my life. To this day I don’t know how I got through it. I lasted 9 years in the classroom, 6 as Head of Department. I loved it for about 6 of those years before gradually the endless shit started to erode my passion. I loved the kids but the relentlessness of it just got too much.

I quit last year and I would never go back. Honestly I wouldn’t recommend it as a profession to anyone. It sucks the life out of you. I’m a different person now. Everyone keeps telling me how amazing I look. Makes me realise how haggard I must have looked for the past decade!!

Meem321 · 08/05/2022 22:45

An hour to get to uni is standard. I did my training through the GTP programme and drove 1 hour to uni once a week. I did this whilst parenting 2 primary aged children. I was grateful to be given the opportunity to train and be paid to do so.

I get the impression that you think teaching is going to be easy... That you won't be willing to work late into the night, and that a school would be lucky to have you. With that attitude you'll be in senior leadership in no time. You'll not gain many allies though.

Jolly good luck 👍

bridgetreilly · 08/05/2022 22:37

Plenty of teachers commute 45 minutes. I think you need to realise that when you get a job it won’t necessarily be on you doorstep.

howtomoveforwards · 08/05/2022 22:35

If it helps, I did a PGCE as a single parent with kids in primary with wraparound from 8am - 6pm. The uni was about an hour’s drive, sometimes a bit more. I volunteered in a local school one day a week to get a feel for it and then at interview, essentially said what I would/wouldn’t be able to manage commute-wise. It was never an issue - both my placements were in my town. I got a job at my second placement and stayed a further 5 years.

I would say it took me those 5 years to get myself in a place where I had lots of resources to fall back on and could teach most lessons by opening something I’d previously prepared rather than having to start from scratch. But each lesson is planned in it’s own right, every year if that makes sense. The goalposts change continually, new fads come and go, you shift and adapt to suit it and the needs of your classes. No two years are the same, that’s for sure, Due to family issues, I took a few years out on supply and then got a long term supply role and 5 years later am still there. I am lucky - I teach in both primary and secondary and have a superb HOD who is supportive and who has my back (and that of the rest of the department). I don’t know how much longer I have in me as I’m past 50 now but I’m OK for now.

it is not a job for the faint-hearted and I strongly suggest getting some school experience before you go any further.

OwlinaTree · 08/05/2022 22:27

I'm a teacher and I drop my children at child care around 8 and 8:05 (two different schools). I get to work around 8:30. I make sure everything is ready before I leave the night before. So it's possible. We are not contracted to be there until 8:40 anyway.

Moomeh · 08/05/2022 22:23

Your posts read as though you would be doing schools a favour by training to teach.

I think this from bluevelvetsofa has hit on why I felt a bit irritated by the op, as an experienced teacher myself.

Many non teachers, especially parents, have on the one hand extremely high expectations of teachers and low thresholds for complaints. But simultaneously on the other hand see it as an extremely easy, cushy job with short "family-friendly" hours. They expect us to be there before the kids arrive and stay well after they leave, but then think we have 9-3 jobs. They also are often incensed when they find out their own child's teacher is a trainee or newly qualified.

I do now have a fairly cushy job but I also have ten years' experience and so I know what I'm doing and have found time saving strategies and so on. Training was really hard. And one of the things that made it hard was the relentlessly high expectations, including from parents - don't get me wrong, kids deserve good teachers - but therefore I'm amazed that any parent can think it's an easy job and that they can just rock up and save some poor understaffed school.

InChocolateWeTrust · 08/05/2022 22:10

Teacher training isnt designed to make it flexible for mums with kids.

Its focus is on making you an optimal highly skilled teacher.

Also from the governments perspective, any funded course gets a better rate of return training younger people who may serve a 40 year career.

Swipe left for the next trending thread