Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel so foolish for underestimating house renovation timescale

93 replies

Eastie77Returns · 08/05/2022 13:25

Apologies this is long:((

We bought our house in March. I had a number of ongoing threads for months as there were so many ups and downs so felt incredibly relieved when we finally Completed.

It is a 3/4 bed semi and I knew it needed work when I first viewed back in September but only had a vague understanding of the level required. The survey/report didn’t flag any major issues so I told DP that we should move in upon completion and just renovate as and when.

When we went for the pre-exchange viewing in Feb (the first time I had seen it since September) it became apparent the kitchen and bathroom would have to be ripped out as they were in an awful state. The vendor was an older woman with significant mental health issues and the place had been left to wrack and ruin. Despite this I was misguided enough to give our landlady 2 months notice as I thought the house would be liveable in that time. DP, who has actually renovated houses before said nothing to dissuade me.

So we move out next week and the situation is this: bathroom is done but we are looking at least another 3 months for the rest. The rest of the house needs to be plastered, ceilings still to be taken down, complete rewiring, new flooring has been ordered and has a 4 week lead time and can’t be laid until plastering etc is done. I agreed to DP’s suggestions without understanding the timeframes such as moving the boiler into an exterior utility room which will take a several weeks as we wait for the engineer to remove and install the new one.

We will now have to stay with my parents which I am absolutely dreading (that’s a whole other thread). Kids schooling is up in the air as their new school is several miles from parents so would be easier to keep them at current school around the corner but think I have to move them now or loose the places.

I frequently feel like crying and wake up each day feeling anxious and stressed. I also completely understand this is a first world problem and there are millions of people with real and bigger problems than me.

Thank you if you’ve got this far. I’m just venting at my foolish naivety really and also hoping for some success stories from anyone whose renovations actually happened a lot quicker than they thought?

OP posts:
Eastie77Returns · 10/06/2022 09:41

@Candleabra the electrics are still ongoing but progress has been made and it seems as if it will be completed by the end of today. The builder got an electrician to do some of the work after originally saying he would do it all himself and he (the electrician) has been great. I do think if we had worked directly with the trades it would have been quicker and less expensive. However he seems to wield some kind of control over his crew. The plasterers said they couldn’t work directly for us as there would be hell to pay if he found out.

He has quoted us for the kitchen installation and will be working with an installer who we know via word of mouth is brilliant. So again we’d rather work directly with him and cut out the builder but the fitter has also said he can’t do that.

OP posts:
artisanbread · 10/06/2022 07:59

I should add, it wasn't two years in total - we had the rewiring, heating and bathroom done and livwd with the kitchen then had the downstairs internal work done the following year.

artisanbread · 10/06/2022 07:58

Ours took two years - new heating system and boiler, rewiring and some replastering, new kitchen, new bathroom, internal structural changes and new flooring downstairs. We lived in it throughout (with a pre-schooler and toddler) except for one week when the rewiring was done. We spent two weeks living entirely upstairs using a microwave and a camping stove. It wasn't the most fun experience but it was tolerable.

Candleabra · 10/06/2022 07:39

@Eastie77Returns how are things going? Are the electrics finished?

NewPapaGuinea · 08/06/2022 14:33

What is the builder really doing other than project (mis)managing? I’d be inclined to sack him off and hire the trades directly. I’ve heard enough horror stories of “builders” that I’d much rather have a firm grip of who/when and at what cost and hire directly.

stuntbubbles · 08/06/2022 13:04

@Eastie77Returns Great, isn’t it? You can really smell the horror.

If it also helps cheer you, our reno began in March 2020 so you can guess how well that went. Three weeks of rubble and destruction then total shutdown, leaving us without a garden (filled with rubble), a sitting room (filled with builders tools and a kitchen yet to be fitted), a kitchen (gutted), or a downstairs loo. Every time we flushed the upstairs loo the downstairs HOLE would emit a waft. And sometimes a rat…

Eastie77Returns · 08/06/2022 11:06

@stuntbubbles I’ve been scrolling through victorianwreckbythesea on Insta and I’m addicted. So much of it resonates with me. Sounds horrible but it’s comforting to see someone else going through an equally horrendous renovation but I can also see she is slowly coming through the other side!

OP posts:
Dixiechickonhols · 08/06/2022 09:54

No kitchen I’d get an ninja foodi love ours. It’s bake, airfryer, slowcooker and pressure cooker. Set up temporary kitchen.

londonlass71 · 08/06/2022 09:50

I've been in my house since beg Nov. Still working on it. Extension hasn't even started. Its gonna be over a year I reckon before it's finished.

Eastie77Returns · 08/06/2022 09:25

The 4.30am call was because he “starts the day at 3am” and I was first on his list of people to call. Agree it was all very odd. I picked up in desperation as hadn’t heard from him.

I know he has other projects on. I am in direct contact with one of the plasterers who has randomly turned out to be an old classmate of my brother. He said builder is working on a huge renovation in Essex (house is owned by a footballer) plus another job and is spread thin. He is sending his crew of men everywhere and the plasterers were at the Essex house yesterday. I imagine our job is minor in terms of the £££ the other work is worth.

I have my clipboard and schedule notes ready and am meeting him at the house today. I will not make any further payments. He is now making agreeable conciliatory noises and this morning turned up with a full crew.

I totally understand the logic behind ditching this builder now but I’m not sure mentally I can go through the stress of trying to find a trustworthy builder. Do they even exist? I chose this guy on the basis of two personal recommendations. I’ve seen threads on MN where builders with positive online reviews have also turned into nightmares. So regardless of how you find a builder, it can all go wrong. It feels like pot luck and I’m not sure I can risk rolling the dice again and hoping I get a good builder. Feels like better the devil I know…

OP posts:
stuntbubbles · 08/06/2022 09:00

Get rid of the builder!

Are you on Instagram? Highly recommend following victorianwreckbythesea which is/was a proper disaster house with rot and damp and rats and blocked up windows and horror after horror, similar tales of no hot water and such, and living there during the renovation with children and full-time jobs. When you’ve got dust in your hair and no oven, it’s a proper balm to the soul to read.

Candleabra · 08/06/2022 07:50

Oh dear. I remember you from the house move threads and I’m sorry to hear things have been so difficult.
Renovations are always a nightmare.

However, completely agree with above poster that ranty 4.30 calls are not normal. I imagine cash problems. He sounds desperate for money and will literally promise you anything to get it.
Do not pay any more. If the electrics aren’t done today as promised I would remove him.
I know it’ll cock up your schedule with other trades but you’ll have to replan.
I’ve been in similar situations and it’s horrible. It’s because you feel out of control and always on the back foot. Your builder holds all the cards, and you’re just waiting (hoping) that he will somehow perform better, but you don’t really believe it.
You need a bigger builder with more resources to throw at it.
Make a big list this morning in the cold light of day and then make a proper plan, including a scenario where you sack this builder and start the whole process again. You were hardly in a position for rational thought at 4.30 and he knew that. There will be tough decisions to make, but even if it means a delay you’ll feel better if you take back control.

Netaporter · 08/06/2022 07:26

@Eastie77Returns i fear your chap is demonstrating the behaviour which comes from someone with money issues. Demanding cash and then A 4.30an call is not normal and I’d suggest you no longer answer the phone to him outside of normal working hours. Your DP needs to make it very clear that he should not speak to you in such a manner. I’d say it is most likely that he is taking staged payments from multiple clients to pay suppliers for other jobs. I think you both need to send a calm email asking for confirmation of what is being done as per the call and when and also confirmation of what exactly he has bought in terms of the materials he says he has. And that he brings them to site. You should also state when and how much you paid the various amounts of cash. Your flooring chap is quite correct, the flooring needs to acclimatise for at least a week and they won’t compromise on that because they are providing the warranty for the work.

You also need to get receipts for the cash you have given him. He may ask for cash but without proof he has asked and also accepted it, it may be construed that you are avoiding VAT. Buy a simple receipt book today and get him to sign from now on. Ideally also he’d sign for the backdated payments.

Also, make sure you purchase corex protective floor covering and put down everywhere fixed with duct tape to avoid any damage to it after it is fitted.

Wilkolampshade · 08/06/2022 06:35

Oh OP. Been there. And completely understand why you feel the need to keep him onside BUT like PP's have said I would still plan for him not finishing the job and start looking for someone else.WTF with the 4:30 a.m call? Was he pissed? High?Under the circumstances, I would agree a deadline for wiring and if (when) he misses it, that's the end of it. Pay him off at that stage and move on.
Hire a bigger firm with more bodies to get you to the stage where you can at least camp in an upstairs makeshift kitchen, washing up in the bathroom, with a room for the kids.
Yes, organise storage, but prioritise 'getting in' and taking control of YOUR house, so a whiteboard/spreadsheets for planning, a mini kitchen - oh- and change the locks so old wanker builder no longer has access.

Eastie77Returns · 08/06/2022 06:19

Sorry @Netaporter, cross posted with you.

The switches, sockets etc were agreed on and marked in the walls. He said he has bought everything.

The plastering has only taken place upstairs. The electrics need to be completed downstairs hence the reason none of the downstairs plastering has started.

He did bring a dehumidifier for the rooms upstairs.

It will be difficult to move the flooring fitters as they have a tight schedule and if we reschedule they won’t be able to fit us in for weeks. Pushing back the kitchen delivery will also be problematic (currently due the week after the floor fitters). The flooring guys said they need to bring the flooring into the house one week beforehand in order to acclimatise it and the ground floor plastering therefore needs to be completed and whole area clear by then. So they need to bring it next week. During his rant the builder said that this is all nonsense and acclimatisation is not needed for so long.

Yes if I could get a motor home/caravan in the garden I would certainly camp in there, just not sure how feasible it is and I’ve seen some eye watering hire costs.

OP posts:
Bumtum126 · 08/06/2022 06:17

I would still look into another builder or source trades individually. Best of luck if you do carry on using him.

Eastie77Returns · 08/06/2022 06:05

He called this morning at 4.30am (!!) and sounded very angry. Said he felt he was being accused of shoddy work and didn’t appreciate the tone of the e-mails from DP in particular. Began reeling off all the things he has done for us and not charged us for (news to me), he has driven around the city for hours sourcing materials for us and basically ranted for about 20 minutes without letting me speak. He said he would not allow his integrity to be attacked. The whole call was stressful. However in all honesty I felt I had to pacify him and keep him on side because I am desperate to get this work finished and getting a new builder will just add weeks we don’t have.

When he calmed down he eventually agreed on a schedule and he will send me through a list of all outstanding work and associated costs. He promised the electrics will be finished today.

I have two young DC. I’m at the mercy of this guy and I can only hope it all turns out ok. He came recommended by both sets of our new neighbours and one told us he can be very prickly but he gets the job done.

OP posts:
Netaporter · 08/06/2022 05:35

Do not give the builder any more money. Ask them for a breakdown of the spend so far and where your money has gone. Stop all plastering until the electrics and plumbing are done. I cannot see why any competent builder is allowing plastering when the rewire/plumbing is not complete? If the channeling/rewire is done and also any plumbing you just need the sockets/rads etc installing then plastering is ok. Get dehumidifiers in the room just plastered to speed up the drying process. Make sure you have detailed plans where you want everything in terms of light fittings, radiators and sockets/switches. Who is supplying the materials such as sockets/switches? Are they on site? You can just get in an electrician, plumber plasterer and carpenter yourself to fit your materials. Take a deep breath and draw up a chart with your OH as to what needs doing and in what order.

move the floor and kitchen fitters back by two weeks if possible to give yourself breathing room. The weather is not terrible so could you camp in the garden/hire a motor home for a bit to save money?

MaximumLeeway · 08/06/2022 05:30

Do not pay! Do you have a cost breakdown on the quote/invoice? Has he completed what you've paid for?

Never pay in advance, there should be a staged release of funds triggered by milestones of work being completed to spec.

WTF475878237NC · 08/06/2022 05:21

Get a new builder and agree schedules in writing with contingencies.

Bumtum126 · 08/06/2022 05:15

Get rid of the builder you will be throwing good money after bad .

Eastie77Returns · 08/06/2022 00:43

Hi all

Thought I’d provide an update. Sadly it is not a happy one.

In the month since I posted very little progress has been made. The new builder is a one man disaster. He went on holiday shortly after I opened this thread but promised that once he returned he would crack on with the required electrics, plastering and installing radiators. He has a couple of plasterers who have plastered one bedroom and partially plastered another but the rest of the house including the entirety of the ground floor remains untouched. No electrics completed, radiators not done which has a knock on effect as we can’t get the boiler installed and so have no hot water.

He had continually promised the electrics would be completed by this Wednesday and the plastering by Friday but there is not a hope in hell.

As far as I can tell he occasionally goes to the house for a few every now and then but there is no sustained period of work. Today no-one was on site at all and we have been unable to reach him. He doesn’t respond to calls or messages. We have no written timetable or schedule as to when work will be carried out. My mistake. I assume he is working on other projects.

We are due to have flooring installed w/c June 20th but this can only happen if the plastering is complete and the flooring team have made it clear they cannot carry out the work with the house in its current state. The following week the new kitchen arrives. The builder told us to order it for that week as he would be a position to install it then but again it just seems impossible. I’ve sent him messages this evening pleading with him to just call me and give me an honest update, if the job is too big for him just let me know.

I don’t know what to do. I feel like putting the house up for sale.

We stayed with my parents for 2 weeks and we are now in an Air BnB near the new house as the kids started their new school here. I hate dragging them from pillar to post plus it costs a fortune.

The last message from him (last week) requested we pay him the remaining balance for the electrics work even though the work is not finished. It all has to be cash as he is dodging the tax man.

I am completely stuck and no idea what we will do once the Air BnB ends as it is all so expensive.

OP posts:
Eastie77Returns · 09/05/2022 15:15

honeylulu · 08/05/2022 17:44

We bought a house two and a half years ago that needed complete renovation. We planned to stay in our old house for six months while we got the heftiest stages done, but our old house sold much quicker than expected and our buyers were pressing for the sale to go through. As they'd offered full asking price we didn't want to lose them. So we actually only had 9 weeks before we moved in.

In that time we got the lofts boarded (so we could store as much as possible up there), boiler and gas fires replaced, new external doors, windows renovated, downstairs floorboards all stripped and varnished and all bedrooms decorated and carpeted.

So when we moved in the lofts and bedrooms were in a finished state, the property was secure, we had reliable heating and hot water and one of the messiest stages (sanding) we didn't have to live through. There was still a lot to do but it was certainly liveable. Replacing the bathrooms and kitchen and decorating all the other areas were done with us living there. It was not ideal but perfectly possible.

In the last year or so we've been doing the exterior and garden and finally nearly finished. The exterior has barely been any stress at all (except when our Internet cable got chopped in half!)

So I would say start with the inside, from the top down if possible and messiest/ most essential stuff done first.

Yes, we are trying to get all the messy stuff out of the way and work from the top down although we have had to prioritize dealing with an outhouse in the garden as we will be storing the boiler in there.

I woke up startled and sweating after having a nightmare that the ceiling in one of the rooms fell through and a builder gave us a quote for thousands of pounds. I was shouting (in the nightmare) that I do not have any more money and the builder was just chuckling. To be honest it feels more like a premonition as we are burning through our funds quite quickly and so much remains to be done.

Positive vibes. I've been saving for a year for our annual holiday to Wales and I booked it today. I could have put it towards the house but I think I really need this break for the good of my mental health

DP has just called me in meltdown mode as the skip I hired is almost full and we have a gardener coming tomorrow to sort out the absolute jungle of our garden and he needs the skip as well.

OP posts:
honeylulu · 08/05/2022 17:44

We bought a house two and a half years ago that needed complete renovation. We planned to stay in our old house for six months while we got the heftiest stages done, but our old house sold much quicker than expected and our buyers were pressing for the sale to go through. As they'd offered full asking price we didn't want to lose them. So we actually only had 9 weeks before we moved in.

In that time we got the lofts boarded (so we could store as much as possible up there), boiler and gas fires replaced, new external doors, windows renovated, downstairs floorboards all stripped and varnished and all bedrooms decorated and carpeted.

So when we moved in the lofts and bedrooms were in a finished state, the property was secure, we had reliable heating and hot water and one of the messiest stages (sanding) we didn't have to live through. There was still a lot to do but it was certainly liveable. Replacing the bathrooms and kitchen and decorating all the other areas were done with us living there. It was not ideal but perfectly possible.

In the last year or so we've been doing the exterior and garden and finally nearly finished. The exterior has barely been any stress at all (except when our Internet cable got chopped in half!)

So I would say start with the inside, from the top down if possible and messiest/ most essential stuff done first.

Eastie77Returns · 08/05/2022 16:41

@kathmacc we have a huge garden. I thought about a caravan but wondered how we’d get it into the garden - we have side access but it’s very narrow.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread