Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To WFH while on holiday abroad so I don’t use up holiday entitlement?

261 replies

RaspberryFarfait · 08/05/2022 12:43

We have already have a big holiday booked this year and DH also wants to spend a month in his home country with his parents during the summer holidays.

He doesn’t WFH, so will use all holiday entitlement, but I do. Colleague is also on leave for some of that time so I wouldn’t normally be able to be off as need to cover.

WIBU to not book holiday, travel over there and work as normal, without telling work. I only work part time and it’s certainly doable.

Only problem is will I be able to log in remotely from abroad? Has anyone done this?

Don’t want to ask work yet as they’ll cotton on!

OP posts:
Festivecheer26 · 09/05/2022 09:05

@Oblomov22

As I have already said, the employing company might have to file a corporation tax return and pay corporation tax in the jurisdiction the OP travels to. These are the potential corporation tax consequences of an employee of a UK tax resident company working from another jurisdiction.

As a chartered tax advisor of 15 years specialising in corporate tax I can tell you that actually your statement “How would OP's situation affect corporation tax? The answer is, it wouldn't.” is factually incorrect. As @Howmuchwood says, there isn’t enough information in the OP to conclude one way or the other. As I said in my original post, the risk of a single trip is low but there can be circumstances in which this is enough to mean the company the employee works for has to file a tax return overseas. I’ve seen this in practice so can assure you that it does happen.

I’m not trying to scaremonger or intimidate anyone, the only reason I posted was because you started rebuffing the mention of tax implications so strongly and you aren’t correct. Maybe you mean that there won’t be any tax implications in a situation like OP’s because local tax authorities will have no way of finding out?

The OP came on to ask essentially whether she needed to ask her boss before working remotely overseas and the short answer is yes. Part of the explanation for this answer is that her employer will need to consider any potential corporation tax risks of her proposed arrangement - there may well not be any, but they need to work through the analysis to conclude.

In defence of the people who have replied with “there might be tax implications” - this is what they’ll understand from their own employers. Lots of employers had to address the issue of employees requesting to work abroad / being found to be logging on from other jurisdictions during covid and so had to either remind their staff of their employment contract terms or communicate new policies around remote working and did so in layman’s terms rather than issuing detailed tax technical arguments explaining why. These people aren’t spouting “nonsense” as you say, they are sharing their experiences.

I’d be interested to know why you think so resolutely that there are absolutely no potential tax implications of a situation like OP’s?

@RaspberryFarfait I’m sorry but without seeing the wording I’m not sure how it would apply. Is it suggesting that any amounts earned over a certain threshold would mean you have to pay some income tax?

tcjotm · 09/05/2022 09:05

@Oblomov22 I guess you’d prefer “sounds great hun, you enjoy your trip”.

I do hope @RaspberryFarfait has a great trip but I’d like it better if she doesn’t get any grief afterwards too.

tcjotm · 09/05/2022 09:00

Oblomov22 · 09/05/2022 05:08

"But it’s breaking all sorts of regulations."

@tcjotm

What regulations is it breaking?

I was agreeing with the post that used that sentence you quoted, that wasn’t my wording, But our risk assessments would consider if we were risking breaking regulations such as:

-taxes/social security contributions to be paid by any employer with someone working in that country
-Insurance contributions to be paid by employers on behalf of staff working in that country
-employment laws vary considerably - we wouldn’t know what they were and what we had to follow. Will we be in breech by accident? Does the employee gain any additional rights we don’t know about?
-Workers compensation. What happens if they are injured, how will that be covered?

Approved business travel addresses these issues. Someone spending a month abroad without their employers knowledge, leaves a lot unaddressed. Probably fine but I don’t want OP to face a misconduct accusation. I’m giving her reasons she hadn’t considered to encourage her to speak to her boss first.That ok with you?

tcjotm · 09/05/2022 08:50

Oblomov22 · 09/05/2022 05:53

@tcjotm

Employers "payroll tax". Really?
Which payroll tax is that then? That applies to OP's situation.

I hate it when people try to intimidate general folk, bedazzling them with technical terms. This is so complicated, you stupid folk couldn't possibly understand.

Really? Hmm

I’m not trying to intimidate anyone. OP asked for advice. She hasn’t given her jurisdiction and in mine, payroll tax and other obligations (like workers comp as I mentioned in my earlier post) are issues employers have to consider before approving things like that. These are not things the average person would know which is why I mentioned it as something her employer might need to consider. I don’t want her going off without permission and then getting into trouble later. She would be if she worked for my employer, which is why I shared the considerations we’d have with her as something to think about.

How that is intimidation I don’t know?! I’m just trying to be helpful. Other people were saying ‘tax implications’ implying those are on the OP. Where I am, they are concerns for the employer and being risk adverse, they generally refuse any requests to work outside of the country. I wouldn’t expect people to know that which is why in my job if someone asks a question like the OP’s, I give this advice - get it approved first because there are considerations you haven’t thought about. I know enough to know I don’t know enough, which is why I want her to get it approved so she doesn’t accidentally ruin her trip by getting in trouble from her employer.

Oblomov22 · 09/05/2022 07:04

@Howmuchwood

I wasn't referring to you re intimidation. You are the tax expert. I was referring to all the posters who flippantly kept saying 'the tax implications'.

Let's be honest, none of which applies to OP.

But like I said "short periods abroad "
and "separate payroll" don't apply to most people, not OP's month, nor a week in the Costa del sol.

Howmuchwood · 09/05/2022 06:56

@oblomov22 I'm not trying to intimidate anyone, indeed my job is to make complex tax law easy.to understand.

Without knowing the specifics of which country OP is a citizen of and will be travelling to, and what OPs role is, then its hard to say for sure whether its an issue.

There are various red flags with people working outside their home country which means a lot of companies don't want the risk and their policy is noone can work from abroad. If the company breaches local overseas law without knowing (e.g. person goes to Spain, then in theory their employing company has to follow Spanish social security and labour laws) they can have tax and other regulatory problems. One month could be OK in some countries but it depends on the type of worl being done. Anything customer facing is risker for tax than a back office role. Someone who works in sales might create tax problems for the company they work for from day 1.

Other companies have risk assessed that their employees can work for short periods abroad buy they have put in place mitigations to protect the company such as putting the employees that are mobile onto a separate payroll in a different employing company, or setting up branches of their company in lots of overseas countries.

Whatever anyone says on this thread it is essential that OP gets permission from her employer to work remotely while on holiday. The biggest risk to OP personally is the right to work /visa issue. The biggest risk to her employer is that she has an accident while travelling and they can't cover their costs under their UK insurance policies. The tax is a longer term issue in most cases but for some roles will be an issue from day 1 of working overseas.

Oblomov22 · 09/05/2022 05:53

@tcjotm

Employers "payroll tax". Really?
Which payroll tax is that then? That applies to OP's situation.

I hate it when people try to intimidate general folk, bedazzling them with technical terms. This is so complicated, you stupid folk couldn't possibly understand.

Really? Hmm

Oblomov22 · 09/05/2022 05:08

"But it’s breaking all sorts of regulations."

@tcjotm

What regulations is it breaking?

Oblomov22 · 09/05/2022 05:07

I still don't understand how anything mentioned is at all relevant.

The UK has many tax treaty's with USA (largely complicated), Singapore, India, Australia, Pakistan etc.
Eg
"Claiming Double Taxation Relief for companies and other concerns".

I simply don't see how OP's situation is relevant to @Festivecheer26 's statement : "company may suffer tax consequences under the relevant tax treaty". What tax consequences might OP's company suffer? For her 1 month?

I still don't see how any of the OP's situation is at all relevant.
How would OP's situation affect corporation tax? The answer is, it wouldn't.

A company may need tax advice if a number of their employees are travelling or working abroad for a period of time.

It doesn't apply for most normal people going for a weeks holiday to Benidorm/Malaga and needing to respond to an email.

Spanish

The Spanish Tax treaty is in respect of residency. Living in the UK or Spain for "183 days per year".
Which is exactly what I claimed right at the start. I asked anyone to link anything that had more info than the HMRC re working abroad, or residency. It needs to be for a large proportion of the tax year.
OP's 1 month does NOT count.
Even @Howmuchwood said in her second point : "1 month often fine".

So none of anything mentioned applies.

Clearly I've over invested in this thread. But I hate it, it gets my goat, when people come on sprouting false and factually incorrect technical and legal terms.

Many posters posted about tax implications. But it's nonsense. It doesn't apply to OP's situation.

Why can't I do this boss? Um, um you can't. Why? I don't know. Er maybe there are ...,. Tax implications.....
(Er. No. There aren't. They don't apply)

tcjotm · 09/05/2022 00:35

Snowiscold · 08/05/2022 18:41

How on earth would the tax authorities be any the wiser though?
But it’s breaking all sorts of regulations. Any reputable company will be very hot on these rules, and won’t want to be sneaking something past the tax authorities that could have serious repercussions for them.

Exactly this. It’s not tax implications for the employee, it’s for the employer. Employees don’t pay any attention to the various obligations employers have, including things like payroll tax, but the employer will do and they need to assess the risks.

This kind of ‘but why can’t I work from anywhere’ kept us all very busy during the pandemic as it turned out people had scattered all over the place without any approvals.

RaspberryFarfait · 08/05/2022 23:07

My contract does not mention remote working at all. Which is odd as it was from last year and colleagues had already been wfh for almost 2 years. It only mentions ‘based at’.

There is a double tax treaty but the amount specified as taxable earnings is over what I earn in a year, let alone a month! How would that work @Festivecheer26 if you don’t mind me asking?

OP posts:
Festivecheer26 · 08/05/2022 22:25

@Oblomov22 the contracting states are the two jurisdictions the tax treaty is agreed between, so in this case the UK and the jurisdiction OP is travelling to. Assuming the OP works for a company that is UK tax resident, then then the tax treaty between the UK and the country OP is going to applies to her employing company. That company may suffer tax consequences under the relevant tax treaty (and indeed the domestic tax law of the country she’s travelling to). This what @Howmuchwood refers to in point 1 of their post.

To manage the tax risk created by employees working in other jurisdictions (and no doubt for other reasons too) many companies include clauses in employment contracts stating work can only be performed in the UK or have remote working policies stating that there can be no remote working abroad/ up to a maximum of X days worked abroad in a country where the employer already has an office, such as one other poster mentioned. So the relevance for the OP here is that she could find herself in breach of her employment contract or an internal policy if she decides to work whilst abroad without permission.

If you have any materials disproving this then please do share the links.

StarCourt · 08/05/2022 22:23

I work for a global corporate and we are allowed to work abroad for up to 30 days per year

TheDoveFromAboveCooCoo · 08/05/2022 21:37

Good luck - I would definitely broach the subject with work.

I'm also working for an NHS partner and have a member of my team from another European country. Every three months she goes home for a week and will partly work from there and partly take annual leave for her flights and things she has planned with family.

It works really well for us. She does the exact same job to the exact same standards whether she is doing it from 2 miles down the road or from her home country!

3luckystars · 08/05/2022 21:33

I would ask at work to see how they would feel about one week abroad first. A month seems like a long time. Ask about the policy and see how it goes, but I wouldn’t mention a month in the fist conversation. Good luck.

WhereHaveAllTheTwigletsGone · 08/05/2022 21:33

You really need to tell work. It can be complicated legally if you access any data as part of your role, especially customer data. Let them assess it and let you know

FLOWER1982 · 08/05/2022 21:27

As in your equipment laptop etc. I know in my company there were a few that requested this and it all had to go throughHR to agree.

FLOWER1982 · 08/05/2022 21:25

You would need to let work know as you may not be covered by their insurance or any other issues there may be.

BigRedDuck · 08/05/2022 21:19

Our employers say we cannot work from abroad due to tax implications. Work for a big housing association.

Oblomov22 · 08/05/2022 21:18

"Your working illegally in Spain without a visa" @hellesbells , no I'm not!! I'm Spanish.

GrinGrinGrin
Oh this is the best ever.
"I'm a Canadian". Aka best comment on MN, Ever.

PradaOnaBudget · 08/05/2022 21:02

"Your working illegally in Spain without a visa" @hellesbells , no I'm not!! I'm Spanish.

Oblomov22 · 08/05/2022 20:52

@Howmuchwood, as an expert has dispelled a lot of the nonsense written by previous posters.

Aimee1987 · 08/05/2022 20:52

I'm going back to my home country next week. Have some sessions that I cant miss on Friday but there online so I'll just log in remotely from Ireland.
Have done it a few times, no problem

If your worried about logging in you can get a vpn

Oblomov22 · 08/05/2022 20:49

@Festivecheer26

"1. This Convention shall apply to persons who are residents of one or both of the Contracting States. "

How is that relevant to OP?

notimagain · 08/05/2022 20:45

Specifically with regard to the EU, issues such as 90 days in 180 is not a factor in having the right to work. Sadly unless the individual has a business Visa or is indulging in a permitted business activity (see below) ATM most Brits don't have the right to arrive in the EU and start working, at all, not even for just one day:

www.kingsleynapley.co.uk/services/department/immigration/british-citizens-travelling-to-the-eu-for-business-what-employers-need-to-know

item #6 is possibly relevant to this debate..

Prior to Brexit "British citizens were able to travel on the basis of free movement throughout the EU and so it was not necessary to distinguish between what was business visitor activity and work. Care now needs to be taken to ensure that where a British citizen is entering the EU without a prior visa, they are only carrying out permitted business visitor activity...."

The article then lists typically permitted business activities - as has been mentioned upthread it's generally short term transient activities and exact details vary country by country.

Most countries outside the EU have similar rules...and yes I know how it often works in reality.

Swipe left for the next trending thread